PASADENA, CALIF. Fox has more of a chance demonstrating that Dish breached its contract rather than violated copyright law with the Hopper, according to a court opinion released today.
The question of whether Dish has breached its contract with Fox is much closer, wrote Judge Sidney R. Thomas of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Thomas rendered the opinion of a three-judge panel that denied Fox's appeal to make Dish disable the ad-skipping function of its Hopper set-top box.
Judge Thomas notes that in 2010, Dish and Fox amended their 2002 carriage contract such that Dish could offer Fox content on-demand on the condition that it disable fast-forward functionality during all advertisements. It also forbid both parties from attempting to frustrate or circumvent the contract.
Dish released the Hopper in March of 2012. The set-top can be programmed to skip over the commercials in automatically recorded primetime programming. This PrimeTime Anywhere feature is limited to broadcast networks only.
We are dubious of Dish's position that PrimeTime Anywhere is not similar' to interactive time-delayed or video-on-demand' programming, the distribution of which is expressly prohibited by the 2002 contract, Thomas wrote. Dish has convinced us that PrimeTime Anytime is not identical to video-on-demand, but is at a loss to explain why it is not similar.
When pressed, Dish could not provide even a single example of what would be considered similar under the contract if not this.
Judge Dolly Gee of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, first denied the injunction last November, but held that Dish breached contract if PrimeTime Anywhere was indeed video-on-demand. She determined, however, that it was more akin to a digital video recorder than VOD because the feature has to be enabled by subscribers. DVRs constitute fair use under Cablevision.
The appeals panel was not likewise convinced.
The fact that a Dish attorney referred to PrimeTime Anytime as a video-on-demand service' in a trademark application supports Fox's claim that the parties would have understood PrimeTime Anytime to be akin to video-on-demand, Judge Thomas wrote.
The Ninth Circuit nonetheless denied the injunction out of limited and deferential review of the lower court's decision.
Judge Thomas opened his opinion by observing that Dish Network offers two marsupial-inspired products: the Hopper,' which hops' over commercials, and a companion box known as a Joey.'
Fox, as well as NBC and CBS, are suing Dish over the marsupial-inspired products. The ad-skipping function AutoHop works through a sort of watermarking.
Dish technicians in Cheyenne, Wyo., manually view Fox's primetime programming each night and technologically mark the beginning and end of each commercial, the judge wrote. The program content is not altered in any way.
The electronically marked files are then uplinked in Wyoming and eventually transmitted to subscribers in the announcement' file that Dish makes available after the show has aired. Simultaneously, with the uplink, three beta Hoppers' record the Fox primetime block for transmissions in Kentucky, Pennsylvania and Florida to test the marketing announcement.
These copies remain at the uplink facility and are used to make sure the commercials have been accurately marked and that no portion of the program has been cut off.
The lower court ruled that Dish likely breached its contract in making the copies. However, Fox ultimately lost because it could not demonstrate irreparable harm as a result of the copies a criterion for obtaining an injunction.
Judge Thomas also observed that ad-skipping does not interfere with Fox's copyright in that it owns the copyrights to the TV programs, but not the ads. (Several media attorneys noted that Fox may indeed hold the copyright to at least some of the affected ads.)
If recording an entire copyrighted program is fair use, the fact that viewers do not watch the ads not copyrighted by Fox cannot transform the recording into a copyright violation, Judge Thomas wrote.
He further asserted that any analysis of the market harm should exclude consideration of AutoHop because ad-skipping does not implicate Fox's copyright interests.
Fox's lawyers also failed to establish a case for secondary infringement i.e., that Dish was compelling its subscribers to infringe because Dish managed to demonstrate its customers would be exercising fair use, the judge wrote. He further said Fox failed to demonstrate a likelihood of irreparable harm.
A virtual buffet of attorneys worked the case. Fox brought in five hired guns from Jenner & Block LLP, while Dish had eight attorneys from Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe, LLP and Durie Tangri LLP. Paul Smith argued for Fox before the three-judge panel; E. Joshua Rosenkranz of Orrick, et al, argued for Dish. ABC TV stations, Cablevision, the National Association of Broadcasters, Paramount Pictures, the Computer & Communications Industry Association, and the Electronic Frontier Foundation were represented in amicus curiae filings.
See
November 12, 2012: Fox Appeals to Stop the Hop
Fox's legal team wasted no time in appealing a federal judge's decision last week to let Dish keep on skipping broadcast TV commercials.
November 8, 2012: Judge Lets Dish Keep On Hopping
In May, as the networks prepared to sue, news of those impending lawsuits leaked. Within 24 hours, Bloomberg said Dish countersued in U.S. District Court in Manhattan, where the company figured it had a better shot based on the court's 2008 ruling that Cablevision's DVR did not violate copyright. But Dish countered too swiftly to suit Judg
Most recent headlines
05/01/2027
Worlds first 802.15.4ab-UWB chip verified by Calterah and Rohde & Schwarz to be ...
04/08/2026
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, t...
04/07/2026
April 7 2026, 19:00 (PDT) Detective Conan: Fallen Angel of the Highway Opens in...
01/06/2026
January 6 2026, 05:30 (PST) Dolby Sets the New Standard for Premium Entertainment at CES 2026
Throughout the week, Dolby brings to life the latest innovatio...
13/05/2026
New Adobe Premiere Color Grading Mode Accelerated on NVIDIA GPUs
Joel Pennington May 13, 2026
0 Comments
New NVIDIA RTX-accelerated features streamlin...
13/05/2026
Grass Valley announced that dB Broadcast has delivered new IP-based outside broadcast (OB) trucks for Cloudbass, featuring Grass Valley LDX 100 Series cameras a...
13/05/2026
Ikegami will exhibit the latest additions to its wide range of broadcast production cameras, control units, viewfinders and monitors on stand 5D3-1 at Broadcast...
13/05/2026
FISE, working with the founding members of the XR Sports Alliance (XRSA), Accedo, Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. and HBS, have collaborated to develop an immersive...
13/05/2026
Canon Unveils New EOS R6 V Full-Frame EOS Camera and RF20-50mm F4 L IS USM PZ Bu...
13/05/2026
Boston Conservatory at Berklee Honors Beth Morrison and Moses Pendleton at Comme...
13/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
13/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
13/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
13/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
13/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
13/05/2026
Creative software developer Foundry today announced the latest developments on Nuke Stage. A purpose-built application for end-to-end virtual production and in-...
13/05/2026
A definitive portrait of one of Ireland's most influential musicians
New TV documentary airs Monday 18 May on RT One and RT Player at 9.35pm
Watch the...
13/05/2026
Agentic AI is changing the way users get work done. Following the success of OpenClaw, the community is embracing new open source agentic frameworks. The latest...
13/05/2026
Reinforcement-learning agents - AI systems that learn by trial and error - can c...
12/05/2026
Beyond the Hype: A Strategic Post-Hoc Analysis of NAB 2026 If NAB Show 2026 had an underlying theme, it was a quiet, industry-wide pivot from the high-energy sp...
12/05/2026
Guntermann and Drunck (G&D), a Panoptec Technologies Group company, and CT Square, led by Chandresh Shah, have announced a joint venture to distribute G&D and V...
12/05/2026
With 30 days until the start of the FIFA World Cup 2026, Telemundo, the exclusive Spanish-language home of the tournament in the United States, has announced th...
12/05/2026
The NHL has announced the return of Stanley Pup for its third consecutive year, a 90-minute special featuring adoptable rescue dogs competing on a miniature rin...
12/05/2026
NBCUniversal presented its 2026 Upfront to advertisers at Radio City Music Hall, detailing upcoming programming across NBC, Peacock, Bravo, and Versant properti...
12/05/2026
FOX Sports has announced funding for the Fandom and Social Connection Initiative at Harvard Kennedy School's Shorenstein Center on Media, Politics, and Publ...
12/05/2026
TNDV and Live Media, both divisions of Live Media Group, supported live broadcast coverage around NCAA Final Four weekend in Indianapolis, including the March M...
12/05/2026
The European Football Alliance (EFA) has announced a content distribution agreement with Fubo Sports Network, the free ad-supported streaming TV (FAST) channel ...
12/05/2026
For the first time, Spanish-speaking fans in the U.S. will have two separate tel...
12/05/2026
CP Communications led a comprehensive spectrum management initiative on behalf of Churchill Downs during Kentucky Derby week, coordinating RF assets across the ...
12/05/2026
LiveU has announced a strategic partnership with DRONERESPONDERS, a 501(c)3 non-...
12/05/2026
Open Broadcast Systems has announced that BMC TV, a specialist in IP transport of broadcast content, has selected the Open Broadcast Systems 5G Flyaway solution...
12/05/2026
NEP Europe, part of NEP Group, has announced it will deliver broadcast solutions...
12/05/2026
Grass Valley has announced continued collaboration with Ravensbourne University ...
12/05/2026
Stats Perform has announced the launch of Opta Pulse, an AI-assisted video creation and distribution platform for leagues, rights holders, and broadcasters. The...
12/05/2026
FOX Sports has announced a collaboration with Sesame Workshop to integrate Sesame Street characters into FOX Sports' FIFA World Cup 2026 programming. Conten...
12/05/2026
To date, NHL Productions has produced 19 broadcasts with commentary in American Sign Language
NHL in ASL (American Sign Language) may be just one show, but the...
12/05/2026
Google's Brian Albert: creators, athletes, highlights, nostalgia, second-scr...
12/05/2026
A still from Past Lives by Celine Song, an official selection of the Premieres program at the 2023 Sundance Film Festival. (Courtesy of Sundance Institute | p...
12/05/2026
Spotify is where fans and artists come together, turning discovery into somethin...
12/05/2026
Features patented Marco-MMC clocking technology
Black Lion Audio's latest release combines the company's expertise in clocking with their renowned p...
12/05/2026
New Track Panel, sequencer upgrades & more
Following their recent public beta release, Reason Studios have announced the full release of Reason 14. With the...
12/05/2026
One month to go! SBS reveals expansive FIFA World Cup 2026 lineup beyond the pi...
12/05/2026
Rohde & Schwarz presents its advanced solutions for power electronics testing at...
12/05/2026
aconnic AG (ISIN: DE000A0LBKW6), Munich, has developed a modified fund raising p...
12/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
12/05/2026
Tyrell Corporation, specialists in high-end live sports and entertainment broadcasts, was tasked with delivering compelling broadcast coverage of premier equest...
12/05/2026
Registration is now open for IBC2026 as the global media, entertainment and technology community prepares to converge on the RAI Amsterdam from 11 14 September ...
12/05/2026
Ross Video, a global leader in live video production technology, will present its latest innovations and integrated production workflows at BroadcastAsia 2026, ...
12/05/2026
500 selected leaders from around the world across start-ups, corporates, and venture capital. Over 50bn in assets under management among attending investors, a...
PASADENA, CALIF. Fox has more of a chance demonstrating that Dish breached its contract rather than violated copyright law with the Hopper, according to a court opinion released today.
