SVG Sit-Down: Calrec's Dave Letson on the Arrival of IP Audio-Signal Transport Standards and protocols, better control, more training are the main challenges By Dan Daley, Audio Editor
Tuesday, August 28, 2018 - 12:59 pm
Print This Story
Story Highlights
The transition to IP signal transport for broadcast audio is taking place surprisingly quickly, although not everyone on this field of play is necessarily ready for it. The alignment between industry technical standards and proprietary protocols, the increasing need for better network control, and the paucity of training are just a few of the challenges facing broadcasters as they go about implementing IP. SVG sat down with Calrec VP, Sales, Dave Letson to discuss these and other issues facing broadcasters transitioning to IP.
Calrec's Dave Letson: The primary challenge has really been in aligning to standards.
The shift to AoIP seems to have occurred rather quickly, although we know that AES67 and the SMPTE ST-2110 suite of standards were years in development. Looking back on recent history, what would you say have been the salient points of this transition?
From an audio perspective, AoIP has been happening slowly over a long number of years. Fifteen years ago, Calrec, like many companies, had proprietary-based audio-over-IP solutions. The drivers then are still very much the same: customers want to move away from expensive, point-to-point cable runs. The attractiveness is to have a network of different devices coexisting on a cheaper infrastructure that is flood-wired in the building and connected on commercial off-the-shelf switches. The advance of switch technology now allows for much more bandwidth, and it's only in recent years that the broadcast industry has been able to move large numbers of HD video channels across an enterprise-level network.
What were the challenges in transitioning broadcast audio's main product platforms - consoles and routing, in Calrec's case - to AoIP, and what are the challenges still to be met?
The primary challenge has really been in aligning to standards. All those proprietary network systems had to move over to competing standards, and those had their uses and benefits. However, the relatively recent shift to SMPTE-2110 has started to move more towards interoperability.
The challenge now is to provide a level of control over all of these elemental audio, video, and data streams on a broadcast network. The NMOS-04 and NMOS-05 standards start to bring that much closer to reality. However, it is not yet fully adopted, and there is a lack of available stream-management tools. This was the primary reason Calrec created Calrec Connect, our own stream manager leveraging NMOS-IS04 and NMOS-IS05. This, however, is just the beginning. Broadcasters will demand truly interoperable systems that can provide deeper integration of device-level controls. I believe that is our next big challenge as an industry.
What's the status of implementation for AoIP into remote-production vans? The leading providers of those environments have developed pilot examples for integrating AoIP into remote broadcast, but that's a market sector historically slow to change (and for good reasons). What is the narrative for this?
I think it's mostly the old adage that, if it's not broken, why fix it. With the adoption of IP in an OB van, you gain the same benefits of a large broadcast facility. Everything is self-contained, on short cable runs within the truck. Then, there is the literally dirty side of life on an OB truck, like fault finding in the pouring rain at 10 p.m. on a Saturday evening. The maintenance and support tools just aren't there yet. IP fault-finding is new to pretty much all of us. EICs on trucks need to get on with doing the job. The show must go on!
However, this is changing. Companies like NEP and Game Creek are migrating to products like Evertz EXE-VSR routers, not necessarily just because it's IP but because they can no longer build systems large enough on baseband equipment and the prospect of deeper integration of control is also attractive.
How will AoIP impact deployment of at-home-production practices?
In the short term, not very much. AES67 isn't really suited to WAN networks; companies will still want to use J2K codecs or products like Net Insight's Nimbra, [which] allow all of the audio and video to be packaged together and sent back in sync. In the longer term, as the whole industry starts to understand how to work with SMPTE 2110 and AES67 networks, there will be a natural extension to move to WAN networks over longer distances.
Has development of training around AoIP in general and various specific AoIP-enabled products been keeping up with their implementation? For instance, in a related development, Dolby contracted with a for-profit technical academy to develop an online syllabus to provide instruction for its Atmos format. How is the broadcast-audio industry responding to the challenge of training?
Unfortunately, we don't think there is enough IP training to keep up with implementation. There is a distinct lack of knowledge in the market today. However, this is a good thing, because the broadcast engineer's skill set is expanding. There are many opportunities for experienced broadcast engineers to embark on training opportunities: for example, the Cisco CCNA training. This tests a candidate's knowledge and skills required to install, operate, and troubleshoot a small to medium-size branch network and covers topics like routing and switching fundamentals, WAN technologies, determining IP routes, managing IP traffic with access lists, and establishing point-to-point connections.
Where does Networked Media Open Specifications (NMOS) fit into the AoIP narrative? Specifically, NMOS for Discovery and Registration (IS-04),
Most recent headlines
04/08/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, is excited to announce Santiago Solanas as its new Chief Executive Officer (CEO)....
03/06/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, a...
30/04/2024
By Adam Piron
In anticipation of this edition of the Indigenous Program's Native Lab, it actually dawned on me that this will be our lab's tenth year i...
30/04/2024
Launch of SBS South Asian channel and SBS Spice, a new English language offering...
30/04/2024
LOS ANGELES (April 30, 2024) Light Iron, the post-production creative-services division of Panavision, is excited to announce that lodie Ichter has joined th...
30/04/2024
Now streaming on Netflix, Good Grief marks the feature-film directorial debut of Daniel Levy, well known as the co-creator and costar of the series Schitt's...
30/04/2024
The Forsyte Saga, John Galsworthy's sweeping portrait of a wealthy British family in 1880s London, is getting its third TV adaptation in less than 60 years....
30/04/2024
eds3_5_jq(document).ready(function($) { $(#eds_sliderM519).chameleonSlider_2_1({...
30/04/2024
CAMPBELL, Calif. Streaming media company Plex and T-Mobile will work together to expand T-Mobile's connected TV (CTV) inventory and advance the connection b...
30/04/2024
SAN JOSE, Calif. & BELLEVUE, Wash. Roku, Inc. has announced an expanded measurement partnership with iSpot.tv, the cross-platform TV measurement company....
30/04/2024
NEW YORK As Paramount Global wrestled with management turmoil and ongoing negotiations for a proposed merger with Skydance, the company managed to report improv...
30/04/2024
Cobalt Digital Receives Trifecta of Awards at NAB 2024
Company adds two 2024 NAB Show Product of the Year awards and one Best of Show from TV Tech to long list...
30/04/2024
arkona technologies GmbH, provider of IP core infrastructure solutions for top-tier broadcast productions, has announced that its BLADE//runner IP Audio Engine ...
30/04/2024
OpenDrives, Inc., the global provider of software-defined media workflow solutions and data management capabilities, announced today that it has joined the glob...
30/04/2024
The first norm conform sustainability service dedicated to the needs of the events industry
Easy-to-use, intuitive platform for venues, event organisers and su...
30/04/2024
Dejero GateWay enables Stream7 to create independent internet connectivity at any venue or location, including UK teaching hospital for live streaming of surgic...
30/04/2024
Excitement is building as farmerswife, a leading software provider for resource scheduling, project management, and team collaboration in the media industry, ha...
30/04/2024
XL8, a leading deep-tech startup specializing in AI-powered machine translation technology, proudly announces the successful completion of a System and Organiza...
30/04/2024
Test & measurement innovator, Leader Electronics of Europe, has announced that it will exhibit at CABSAT, which takes place this year from 21-23 May 2024 at the...
30/04/2024
MRMC Debuts Cinebot Max Camera Robot at NAB 2024
Brie Clayton April 30, 2024
0 Comments
Expands its range of live-action, motion-control camera robots...
30/04/2024
Next Jazz Legacy Announces 2024 Cohort of Women and Nonbinary Awardees The program was created by New Music USA and the Berklee Institute of Jazz and Gender J...
30/04/2024
European telecom satellite company SES announced today that it is acquiring rival Intelsat for $3.1 billion. The deal, unanimously approved by both companies...
30/04/2024
Bob Bakish, chief executive of Paramount stepped down on Monday, effective immediately. Bakish, who was a staunch ally of Shari Redstone, controlling shareholde...
30/04/2024
Hotspring said the breakthrough had been achieved through the acceleration of machine learning technology
By Matthew Corrigan
Published: April 30, 2024
Ho...
30/04/2024
Speaking about the deal, Adel Al-Saleh, CEO of SES, said: it will bring value-added, efficient, and reliable offerings for both companies media customers
By Je...
30/04/2024
Paramount said the Office of the CEO is working with its board to develop a comp...
30/04/2024
LOUISVILLE, Ky. In another sign that broadcasters are finally using NextGen TV broadcasts to offer viewers new features instead of simply simulcasting existing ...
30/04/2024
OKLAHOMA CITY The Oklahoma Journalism Hall of Fame will induct Blaise Labbe, a group news director for Sinclair Broadcast Group, May 2 at the 54th Anniversary I...
30/04/2024
ATLANTA and ENGLEWOOD, Colo. Cox Media Group and Dish have ended a dispute over retransmission fees that lasted nearly a year and a half with a new multi-year ...
30/04/2024
Video transport solution provider LTN has announced that it is working with TelevisaUnivision to help the Spanish-language media giant migrate to IP-based video...
30/04/2024
ALAMEDA, Calif. Clear-Com has released details about how it played a pivotal role in the seamless coverage of the recent solar eclipse on April 8, 2024 by NBC K...
30/04/2024
CINCINNATI The E.W. Scripps Company is adding Seth Walters to its sales leadership team as head of CTV sales, effective April 29....
30/04/2024
The force was strong at the Durham Bulls Athletic Park on Saturday night, April 27, 2024, as the night netted the ballpark's first official sellout crowd of...
30/04/2024
Revry, a network celebrating queer culture. said its second annual NewFront presentation will be a cabaret-type spectacle showcasing the spirit of the LGBTQ+ co...
30/04/2024
Family Entertainment Television (FETV) said that the Western series The Life and Legend of Wyatt Earp will be joining the network's afternoon lineup startin...
30/04/2024
Bob Bakish, president and CEO of Paramount Global, will depart the company as Paramount explores a merger, according to numerous published reports. The reports ...
30/04/2024
April 30th, 2024 Press Materials Available Here
TRIBECA FESTIVAL 2024 ANNOUNCES TALKS, REUNIONS, & RETROSPECTIVES
Live Conversations with Judd Apatow, Andy C...
30/04/2024
6 minute read
Share
alt=Alternative descriptive text class=lazyload main main-lazyloaded responsive-image data-v-1a5ebb10>
Telenor showed good momentum...
30/04/2024
SES Acquiring Intelsat to Create New Satellite Giant; Will Offer Improved Reach ...
30/04/2024
Wuppertal April 30, 2024
WDR Filmhaus to Implement Riedel Infrastructure Award-Winning MediorNet HorizoN Hybrid Processing Platform Serves as Bridge to IP
Ri...
30/04/2024
Back to All News
Tilda Swinton Joins Colin Farrell in Edward Bergers The Ballad...
30/04/2024
Back to All News
Netflix Reveals First Look Images and Teaser from Senna, Inspi...
30/04/2024
Back to All News
Top 10 Week of Apr. 22: Baby Reindeer' and Rebel Moon - ...
30/04/2024
Dr. Nicola Hodson, Chief Executive, IBM UK & Ireland introduces the UK findings of an IBM study on female leadership in the age of AI
Advances in Artificial In...
30/04/2024
Channel Expansion, and New Codecs, Compression and Transport Technology Among Latest Updates...
30/04/2024
Accel-KKR Credit Partners today announced that it has provided debt financing to support Dalet in its next chapter of innovation and growth. Accel-KKR Credit Pa...
30/04/2024
Skeem Saam: Monday's episode, 29 April 2024 [video]Missed an episode of Skeem Saam? No problem! Watch the latest episode of your favourite South African soa...
30/04/2024
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Lewatle witnesses an explosive fight between Sthoko and B...
30/04/2024
RT News is pleased to announce the appointment of David Murphy as its new Economics & Public Affairs Correspondent. David is currently RT 's Political Cove...
SVG Sit-Down: Calrec's Dave Letson on the Arrival of IP Audio-Signal Transport Standards and protocols, better control, more training are the main challenges By Dan Daley, Audio Editor 
