TOWER OF BABEL?
File-based camera systems bring equal parts creativity and chaos, as Guild camera teams decipher how to keep the many different workflows on track
by Chris Wolski for ICG Magazine - April 2011
Dean Semler, ACS, ASC
Photo by Andrew Cooper
File-based camera systems have been a staple of television production for a number of years now, and thanks to systems like the Genesis, RED, and the ALEXA, feature-film productions are also benefiting from the technological boom.
But as with any evolutionary (some would say revolutionary) change, there have been unintended consequences. Like creating a veritable Tower of Babel of mixed digital codecs in the world of postproductions, not to mention the challenge for Guild cinematographers on the set trying to safeguard the image down through the pipeline.
With each new and unique file-based language have come secret sauces, developed by post vendors to cope with the plethora of formats. Whatever the technical outcomes may be, the key to working in today's file-based world is flexibility and creativity; cinematographers now have a host of decisions to make when choosing a camera, always knowing in the back of their minds that they may be opening the door to an unfamiliar workflow and new headaches somewhere down the line.
Guild cinematographer James Mathers was an early adopter of RED, and knows all too well the consequences of picking a radically new camera system. While Mathers says he loved the filmic results of the first REDs, the results were hardly without tradeoffs.
Only a few places in town knew what they were doing, Mathers recounts. RED didn't fit into the same post-production workflow as other cameras, although now a lot more places are up to speed and can handle it.
Other new file-based systems on the scene include ARRI's ALEXA, celebrated for its huge dynamic range and ultra-low light sensitivity. Hitting the market just last June, the camera has been eagerly embraced by Local 600 camera crews. A big reason why was ARRI's commitment to designing a file-based system that looked and felt like a traditional film camera and imitated a film workflow, describes ARRI president and CEO Glenn Kennel. Likewise for Panavision , which has been trying (reps say) to ease the chaos of an all-file based set with products like its Digital Transfer Station (DTS), designed to help manage the transition of images to post-production more easily and smoothly. The DTS is a complimentary product to Panavision's Solid State Recorder (SSR) and provides consistency throughout the production workflow. The DTS takes uncompressed content from the SSR and outputs DPX or QuickTime files while offering production the option to simultaneously generate a backup tape. The system also helps to accelerate the delivery of off-line files for the editorial process, and, because it generates a DPX file, makes handling visual effects much easier.
All the cinematographers polled for this article say that if there is one single lesson to be gleaned from working in a file-based world, it's that there is no one single approach that will work for everyone. Patrick Cady, a Guild shooter who has worked in both features (Lottery Ticket, Girl Fight) and television (In Treatment, Uncle Nigel) says planning and patience were the virtues that got him through a show packed with an array of file formats.
It is so important when using blended digital formats like the Canon 7D and 5Ds we alternated with the Sony F35 on my last show to get post-production involved early and completely, Cady explains. I was already familiar with mixing the formats and a post chain that took the Canon footage and allowed it to be used in a final DaVinci-based color correct. The 7D and [1080P] GoPro footage was imported off the memory cards into the Clipster and converted into a DPX file. This takes roughly twice as long as the footage's run time. It was then output onto an HDCam SR tape, at real time, so all told it took three hours for an hour of footage on the 7D to get ready for color.
Nancy Schreiber, ASC has worked on plenty of studio and independent productions (Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2, Fugly) using a variety of formats and systems, including the Panavision GENESIS, the Sony F35, RED One, the Panasonic 3700, The Sony PVW 800, ALEXA, and the Canon 5D and 7D.
It is important for me to have a DIT to help ensure that my LUTs or looks are getting translated into post for dailies, as well as onto video village monitors to ensure everyone knows the intention of the show's look, Schreiber says. On low budget films, having a DIT is a non-existent luxury so I do it myself, but I make sure the data downloader is a qualified technician. The files are, after all, our negatives.
Another digital capture veteran, Dean Semler, ACS, ASC, describes file-based systems as having allowed him to sleep more soundly during complex location shoots like Apocalypto or last year's Secretariat. Semler has famously embraced Panavision's Genesis system, having used it on his last seven movies and counting. Semler says he relied on Panavision cameras in his celluloid days and that loyalty has paid off with troublefree shoots in the more challenging file-based landscape.
The Genesis has been the best of both worlds for me, Semler states. Ergonomically, it's like a traditional film camera, and delivers images matching the best 35mm film stocks,
yet it gives me the many advantages of high-end digital image capture, such as high ISO speeds, long running time and instant dailies.
Semler's smooth workflow results are a testament to his long-standing relationship with one post-house, EFILM. The company has created a workflow - in conjunction with Panavision's DTS - that gives the cinematographer complete trust in his images.
They
Most recent headlines
11/12/2025
Dalet, a leading provider of cloud-native, end-to-end media workflow solutions, ...
02/12/2025
Case Study: How Mid-Atlantic Sports Network Moved to All-IP Distribution in 60 D...
02/12/2025
2025 Sports Broadcasting Hall of Fame: Lee Corso, Coach, Commentator, FirebrandBy Ken Kerschbaumer
Tuesday, December 2, 2025 - 7:00 am
Print This Story | S...
02/12/2025
SVG All-Stars: Dan Nabors, Senior Director, Remote Engineering, TNT SportsThe veteran tech leader is helping guide Warner Bros. Discovery's at-home' re...
02/12/2025
National Lacrosse League Opens Season With New Cloud-Based Official Replay-Revie...
02/12/2025
Platinum White Paper: The Cinematic Look in Live Production - Bridging Aesthetic...
02/12/2025
SVG India Announces Advisory Board; JioStar's Prashant Khanna Named ChairmanBy Ken Kerschbaumer
Tuesday, December 2, 2025 - 11:15 am
Print This Story |...
02/12/2025
SVG Summit 2025 Preview: New AI Production Tools Workshop' Features ESPN, F...
02/12/2025
Written and directed by Hailey Gates, Atropia won the U.S. Grand Jury Prize: Dramatic at the 2025 Sundance Film Festival....
02/12/2025
The lightweight and highly portable CORVUS-RAVEN, recently demonstrated at the V...
02/12/2025
The lightweight, rugged Panther 2 tri-band VSAT delivers high-speed data communications for Internet, VPN connectivity and video transmission over commercial an...
02/12/2025
eds3_5_jq(document).ready(function($) { $(#eds_sliderM519).chameleonSlider_2_1({...
02/12/2025
NGID volunteers in the United States
NGID volunteers in Mexico
NGID volunteers in India
NGID volunteers in Spain
NGID volunteers in Australia
NGID voluntee...
02/12/2025
WASHINGTON The Federal Communications Commission's Media Bureau has issued a reminder that stations in DMAs 111 through 120 must implement its audio descrip...
02/12/2025
SAN DIEGO Sony Electronics today introduced the Alpha 7 V (ILCE-7M5), the fifth generation of its Alpha 7 full-frame mirrorless lineup, powered by the newly dev...
02/12/2025
WASHINGTON The Federal Communications Commission has opened a docket for comments on Nexstar Media Group's proposed $6.2 billion acquisition of Tegna and se...
02/12/2025
WASHINGTON The National Association of Broadcasters has added a trio of media executives, Veronica Rodriguez, Matt Schnaars and Jeff Warshaw, to its board of di...
02/12/2025
MILAN, Italy Brightcove has released seven new features designed to expand global reach, improve audience engagement, enhance live-streaming quality and streaml...
02/12/2025
BCNEXXT, the developers of the advanced playout platform Vipe, today announced a new Service Provider Partner agreement with NPC Media, the Australian managed p...
02/12/2025
DPA Microphones today announces the immediate availability of its new N-Series Digital Wireless Microphone System for customers throughout the U.S. In addition ...
02/12/2025
Hiltron Communications reports a well attended and successful Space Tech Expo exhibition, held at the Messe Bremen from Tuesday November 18 through Thursday Nov...
02/12/2025
The beginning of September saw Riverfire by Australian Retirement Trust, in association with Channel 9 and Triple M, kick off the 2025 Brisbane Festival in spec...
02/12/2025
SGM Lighting is pleased to announce an exciting new partnership with ACT Entertainment, under which ACT will serve as the exclusive distributor for SGM's ne...
02/12/2025
Harmonic (NASDAQ: HLIT) today announced that Telia, the second largest telecom operator in Norway, is modernizing its broadband network with the company's i...
02/12/2025
European cloud data protection specialist Keepit is expanding its sales network in the DACH region and has gained TIM AG, one of the leading value-added distrib...
02/12/2025
Featured products at ISE 2026
This year s ISE 2026 theme "Push Beyond" reflects Calrec s direction of travel. The company is dedicated to supporting the AV an...
02/12/2025
Czech Television, the national public broadcaster, has deployed one of the largest LiveU live production projects in the region for live sports and news coverag...
02/12/2025
Test & measurement innovator, Leader Electronics, has announced the release of v8.2 software for its ZEN and ZEN-W Series, bringing advanced cinematic camera se...
02/12/2025
Global provider of video streaming software and services, Accedo, and OTT platform provider, Magine Pro, have signed a binding agreement to carve out and merge ...
02/12/2025
With proven success in broadcast, OTT, and content supply chains, K.S Avinash set to scale Skandha's service-first approach across APAC
Skandha Media Servi...
02/12/2025
AJA Video Systems has joined the RAVENNA community, a network of partners devoted to advancing the RAVENNA standard for distributing real-time audio over intern...
02/12/2025
HUNT VALLEY, Md. Sinclair and its wholly-owned subsidiary One Media Technologies have released a new report focused on how ATSC 3.0, the IP-based NextGen TV sta...
02/12/2025
WASHINGTON The Federal Communications Commission's Media Bureau has issued a reminder that stations in DMAs 111 through 120 must implement its audio descrip...
02/12/2025
WASHINGTON Members of the Advanced Television Systems Committee have elected four industry veterans to three-year terms on the organization's board of direc...
02/12/2025
A new survey from S&P Global Market Intelligence Kagan highlights how important social media is for younger consumers, with Gen Z spending 5.1 hours a day on so...
02/12/2025
Faculty Notes: Fall/Winter 2025 Recent accomplishments, releases, and events by Berklee faculty.
December 1, 2025
By
Editorial Staff
The cast of Kind of M...
02/12/2025
Ring In The Holidays With Our Biggest Sale Ever On Ivory II Pianos!From now until December 31st, you can save 50% or more on every Ivory II piano and collection...
02/12/2025
Back to All News
Made in America: How Stranger Things' Electrified the US Economy
Entertainment
02 December 2025
GlobalUnited States
Link copied to cl...
02/12/2025
Back to All News
Culinary Class Wars' Season 2 Trailer Teases New Rules, R...
02/12/2025
--
The International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC), the International Organization for Standardization (ISO), and the International Telecommunication Unio...
02/12/2025
Harmonic's cOS Platform Will Redefine Subscribers' Quality of Experience, Lowering Churn SAN JOSE, Calif. - Dec. 2, 2025 - Harmonic (NASDAQ: HLIT) today...
02/12/2025
At AWS re:Invent, NVIDIA and Amazon Web Services expanded their strategic collab...
02/12/2025
S an Nollaig
Hollywood blockbusters The Banshees of Inisherin, Barbie and Oppenheimer make their Irish TV debut
Tune into the classics such as Love Actual...
02/12/2025
Showcasing fresh Irish storytelling and emerging talent Storyland 2025 signals a fantastic time for Irish drama
RT and F s ireann/Screen Ireland are proud to...
01/12/2025
L3Harris and PentenAmio formalise their teaming agreement at MilCIS 2025, streng...
01/12/2025
Artemis II is NASA's first crewed flight test of the Space Launch System rocket and Orion spacecraft. The crew, from left: Commander Reid Wiseman, Pilot Vic...
01/12/2025
IRVINE, Calif. Wooden Camera has introduced its new Accessory Collection for the Canon EOS C50. The new lineup includes a low-profile, gimbal-ready cage, expand...
01/12/2025
WASHINGTON The Federal Communications Commission has released a tentative agenda for its Dec. 18 Open Commission Meeting that will include a vote on a report an...
01/12/2025
In most years, a graph of annual local TV ad spending is about as predictable as an electrocardiogram of a reasonably healthy patient in a doctor's office. ...
TOWER OF BABEL?
