Port of Stockton. Photo: Shelah, some rights reserved.
Stockton is embroiled in controversy over a proposal to change the way it disinfects North Stockton's drinking water. Some observers, such as celebrity environmental activist Erin Brockovich, charge that the citys proposed switch from chlorine to chloramines poses a serious public health risk similar to that seen in Flint, Michigan. But water quality experts working in and around Stockton and the Delta see the real threat to Stocktons water supply coming from substantial exports of water out of the Delta.
Those experts point to a looming project that may make Stockton's water a lot worse, and it isn't adding chloramines. It's Governor Jerry Browns Water Fix : two tunnels that would siphon water from the Sacramento River for transport south before it has the chance of entering the Delta system.
--
--
San Joaquin County's largest city and its residents aren't new to the California water wars scene. Public anxiety and mistrust of Stockton officials over water issues - on display at a recent town hall meeting - had its groundwork laid back in 2002. That's when then-mayor Gary Podesto led the City Council in a vote to privatize the citys water company. The city council moved to privatize two weeks before a citizen driven referendum that would have given the citizens of Stockton the right to vote on the issue passed with over 60 percent voter approval.
The Concerned Citizens Coalition, the group that led the fight against privatization, then took the City to court. By 2008, after two court rulings found that the privatization contract violated state environmental laws, the water utility was back in public hands. But the damage to the utility - and to public trust - was done.
A 2014-2015 grand jury investigation found serious, ongoing problems within the operations of Stockton Municipal Utilities Department (MUD) because of three major events over the years, including privatizing MUD operations for several years, the City bankruptcy, and staff turnover that has undermined the utilitys institutional knowledge.
Community activist Motecuzoma Sanchez, a member of the citys Water Advisory Board, contends that there is a chronic undercurrent in Stockton of distrust of their city officials and elected politicians. Distrust is historic, says Sanchez, and most recently highlighted by the bankruptcy, high violent crime rates, and these Band-Aid approaches to fixing our citys issues.
It becomes easy to understand why, when celebrity environmental activist Erin Brockovich published a post on her Facebook page on January 16 warning Stockton that the city was on its way to becoming the next Flint, Michigan, the public outcry was loud and swift. Congratulations to the City of Stockton, California you're adding ammonia to your drinking water because you're too lazy and cheap to remove dirt (organics) from your water supplies, Brockovich wrote.
Photo: Images by John K, some rights reserved
One similarity that Flint and Stockton do share is that both cities are using degraded bodies of water for at least some of their drinking water supplies. Stockton originally relied on four sources for its drinking water; the Stanislaus, Calaveras, and Mokelumne rivers, and groundwater. In January 2015, when the Delta Water Supply Project (DWSP) treatment plant came online, Stockton started bringing in water from the Delta in order to supplement the citys supply.
Both Stockton and Flint use ozone and chlorine as water disinfectants. Both cities have, on a number of occasions, been found to exceed federal limits of trihalomethanes, created when chlorine reacts with organic matter, in their drinking water.
Chloramines disinfect water as effectively as chlorine, but produce lower levels of dangerous trihalomethanes. Cities in the East Bay have used chloramines to disinfect their water since 1998, and San Francisco switched from chlorine to chloramines in 2004. Chloramines are generally considered safe at concentrations used in drinking water supplies, though there have been anecdotal reports of rashes and other allergic reactions after contact with chloramine-treated water.
Barbara Barrigan-Parrilla, executive director for Restore the Delta (RTD), one of the largest Delta ecosystem advocacy groups, says that like Brockovich, RTD initially drew parallels between Flint and the Delta. But the group corrected course after a fuller picture of Flints crisis came into view. In Flint you are talking about criminal malfeasance, about a deliberate attempt to hide from the government what was happening, and a willful dismissal of warning signs and of tests that showed the lives of thousands of people were being ruined. We dont have that problem in Stockton.
If we believed the City of Stockton's treatment of drinking water was seriously violating the law... we would have already sued them.
Chloramines arent mentioned in the City of Flint 2014 Water Quality Report, in EPA memos addressing Flints lead contamination, or in the recommendations given to Flints mayor and City Council by Erin Brockovichs colleague Bob Bowcock. There is no indication that they were used as a disinfectant in Flints water.
In fact, in August of 2015 the City of Flint published an Operational Evaluation Report entitled Trihalomethane Formation Concern in which a switch to chloramines was described as deemed unnecessary.
Invoking Flint is a powerful way to spark fear, and the comparison between Flint and Stockton apparently stoked nervousness over chloramine use. On February 6, 1,200 concerned Stocktonians came to a water quality town hall meeting convened by mayor Anthony Silva and headlined by Erin Brockovich. Silva organized the meeting in response to Brockovichs social media comments about chloramines.
Barrigan-Parilla and Bill J
Most recent headlines
09/11/2025
Dalet today announced a transformative leap forward for media operations: Agentic Artificial Intelligence (AI) that unifies the Dalet ecosystem under one natura...
22/10/2025
The Orion spacecraft for NASA's Artemis II mission is stacked on the Space Launch System (SLS) rocket in High Bay 3 of the Vehicle Assembly Building at Kenn...
22/10/2025
L3Harris' Hybrid SATCOM is resilient by design, offering path diversity that eliminates vulnerabilities by routing data across the best available networks i...
22/10/2025
WASHINGTON, D.C. Organizers of NAB Show New York said they are expecting more than 12,000 registered attendees from about 100 countries along with 260 exhibitor...
22/10/2025
WASHINGTON, D.C The organizers of The 2025 NAB Show New York have announced that they are expecting more than 12,000 registered attendees from about 100 countr...
22/10/2025
Masque Sound, a leading theatrical sound reinforcement, installation and design company, supplied an extensive gear package of professional-grade equipment for ...
22/10/2025
Lightware, a global leader in signal management and AV connectivity solutions, is seeing strong market momentum for the UCX-3x3-TPX-RX20, a compact transmitter-...
22/10/2025
MELVILLE, N.Y. Chyron has released PAINT 10.2, the latest update for its telestration platform, adding support for SMPTE ST 2110 IP workflows, expanding brandin...
22/10/2025
WASHINGTON Run3TV today said NBCUniversal is joining as an investor in the ATSC 3.0 Framework Authority, which develops the Run3TV NextGen TV application platfo...
22/10/2025
ATLANTA swXtch.io will feature two new networking solutions extending the company's reach across more cloud and on-prem workflows at NAB Show New York, set ...
22/10/2025
The Warner Bros. Discoverys HBO Max streaming services has increased prices for all its streaming tiers effectively immediately for new customers. Existing cust...
22/10/2025
LOS ANGELES OpenDrives has signed a new distribution partnership deal with Versatile Distribution Services (VDS) to strengthen its channel and streamline how it...
22/10/2025
WASHINGTON, D.C The organizers of The 2025 NAB Show New York have announced that they are expecting more than 12,000 registered attendees from about 100 countr...
22/10/2025
Samora Pinderhughes Brings Immersive Sound to Berklee's Signature Series The artist and composer, who's worked with Herbie Hancock, Robert Glasper, Co...
22/10/2025
BMI Day at Berklee Celebrates Composer Fil Eisler and Awards Scholarship to Stud...
22/10/2025
Rohde & Schwarz and TRUMPF cooperate in drone defense Rohde & Schwarz and TRUMPF partner to deliver a comprehensive drone defense solution combining Rohde & S...
22/10/2025
European Broadcaster Upgrades To Grass Valley's NativeIP LDX 135 Cameras And...
22/10/2025
Everyone Gets a Better Deal on Verizon with New FOX One Perk The $15 FOX One streaming service perk is yet another way Verizon continues to add savings for cu...
22/10/2025
First Look Hidden Assets Series 3
Premieres on 9th November 9:30pm on RT One & RT Player
WATCH HERE Promo Link: Hidden Assets Series 3 | RT
The Crimin...
21/10/2025
NAB New York 2025: Although AES Show Is on Its Own, Audio Will Be a Major Part o...
21/10/2025
NAB New York 2025: Business of Broadcast and Media,' Future of Content'...
21/10/2025
SVG All-Stars: Ethan Folz, Senior Director, Digital Operations and Quality of Ex...
21/10/2025
NBA on NBC/Peacock: Livestream Offers Graphic Overlays, Predictive Gaming, Ancil...
21/10/2025
NBA on NBC/Peacock: At the Front Bench With Producer Frank DiGraci and Director ...
21/10/2025
NBA on NBC/Peacock: NBC Sports, NEP Build Ultra-Flexible Production Plan That Se...
21/10/2025
Indigenous storytelling has been at the heart of the work of the Sundance Instit...
21/10/2025
Top L-R: Mysterious Skin, American Dream Second Row L-R: Little Miss Sunshine, D...
21/10/2025
Last week, Spotify and Columbia Records transformed Pier 4 at the Brooklyn Army ...
21/10/2025
SBS Learn's Dharug Ngurra resource empowers classrooms to meaningfully celeb...
21/10/2025
As global operators simplify and evolve their digital platforms, NPS improvement...
21/10/2025
Critical Design Review completion is a key milestone on the path toward Wideband Global Satellite Communications certification for the network in 2026, opening ...
21/10/2025
New Australian undersea training range to implement and improve warfighting tactics, proficiency and safety; enable joint/allied training that contributes to pr...
21/10/2025
eds3_5_jq(document).ready(function($) { $(#eds_sliderM519).chameleonSlider_2_1({...
21/10/2025
September, the beginning of autumn, brought an expected revival to the TV market, largely due to the new fall TV schedules. The time spent in front of the TV sc...
21/10/2025
Broadcast Booms with 20% Uptick vs. August, Achieving Largest Monthly
Increase ...
21/10/2025
During September, streaming's share of TV viewing in Mexico settled at 24.5%, a marginal shift of -0.5 share points from the previous month.
Disclaimer: YU...
21/10/2025
RENNES, France BBright and GlobalM have conducted a technical trial validating Ultra HD interoperability across the entire contribution chain in the cloud, achi...
21/10/2025
Kokusai Denki Electric America will mark the U.S. debut of a new 4K camera at the 2025 NAB New York, Oct. 22-23. Now available, the Z-HD6500-S1 UHD/HD productio...
21/10/2025
Triveni Digital, a trusted leader in ATSC 1.0 and 3.0 service delivery, data broadcasting, and quality assurance solutions, will showcase its entire NEXTGEN TV ...
21/10/2025
Radio Azzurra FM, longest-running radio station in the province of Novara, northwest Italy, has invested in an DHD SX2 audio routing and mixing console for inte...
21/10/2025
Globecast, the leading provider of broadcast, media and entertainment managed services, has announced the appointment of G Morgan as Executive Vice President of...
21/10/2025
Visual Data announces the appointment of Maz Al-Jumaili as Senior Vice President, Worldwide Localization, to advance client engagement, strategic partnerships, ...
21/10/2025
As Amazon's Prime Video prepares to launch its coverage of NBA basketball under a major new deal, Grup Mediapro has announced that it is working with the st...
21/10/2025
ATLANTA Good news for consumers using an Atlanta DTH receiver to watch ATSC 3.0: with a new software update, they will be able to blanket their homes with Wi-Fi...
21/10/2025
While recent news has been heavily focused on Hispanic migration into the U.S., The 2025 Hispanic Market Report from Claritas highlights the fact that this gr...
21/10/2025
MAIDENHEAD, UK RWS has hired Michael Wayne as its head of media and entertainment in Los Angeles where he will lead the company's media localization busines...
21/10/2025
Imagine Communications and Rohde & Schwarz today announced a definitive agreement under which Imagine will acquire Pixel Power Limited, a wholly owned subsidiar...
21/10/2025
Atlanta DTH (ADTH) today announced a major update that will expand the functionality of its NEXTGEN TV receiver by enabling gateway capabilities allowing viewer...
21/10/2025
Heartland Video Systems, Inc. (HVS), a premier video systems integration, consulting, and expert ATSC 3.0 implementation firm announces that it has partnered wi...
Port of Stockton. Photo: Shelah, some rights reserved.
