Sony Pixel Power calrec Sony

The End of ESPN D, the Future of the D Format

13/06/2013

It was June 2010 and the ESPN campus was buzzing. Not only was the network immersed in the kickoff of the 2010 World Cup in South Africa, but company executives as well as a number of reporters were on hand for the start of something new: ESPN 3D. A new era in televised sport had begun.

But, at the end of this year, that era let's call it the first 3D-sports era in the U.S. will come to an end. There will be no 3D World Cup in 2014, at least not in the U.S. (FIFA has not decided whether it will offer a 3D feed, but ESPN's dropping out of the we are interested column definitely does not help another 3D World Cup become a reality). And a wealth of other sports Wimbledon, The Masters, college football's national championship, the X Games will also not be available in 3D.

When ESPN launched the 3D service, it seemed as if it would not be alone in its commitment to the cause. Sony was on board as a partner, sponsoring the channel. And Panasonic and DIRECTV had a similar arrangement for a channel, with the former doubling down and sponsoring the US Open tennis tournament in 3D as well. Fox Sports delivered a 3D broadcast of the National Football Championship Game from Miami. Fox also delivered the MLB All-Star Game in 3D, and the YES Network did the same for a Yankees-Mariners baseball game. CBS broadcast the NCAA Final Four men's tournament to theaters around the country in 3D. The Masters also received the 3D treatment. Even the NFL dabbled in a 3D theater broadcast. And, of course, all those events were simply catching up to the NBA, which had been working in 3D since 2007. And then there were the London 2012 Olympics and countless other sports events produced in 3D around the globe.

But, with ESPN's announcement that its 3D channel will end broadcasts at the end of this year, the 3D format seems officially headed into hibernation mode, at least among U.S. broadcasters. The 3D format will, however, still have a presence in video-on-demand services, Blu-ray, and theaters.

Producing content in 3D was never easy, especially in 2010-11. The 3D camera rigs and the quality-control equipment were still in their infancy.

Since those early days, the efforts of ESPN, BskyB, and CBS with technology partners CAMERON PACE Group (CPG) and 3ality Technica have continually improved the 3D production process. And the uncompressed 3D images in the production truck? They were always stunning, comfortable, and compelling, regardless of the event. Even the very first event, the 2010 World Cup, saw improvement from the first match to the last. There was little doubt that positive developments related to 3D production tools were directly correlated to the number of events being produced in 3D.

Of course, many involved in live sports production are probably sleeping a bit easier: 3D broadcasts are difficult, time-consuming, and often simply layered on top of HD duties. And then there is 4K, the new darling of the consumer-electronics industry. The 4K-marketing dollars will soon begin flowing to make 4K sports productions a reality, much the way 3D-marketing dollars flowed to sports productions (and ESPN) three years ago.

In the coming days, there will no doubt be articles about ESPN's decision and whether it means the death of 3D. There will be discussions about why 3D failed. Topping the list of reasons? The glasses.

The glasses problem turned out to be about much more than their use in the living room. The need for glasses greatly inhibited the ability of consumer-electronics showrooms to properly demonstrate 3D to the public.

First, the need for active glasses led most 3D displays to require consumers to look through a pair of 3D glasses mounted atop an adjustable pole so that it could be raised and lowered to suit the viewer's height. Of course, many of those poles often had no glasses, which had been stolen. And, even if there was a pair of glasses, one could not help thinking that sticking your nose into a pair of glasses sitting in a showroom was about as sanitary as licking the buttons on an elevator. Trying out consumer electronics should never make you wonder whether you've recently had a tetanus shot.

So consumers never had a chance to really experience the 3D-viewing experience.

A bigger problem faced consumers even if they did decide to partake of 3D broadcasts: lousy resolution. The 3D channels are sent over the same bandwidth as an HD channel. Because the left- and right-eye signals (or top and bottom) share the same bandwidth, resolution is effectively cut in half, making consumers choose between an HD 2D experience or an SD 3D one. And that makes the 3D experience sometimes seem as much a step back as a step forward.

Lack of Marketing Cohesion

As if the retail 3D experience were not bad enough to discourage consumers from buying into 3D, there was also marketing confusion and a lack of cohesion. First, unlike HD, 3D never had a chance to become a marketing tool for satellite, cable, and telco operators to use against each other.

When DIRECTV began delivering dozens of HD channels, it turned up the competitive pressure on cable operators to respond in kind. And both offered broadcast and cable networks a reason to launch HD services. When DIRECTV launched its 3D services, cable operators simply launched 3D VOD services and called it a day. As a result, 3D never became a buzz.

Another problem was having companies like Sony and Panasonic sponsor channels. True, it gave ESPN 3D the financial gas to be a reality. Ditto for DIRECTV's 3D channel. But it led to issues that, ultimately, stymied the popularity of 3D, siphoning away money that could have ensured that the nation's biggest sports events were delivered in 3D, regardless of which network carried the event.

Will 3D Go Away?

The irony of the current situation is that a good porti
LINK: http://sportsvideo.org/main/blog/2013/06/13/the-end-of-espn-3d-the-fut...
See more stories from svg

Most recent headlines

04/08/2024

Dalet Appoints Santiago Solanas as CEO to Lead Next Era of Growth and Innovation

Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, is excited to announce Santiago Solanas as its new Chief Executive Officer (CEO)....

03/06/2024

Dalet and Veritone Reach Agreement to Distribute, Transact and Monetize Media Archives

Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, a...

30/04/2024

The Anchor of Our Work at the Native Lab: A Dispatch from Adam Piron

By Adam Piron In anticipation of this edition of the Indigenous Program's Native Lab, it actually dawned on me that this will be our lab's tenth year i...

30/04/2024

Launch of SBS South Asian channel and SBS Spice, a new English language offering for younger South Asian Australians

Launch of SBS South Asian channel and SBS Spice, a new English language offering...

30/04/2024

lodie Ichter Joins Light Iron as Senior Colorist

LOS ANGELES (April 30, 2024) Light Iron, the post-production creative-services division of Panavision, is excited to announce that lodie Ichter has joined th...

30/04/2024

Breadth of Support

Now streaming on Netflix, Good Grief marks the feature-film directorial debut of Daniel Levy, well known as the co-creator and costar of the series Schitt's...

30/04/2024

PBS Masterpiece Sets Third TV Adaptation Of The Forsyte Saga'

The Forsyte Saga, John Galsworthy's sweeping portrait of a wealthy British family in 1880s London, is getting its third TV adaptation in less than 60 years....

30/04/2024

Clear-Coms Eclipse HX and Agent-IC Technology Illuminate Coverage of Solar Eclipse

eds3_5_jq(document).ready(function($) { $(#eds_sliderM519).chameleonSlider_2_1({...

30/04/2024

Plex Partners with T-Mobile To Grow Connected TV Reach

CAMPBELL, Calif. Streaming media company Plex and T-Mobile will work together to expand T-Mobile's connected TV (CTV) inventory and advance the connection b...

30/04/2024

Roku, iSpot Launch Expanded Streaming Audience Measurement Partnership

SAN JOSE, Calif. & BELLEVUE, Wash. Roku, Inc. has announced an expanded measurement partnership with iSpot.tv, the cross-platform TV measurement company....

30/04/2024

Paramount+ Subs Hit 71M as Revenue Grew by 51% YoY

NEW YORK As Paramount Global wrestled with management turmoil and ongoing negotiations for a proposed merger with Skydance, the company managed to report improv...

30/04/2024

Cobalt Digital Receives Trifecta of Awards at NAB 2024

Cobalt Digital Receives Trifecta of Awards at NAB 2024 Company adds two 2024 NAB Show Product of the Year awards and one Best of Show from TV Tech to long list...

30/04/2024

arkonas BLADE runner IP Audio Engine Receives Best of Sho...

arkona technologies GmbH, provider of IP core infrastructure solutions for top-tier broadcast productions, has announced that its BLADE//runner IP Audio Engine ...

30/04/2024

OpenDrives Joins AWS Partner Network

OpenDrives, Inc., the global provider of software-defined media workflow solutions and data management capabilities, announced today that it has joined the glob...

30/04/2024

dandb group unveils SustainSymphony a ground-breaking clo...

The first norm conform sustainability service dedicated to the needs of the events industry Easy-to-use, intuitive platform for venues, event organisers and su...

30/04/2024

Dejero Smart Blending Technology opens new opportunities...

Dejero GateWay enables Stream7 to create independent internet connectivity at any venue or location, including UK teaching hospital for live streaming of surgic...

30/04/2024

farmerswife and Cirkus to Showcase Cutting-Edge Solutions...

Excitement is building as farmerswife, a leading software provider for resource scheduling, project management, and team collaboration in the media industry, ha...

30/04/2024

XL8 Clears SOC 2 Type II Audit Enhancing Data Security

XL8, a leading deep-tech startup specializing in AI-powered machine translation technology, proudly announces the successful completion of a System and Organiza...

30/04/2024

CABSAT 2024 - Leader and PHABRIX to showcase latest Test...

Test & measurement innovator, Leader Electronics of Europe, has announced that it will exhibit at CABSAT, which takes place this year from 21-23 May 2024 at the...

30/04/2024

MRMC Debuts Cinebot Max Camera Robot at NAB 2024

MRMC Debuts Cinebot Max Camera Robot at NAB 2024 Brie Clayton April 30, 2024 0 Comments Expands its range of live-action, motion-control camera robots...

30/04/2024

Next Jazz Legacy Announces 2024 Cohort of Women and Nonbinary Awardees

Next Jazz Legacy Announces 2024 Cohort of Women and Nonbinary Awardees The program was created by New Music USA and the Berklee Institute of Jazz and Gender J...

30/04/2024

SES Announces Acqusition of Intelsat for $3.1B

European telecom satellite company SES announced today that it is acquiring rival Intelsat for $3.1 billion. The deal, unanimously approved by both companies...

30/04/2024

Bakish Out at Paramount

Bob Bakish, chief executive of Paramount stepped down on Monday, effective immediately. Bakish, who was a staunch ally of Shari Redstone, controlling shareholde...

30/04/2024

Hotspring unveils Slapshot ML-driven rotoscoping solution

Hotspring said the breakthrough had been achieved through the acceleration of machine learning technology By Matthew Corrigan Published: April 30, 2024 Ho...

30/04/2024

SES to acquire Intelsat in $3.1 billion deal

Speaking about the deal, Adel Al-Saleh, CEO of SES, said: it will bring value-added, efficient, and reliable offerings for both companies media customers By Je...

30/04/2024

Bob Bakish officially out at Paramount, new Office of the CEO finalising long-term plan'

Paramount said the Office of the CEO is working with its board to develop a comp...

30/04/2024

Gray Television Using NextGen TV to Roll Out Advanced Features Like HDR

LOUISVILLE, Ky. In another sign that broadcasters are finally using NextGen TV broadcasts to offer viewers new features instead of simply simulcasting existing ...

30/04/2024

Oklahoma Journalism Hall of Fame To Honor Blaise Labbe

OKLAHOMA CITY The Oklahoma Journalism Hall of Fame will induct Blaise Labbe, a group news director for Sinclair Broadcast Group, May 2 at the 54th Anniversary I...

30/04/2024

Cox Media Group, Dish Ink New Multi-Year Agreement

ATLANTA and ENGLEWOOD, Colo. Cox Media Group and Dish have ended a dispute over retransmission fees that lasted nearly a year and a half with a new multi-year ...

30/04/2024

TelevisaUnivision Taps LTN for IP-Based Distribution

Video transport solution provider LTN has announced that it is working with TelevisaUnivision to help the Spanish-language media giant migrate to IP-based video...

30/04/2024

NBC KXAS and Telemundo KXTX Used Clear-Com Solutions for Eclipse Coverage

ALAMEDA, Calif. Clear-Com has released details about how it played a pivotal role in the seamless coverage of the recent solar eclipse on April 8, 2024 by NBC K...

30/04/2024

Scripps Appoints Seth Walters To Steer CTV Sales Strategy

CINCINNATI The E.W. Scripps Company is adding Seth Walters to its sales leadership team as head of CTV sales, effective April 29....

30/04/2024

Durham Bulls Saturday Game, First Sellout of 2024 Season

The force was strong at the Durham Bulls Athletic Park on Saturday night, April 27, 2024, as the night netted the ballpark's first official sellout crowd of...

30/04/2024

NewFront Life Is a Cabaret for LGBTQ+ Network Revry

Revry, a network celebrating queer culture. said its second annual NewFront presentation will be a cabaret-type spectacle showcasing the spirit of the LGBTQ+ co...

30/04/2024

FETV Viewers Say Howdy' as Wyatt Earp' Joins Lineup

Family Entertainment Television (FETV) said that the Western series The Life and Legend of Wyatt Earp will be joining the network's afternoon lineup startin...

30/04/2024

Bob Bakish Departing Paramount, According to Reports

Bob Bakish, president and CEO of Paramount Global, will depart the company as Paramount explores a merger, according to numerous published reports. The reports ...

30/04/2024

Tribeca Festival Announces Talks, Reunions & Retrospectives

April 30th, 2024 Press Materials Available Here TRIBECA FESTIVAL 2024 ANNOUNCES TALKS, REUNIONS, & RETROSPECTIVES Live Conversations with Judd Apatow, Andy C...

30/04/2024

Solid momentum into the year for Telenor

6 minute read Share alt=Alternative descriptive text class=lazyload main main-lazyloaded responsive-image data-v-1a5ebb10> Telenor showed good momentum...

30/04/2024

SES Acquiring Intelsat to Create New Satellite Giant; Will Offer Improved Reach and Redundancy for Media Customers

SES Acquiring Intelsat to Create New Satellite Giant; Will Offer Improved Reach ...

30/04/2024

WDR Filmhaus to Implement Riedel Infrastructure

Wuppertal April 30, 2024 WDR Filmhaus to Implement Riedel Infrastructure Award-Winning MediorNet HorizoN Hybrid Processing Platform Serves as Bridge to IP Ri...

30/04/2024

Tilda Swinton Joins Colin Farrell in Edward Berger's 'The Ballad of a Small Player' for Netflix

Back to All News Tilda Swinton Joins Colin Farrell in Edward Bergers The Ballad...

30/04/2024

Netflix Reveals First Look Images and Teaser from 'Senna', Inspired on the Life of Famed F1 Driver

Back to All News Netflix Reveals First Look Images and Teaser from Senna, Inspi...

30/04/2024

Top 10 Week of Apr. 22: Baby Reindeer' and Rebel Moon - Part Two: The Scargiver' Hold Onto the Top Spots

Back to All News Top 10 Week of Apr. 22: Baby Reindeer' and Rebel Moon - ...

30/04/2024

Female Leadership in the Age of AI: United Kingdom

Dr. Nicola Hodson, Chief Executive, IBM UK & Ireland introduces the UK findings of an IBM study on female leadership in the age of AI Advances in Artificial In...

30/04/2024

FOR-As RDS Conductor Wins 2024 NAB Show Product of the Year Award

Channel Expansion, and New Codecs, Compression and Transport Technology Among Latest Updates...

30/04/2024

Accel-KKR Credit Partners Provides Growth Financing to Dalet

Accel-KKR Credit Partners today announced that it has provided debt financing to support Dalet in its next chapter of innovation and growth. Accel-KKR Credit Pa...

30/04/2024

Skeem Saam: Monday's episode, 29 April 2024 [video]

Skeem Saam: Monday's episode, 29 April 2024 [video]Missed an episode of Skeem Saam? No problem! Watch the latest episode of your favourite South African soa...

30/04/2024

Tonight on Skeem Saam: Lewatle witnesses an explosive fight between Sthoko and Babeile

Tonight on Skeem Saam: Lewatle witnesses an explosive fight between Sthoko and B...

30/04/2024

RT NEWS ANNOUNCES DAVID MURPHY AS NEW ECONOMICS & PUBLIC AFFAIRS CORRESPONDENT

RT News is pleased to announce the appointment of David Murphy as its new Economics & Public Affairs Correspondent. David is currently RT 's Political Cove...