Sony Pixel Power calrec Sony

Mother and her autistic son call on Department of Health to apologise after compiling a secret dossier on them

28/09/2023

Mother and her autistic son call on Department of Health to apologise after compiling a secret dossier on them

Unlawful things happened Deputy Data Protection Commissioner

RT Investigates report following Whistleblower Disclosure

A mother and her autistic son who discovered that the Department of Health had been keeping a secret dossier on them have told RT Investigates they have never had an apology despite the Data Protection Commissioner (DPC) ruling this summer that it amounted to serious interference, and which resulted in the DPC imposing a fine on the Department of Health. Speaking publicly for the first time in an RT Investigates report to be broadcast on Prime Time tonight at 9.35pm on RT One and RT Player, the family describe how the revelations have impacted on them.

When Adam Keogh was just 5 years old, his family had been among several families who took legal action against the State to secure special needs education for their children. Their case was not for compensation but to secure special needs supports in primary school. Adam got some supports and the case lay dormant. But 12 years later the Department of Health continued to work on its legal strategy to manage the cases taken by the families. Without telling the families or getting their consent, the Department of Health went to the HSE and asked for what it had on file on the dormant cases, including medical notes.

The sharing of their private patient information would have remained secret had it not been for a whistleblower in the Department of Health. In 2020, Shane Corr a senior civil servant, realised he could see the families' files. Of greater concern to him was the fact that he could read everything that transpired in a private consultation between members of the Keogh family and their HSE doctor.

Shane Corr: I saw something that frankly I can only describe as shocking. I saw an email from an official at the Department of Health to a doctor who is working for the HSE explaining that they were involved in litigation with one of her patients and asking for information from this doctor. There was no way once I saw the piece of correspondence from the Department saying, we're asking for information from you about a child but we're not going to ask for consent to get it', I was ever going to let that lie.

The Department of Health had obtained documents which contained confidential and sensitive details from a consultation between the Keogh Family and their HSE doctor without the family's knowledge or permission. Senior civil servant Shane Corr tried to raise his concerns. Then, in March 2021, he became a whistleblower and revealed to RT Investigates that highly confidential information on the wellbeing of people and their families was shared, and stored, in departmental dossiers. The information was to be used tactically to decide the most opportune time to settle or reactivate long-dormant High Court cases. The people involved, who had been diagnosed with autism, had not been informed. Neither had their parents.

Following Shane Corr's disclosures and the RT broadcast, the Department of Health said what had been done was part of normal litigation and was entirely lawful, proper and appropriate.

In an Oireachtas Health Committee on May 5, 2021, Sinn F in TD David Cullinane raised the issue: Some information of a very serious and sensitive medical and educational nature was being held on children, and that was being collected, in some instances without, in my view, the knowledge of the parents involved.

Robert Watt, Secretary General of the Department of Health replied: I am sorry, but the Deputy is now repeating once again allegations which are not true and which we have comprehensively addressed as being not true. We have set out more than 100 pages of documents that set out the position here, and what the Deputy has said is just not true. It is regrettable that motivation has been twisted in a way to suggest something untoward was being done by officials, when they were trying to close cases which have gone on for too long and in which it was in the interest of all parties that they be closed.

He also told the Oireachtas Health Committee that on the eve of the RT Investigates report he sought to intervene directly and called the then Director General of RT . We did not believe the allegations were correct, and I set out why we did not believe they were, and that I did not think it was appropriate for RT to make such serious allegations. RT however broadcast the report as planned.

After the broadcast, Robert Watt personally wrote to those who were potentially impacted to reassure them that the information was consistent with, and typical of, the sort of information which arises in litigation. He said Shane Corr's disclosures had already been examined and there was no basis to suggest wrongdoing .

But separately the Data Protection Commissioner had begun its own inquiry. Just one week after the RT broadcast, the DPC went into the Department of Health to see did the files reported on actually exist. This summer the Data Protection Commission's decision was published.

The report says the Department's practices were excessive, lacked transparency, and had no clear policy. The DPC report also criticised the level to which people in the Department of Health, with no involvement in litigation, could access the electronic files.

Tony Delaney, Deputy Data Protection Commissioner: Our decision says unlawful things happened from a data protection perspective. They broke the law, they've been penalized for it, they've been reprimanded for it. There's a ban on processing which took immediate effect. The Department got caught out very badly in this case, but others could be doing the very same thing today. And that's why they all need
LINK: https://about.rte.ie/2023/09/28/mother-and-her-autistic-son-call-on-de...
See more stories from rte

More from RTE

20/05/2024

First European Election Major TV Debate this Monday Night on Upfront with Katie Hannon

As part of RT 's extensive coverage in the run up to the European Parliament...

17/05/2024

RT'S Operation Transformation comes to a close after 17 seasons

RT has today announced that Operation Transformation (OT) is to end after 17 seasons. As series come to an end each year, RT undertakes an editorial review to...

16/05/2024

Cruinni na ng 2024 - a day of free creative activity for young people

RT is supporting Cruinni na n g with a nationwide campaign on television, radio, online and digital. For a full listing of all activities and information on h...

14/05/2024

PJ Gallagher explores Ireland's fight for mental wellness in new RT documentary, PJ Gallagher: Changing My Mind

Comedian PJ Gallagher turns mental health warrior in PJ Gallagher: Changing My M...

13/05/2024

Ballyduff Drama Group hailing from Co. Waterford Scoops Top Award in 2024 RT All Ireland Drama Festival

RT Marks 20 Years as Title Sponsor of the Festival with special anniversary vid...

13/05/2024

New landmark documentary series Stardust on RT One and RT Player

New compelling eye-witness testimony of Stardust fire in RT documentary Series filmed over three years includes interview with Charlie Bird filmed in 2021 N...

09/05/2024

RT Supporting the Arts: What's On this May

RT Supporting the Arts: What's On this May Watch our YouTube promo here This May RT is delighted to support Dublin Dance Festival along with 20 other ar...

08/05/2024

Doireann Garrihy to leave RT 2FM

RT has today announced that Doireann Garrihy has decided to leave RT 2FM after five years. Doireann will present her final 2FM Breakfast with Doireann, Donncha...

07/05/2024

RT welcomes publication of reports

RT has today welcomed the publication of three reports by the Minister for Tourism, Culture, Arts, Gaeltacht, Sports and the Media, Catherine Martin TD: The Re...

06/05/2024

RT Announces Series of Major TV Debates as part of its European Parliament Election Coverage

RT has announced details of its coverage across digital, TV and Radio in the ru...

01/05/2024

RT lyric fm turns 25!

RT lyric fm turns 25! Music station Where Life Sounds Better celebrates birthday with a gala concert RT lyric fm celebrates 25 years today Wednesday, ...

01/05/2024

The Dawn Chorus 2024: Sunday 5th May from midnight to 07:00

The Dawn Chorus 2024 Sunday 5th May from midnight to 07:00 on RT Radio 1 and RT Lyric FM & BBC Radio Wales Love nature, love the Dawn Chorus! Listen to th...

30/04/2024

RT All Ireland Drama Festival Schools Playwright Competition 2024 Winner Announced

Congratulations to Amelia O'Donnell from Loreto College, St Stephen's Gr...

30/04/2024

RT NEWS ANNOUNCES DAVID MURPHY AS NEW ECONOMICS & PUBLIC AFFAIRS CORRESPONDENT

RT News is pleased to announce the appointment of David Murphy as its new Economics & Public Affairs Correspondent. David is currently RT 's Political Cove...

30/04/2024

RT Concert Orchestra May and June 2024

Concerts in Limerick, Dublin, Carlow and Cork, including Marty in the Evening, Morricone and May the Fourth Be With You, celebrating the remarkable decade of th...

25/04/2024

AMATEUR DRAMA TAKES CENTRE STAGE AS RT ALL IRELAND DRAMA FESTIVAL LAUNCHES IN THE ABBEY THEATRE

Amateur drama took centre stage as the All Ireland Drama Festival was officially...

22/04/2024

Cian Cobhin's An Taobh Tuathail marks 25 years on air

An Taobh Tuathail (ATT), RT Raidi na Gaeltachta's flagship alternative radio, presented by Cian C obh in show turns 25 in May 2024. The acclaimed music ...

19/04/2024

RT NEWS ANNOUNCES SAMANTHA LIBRERI AS NEW EASTERN CORRESPONDENT

RT News is pleased to announce the appointment of RT journalist, Samantha Libreri, as Eastern Correspondent. Samantha will be reporting and providing analysis...

19/04/2024

Documentary Murder of a GAA Chairman' sheds light on the unanswered questions of the family of Sean Brown

Documentary Murder of a GAA Chairman sheds light on the unanswered questions of ...

18/04/2024

RT Prime Time experiment reveals disturbing content recommended to 13 year old TikTok users in Ireland

In response to growing concerns raised regarding the adverse impact of TikTok co...

18/04/2024

Remembering Alf McCarthy and Larry Masterson

We were saddened to learn this morning of the passing of our friend and former colleague, Alf McCarthy who died yesterday. We remember Alf as a popular present...

15/04/2024

Finalists Confirmed for 2024 RT All Ireland Drama Festival, as RT Celebrates 20 years as title sponsor

Three plays never-before performed will feature in the finals of the 2024 RT Al...

10/04/2024

WINNER OF RT ONE'S HOME OF THE YEAR 2024 REVEALED

Marty Campbell and Shane Murray have lifted the coveted Home of the Year 2024 trophy for their renovated 1920's terrace home in Dublin. In tonight's fi...

08/04/2024

its4women.ie SPONSOR OLIVER CALLAN ON RT RADIO 1

RT Media Sales today announced its4women.ie as the new sponsor of Oliver Callan on RT Radio 1 from Monday 8th April 2024. Oliver Callan's brand-new morni...

04/04/2024

RT Supporting the Arts: What's On this April

Watch our promo: RT Supporting the Arts | What's on This April RT is delighted to support the Incognito Art Sale for the Jack and Jill Children's Fou...

03/04/2024

RT announce new Irish teen drama Louise Lives Large: Eight-part series filmed in Kildare

RT 's biggest ever drama commission for young people, Louise Lives Large, la...

22/03/2024

RT kicks off Guinness Women's Six Nations coverage with France v Ireland

Watch all the games live across RT and Virgin Media Television from Saturday 23rd March All Ireland games live on RT Radio The Guinness Women's Six Nat...

21/03/2024

Award-winning Dizzy Deliveries confirmed for a new series on RTjr this April

Exclusive episode released to celebrate World Down Syndrome Day Award-winning children's series Dizzy Deliveries is back, with season two premiering on 15t...

20/03/2024

RT Winners at the RTS Ireland Awards

RT had six winners across ten categories at last night's RTS Ireland awards which took place in Dublin's Liberty Hall Theatre with host Dermot Whelan a...

15/03/2024

Celebrate the Best of Irish Culture with RT this St Patrick's Weekend

The Late Late Show hosts a world record attempt for the largest c il band performance Irish weekend sporting action from Six Nations to Allianz League Dancin...

13/03/2024

RT SHORT STORY COMPETITION 2024 OPEN FOR ENTRIES

TELL US YOUR (SHORT) STORIES The 2024 RT Short Story Competition is now open for entries. The RT Short Story Competition was set up in 1986 to honour wr...

12/03/2024

Statement by RT Director-General on the death of Charlie Bird

Kevin Bakhurst, Director-General of RT paid tribute to former RT journalist Charlie Bird following his death. We are all deeply saddened by the news of Char...

11/03/2024

Ireland's heartbreaking defeat to England draws average of almost 1 million viewers to RT2

Viewing numbers peak at 1.2m Additional 230,000 streams on RT Player Ireland...

08/03/2024

2024 Celtic Media Festival: RT drama Obituary nominated alongside Amazon Prime and BBC dramas

RT and independent Irish producers receive 19 Nominations for the 2024 Celtic...

08/03/2024

LONGEST FBI CASE RESOLVED BY RT PODCAST SERIES RUNAWAY JOE A FAMILY TORN APART REUNITED

The final episode of the RT true crime podcast series Runaway Joe uncovers new ...

07/03/2024

Cian Ducrot Voted RT Choice Music Prize Irish Song of The Year

Cian Ducrot Voted RT Choice Music Prize Irish Song of The Year Irish Album of The Year to be announced at Live Event in Vicar Street tonight Irish Artist of ...

05/03/2024

New RT lyric fm show on Sunday Afternoons with Simon Delaney

RT lyric fm has announced a new addition to their schedule, Sunday Afternoon with Simon Delaney. Join stage and screen actor Simon Delaney every Sunday afterno...

01/03/2024

HARRY CORRY SPONSOR LIVELINE ON RT RADIO 1

RT Media Sales has announced Harry Corry as new sponsor of Liveline on RTE Radio 1 from today, Friday 1 March 2024. When the nation has something to say, the...

01/03/2024

RT Announces Appointment of Mari Hurley as Chief Financial Officer

RT Announces Appointment of Mari Hurley as Chief Financial Officer RT is pleased to announce the appointment of Mari Hurley to the role of Chief Financial Of...

29/02/2024

Evelyn O'Rourke announced as RT Arts and Media Correspondent

RT News is pleased to announce Evelyn O'Rourke has been appointed as Arts and Media Correspondent following an internal competition. An award winning RT ...

23/02/2024

Statement by Kevin Bakhurst, Director-General of RT: Sin N Raghallaigh

In a note to the staff of RT this morning, Director-General, Kevin Bakhurst, said: It is with deep regret that I share with you the announcement by Si n N R...

22/02/2024

RT Choice Music Prize Classic Irish Album Announced

RT Choice Music Prize In association with IMRO and IRMA Classic Irish Album And the winning album is Achtung Baby by U2 Live Event, Vicar St Thursday 7th...

22/02/2024

RT Publishes Updated Legal Advice Regarding the Departures of Individuals

RT is today making available the updated legal advice received in respect of questions arising in connection with recent departures of executive-level senior m...

21/02/2024

RT Choice Music Prize Conversations 2024: 7th March, 12.00-16.00

RT Choice Music Prize In association with IMRO and IRMA Conversations 2024 7th March, 12.00-16.00 http://www.choicemusicprize.ie/conversations/ Live Event...

21/02/2024

Allcare Pharmacy sponsors Brendan O'Connor on RT Radio 1

RT Media Sales has announced Allcare Pharmacy as sponsor of Brendan O' Connor, RT Radio 1, Saturday & Sunday, 11am-1pm. Brokered by Javelin, the ten-mont...

19/02/2024

Line-up: RT Radio 1 Folk Awards - Vicar Street 27.02.24

The 6th RT Radio 1 Folk Awards will be held in Vicar Street, Dublin on Tuesday 27th of February at 7.45pm. The Awards will be broadcast live on RT Radio 1 and...

17/02/2024

Statement RT Director-General, Kevin Bakhurst

Commenting today, RT Director-General, Kevin Bakhurst said: As I have stated already, RT has previously received legal advice that it is restricted from pro...

14/02/2024

RT and ITV reveal first look at second series of The Dry

RT and ITVX have revealed a first look at the cast of the highly anticipated second series of The Dry, which will air on RT One and RT Player later in the sp...