Remarks of Gordon Smith at Department of Justice Workshop on Music Licensing Competition WASHINGTON, D.C. - NAB President and CEO Gordon Smith testified today at a Department of Justice workshop on competition in the licensing of public performance rights in the music industry.
Below are his remarks as prepared for delivery:
Good afternoon. Thank you to Assistant Attorney General Delrahim and the Department of Justice for inviting me to offer my thoughts, as president and CEO of the National Association of Broadcasters, on the future of the ASCAP and BMI consent decrees.
On behalf of America's local radio and television broadcasters serving communities across the country, I welcome this opportunity to discuss why the ASCAP and BMI antitrust consent decrees continue to be essential, and our significant concerns with the so-called modified skinny decrees currently under consideration. Without the framework the current consent decrees provide, a fair competitive market for the licensing of musical works simply would not exist.
Despite the Department of Justice finding less than five years ago that the decrees were essential to preserving competition, we are yet again being asked to consider modifications to them. For broadcasters and many other licensees, this endeavor raises major concerns.
While NAB always welcomes conversation about ways to improve and modernize government regulation, most of the publicly proposed modifications would likely harm licensees and consumers, stifle innovation and frankly, entirely miss the point.
At the outset, it is critical to recognize that these decrees have been worked through line by line over the course of 80 years, with the parties and courts developing understandings and interpretations of nearly every word. While getting skinny often sounds like an appealing aspiration - especially at my age - in this instance it is quite misleading. Changing or eliminating sections or paragraphs or sentences or even words in the decrees can have harmful and unintended consequences. These are not changes that can be consummated following a workshop or roundtable. If the decrees were to be modified, that could only come after the public fully vets any specific proposal to do so.
Moreover, there are three critical issues that DOJ must be address before we even get to any of the subjects on the agenda for these roundtables. The first of these is fractional licensing. The single biggest change to the PRO consent decree landscape in the last few decades is a federal court's recent mistaken interpretation that the decrees do not require full work licensing. That means that, when a licensee contracts with BMI for a work that either one does not wholly own, the PROs insists that the licensee does not have any right to publicly perform that work unless it has each and every co-owner on board as well. Put differently, following the federal court's ruling on the question of fractional licensing, licensees may very well pay ASCAP or BMI for the right to publicly perform works, but actually have no right to use them. Any discussion of modifying the decrees must start with requiring whole work licensing, through indemnification or another mechanism.
Second, also somewhat buried in the details of the roundtables is the PROs' failure to be transparent about their repertoires. Shockingly, there is no real-time database among the PROs that indicates - with certainty - for what compositions licensees have contracted. What other business is asked to pay for something, yet they have no way of knowing what is included in the package? This issue is exacerbated by the federal court's refusal to find that the existing decrees require whole work licensing.
Finally, the Justice Department should reassess the breadth of the parties to which these consent decrees apply. With the growth of SESAC and the emergence of powerhouse PRO Global Music Rights, broadcasters and other licensees are left without full protection under DOJ's watchful eye. If we are going to get serious about reforming the decrees, all PROs must be brought within their purview. PROs do not compete with each other for licensees and licensees are effectively forced to license each PRO's repertory. This, too, has been made worse by fractional licensing, as even a relatively smaller PRO could simply amass minority interests in key works and force licensees to pay above-market prices for the right to make use of their ASCAP and BMI licenses.
When it comes to the modifications publicly proposed by ASCAP, BMI and the National Music Publishers Association, the Justice Department must proceed with extreme caution. For radio broadcasters, being able to play a wide array of music is essential, as that is what listeners expect and demand. Whether one owns one radio station or hundreds, it is essential to have immediate access to these catalogues and at a reasonable rate. Moreover, for radio stations that air syndicated programming, commercials and live events, they must have the public performance rights to the full catalog of musical works in order to operate lawfully.
Television stations often have even less control regarding the music that goes over their air.Each day, TV stations have music interspersed throughout their programming. Much of those musical performances occur in the background of stations' movies, television shows, live sporting events, local news and commercials. Stations have no editorial control for much of their content, such as network and syndicated programming, live events and commercials. So, if a station lacked the right to publicly perform a single musical work because it was in a repertory it did not license, it would have no practical ability to mitigate the risk that an offending song might air. This would expose the station to the threat of significant pen
Most recent headlines
05/01/2027
Worlds first 802.15.4ab-UWB chip verified by Calterah and Rohde & Schwarz to be ...
06/09/2026
June 9 2026, 23:00 (PDT) Dolby and MagentaTV Bring Fans Closer to the FIFA Worl...
04/08/2026
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, t...
04/07/2026
April 7 2026, 19:00 (PDT) Detective Conan: Fallen Angel of the Highway Opens in...
15/06/2026
Detach from Direct-Attached: How Remote Editing with EVO Keeps Creative Teams Mo...
14/06/2026
Library captures 1960s R&B/pop drum sound
Following on from their recent wave of plug-in effects, Iconic Instruments have just launched an all-new virtual d...
14/06/2026
HBO Comedy Rooster Shot with URSA Cine 17K 65
Brie Clayton June 14, 2026
0 Comments
Large format brings viewers intimately close to characters.
Black...
13/06/2026
Latest expansion pack includes 252 presets
Devious Machines have recently introduced another expansion for their powerful multi-effects plug-in, Infiltrator...
13/06/2026
Create custom DAW/plug-in controllers using prompts
MetaGrid have recently introduced an all-new AI Builder function to their touchscreen-based control surf...
13/06/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
13/06/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
12/06/2026
YES Network and The Gotham Sports App will air seven Athletes Unlimited Softball...
12/06/2026
The United Football League will host its FAST Innovation Suite at the 2026 United Bowl presented by Credit One Bank on Saturday, June 13 at 3:00 p.m. ET at Audi...
12/06/2026
PTZOptics and LayerJot will present live demonstrations at InfoComm 2026 showing how natural-language AI prompting, robotic camera control, and on-device comput...
12/06/2026
MultiDyne Video and Fiber Optic Systems will exhibit at InfoComm 2026, featuring...
12/06/2026
Ateme has announced that Eurovision Services is using Ateme's software-based frame-rate conversion technology for international live event workflows. The de...
12/06/2026
Bitmovin and Simplestream have announced a partnership with Xperi to simplify the launch of OTT streaming services on TiVo OS smart TVs and devices. The collabo...
12/06/2026
Net Insight has announced that a multinational technology company is deploying a...
12/06/2026
MLB Players Inc., the business arm of the MLB Players Association, has announced a partnership with Athletes First to develop and sell brand partnerships across...
12/06/2026
Guntermann and Drunck (G&D) and VuWall have announced the CommandKeyboard-Advanc...
12/06/2026
Comcast Smart Solutions announces a new smart technology deployment with Major L...
12/06/2026
Elevation Worship completed the initial leg of its Elevation Nights 2026 tour ...
12/06/2026
AJA Video Systems has announced KONA IP25 support for Colorfront Transkoder and ...
12/06/2026
Audinate Group Limited (ASX: AD8) will exhibit at InfoComm 2026 (Booth C7321, Ce...
12/06/2026
Pac-12 Commissioner Teresa Gould has announced the appointment of Scott Adametz as Chief Technology Officer. The Pac-12 describes the hire as the first CTO appo...
12/06/2026
Grass Valley has announced AMPP Edge Live, a production system combining Grass Valley hardware, NVIDIA Blackwell GPU acceleration, and AMPP OS in a single platf...
12/06/2026
At one time a trailblazer with the launch of the Longhorn Network, the Universit...
12/06/2026
Ratings Roundup is a rundown of recent rating news and is derived from press rel...
12/06/2026
Chyron has announced PAINT 10.4, an update to its illustrated replay and sports ...
12/06/2026
SVP, Production, Mark Gross: With the new schedule, with not having every Sunday night, it has given us an opportunity to take a step back and reimagine what o...
12/06/2026
For Televisa Technical Engineering Manager Roberto N nez Ibarra and the small team of 12 technicians and two production personnel at the IBC things are already ...
12/06/2026
Simple Steps to Better Acoustics - Taming The Small Room
Most of us mix in spare rooms and small spaces, where the acoustics fight us at every turn. At Gear...
12/06/2026
Latest addition expands vintage-inspired effects palette
Meris' Ottobit pedal range draws its inspiration from vintage gaming consoles, and the latest a...
12/06/2026
Soundbox-based chamber strings series expanded
Sonora Cinematic have just announced the launch of the second instalment in their Soundbox-based chamber stri...
12/06/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
12/06/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
12/06/2026
AJA Announces KONA IP25 Integration with Colorfront Software
Brie Clayton June 12, 2026
0 Comments
Collaboration enables uncompressed SMPTE ST 2110 I/O ...
12/06/2026
URSA Cine 12K LF Used to Create Visuals for STUTS' K-Arena Concert
Brie Clayton June 12, 2026
0 Comments
Organic visuals projected on a giant scre...
12/06/2026
MTI FILM Acquires Mango New Edit, Expanding its Global Post-Production Services ...
12/06/2026
AI Point Tracking Speeds Up Complex VFX Tracks in Mocha Pro
Jessie Electa Petrov June 12, 2026
0 Comments
The 2026.5 release adds automatic point trac...
12/06/2026
Bitmovin, a provider of video streaming solutions, has partnered with Simplestream, a provider of OTT and broadcast solutions, and technology provider Xperi, to...
12/06/2026
Leostream Corporation, creator of the world-leading Leostream Remote Desktop Access Platform, today announced Jigsaw24, a leading B2B IT solutions provider wit...
12/06/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
12/06/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
12/06/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
12/06/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
12/06/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
12/06/2026
How Aussie indie games and screen are levelling up with IP 11 June 2026
Ari Harrison, Pro Jank Footy
Head of Games Joey Egger and Ari Harrison of Umbrella sha...
12/06/2026
AgentPerf from Artificial Analysis, the industry's first agentic AI benchmark, gives developers, enterprises and infrastructure providers a clear way to com...
Remarks of Gordon Smith at Department of Justice Workshop on Music Licensing Competition WASHINGTON, D.C. - NAB President and CEO Gordon Smith testified today at a Department of Justice workshop on competition in the licensing of public performance rights in the music industry.
