Mother and her autistic son call on Department of Health to apologise after compiling a secret dossier on them

28/09/2023

Mother and her autistic son call on Department of Health to apologise after compiling a secret dossier on them

Unlawful things happened Deputy Data Protection Commissioner

RT Investigates report following Whistleblower Disclosure

A mother and her autistic son who discovered that the Department of Health had been keeping a secret dossier on them have told RT Investigates they have never had an apology despite the Data Protection Commissioner (DPC) ruling this summer that it amounted to serious interference, and which resulted in the DPC imposing a fine on the Department of Health. Speaking publicly for the first time in an RT Investigates report to be broadcast on Prime Time tonight at 9.35pm on RT One and RT Player, the family describe how the revelations have impacted on them.

When Adam Keogh was just 5 years old, his family had been among several families who took legal action against the State to secure special needs education for their children. Their case was not for compensation but to secure special needs supports in primary school. Adam got some supports and the case lay dormant. But 12 years later the Department of Health continued to work on its legal strategy to manage the cases taken by the families. Without telling the families or getting their consent, the Department of Health went to the HSE and asked for what it had on file on the dormant cases, including medical notes.

The sharing of their private patient information would have remained secret had it not been for a whistleblower in the Department of Health. In 2020, Shane Corr a senior civil servant, realised he could see the families' files. Of greater concern to him was the fact that he could read everything that transpired in a private consultation between members of the Keogh family and their HSE doctor.

Shane Corr: I saw something that frankly I can only describe as shocking. I saw an email from an official at the Department of Health to a doctor who is working for the HSE explaining that they were involved in litigation with one of her patients and asking for information from this doctor. There was no way once I saw the piece of correspondence from the Department saying, we're asking for information from you about a child but we're not going to ask for consent to get it', I was ever going to let that lie.

The Department of Health had obtained documents which contained confidential and sensitive details from a consultation between the Keogh Family and their HSE doctor without the family's knowledge or permission. Senior civil servant Shane Corr tried to raise his concerns. Then, in March 2021, he became a whistleblower and revealed to RT Investigates that highly confidential information on the wellbeing of people and their families was shared, and stored, in departmental dossiers. The information was to be used tactically to decide the most opportune time to settle or reactivate long-dormant High Court cases. The people involved, who had been diagnosed with autism, had not been informed. Neither had their parents.

Following Shane Corr's disclosures and the RT broadcast, the Department of Health said what had been done was part of normal litigation and was entirely lawful, proper and appropriate.

In an Oireachtas Health Committee on May 5, 2021, Sinn F in TD David Cullinane raised the issue: Some information of a very serious and sensitive medical and educational nature was being held on children, and that was being collected, in some instances without, in my view, the knowledge of the parents involved.

Robert Watt, Secretary General of the Department of Health replied: I am sorry, but the Deputy is now repeating once again allegations which are not true and which we have comprehensively addressed as being not true. We have set out more than 100 pages of documents that set out the position here, and what the Deputy has said is just not true. It is regrettable that motivation has been twisted in a way to suggest something untoward was being done by officials, when they were trying to close cases which have gone on for too long and in which it was in the interest of all parties that they be closed.

He also told the Oireachtas Health Committee that on the eve of the RT Investigates report he sought to intervene directly and called the then Director General of RT . We did not believe the allegations were correct, and I set out why we did not believe they were, and that I did not think it was appropriate for RT to make such serious allegations. RT however broadcast the report as planned.

After the broadcast, Robert Watt personally wrote to those who were potentially impacted to reassure them that the information was consistent with, and typical of, the sort of information which arises in litigation. He said Shane Corr's disclosures had already been examined and there was no basis to suggest wrongdoing .

But separately the Data Protection Commissioner had begun its own inquiry. Just one week after the RT broadcast, the DPC went into the Department of Health to see did the files reported on actually exist. This summer the Data Protection Commission's decision was published.

The report says the Department's practices were excessive, lacked transparency, and had no clear policy. The DPC report also criticised the level to which people in the Department of Health, with no involvement in litigation, could access the electronic files.

Tony Delaney, Deputy Data Protection Commissioner: Our decision says unlawful things happened from a data protection perspective. They broke the law, they've been penalized for it, they've been reprimanded for it. There's a ban on processing which took immediate effect. The Department got caught out very badly in this case, but others could be doing the very same thing today. And that's why they all need

LINK:	https://about.rte.ie/2023/09/28/mother-and-her-autistic-son-call-on-de...
	See more stories from rte

Mother and her autistic son call on Department of Health to apologise after compiling a secret dossier on them

More from RTE

11/09/2026

10/09/2026

10/09/2026

10/09/2026

09/09/2026

07/09/2026

04/09/2026

03/09/2026

02/09/2026

01/09/2026

01/09/2026

27/08/2026

26/08/2026

25/08/2026

24/08/2026

21/08/2026

21/08/2026

21/08/2026

19/08/2026

19/08/2026

18/08/2026

18/08/2026

18/08/2026

13/08/2026

11/08/2026

11/08/2026

07/08/2026

06/08/2026

31/07/2026

31/07/2026

31/07/2026

30/07/2026

29/07/2026

28/07/2026

28/07/2026

27/07/2026

24/07/2026

23/07/2026

23/07/2026

23/07/2026

22/07/2026

22/07/2026

21/07/2026

20/07/2026

17/07/2026

17/07/2026

17/07/2026

16/07/2026

15/07/2026

15/07/2026