PASADENA, CALIF. Fox has more of a chance demonstrating that Dish breached its contract rather than violated copyright law with the Hopper, according to a court opinion released today.
The question of whether Dish has breached its contract with Fox is much closer, wrote Judge Sidney R. Thomas of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Thomas rendered the opinion of a three-judge panel that denied Fox's appeal to make Dish disable the ad-skipping function of its Hopper set-top box.
Judge Thomas notes that in 2010, Dish and Fox amended their 2002 carriage contract such that Dish could offer Fox content on-demand on the condition that it disable fast-forward functionality during all advertisements. It also forbid both parties from attempting to frustrate or circumvent the contract.
Dish released the Hopper in March of 2012. The set-top can be programmed to skip over the commercials in automatically recorded primetime programming. This PrimeTime Anywhere feature is limited to broadcast networks only.
We are dubious of Dish's position that PrimeTime Anywhere is not similar' to interactive time-delayed or video-on-demand' programming, the distribution of which is expressly prohibited by the 2002 contract, Thomas wrote. Dish has convinced us that PrimeTime Anytime is not identical to video-on-demand, but is at a loss to explain why it is not similar.
When pressed, Dish could not provide even a single example of what would be considered similar under the contract if not this.
Judge Dolly Gee of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, first denied the injunction last November, but held that Dish breached contract if PrimeTime Anywhere was indeed video-on-demand. She determined, however, that it was more akin to a digital video recorder than VOD because the feature has to be enabled by subscribers. DVRs constitute fair use under Cablevision.
The appeals panel was not likewise convinced.
The fact that a Dish attorney referred to PrimeTime Anytime as a video-on-demand service' in a trademark application supports Fox's claim that the parties would have understood PrimeTime Anytime to be akin to video-on-demand, Judge Thomas wrote.
The Ninth Circuit nonetheless denied the injunction out of limited and deferential review of the lower court's decision.
Judge Thomas opened his opinion by observing that Dish Network offers two marsupial-inspired products: the Hopper,' which hops' over commercials, and a companion box known as a Joey.'
Fox, as well as NBC and CBS, are suing Dish over the marsupial-inspired products. The ad-skipping function AutoHop works through a sort of watermarking.
Dish technicians in Cheyenne, Wyo., manually view Fox's primetime programming each night and technologically mark the beginning and end of each commercial, the judge wrote. The program content is not altered in any way.
The electronically marked files are then uplinked in Wyoming and eventually transmitted to subscribers in the announcement' file that Dish makes available after the show has aired. Simultaneously, with the uplink, three beta Hoppers' record the Fox primetime block for transmissions in Kentucky, Pennsylvania and Florida to test the marketing announcement.
These copies remain at the uplink facility and are used to make sure the commercials have been accurately marked and that no portion of the program has been cut off.
The lower court ruled that Dish likely breached its contract in making the copies. However, Fox ultimately lost because it could not demonstrate irreparable harm as a result of the copies a criterion for obtaining an injunction.
Judge Thomas also observed that ad-skipping does not interfere with Fox's copyright in that it owns the copyrights to the TV programs, but not the ads. (Several media attorneys noted that Fox may indeed hold the copyright to at least some of the affected ads.)
If recording an entire copyrighted program is fair use, the fact that viewers do not watch the ads not copyrighted by Fox cannot transform the recording into a copyright violation, Judge Thomas wrote.
He further asserted that any analysis of the market harm should exclude consideration of AutoHop because ad-skipping does not implicate Fox's copyright interests.
Fox's lawyers also failed to establish a case for secondary infringement i.e., that Dish was compelling its subscribers to infringe because Dish managed to demonstrate its customers would be exercising fair use, the judge wrote. He further said Fox failed to demonstrate a likelihood of irreparable harm.
A virtual buffet of attorneys worked the case. Fox brought in five hired guns from Jenner & Block LLP, while Dish had eight attorneys from Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe, LLP and Durie Tangri LLP. Paul Smith argued for Fox before the three-judge panel; E. Joshua Rosenkranz of Orrick, et al, argued for Dish. ABC TV stations, Cablevision, the National Association of Broadcasters, Paramount Pictures, the Computer & Communications Industry Association, and the Electronic Frontier Foundation were represented in amicus curiae filings.
See
November 12, 2012: Fox Appeals to Stop the Hop
Fox's legal team wasted no time in appealing a federal judge's decision last week to let Dish keep on skipping broadcast TV commercials.
November 8, 2012: Judge Lets Dish Keep On Hopping
In May, as the networks prepared to sue, news of those impending lawsuits leaked. Within 24 hours, Bloomberg said Dish countersued in U.S. District Court in Manhattan, where the company figured it had a better shot based on the court's 2008 ruling that Cablevision's DVR did not violate copyright. But Dish countered too swiftly to suit Judg
Most recent headlines
06/10/2025
France T l visions, France's leading broadcaster, has received the 2025 EBU ...
04/09/2025
Monumental Sports & Entertainment (MSE), in collaboration with Dalet, has been a...
30/08/2025
WASHINGTON The Federal Communications Commission has adopted its FY 2025 Regulatory Fees Order that establishes the regulatory fee rates for the broadcast stati...
29/08/2025
Australian Red Cross and SBS launch training to help workplaces in the fight aga...
29/08/2025
The National Film and Video Foundation (NFVF), an agency of the Department of Sp...
29/08/2025
L3Harris Technologies has concentrated decades of expertise across the entire enterprise to develop affordable and reliable best-of-breed solutions to rapidly c...
29/08/2025
BURBANK, Calif. The CW Network and the Pac-12 Conference have announced a new media rights deal that will extend their broadcast partnership beginning with the ...
29/08/2025
NEW YORK Gracenote has released a new analysis of its global video dataset showing that the number of FAST channels grew nearly 14% from Q1 2025 and 76% since 2...
29/08/2025
SAN JOSE, Calif. Harmonic has announced a series of improvements to its live sports streaming solution that the company said will improve fan engagement, protec...
29/08/2025
NEW YORK and LOS ANGELES Fox Corp. and YouTube TV last night announced a renewal of the full portfolio of Fox networks, including Fox News Channel, Fox Business...
29/08/2025
Budapest, Hungary, August 2025 - The integration of Microsoft Teams Rooms (MTR) with Lightware's Taurus universal matrix switchers delivers a new level of f...
29/08/2025
Frequency, the engine behind many of the world's best-known streaming television channels, today announced it will launch Studio Live, a next-generation uni...
29/08/2025
In an era when AI and cyber resilience are essential, Scality will mark the 10th anniversary of Scality Day on October 16, 2025 in Paris. This flagship global e...
29/08/2025
Disguise's In-House Creative and Technical Teams Pre-Visualised, Programmed and Delivered Content for the Experience, All Powered by EX 3+
Technology solu...
29/08/2025
Disguise will be demonstrating the latest workflows for TV, film and live events on a number of partner booths at the show
Disguise, the industry-leading tech...
29/08/2025
STOCKHOLM, Sweden Accedo will showcase Accedo Compose, its AI agent-powered modular orchestration layer that assists streaming providers in transitioning client...
29/08/2025
LOS ANGELES Cineverse has announced that it is working with Xperi to bring four of its streaming channels to automobiles for the first time as part of the DTS A...
29/08/2025
DALLAS & ATLANTA Gray Media has announced an agreement with the sports streaming service Victory+ to simulcast 17 Dallas Stars NHL games in 15 television market...
29/08/2025
NEW YORK AND CULVER CITY Comcast NBCUniversal and Amazon have announced new and extended distribution agreements that will expand the content available on their...
29/08/2025
FOOTHILL RANCH, Calif. RED Digital Cinema will feature its Cine-Broadcast Module supporting live broadcast workflows during IBC2025, Sept. 12-15, at the RAI Ams...
29/08/2025
29 Aug 2025
Kyivstar Rings Opening Bell at Nasdaq Marking Landmark Listing and ...
29/08/2025
More than half of all NFL games live on Sky for the first timeFriday 29 August 2025
Sky Sports has announced a new three-year deal with the NFL, extending its ...
29/08/2025
Back to All News
RIV4LRIES: The Trailer of the New Series With Samuele Carrino ...
29/08/2025
Get ready for an inspiring and emotional insight into the world of competitive Irish dancing with My Story: Tomi Champion of the World airing on RT 2 this monda...
29/08/2025
RT has today announced that David McCullagh is to be the new presenter of RT Radio 1's flagship Today programme, which airs every weekday at 10am, replaci...
28/08/2025
By Kristin Feeley, Director, Documentary Film & Artist Programs
If you want to tell untold stories, if you want to give voice to the voiceless, you've got ...
28/08/2025
Directed by Steven Bognar and Julia Reichert, Sundance Institute-supported Amer...
28/08/2025
Corridos have been a cornerstone of M sica Mexicana for generations, telling stories rooted in everyday life. Now, a new chapter is taking shape: motivational c...
28/08/2025
Los corridos han sido un pilar de la M sica Mexicana durante generaciones, contando historias enraizadas en la vida cotidiana. Ahora, un nuevo cap tulo est tom...
28/08/2025
Earlier this month, we promised our Verano Forever party would bring the heat, a...
28/08/2025
L3Harris will provide the Polish F-16V fleet with the Viper Shield electronic warfare system as part of an upgrade program....
28/08/2025
Bilbao, August 26, 2025 - AgileTV, an international television and video technol...
28/08/2025
Ken Wilkinson is an Emmy Awards nominated New York audio engineer who specialises in production sound mixing for film, commercial, episodic and documentary work...
28/08/2025
NEW YORK FuboTV today announced that it will launch Fubo Sports, a skinny bundle that focuses on sports with a subscription price of $56 monthly....
28/08/2025
NEVADA City, Calif. At IBC2025, Sept. 12-15 at the RAI Amsterdam, Telestream will debut its new Global Ingest strategy, introducing a next-generation ingest arc...
28/08/2025
Dr. Rhoda Bernard Releases Groundbreaking Debut Book on Accessible Arts Educatio...
28/08/2025
TAG Video Systems, the leader in software-based IP end-to-end workflow monitoring, deep probing, and real-time visualization, has named Oliver Gappa as Sales Di...
28/08/2025
AI-based voice enhancement will be among a series of innovations making their IBC 2025 debut on the DHD stand B46 in Hall 8 at the RAI Amsterdam Convention Cent...
28/08/2025
Telef nica Servicios Audiovisuales (TSA), the leading system integrator and service provider in the media sector in Spain, with the support of Appear, the globa...
28/08/2025
To fully immerse sailing fans in the world's biggest offshore yacht race, production company, Optical Media turned to LiveU's On-site Production solutio...
28/08/2025
Working with Calrec on its most recent overhaul, radio and television broadcaster, WNED has migrated to a fully IP infrastructure with multiple Type R consoles,...
28/08/2025
Cleeng, the Subscriber Retention Management (SRM ) inventor, has unveiled Cleeng Pro, the first-ever direct-to-consumer (D2C) subscription management platform t...
28/08/2025
Zixi, the industry leader in live broadcast-quality video over IP, today announced that French media distribution platform OKAST has selected Zixi to enable rel...
28/08/2025
Solution offers a streamlined, speaker-free architecture to optimize integration with premium external loudspeakers and advanced loudness metering
Nixer Pro Au...
28/08/2025
Cinegy, the premier provider of software-defined television technology, has announced a strategic partnership with Vision One Touch Film Production Services L.L...
28/08/2025
Telestream, a global leader in media workflow technologies, will debut its new Global Ingest strategy at IBC2025, introducing a next-generation ingest architect...
28/08/2025
Tier 1 operator selects Broadpeak to power high-performance, unified CDN solution across Norway, Sweden and Finland
Broadpeak, a leader in streaming and moneti...
28/08/2025
Leading video software provider, Synamedia, today announced that 24 Frames Digital, one of India's leading live event streaming service providers, has chose...
28/08/2025
Meet VisualOn at IBC2025: See What's Next in AI-Powered Video Streaming Join VisualOn at IBC2025 and discover how our AI-driven Optimizer and advanced media...
PASADENA, CALIF. Fox has more of a chance demonstrating that Dish breached its contract rather than violated copyright law with the Hopper, according to a court opinion released today.
