One Week In, NFL Crowds' Are Finding Their Sound Footing A1s are adapting to a new element in their mixes By Dan Daley, Audio Editor
Friday, September 18, 2020 - 9:48 am
Print This Story | Subscribe
Story Highlights
The NFL has gotten through Week 1, and the crowds at the games seem to like the way it sounds. The league has joined other sports in creating its own crowd-sound system.
In doing so, the NFL took a very different path from the NBA, whose players are the focus of its faux-crowd-sound system. While football players on the gridiron hear a constant buzz of crowd sound played continuously at about 70 dB through the stadium PA systems, intended to provide a semblance of crowd noise, home viewers of NFL games get a constantly changing soundscape intended to dynamically follow the action on the field.
Mixers have five levels of intensity to choose as they follow the action on the field. In addition, they can lay three levels of positive- and negative-reaction crowd sounds atop the ambience tracks.
Like the NBA, the NFL uses a separate mix team for these sounds. The league's kit for this, developed by consultant Robert Brock and drawing on content collected and edited by NFL Films, uses the Wwise videogame-authoring platform.
New to the A1s Like the fans at home, NFL A1s encountered the new crowd-sound system for the first time when the league started play on Thursday, Sept. 10. Wendel Stevens, who mixed the season opener for NBC with Super Bowl champs Chiefs vs. the Texans in Kansas City, barely had to touch the faders that would bring the prerecorded crowd sounds into the broadcast mix: thanks to local regulations that allowed nearly 16,000 fans in the seats, there was enough input for his crowd microphones to generate a respectable roar when needed. He used the prerecorded crowd-sound feed, submixed by Jesse Van Der Vyver, just once, for the banner-reveal moment at the beginning of the show.
A relatively sparse audience of almost 16,000 at the NFL opener in Kansas City was enough to create a semblance of crowd noise, but it has fallen to the league's newly minted corps of curated-crowd-sound mixers and broadcast's veteran A1s to re-create that for most other games this season, using prerecorded crowd audio files.
By Sunday night's NBC primetime Rams-Cowboys game in Los Angeles, though, crowd-sound mixer Phil Gebhardt had his hands full.
The NFL-curated sounds were awesome, says Stevens. The issue is the dynamics, and getting them to follow the ebb and flow of how a real crowd would react.
He notes that Gebhardt was able to create a credible crowd dynamic but also had to ride the overall crowd-sound submix to some extent to match what his decades of experience mixing live football told him the crowd swells should be. For instance, the steady-murmur tracks that the NFL system defaults to when the crowd-sound mixer isn't adding any action-specific reaction elements felt inauthentic to him.
When an NFL crowd is quiet, they're quiet, he says, noting that he sometimes pulled those moments down slightly in the overall mix. That constant murmur can take away from the realism. Also, it can wear on the ears after a while. That's why dynamics are so important.
Working the Bengals-Rams game on Sunday, Phil Adler, a veteran football A1 for CBS, says he was pleasantly surprised, calling it a good experience after some initial hesitancy: My concern was that I was going to have to coach the [crowd mixer] while mixing my own game. Instead, Aaron Sharpe, who mixed the crowds for my show, understood what he had to do, which was follow the game.
Adler credits Sharpe, a musician and DJ who lives in the Cincinnati area, with knowing his market - NFL crowd-sound mixers are assigned to a specific team and its stadium - and diligently applying the training materials the NFL provided, keeping the crowds tuned to what the Bengals' home-crowd reactions would be. He adds that wasn't the case with a few other games whose highlights he has listened to.
The strength and the Achilles heel of this system is the operator, Adler stresses. That person has to understand how a real crowd acts and has to understand football. It's dynamic and fluid, and Aaron got it. Not everyone did on Week 1. But, Week 1, everyone gets a pass, because this is so new.
Adler is impressed with the sonic quality of the NFL's crowd-sound files. He used the Calrec Artemis's four-band EQ aboard Game Creek Columbia to notch the files' overall tone down 2 dB-3 dB at 7 kHz to reduce what he perceived as some harshness in the sounds and to better blend them into the larger broadcast mix and with the four high-up venue ambience microphones he was also mixing in.
Once he had that dialed in, Adler says, he could almost believe there was a crowd in the stands. I heard the Let's go, Bengals!' chant come up, and it caught me off guard. I asked Aaron, was that you? And of course, it was; there was nobody in the seats! It sounded that good.
We're All Learning Vince Caputo, VP/supervising sound mixer, NFL Films, who oversees the crowd-sound initiative, says everyone learned more in a single day of actual games than in all the practice sessions conducted using recently archived game videos. The main takeaway, he says, is the need for crowd-sound mixers to better anticipate events on the field and to react to them more the way partisan fans would. This would also make the best use of the crowd-sound audio, which was sourced specifically from each team's stadium during previous seasons.
Home fans are always optimistic, Caputo points out. They start to cheer before the receiver catches the ball or just as they see the sack coming. If you try to catch up to the action, if you wait to see what happens, you're too late. And if you're wrong
Most recent headlines
04/08/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, is excited to announce Santiago Solanas as its new Chief Executive Officer (CEO)....
03/06/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, a...
28/04/2024
Mediahaus delivers the first SRT live-streaming sports production over 5G with U...
23/04/2024
Psychology can play an important role in helping us understand what audiences respond to (Dr Jon Roozenbeek, Cambridge Social Decision-Making Lab)
For newsroom...
23/04/2024
IN ADDITION TO FICTION AND DOCUMENTARY FEATURES, THE SELECTION INCLUDES:
PRO...
23/04/2024
Today, we announced our first quarter 2024 earnings. In a solid start to the year, Spotify reported
Monthly Active Users grew 19% Y/Y to 615 million.
Subscri...
23/04/2024
Idag publicerar Spotify sina finansiella resultat f r f rsta kvartalet 2024. ret har inletts stabilt:
M natliga aktiva anv ndare kade med 19 % j mf rt med f...
23/04/2024
In the last decade, as K-Pop cemented its status as a global phenomenon, Spotify has helped fans around the world keep their fingers on the pulse at every step ...
23/04/2024
Social entrepreneur Hedayat Osyan wins Les Murray Award for Refugee Recognition
23 April, 2024
Media releases
The prestigious award is now in its third yea...
23/04/2024
LONDON IBC is now accepting nominations for its IBC2024 Innovation Awards, which honor achievements in technological innovation and social impact media & entert...
23/04/2024
WASHINGTON, D.C. In response to the introduction of the Broadcast VOICES Act that seeks to encourage more diversity in the ownership of TV and radio stations, t...
23/04/2024
MIAMI, Fla. As part of a push to expand its FAST channel and streaming operations, Hemisphere Media Group has launched its free ad supported television (FAST) c...
23/04/2024
LOS ANGELES DirecTV is adding seven new channels to its rapidly expanding streaming lineup through new licensing agreements with Cineverse Corp. and Scripps Net...
23/04/2024
Entitled Our Creative Future, the manifesto calls for radical new action' t...
23/04/2024
The company has secured investment from private equity firm PAI Partners, which also holds a stake in outside broadcasting company EMG
By Jenny Priestley
Pub...
23/04/2024
Cameron also said he recognised Marlow as a potential UK and European base for his new company, LIGHTSTORM 3D
By Matthew Corrigan
Published: April 23, 2024 ...
23/04/2024
The five categories cover Content Creation, Content Distribution, Content Everywhere, Social Impact and Environment & Sustainability
By Matthew Corrigan
Publ...
23/04/2024
He played a central role in securing key broadcast rights, including the FIFA World Cup 2018 and 2022
By Matthew Corrigan
Published: April 23, 2024
He pla...
23/04/2024
IBC is preparing to honour the highest achievements in technological innovation and social impact with the launch of its prestigious IBC2024 Innovation Awards, ...
23/04/2024
BREA, Calif. Bolin Technology is integrating Network Device Interface (NDI) across its product line, bringing support for the latest NDI technologies to its PTZ...
23/04/2024
WYOMISSING, Pa. PENN Entertainment has announced that longtime Disney and ESPN executive Aaron LaBerge has been named chief technology officer effective July 1,...
23/04/2024
In response to an FCC ruling in March proposing a $1.2 million fine against Nexstar and a ruling that Mission Broadcasting sell WPIX, Nexstar has filled a respo...
23/04/2024
Sony has announced new details about how the National Hot Rod Association (NHRA) is using Sony's Ci Media Cloud platform to streamline its workflows and spe...
23/04/2024
Esports' rapid rise to popularity can be attributed to many factors, from technological advancements that have enhanced the quality of modern gaming experie...
23/04/2024
OpenDrives, Inc., the global provider of software-defined media workflow solutions and data management capabilities, has been selected as a winner in the 2024 N...
23/04/2024
BCNEXXT is pleased to announce that Vpe has won the 2024 NAB Show Product of the Year Award in the Asset Management, Automation and Playout category. The offici...
23/04/2024
Gravity Media, a world leading global provider of complex live creative production and media services, today outlined the broadcast technology and television pr...
23/04/2024
Scality, a global leader in cyber-resilient storage for the AI era, today announced the appointment of Peter Brennan as Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of Scality...
23/04/2024
Blackmagic Design today announced ATEM 1 M/E Constellation 4K and ATEM 2 M/E Constellation 4K switchers, two new Ultra HD models of the ATEM Constellation famil...
23/04/2024
Blackmagic Design today announced Blackmagic Videohub 120x120 12G, the newest model in the Videohub 12G router family. The massive Blackmagic Videohub 120x120 1...
23/04/2024
Blackmagic Design today announced new lower prices for Blackmagic Video Assist 3G and 12G models. Customers can save US$200 on all models. These lower prices ma...
23/04/2024
Adder Technology continues to shine brightly, with its groundbreaking product, the ADDERLink INFINITY 3000 (ALIF3000), once again taking center stage. Hot on t...
23/04/2024
Pliant Technologies' CRP-C12 Compact Radio Pack is an Audio Production, Processing and Networking category winner in the 2024 NAB Show Product of the Year A...
23/04/2024
SipRadius, the specialists in live media transport and transcoding, will showcase their world-leading implementation of AV1 and JPEG-XS over transport streams a...
23/04/2024
Composer Rafael Krux has added a Prism Sound Dream ADA-128 modular conversion system to his production studio where he creates music for commercials, trailers, ...
23/04/2024
PMC proudly provides the ultimate large-scale Dolby Atmos audio system for the legendary musician Steven Wilson at the High End, Munich. He will share his exten...
23/04/2024
Particles emitting from a 3D rotating shape's edge
Graham Quince April 22, 2024
0 Comments
In Fixin' FX, people send me their problematic proj...
23/04/2024
Hollyland Technology Announces a New Line of Video Transmitters: Introducing the...
23/04/2024
Charlotte Deleste, anchor at WISC Madison, Wisconsin, is leaving the station. Her final day on the air is April 24. Deleste has spent 18 years there....
23/04/2024
Top WNBA draft choice Caitlin Clark will appear on local broadcast for 17 games next season in a deal between Tegna and the Indiana Fever....
23/04/2024
The merger will provide vertical integration potential and enhanced product offerings to capture regional and international opportunities for revenue growth and...
23/04/2024
Abu Dhabi, 23 April, 2024 : Partnership delivers greater cybersecurity to Thura...
23/04/2024
Soccer's Appeal to Younger Audiences: Inside the Gamification of European Fo...
23/04/2024
With NBA and NHL Playoffs in Full Swing, Never a Dull Moment for TNT Sports Prod...
23/04/2024
NAB 2024: AT&T Business's Scott Beckett Details Transmission Firepower With ...
23/04/2024
NAB 2024: Manufacturers focus on cinematic look for live productions By George Bevir
Tuesday, April 23, 2024 - 10:40
Print This Story
With live sports pro...
23/04/2024
Save the Date: SVG Sports Content Management Forum Returns to NYC on July 24 By SVG Staff
Tuesday, April 23, 2024 - 4:05 pm
Print This Story | Subscribe
...
23/04/2024
Published On: April 23rd, 2024
data-orig-src=https://www.sgo.es/wp-content/upl...
23/04/2024
Rohde & Schwarz introduces new R&S SMB100B microwave signal generator for analog...
One Week In, NFL Crowds' Are Finding Their Sound Footing A1s are adapting to a new element in their mixes By Dan Daley, Audio Editor 
