2012 protest at Foster City drug company Gilead Sciences | Noah Berger / Associated Press
Story Partners
When Californians go to the polls this November, they'll likely weigh-in on a contentious health care topic amplified by presidential campaigns: prescription drug prices.
A state ballot measure, the California Drug Price Relief Act, would restrict California health programs from paying more for a prescription drug than what's paid by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, which is widely cited as paying the lowest prices in the nation.
The initiative's proponents, Los-Angeles based AIDS Healthcare Foundation, say the measure is a remedy to excessively priced drugs that make it harder for patients to get the drugs that they need.
But what looks like a straightforward framework to protect California's budget from escalating drug costs has policy experts perplexed, and potential allies on the sidelines. Critics and consumer advocates alike say the initiative's language is flawed, and may lead to higher drug prices and access problems for patients.
A small army of pharmaceutical companies have raised more than $52 million to defeat the measure, more than 12 times what the AIDS Healthcare Foundation spent to put it on the ballot. But one need not go farther than the AIDS advocacy community itself to find criticism of the proposal.
We are incredibly supportive of the intent, said Anne Donnelly, director of health care policy for Project Inform, a San Francisco-based organization that advocates for HIV and hepatitis C patients, and is part of the ad-hoc Fair Pricing Coalition to bring down prescription costs.
The details of the measure are so obscure and unclear, Donnelly said, there is a possibility for some unintended, very harmful consequences.
The initiative says it applies to any health program where the state is the ultimate payer, but Donnelly says it's not clear to her which agencies that would involve. California's AIDS Drugs Assistance Program, for instance, is funded with federal money. The proposition does list the AIDS program.
--
--
Donnelly also wonders what options state agencies have if the V.A. price could not be obtained.
Drugmakers could raise the initial sticker price, said Donnelly, or stop giving discounts to the V.A.
It's kind of like the whack-a-mole thing, right? When you try to push one thing down are you really sure that something else isn't going to pop up? Donnelly said.
Proponents say any questions about the measure, including decisions about which agencies would be subject to the law, can be ironed out by state officials carrying out the law.
We're not going to be in the business of micromanaging the administration and telling them how they need to implement this program, said Rand Martin, a lobbyist with MVM Strategy Group and a spokesman for the AIDS Healthcare Foundation.
Whatever the challenges to getting this initiative implemented are going to be because the pharmaceutical industry wants it that way, he said.
Project Inform, as well as another consumer advocacy group, San Francisco AIDS Foundation, say their concerns about the measure don't amount to opposition. Both groups accept money from drugmakers but say their advocacy priorities are independent from their funding.
Groups who don't have a stake in the drug pricing issue also say the impact of such a law is impossible to forecast.
A drug's sticker price is almost always negotiated down, and the final price paid by the state or an insurer is generally sealed by law or through private contracts.
That lack of transparency makes it hard to assess how much money, if any, the state would save from the measure, says the Legislative Analyst's Office.
We rarely are not able to complete the analysis, said Amber Didier, an LAO fiscal and policy analyst who wasn't able to perform a write-up for the signature gathering on the ballot, but is working on language for the November voter guide.
Didier said even if she knew the final drug discounts state agencies receive, it would still be hard to predict how the pharmaceutical industry might change pricing if the measure became law.
There are potentially different ways that pharmaceutical companies could react to this that would then influence the fiscal impact, Didier said.
Proponents argue the measure would create significant savings to California taxpayers. They point to a 2005 Congressional Budget Office report suggesting that, on average, the V.A. pays 42 percent of a brand name drug's sticker price, whereas state Medicaid programs pay 51 percent.
Medi-Cal officials say while they don't know what the VA ultimately pays for drugs, if you include the additional discounts the California agency secures from drugmakers, its payments may already be close to or do better than what the V.A. pays.
We negotiate hard, said Mike Wofford, chief of pharmacy policy at the California Department of Health Care Services, which oversees Medi-Cal.
The drugmaker-funded opposition campaign says patients should be concerned about the measure. Pharmaceutical manufacturers could choose not to give state-negotiated discounts because of the law. Under Medi-Cal rules, when a deeper discount is not obtained for a drug, doctors have to get approval before the medication can be dispensed. That could result in delays for patients, according to the no campaign.
There's a million questions you could raise about this initiative, said Kathy Fairbanks, spokesperson for the no campaign. It's not going to work. It's a hot mess.
Meantime, there is evidence that the state is seeing a rise in drug spending despite new policies to control costs.
A CALmatters analysis found that state prisons, the California public pension system, and a subset of the Medi-Ca
Most recent headlines
04/08/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, is excited to announce Santiago Solanas as its new Chief Executive Officer (CEO)....
03/06/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, a...
06/05/2024
By Ilyse McKimmie
Now, more than ever
That's a phrase so often used in the last few years that I've come to dread seeing it in notes like this one. A...
06/05/2024
alt= class=wp-image-12099 data-lazy-src=/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/Blog-Exabyte-Storage-Demand-960x540-1.jpg/> Demand for storage solutions has reached unprece...
06/05/2024
Around the world, Asian and Pacific Islander (API) artists continue to impact mu...
06/05/2024
Spotify is making it easier for booklovers to count down the days, hours, minutes, and seconds until a new audiobook releases. With Countdown Pages for audioboo...
06/05/2024
Get Ready to join Dan Hong as he hits the streets in his ultimate culinary journ...
06/05/2024
In this video, cinematographer Simon Rowling welcomes viewers behind the scenes as he lights a daytime-interior scene inside a coffee shop. Shooting on Panavisi...
06/05/2024
L3Harris is well positioned to support the complex and multifaceted nature of special operations forces in all domains through our agile and responsive technolo...
06/05/2024
OAKVILLE, Ontario As part of Emergency Preparedness Week, Alert Ready, Canadas national public alerting system, will be distributing a test alert to Canadians i...
06/05/2024
NEW ROCHELLE, N.Y. Horowitz Research has released a new study on the viewing and media habits of U.S. Hispanic/Latine audiences that shows a dramatic decline in...
06/05/2024
RE:Vision Effects Autograph 2024.4 released! 50% Off Through May 9th
Brie Clayton May 6, 2024
0 Comments
New game-changing motion graphics & VFX featu...
06/05/2024
NBC has renewed Night Court for a third season. The courtroom comedy was on the network from 1984 to 1992, and NBC rebooted it in early 2023....
06/05/2024
ABC has revealed its summer schedule. The Bachelorette gets going Monday, July 8, with Jenn Tran the star in season 21. Celebrity Family Feud starts up Tuesday,...
06/05/2024
It's almost go-time for the Holly Springs Salamanders! The season opener is ...
06/05/2024
06 May 2024
AI and Big Data Take the Centre Stage in Central Asia at Beetech 20...
06/05/2024
FIRST LOOK AT JIM PARSONS & MAYIM BIALIK REPRISING THEIR ROLES FROM THE BIG BAN...
06/05/2024
NBC Sports and Churchill Downs Extend Historic Partnership, Kentucky Derby to Be...
06/05/2024
Beverly Hills Aerials, LIV Golf Make Australian-Broadcast History by Flying Live...
06/05/2024
Back to All News
Watch the Trailer for A Part of You - Felicia Maxime, Edvin Ry...
06/05/2024
Leadership in 12G-SDI for low impact migration to 4k production...
06/05/2024
Press release - 6 May 2024 07:31
STATEMENT CONCERNING EUTELSAT GROUP'S GROUND NETWORK Facebook
LinkedIn
Twitter
Download as PDF
Paris, 06 May 2024 ...
06/05/2024
Tyngsboro, Mass. - May 6, 2024 - Join us at InfoComm 2024 to experience the latest advancements in live production technology. From June 12-14, 2024, at the Las...
06/05/2024
To champion global movements to protect and advance equality for LGBTQ+ communities, Apple is introducing a new Apple Watch Pride Edition Braided Solo Loop, ava...
06/05/2024
Actress Matseliso Mohale has joined Muvhango'Talented actress Matseliso Mohale has joined SABC2's soapie Muvhango' as Vhangani's lover and a c...
06/05/2024
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: Leroy refuses to give up fighting to bury MthethoDon't miss Monday, 6 May's riveting episode of South African soapie Smoke...
06/05/2024
Intrinsic, a software and AI robotics company at Alphabet, has integrated NVIDIA AI and Isaac platform technologies to advance the complex field of autonomous r...
06/05/2024
Cybersecurity experts at the RSA Conference this week will be on the hunt for ways to secure their operations in the era of generative AI.
They'll find man...
06/05/2024
1) What is the rationale of the transaction? What is the benefit for SES shareholders?
This combination creates a stronger and more competitive multi-orbit ope...
05/05/2024
A special evening performance by multiplatinum singer Becky G will provide a memorable conclusion to TeievisaUnivision's Casa Cultura upfront event on May 1...
05/05/2024
Giant media buyer Publicis is telling network sales executives that it does not think Nielsen's new panel-plus-big-data currency is ready for this upfront....
05/05/2024
WASHINGTON Glenn Kirschner, legal analyst at NBC News, blasted the media for referring to the New York trial of former President Donald Trump as a hush-money ...
05/05/2024
Catchy Comedy's weekend marathon sees The Beverly Hillbillies on the weekend of May 4-5. The event kicks off Saturday, May 4 at 11 a.m. ET, and runs through...
05/05/2024
NBC Sports has the 150th Kentucky Derby Saturday, May 4. The coverage begins at 2:30 p.m. ET on NBC and Peacock and the feature race at Churchill Downs in Louis...
05/05/2024
Back to All News
Netflix Announces New Comedy Series Roosters, Starring Jeroen ...
05/05/2024
Back to All News
Showdown Alert: Baki Hanma VS Kengan Ashura' Drops Electr...
04/05/2024
NEW YORK As the Asian Pacific American Heritage Month kicks off in May, Nielsen has released an extensive new report diving into their media habits with data sh...
04/05/2024
PHILADELPHIA As National Military Appreciation Month gets underway, Comcast has announced several new initiatives to help veterans, service members, and their f...
04/05/2024
WASHINGTON, D.C. Federal Communications Commission chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel has announced a tentative agenda for the May Open Commission Meeting scheduled...
04/05/2024
The Broadband Forum has announced major enhancements to key 5G convergence standards that the group said will help advance next-generation applications, improve...
04/05/2024
Spotify Wrapped Campaign Spot Graded With DaVinci Resolve Studio
Brie Clayton May 3, 2024
0 Comments
Blackmagic Design today announced that Colorist M...
04/05/2024
Three Boston Conservatory at Berklee Alums Nominated for Tony Awards An additional eight alums and two current students performed in nominated productions.
...
04/05/2024
New faces and new storylines': What to expect on Izingane ZeS'thembu...
03/05/2024
An innovative learning tool to help media and civil society better understand ho...
03/05/2024
PARK CITY, UTAH - JANUARY 21: (L-R) Actors K stutis Cic nas and Greta Grinevi i t , Director Marija Kavtaradze and Producer Marija Razgute attend the 2023 Sunda...
03/05/2024
If you aren't familiar with Danny Ocean's music, it's only a matter ...
03/05/2024
Spotify has an unwavering commitment to supporting emerging artists across all genres, to helping them launch and thrive in their careers, and to connecting the...
03/05/2024
Como uno de los sonidos de mayor expansi n en el mundo, la M sica Mexicana va m ...
03/05/2024
As one of the fastest-growing sounds worldwide, M sica Mexicana is more than jus...
2012 protest at Foster City drug company Gilead Sciences | Noah Berger / Associated Press 
