
Why the Best Cover Songs Succeed From Fast Car to Heartbeats, there's no formula to making a successful cover song. But the best covers answer two important questions.
By
John Mirisola
September 18, 2023
Every great cover song answers two questions: why this song, and why this performance?
When theyre successful, a good cover manages to comment on the original song-its brilliance, its mood, even its shortcomings-while also highlighting the new performers own voice and creative interpretation. As a result, the best cover songs are great music and great music criticism all rolled into one.
Consider one of the undisputed best: Hallelujah by Jeff Buckley.
Why this song? Its Leonard Cohens masterpiece, refined over years, but dated by his '80s synth-driven style. Yet every word, every chord change is a testament to the songs greatness. And why this aching, elemental lightning strike of a performance by one of the nineties most luminous voices and most tragic figures? Because, well, see the previous sentence.
This is only one example, but the paths to creating a great cover song are as wide-ranging as any artists influences and imagination. In this playlist, we look at a small sampling of successful cover songs from the past six decades, and explore the many ways that artists have made something fresh and memorable from songs we might still remember.
1. Fast Car, Luke Combs (Originally by Tracy Chapman)Some moments in a classic recording are sacred-like when the snare drum first enters Tracy Chapmans Fast Car at the lyric, I remember when we were driving. Country singer Luke Combss faithful cover preserves the essence but introduces subtle tweaks-vocal twang, production polish-turning a queer Black womans 1988 folk-rock anthem into a country radio staple and one of 2023s songs of the summer. I never expected to find myself on the country charts, Chapman told Billboard in July, but I'm honored to be there. I'm happy for Luke and his success and grateful that new fans have found and embraced Fast Car.
2. All Along the Watchtower, The Jimi Hendrix Experience (Originally by Bob Dylan)Bob Dylans original version of All Along the Watchtower, simply arranged with a trotting acoustic trio behind him, presents a striking cast of characters: the jaded joker, the pragmatic thief, the princes who watch the vagrants approach from high above it all. Every scene in Dylans rendition is like a silent, close-up shot in black and white. Jimi Hendrixs cover, recorded just a year later, is a panoramic, technicolor masterpiece to rival the original. Hendrix builds upon the cryptic spookiness at the songs core with lush studio overdubs, miles of reverb, and that unmistakable guitar, howling like the wind.
Lost John Coltrane Record Still Sounds Like Freedom
Ethnomusicologist Emmett G. Price III unpacks the enduring power of Coltrane and Dolphys lost collaboration, and the sound so bold and liberated that some critics dismissed it as anti-jazz.
3. My Favorite Things, John Coltrane with Eric Dolphy (Originally by Rodgers and Hammerstein for The Sound of Music)Like Hendrix with All Along the Watchtower, John Coltrane began playing this now-famous show tune just a year after The Sound of Music debuted on Broadway. This freewheeling interpretation became a prime example of the artists ability to turn melodies and chords inside-out and upside-down, transforming the familiar into the utterly new. On this 1961 recording, Coltrane is joined by Eric Dolphy, whose flute adds another level of strangeness to the familiar tune, making the immediately recognizable melody that much sweeter when it finally emerges.
4. Born Under Punches, Ang lique Kidjo (Originally by Talking Heads)On their classic 1980 album, Remain in Light, Talking Heads channeled the trance-like rhythms of Afrobeat and Fela Kuti, an influence thats unmistakable from the opening seconds of Born Under Punches, says Nick Balkin, director of editorial services at Berklee. Beninese singer Ang lique Kidjo's 2018 version [produced by Jeff Bhasker '99] breathes new life into the track, honoring the original while infusing it with the spirit of her African roots.
5. I Will Always Love You, Whitney Houston (Originally by Dolly Parton)Is the cover greater than the original? Is the original greater than the cover? In this instance, both exist in a rare, perfect harmony. With her spellbinding vocal performance, Houston earns the right to call this a signature song-even as it has remained one of Partons most cherished tracks throughout her career. The two versions somehow amplify one another rather than replacing each other. As one YouTube commenter puts it: Listen to Dollys original version when your heart is breaking, listen to Whitneys version when youre ready to move on.
6. Ring of Fire, Johnny Cash (Originally by Anita Carter)It was in 1963 that Johnny Cash first reworked Anita Carters folk ballad (Loves) Ring of Fire (cowritten by future wife June Carter), picking up the pace and giving it a proper backing band with its trademark horns and shuffling drums and cooing back-up singers. With his classic baritone speak-singing, it almost sounds like Cash is less interested in defining love than describing the fire. This version became authoritative, overshadowing Carters earnest, sentimental original in cultural memory.
7. Ring of Fire, Social Distortion (Originally by Anita Carter, by way of Johnny Cash)Punk covers have a way of revealing a songs core. In Social Distortions version of Ring of Fire, Cashs version loses its mariachi trumpets in the flames of chugging distortion, but what emerges is a streamlined, snarling testament to the songs durability. Through every sonic transformation, in those chords, in those words, the same cynical romance burns, burns, burns.
8. Hurt, Johnny Cash (Originally by Nine Inch Nails)Perhaps eve
Most recent headlines
04/12/2023
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, announced the release of Dalet Cut, the cloud-native, lightning-fast multimedia a...
30/09/2023
With this summers strikes hurting the flow of new content into TV and streaming platforms, live sports have become an even more important programming staple, wi...
30/09/2023
Viewing of the second GOP debate on Sept. 27 fell to 4.1 million homes, a notable 39% drop from the 6.6 million homes that watched that first GOP debate, accord...
30/09/2023
WASHINGTON, D.C. In the long-running regulatory saga of the FCC's station ownership rules, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit has issued a rulin...
30/09/2023
Calrec Audio Ltd. will feature its latest solutions to help broadcasters and OB suppliers transition to IP workflows at NAB Show New York, Oct. 25 26....
30/09/2023
Northern Minnesota residents can watch live City Council meetings and more on all viewing platforms thanks to broad network stream support
Between support for...
30/09/2023
The classic Instreamer-to-Exstreamer combination comes through for Spanish language audiences in the United States and Mexico, with the Instreamer handling remo...
30/09/2023
Zeros in Ones Hits the Road with AJA's Dante AV 4K-R and 4K-T
Brie Clayton September 29, 2023
0 Comments
As founder of video production company Zer...
30/09/2023
Arcturus Appoints Former Microsoft and Lucasfilm Veteran Steve Sullivan as Chief...
30/09/2023
Vodafone Studios Boosts Audiovisual Production Capabilities with Blackmagic Desi...
30/09/2023
Moving Above LTO - How Cloud Storage Helps One Texas Church Deliver a Modern Dig...
30/09/2023
New Pass the Mic Podcast to Highlight Inspiring Berklee Alumni Listen to the first episode featuring Captain Marvel composer Pinar Toprak B.M. '00.
By
Dan...
30/09/2023
Live from the 2023 Ryder Cup: Sky Sports Virtual Studio in UK Plays Big Role in ...
29/09/2023
One of the most exciting things about the Sundance Film Festival is having a fro...
29/09/2023
You might know all the songs and albums of your favorite musicians, but do you know the experiences and inspirations behind their work? Luckily, you can find ou...
29/09/2023
There are times when the daily grind might not leave you feeling the most inspired. But it doesn't always have to be like that. Words of wisdom may be just ...
29/09/2023
Sometimes you might notice a thoughtful review from a friend on your feed, or stumble upon a flash summary straight out of your favorite social influencer's...
29/09/2023
Whether it's chilling on the couch or crashing into bed, nothing beats settling into a nice long rest at the end of the day. And few things are more frustra...
29/09/2023
Which was better, the book or the movie?
It's a common argument that has withstood the test of time and has only gotten stronger as more and more hit tele...
29/09/2023
Whether you like to begin your day the moment you get out of bed or ease gently into it with a cup of coffee, you can count on audiobooks to boost your mornings...
29/09/2023
With elaborate storytelling, immersive worlds, and an enthusiastic fandom hyping it up, getting into a new book can be an exciting and fun moment. And with the ...
29/09/2023
Fans flock to music festivals to see dozens of their favorite artists in one go,...
29/09/2023
Now streaming on Disney+, Launchpad Season 2 comprises six original live-action short films from underrepresented filmmakers whose unique voices bring new persp...
29/09/2023
Wasabi hot cloud storage is purpose-built to store the world's data. Wasabi ...
29/09/2023
Sohonet, the global experts in media collaboration for the film and TV industry, announce a series of significant product updates set to redefine and streamline...
29/09/2023
Current and incoming L3Harris innovations provide warfighters immersive battlefield awareness capabilities during the day and at night - with the ability to pus...
29/09/2023
After graduating high school at the age of 16, I left my native Venezuela and moved to Miami, Florida, with the goal of becoming an electrical engineer. The fol...
29/09/2023
L3Harris employees in Mirabel, Quebec, proudly wore their Mother Bear Energy shirts on September 28, 2023....
29/09/2023
The 2023 edition of GSMA MWC Las Vegas saw a rise in attendees from vertical ind...
29/09/2023
Timed to coincide with the Utah Jazz's 50th season celebration, SEG Media has launched the direct-to-consumer streaming service Jazz+, which offers exclusiv...
29/09/2023
WASHINGTON, D.C. The National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) hosted a virtual town hall for members on Sept. 28 where it provided updates on NAB's policy...
29/09/2023
SINGAPORE Ikegami has announced that RE:LIVE Productions, one of Singapore's leading providers of creative video, event management and live streaming servic...
29/09/2023
- The popular showcase for the latest production solutions, technology and insights returns for its third year -
CVP, one of Europe s leading resellers and pro...
29/09/2023
Well known for cross-divisional collaboration and staying connected with our for...
29/09/2023
Berklee Abu Dhabi Convenes Community Leaders for Creative Arts Educators Symposi...
29/09/2023
TransUnion said it is working with Crackle Connex, Chicken Soup For the Soul Entertainment's advertising sales unit, to create custom audiences from first-p...
29/09/2023
Spotify and Roku said they are bringing video ads to the Spotify app on the Roku platform....
29/09/2023
The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame induction ceremony is moving from HBO to Disney Plus and ABC....
29/09/2023
Auto entertainment network Speedvision said it is available as a free ad-supported streaming television (FAST) channel on Xumo Play....
29/09/2023
Scripps News said it hired Chris Nguyen as an anchor....
29/09/2023
The first-ever People's Choice Country Awards happens on NBC and Peacock Thursday, September 28. Little Big Town hosts from the Grand Ole Opry House in Nash...
29/09/2023
Seeing their docuseries Rebuilding Black Wall Street appear on the Oprah Winfrey...
29/09/2023
Scripps News got its first national News Emmy for its docuseries In Real Life. Scripps News won in the outstanding science, technology or environmental coverage...
29/09/2023
John Brohel has been named chief executive officer of Locality, formed in June when CoxReps and Gamut were combined....
29/09/2023
An animal act has won season 18 of America's Got Talent, as Adrian Stoica and his dog Hurricane were the top vote getters. They won $1 million and join the ...
29/09/2023
Zest4.tv's managing director, Simon Roe, looks at the ways in which compact OB Vans are the epitome of efficiency, proving that size does not limit their po...
29/09/2023
TVBEurope talks to the team behind the film about Eddie Jones and the Japanese r...
29/09/2023
Ashish Patel has been appointed president, MediaKind operator platforms, and Tony Goncalves joins as strategic advisor
By Jenny Priestley
Published: Septembe...
29/09/2023
Building on the momentum of major product announcements and award wins at NAB Show earlier this year, Chyron last week concluded a successful showing at IBC2023...
29/09/2023
Visit Matrox Video at Smart Building Expo 2023 in Hall 6P, Stand B37
Technology innovator Matrox Video today announced its lineup for the Smart Building Expo 2...