Audio Loudness Waters Are a Little Less CALM Than Before Streaming is disrupting the dynamic balance between commercial- and program-audio levels By Dan Daley, Audio Editor
Wednesday, June 15, 2022 - 12:28 pm
Print This Story | Subscribe
Story Highlights
Once again, the volume of complaints about loud television commercials is rivaling the volume of the blaring blurbs themselves. In the four months from November 2020 to February 2021, complaints to the Federal Communications Commission about loud commercials more than doubled, up 140% compared with the same period a year earlier. That has precipitated a congressional call to have another look at the matter.
A dozen years ago, the CALM Act set out to mitigate one of the banes of modern broadcast media: annoyingly loud commercials. Specifically, the Commercial Advertisement Loudness Mitigation Act directed the FCC to establish rules that would require TV stations, cable operators, satellite-TV providers, and other multichannel video program distributors to apply the ATSC's A/85 Recommended Practice (ATSC A/85 RP) to commercials they broadcast to viewers, in order to prevent that audio from being louder than the program material.
New Version of CALM Act Now a proposed revision of the CALM Act, the CALM Modernization Act, proposed by Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI) and Rep. Anna G. Eshoo (D-CA) in May, is intended to update the Act as follows:
Modify the 2010 CALM Act's safe harbor to a rebuttable presumption based on whether a provider uses appropriate equipment and software to moderate volume; the number and pattern of complaints the FCC receives about the provider; and other factors.
Direct the FCC to promulgate regulations limiting the volume of ads on ad-supported TV-streaming services similar in effect to the regulations for traditional TV.
Enable the FCC to enforce violations of the legislation as it would enforce other violations of the Communications Act.
Direct the General Accounting Office to submit a report to Congress analyzing the effectiveness of the CALM Act in moderating loudness, evaluating enforcement provisions of the law, and recommending policy solutions to better moderate loudness.
New ways to watch TV shouldn't mean new ways for corporations to blare ads at outrageously high volumes, Whitehouse said in a prepared statement. It's time to update our CALM Act to address the uptick in streaming and to boost enforcement of existing rules against loud commercials. I'm glad to partner with Congresswoman Eshoo to help annoyed TV watchers everywhere. We've all had enough.
In fact, the updated legislation's sponsors argue, in the years since its enactment, the FCC has never enforced the law despite having the authority to do so and, in that time, has sent only two letters of inquiry, even though it continues to receive thousands of consumer complaints per year.
In some ways, the requirements of the CALM Act produced a major change in workflow for broadcasters by shifting the metrics from audio peak normalization to loudness normalization. However, acceptance and application of the CALM Act was relatively quick and smooth; in many cases, it was welcomed by broadcasters for its clarity and accelerated by a growing subsector of products aimed at more precisely measuring and managing broadcast-audio loudness. As for infractions of the regulation, the CALM Act didn't provide specific penalties against broadcasters, although it did provide a one-year grace period for implementation of the appropriate equipment and a safe-harbor provision for broadcasters who did. It also subjected cable operators to the same regulations as the FCC's traditional bailiwick of over-the-air broadcasters. A broadcaster or distributor is considered in compliance as long as it installs and uses suitable equipment and software for loudness monitoring and management.
However, although the Act did initially reduce the number of loudness complaints from consumers, complaints have begun to ratchet up in recent years. Much of that is a result of the growth of streaming, which wasn't addressed in the original CALM Act, and that has created an entirely new universe of potentially loud media.
Meters and Metrics Manufacturers of loudness-monitoring and -management systems say they're ready for any modifications to CALM.
Nugen Audio's Charles Blessing: The -24 standard [used in the CALM Act] wasn't adequate for the shift to mobile devices.
Not much will need changing, says Charles Blessing, CTO, Nugen Audio, which makes the VisLM loudness-measurement and the LM Correct automated-compliance plugins. He notes that the existing standards used to measure and manage loudness have been able to accommodate broadcast audio as it evolved from stereo to surround to immersive and can do the same for streaming.
ITU-1770-4 provided for different [loudness] targets for streaming applications: -16 vs. the -24 used for the CALM Act, he explains, referencing the LKFS (loudness, K-weighted/full-scale) metric used to measure loudness over the whole of the program. The -24 standard wasn't adequate for the shift to mobile devices. It wasn't loud enough to let them be heard in noisy environments. Our products have algorithms that can adjust for the type of content and environment.
Blessing says audio specifications for both Netflix and Disney+ use the -27 target successfully, with many viewers watching on the same television platforms they use for broadcast and cable viewing. Both streaming services are also applying Dolby Dialog Intelligence Gating at -27 LKFS. Amazon Prime Video doesn't publicly share its audio technical requirements.
UK-based Blessing sits on the EBU's Ploud group, which established the EBU R 128 Loudness Recommendation to create a common, vendor-independent and relativ
Most recent headlines
04/08/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, is excited to announce Santiago Solanas as its new Chief Executive Officer (CEO)....
03/06/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, a...
28/04/2024
Mediahaus delivers the first SRT live-streaming sports production over 5G with U...
27/04/2024
On April 26, L3Harris Chair and CEO Christopher E. Kubasik joined CNBC's Mor...
27/04/2024
PORTLAND, Oregon Audinate Group Limited, the developer of the Dante AV-over-IP solution, announced significant new additions to Dante Connect, its cloud-based D...
27/04/2024
TORONTO Bell Media has launched 10 English and French-language FAST channels featuring entertainment, factual, news, and sports programming. The new free stream...
27/04/2024
An extensive new analysis of the news segments in the broadcast evening news programs of ABC, CBS, NBC and PBS has found that broadcasters devoted most of their...
27/04/2024
GERMANTOWN, Md. EchoStar's Hughes Network Systems has opened a new manufacturing facility and private 5G incubation center in Germantown, Maryland....
27/04/2024
Harry Pappas, one of three brothers who founded Pappas Telecasting Companies in 1971, died April 24. He was 78 years old....
27/04/2024
ATLANTA and LONDON Mexican telecommunications and broadcast company Televisa has selected Synamedia for an overhaul of its broadcast distribution....
27/04/2024
Participate in the Survey - The Impact of AI on Media and the Creative Industry
Pascal Wagner April 26, 2024
0 Comments
By participating in this surve...
27/04/2024
SDVI Rally Access Workstation Earns Two Top Awards at 2024 NAB Show
Brie Clayton April 26, 2024
0 Comments
SDVI, the leading platform provider for clo...
27/04/2024
Berklee's Music and Health Institute Launches Community Health Musician Cert...
27/04/2024
Charter Communications reported higher first-quarter profits despite continued cord-cutting and competition for broadband customers....
27/04/2024
Two environmentally-focused groups are partnering to engage the unscripted TV world in finding better ways to address climate change. Reality of Change is an ec...
27/04/2024
Sarah Garcia has been promoted to weekend anchor at KTLM McAllen, Texas, known as Telemundo 40. Starting April 27, she will anchor Noticias Telemundo 40 weekend...
27/04/2024
CBS Sports said it launched a new 24-hour free, ad supported streaming television (FAST) channel devoted to the UEFA Champions League....
27/04/2024
Comcast chairman and CEO Brian Roberts received $35.4 million in compensation in 2023, up 11% from the previous year, according to a proxy statement filed by th...
27/04/2024
Art Happens Here With John Lithgow, which sees the actor study dance, ceramics, silk-screen printing and vocal jazz with students in Los Angeles, debuts on PBS ...
27/04/2024
Remember Leave It to Beaver? Bewitched? Dragnet? When cable ratings were rising?...
27/04/2024
Next up for the weekend binge at Catchy Comedy is Gomer Pyle, U.S.M.C. Every weekend, Catchy Comedy features The Catchy Binge, a marathon of a classic sitcom....
26/04/2024
Sundance Film Festival CDMX 2024 kicks-off today with screenings in 5 theaters in Mexico City and the opening-night film, FRIDA, directed by Carla Guti rrez...
26/04/2024
[Editor's Note: This interview is part of a larger feature about the women d...
26/04/2024
Once again this year, SGL Carbon opened its doors to interested children and young people. On the occasion of the German Girls and Boys Day, which took place on...
26/04/2024
Orders1 of $5.5 billion; book-to-bill of 1.06x
Revenue of $5.2 billion, up 17%,...
26/04/2024
Five Considerations For Communications Modernization In The 21st Century
In the digital-enabled battlespace, the Joint Force needs to shoot, move and communica...
26/04/2024
CBS Sports has launched Champions League as a new, 24-hour streaming channel that will serve as the year-round destination for nonstop highlights of the UEFA ...
26/04/2024
Despite tough competition in the streaming space, Roku reported solid results in Q1 2024, beating revenue expectations, with total net revenue up 19% YoY to $88...
26/04/2024
LONDON AND TORONTO Pinewood Toronto Studios has appointed Sarah Farrell as general manager of the Studios in downtown Toronto....
26/04/2024
Quantum to Offer Advanced Filesharing Technology and Performance in StorNext and...
26/04/2024
FilmLight Colour Awards welcomes 2024 entries and introduces new Emerging Talen...
26/04/2024
Picture Shop Announces Chris Evans as Head of Unscripted
Brie Clayton April 26, 2024
0 Comments
Picture Shop announced Chris Evans will lead Unscripte...
26/04/2024
Participate in a Survey - The Impact of AI on Media and the Creative Industry
Pascal Wagner April 26, 2024
0 Comments
By participating in this survey,...
26/04/2024
Toy maker Mattel said it is working with Samsung to launch its first free ad-supported streaming television (FAST) channels later this year....
26/04/2024
Trusted Media Brands (TMB) said it named Marty Moe as president....
26/04/2024
Ron Howard is the director on Jim Henson Idea Man, a documentary that premieres on Disney Plus May 31. Henson of course created Kermit the Frog, Miss Piggy, Big...
26/04/2024
The ice continues to melt under the regional sports network business as the Seattle Kraken of the National Hockey League have made a long-term deal to broadcast...
26/04/2024
Heading into the upfronts, Warner Bros. Discovery said it launched Olli, a first-party data platform advertiser can use for converged, targeted advertising camp...
26/04/2024
CBS has renewed the drama The Equalizer, which will see season five on in 2024-2025. Queen Latifah stars....
26/04/2024
The CW has entered into an exclusive multiyear broadcast partnership for the Miss USA Pageant and the Miss Teen USA Pageant. The 73rd Miss USA Pageant will air ...
26/04/2024
Fuse Media isn't mincing words in a campaign urging its young viewers to register and participate in the 2024 elections....
26/04/2024
Dead Boy Detectives, a series from Neil Gaiman about a detective agency staffed by ghosts, debuts on Netflix April 25. George Rexstrew and Jayden Revri are in t...
26/04/2024
The Story Collective has gradually repurposed the former Mortlake Brewery to include production offices, workshops and sound stages
By Matthew Corrigan
Publi...
26/04/2024
Perkett joins the company following a 25 year career in product management, product marketing, engineering and user experience (UX) across multiple industries
...
26/04/2024
Teradek, the industry leader in wireless video transmitters and receivers, announced today the launch of new Bolt 6 LT 750 and Bolt 6 Monitor Module 750 RX with...
26/04/2024
NEW YORK Amagi has appointed Richard Perkett chief product officer (CPO)....
26/04/2024
WASHINGTON, D.C. The National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) has announced the results of the 2024 NAB Radio and Television Board of Directors elections. The...
26/04/2024
EL SEGUNDO, Calif. & NEW YORK Mattel has announced a deal to launch its first three 24/7 free ad supported streaming (FAST) channels on Samsung TV Plus, Samsung...
26/04/2024
PORTLAND, Maine Viewers here can now receive the NextGen TV signals of five local stations with the launch of ATSC 3.0 service from host station WPFO, which is ...
Audio Loudness Waters Are a Little Less CALM Than Before Streaming is disrupting the dynamic balance between commercial- and program-audio levels By Dan Daley, Audio Editor 
