2 June, 2016 - 08:00
e.tv has won its court appeal over the South African governments digital terrestrial television (DTT) policy, once again throwing the long-delayed switch to digital TV into further turmoil. by Thinus Ferreira
The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) in its scathing judgment slammed the minister of communications, Faith Muthambi, as confused, her decisions as irrational and found that she failed to consult South Africas broadcasters and TV industry properly over multiple changes to the countrys digital TV migration policy, most notably a far-reaching decision to allow for non-encrypted decoders.
In the switch from analogue to digital TV, a process known as digital migration, South African TV households have to buy a new set-top box (STB) for around R800 (households earning less than R3200 get a subsidised free box) to keep watching free-to-air TV channels like the SABC and e.tv which will in addition to their existing channel offering start additional channels.
After the original DTT policy said STBs will be encrypted and contain what is known as conditional access (CA), a form of STB control similar to a M-Net decoder, Faith Muthambi suddenly announced that free-to-air services will have non-encrypted decoders.
MultiChoice and the SABC - with the SABC now producing channels for DStv in a contract worth hundreds of millions of rand - supported the decision on non-encryption for free-to-air TV channels offering.
e.tv was against the decision and argued that it wont be able to compete since it wont be able to provide high definition (HD) channels and premium content because premium content providers, especially international suppliers, wont readily give content to a broadcaster who cant limit possible piracy.
e.tv, together with the public broadcasting civil society groups SOS Coalition, Media Monitoring Africa (MMA) and the industry body Namec took minister Faith Muthambi to court and the North High Court found in the department of communications favour.
e.tv however decided to appeal the decision and now the Supreme Court of Appeal has found in e.tvs favour.
This comes after the department of communications already ordered 1.5 million non-encrypted STBs from various local manufacturers - decoders that dont contain conditional access hardware and software.
Court: Minister misunderstood impact, failed to consult
The judgment means more disruption in the process already long-delayed with the South African government that has, after years of court battles, infighting, scandals, constant regulatory changes and bureaucratic bungling missed the internationally agreed to deadline of June 2015 by which to complete the process. In South Africa the commercial DTT phase has not even begun.
The Supreme Court of Appeal slammed Faith Muthambis decisions as irrational, saying she misunderstood the massive impact of the non-encryption signal issue on South Africas TV industry.
The Supreme Court of Appeal in its scathing judgment also slammed Faith Muthambi for failing to properly consult with the TV industry and broadcasters.
Minister Faith Muthambis failure to consult, based upon her misunderstanding of what the 2015 amendment signified, was taken in a procedurally unfair manner, and was irrational, says the Supreme Court of Appeal in its judgment that finds that e.tv would be unable to compete with pay-TV providers.
The Ministers confusion as to the effect of the amendment shows its irrationality, and for that reason too it is in breach of the principle of legality and invalid. The appeal must succeed on the ground that the amendment was made in an irrational and thus unlawful manner and is inherently irrational as well.
The judgment founds that Faith Muthambi failed to consult properly with South Africas broadcasting regulator, the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (Icasa), the Universal Service & Access Agency of South Africa (Usaasa), and broadcasters like e.tv and others over the change to non-encryption for the digital TV regulations change.
The failure by minister Faith Muthambi to consult Icasa and Usaasa is even more egregious given their statutory duties. So, too, the failure to consult the appellants (e.tv and others), all of whom had an interest in the policy, was quite simply irrational.
e.tvs spokesperson Vasili Vass told Channel24 that the broadcaster is working on a statement.
In a statement from the SOS Coalition and MMA the groups say this judgment is not only a victory for e.tv, ourselves and and the people of South Africa in respect of the benefits they will derive from government-manufactured STBs outfitted with encryption technology. It is also a victory for our constitutional democracy.
http://www.channel24.co.za
Television
Africa South Africa
Most recent headlines
05/01/2027
Worlds first 802.15.4ab-UWB chip verified by Calterah and Rohde & Schwarz to be ...
04/08/2026
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, t...
04/07/2026
April 7 2026, 19:00 (PDT) Detective Conan: Fallen Angel of the Highway Opens in...
01/06/2026
January 6 2026, 05:30 (PST) Dolby Sets the New Standard for Premium Entertainment at CES 2026
Throughout the week, Dolby brings to life the latest innovatio...
30/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
30/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
30/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
30/05/2026
Zero in on one that says yes (and no)
Andy Marken May 29, 2026
0 Comments
Hero image courtesy of Deposit Photos
For content creators the most difficu...
29/05/2026
With InfoComm 2026 just weeks away, NDI is giving attendees plenty of reasons to...
29/05/2026
Reaffirming a partnership that has defined Canadian sports broadcasting since 19...
29/05/2026
Mobile/tablet is No. 2 device for watching TV, suggesting that the sports-production industry needs to take another look at the format
Ring Digital's Sprin...
29/05/2026
Berliner Ensemble, one of Berlin's five major theater companies, has expande...
29/05/2026
Solid State Logic will showcase its new compact, fly-away TCA Tour audio product...
29/05/2026
Gerald (Jerry) Pierce, a pioneering technologist who helped shape the digital transformation of the motion picture industry, passed away last month on April 12 ...
29/05/2026
Paramount+ will be the English-language U.S. home for Barclays Women's Super...
29/05/2026
Further strengthening its virtualisation strategy to fully support broadcasters ...
29/05/2026
Swiss broadcaster Canal Alpha has deployed Harmonic's award-winning, software-based XOS Advanced Media Processor to modernize playout operations across cant...
29/05/2026
PTZOptics will showcase a new generation of intelligent video workflows at InfoComm 2026, June 17-19, Las Vegas. Visitors to booth N8227 will see how PTZOptics ...
29/05/2026
Arizona's Family has launched the Arizona's Family Sports (AZFS) streaming app, a new direct-to-consumer destination for live, local sports. The app is ...
29/05/2026
Starting in 2027, DAZN will be the exclusive home of The Canadian Football Leagu...
29/05/2026
Comcast Business has detailed the advanced network infrastructure it has deploye...
29/05/2026
In two-day event, leaders from academia and industry explored solutions to chall...
29/05/2026
The Basketball Tournament (TBT), now entering their 13th year of competition, ha...
29/05/2026
Roku has launched FOX One as a Premium Subscription on The Roku Channel in the U.S. Roku customers can now subscribe to FOX One using their Roku account for liv...
29/05/2026
In its sixth year, the broadcaster's coverage has become a global brand and ...
29/05/2026
Ratings Roundup is a rundown of recent ratings news and is derived from press re...
29/05/2026
The days are getting longer, the temperatures are rising, and playlists are filling up for the season. With summer around the corner, Spotify's global edito...
29/05/2026
New retro-inspired MPC announced
There are few devices that have gained the status held by Akai Pro's MPC range, and in recent years, the company have s...
29/05/2026
Save up to 30 on acclaimed titles
Following a successful launch at Superbooth 2026, Bjooks have revealed that they will be continuing the Kickstarter campa...
29/05/2026
Binaural monitoring application improved
Genelec have just released an update that brings some powerful new features to their HRTF-based binaural headphone ...
29/05/2026
6 June 2026 at SAE Institute, London, UK
IMSTA FESTA 2026 is almost upon us, with some of the biggest names in pro-audio set to descend upon SAE Institute i...
29/05/2026
Gerald (Jerry) Pierce, a pioneering technologist who helped shape the digital transformation of the motion picture industry, died April 12, 2026, at his home in...
29/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
29/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
29/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
29/05/2026
Comparing 5 AI Video Enhancers for Restoring Old Video Quality
Kate Luvis May 29, 2026
0 Comments
Digitizing VHS, MiniDV, and other legacy formats doe...
29/05/2026
Studio Hamburg Builds New Post Pipeline with DaVinci Resolve Studio
Brie Clayton May 29, 2026
0 Comments
Workflow replaces a patchwork of legacy tools...
29/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
29/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
29/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
29/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
29/05/2026
Share
Copy link
Facebook
X
Linkedin
Bluesky
Email...
29/05/2026
At the Intersection of Music and Dance, an Epic Collaboration Boston Conservatory musicians and dancers found creative parallels in their recent performance o...
29/05/2026
Back to All News
Latino Film Institute Fellows Screen Their Short Films at the Egyptian Theatre
The Inclusion Fellowship and Spark Animation Grant uplifts 15 ...
29/05/2026
GLOOKAST LAUNCHES CINNAFILM TACHYON PLUGIN FOR MEDIA PRODUCER AND MEDIA SERVICES
This release first appeared here.
Visit our Tachyon product page or contact...
29/05/2026
May 29 2026, 09:00 (PDT) Dolby and rednote Bring More Immersive Storytelling to...
29/05/2026
Something fundamental has shifted in how people consume media. Audiences aren't abandoning television or radio content; they're just expanding how, wher...
29/05/2026
Youtube exclusive special drops today
Watch now
UKTV today announces another e...
29/05/2026
Back to All News
The Official Trailer of Physical 100 Italy, on Netflix From Se...
2 June, 2016 - 08:00 
