
Survey Says: SDI-IP Transition More Disruptive than Most This blog was written by Joe McGarvey, Director of Marketing at Imagine Communications and was posted online on 27 March 2017. Click here to view the original
The people have spoken - loudly. By an overwhelming majority, respondents to our Instant Opinion Poll from back in January view the ongoing migration of all media operations to an IT-based environment as anything but business as usual. In fact, 78% of you said that the SDI-to-IP technology changeover was a once-in-a-generation transition, scoring much higher on the degree-of-difficultly (and disruption) meter than, say, the evolution from SD to HD or from MPEG-2 to MPEG-4.
We also know, based on a not-so-instant survey from last year, that media industry professionals are just as concerned about the cultural disturbances of a shift of operations to a new technology foundation as they are the technological ones. Nearly half of you told us you were worried about weathering the potential job-related fallout associated with applying your skills and expertise to a new technology environment.
Concerns range from the need for additional training to overall job security. Some of the questions broadcast engineers may be asking include:
Do I possess the skills to architect, support and troubleshoot IP-based facilities?
Will I require extensive retraining, including new certifications?
Will I be reporting to the CIO?
Will my job be devalued given the size of the IT workforce?
Is my career in jeopardy and will I be displaced by a new breed of IT-savvy engineers?
The unvarnished reality for today's broadcast engineers and other media professionals is that the transition to a more agile and flexible technology platform, mandated by the need to meet evolving and increasingly personalized consumption habits, will bring changes to your day-to-day job descriptions. There's no sugarcoating the fact that media professionals will need to understand how IP networks work and acquire some degree of proficiency in IP network design principles and terminology. How much expertise is still up in the air and will likely vary from company to company and depend heavily on the manner in which media companies integrate - or keep segregated - the media production and IT portions of their organizations.
Degree of Difficulty
At a minimum, broadcast engineers will need to learn a new lexicon. Overcoming the jargon of a new specialty is often the first - and sometimes the biggest - hurdle to gaining proficiency in a new discipline. Broadcast engineers and IT specialists sometimes use different terms for the same concept or, even more confounding, alike terms for dissimilar concepts. The terms router and routing, as obvious examples, mean different things to broadcasters and IT professionals.
Transitioning skill sets to a new technology environment, though, will likely require more than simply breaking through language barriers. Additional education and certification from established enterprise and cloud IT specialists, such as Cisco or Microsoft, is a strong possibility. Chances are that you'll need to join the ranks of those who have been certified to work with equipment from one or more of a dozen makers of IP-based routing and switching gear. Familiarity with popular IT configuration and troubleshooting software, such as Chef, Puppet and Wireshark, is probably in your future, too.
In larger media companies, broadcast professionals may be able to leave much of the heavy lifting to IT specialists, functioning more as consultants and network architects to ensure that the resulting network delivers acceptable latency and is capable of the split-second synchronization that complex and multi-camera live broadcasts require. Other scenarios may require broadcast engineers to possess the skills to assemble broadcast-quality IP facilities, meaning they will need familiarity with and proficiency in IP network architectures, like leaf and spine, and Software Defined Networking (SDN), as well as troubleshooting skills, such as Ethernet debugging.
At the extreme end of the broadcast engineer IP transition spectrum is the need for a new job description and title. Some industry experts suspect that the assimilation of broadcast engineers into the IT realm will be significant enough to result in an entirely new job description, one that is essentially equal parts broadcast and IT. Already popping up on some job boards are titles like IP Broadcast Engineer or Broadcast IT Engineer.
Continued Reading The changing role of media industry technologists in the hybrid SDI-IP or all-IP production facility and related topics are expanded upon in the recently released eBook The Future of Broadcast Engineering: Dealing with the Cultural Impact of the Fusion of Broadcast and IT.
The new eBook includes an objective assessment of how the ongoing commingling of the broadcast and IT realms may impact the day-to-day activities of broadcast engineers, as well as potentially alter the trajectory of their career paths. It provides a preview of the potential training and education broadcast engineers may need to acquire in the future and offers guidelines on how media companies and broadcast professionals can manage this generational transition with the least amount of disruption and greatest probability of success.
Polls and surveys can be helpful, mostly by giving credence to what we already know. The job description of the broadcast engineer is destined to evolve. That reality is undisputable. But for those of you who are willing to embrace change and seize the opportunities it presents, your futures in the IP-enabled era of the media & entertainment industry could be brighter than ever.
Questions or comments? Send your feedback
Most recent headlines
09/11/2025
Dalet today announced a transformative leap forward for media operations: Agentic Artificial Intelligence (AI) that unifies the Dalet ecosystem under one natura...
03/11/2025
Broadcasters have spent years trying to integrate different vendor technologies in their facilities. As the industry has moved closer to software, that struggle...
03/11/2025
As the malevolent siege against broadcasters' interests intensifies from the far reaches of artificial intelligence misuse to relentless innovation in the m...
03/11/2025
Wheatstone founder and owner Gary Snow will retire from the company by the end of next year....
03/11/2025
In ye olde days of traditional television, when U.S. TV viewing options were limited to ABC, CBS, NBC and PBS, Nielsen's paper diaries were sufficient for t...
03/11/2025
They've made that decision and ruined an awful lot of people's lives.
...
02/11/2025
Abu Dhabi, UAE November 2, 2025: Space42 (ADX: SPACE42), the UAE-based AI-powe...
01/11/2025
Thunderbolt 3 Now Standard on Symphony MkII - Starting November 11 Beginning November 11, all new Apogee Symphony I/O MkII units will ship with Thunderbolt 3 as...
01/11/2025
How to Expand the Apogee Symphony Desktop with Cranborne 500ADAT Want to expand your Symphony Desktop beyond two inputs? Whether you're tracking a full drum...
01/11/2025
aconnic AG (ISIN: DE000A0LBKW6), Munich, has published the Financial Report for ...
01/11/2025
tvONE is proud to announce a strategic partnership with Matrox Video, combining CALICO PRO's high-performance video processing with the Matrox ConvertIP Ser...
01/11/2025
CJP Broadcast has joined the Grass Valley partner programme as both a Systems Integration Partner and AMPP Partner. The collaboration enhances CJP's ability...
01/11/2025
TAG Video Systems, the leader in software-based IP end-to-end workflow monitoring, deep probing, and real-time visualization, has earned a higher-rated DPP Comm...
01/11/2025
Michael Napodano Appointed New CEO Of Operative Media
Operative today announced the appointment of Mike Napodano as Chief Executive Officer, marking the next s...
01/11/2025
Film industry professionals flocked to Cine Gear Expo Atlanta 2025 at celebrated Trilith Studios in Fayetteville, Georgia, on October 3 and 4. Back for its 6th ...
01/11/2025
Photo courtesy of Peacock and Sky
Christopher Ross, BSC, began his cinematic obsession early. He cites reading Scorsese on Scorsese as a teenager with teaching...
01/11/2025
NEW YORK ITN and the sell-side advertising company Magnite have announced the launch of what they are billing as the industrys first Local Linear TV Private Mar...
31/10/2025
FanDuel Sports Network To Deliver Selected Live NBA, NHL Games to Major Streamin...
31/10/2025
NBC Jumps Out of the Gate in Extended Breeder's Cup Deal With Dual Drones, J...
31/10/2025
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
30 October 2025
It is with great sadness that we mourn the passing of Segomotso Keorapetse, an award- winning South African television d...
31/10/2025
IRVING, Texas As station groups move into an era that promises rapid tech, regulatory and economic changes, Nexstar Media Group said its board has extended chai...
31/10/2025
While some analysts have questioned the ongoing economic viability of broacast-TV late night shows amid ongoing declines in linear viewing, new data from Tubula...
31/10/2025
The contentious contract negotiations between The Walt Disney Co. and YouTube TV have resulted in a blackout of Disney-owned programming on the pay TV operator....
31/10/2025
CINCINNATI Video conversion and AV signal distribution specialist tvONE and Matrox Video have struck a strategic partnership, combining CALICO PRO's video p...
31/10/2025
NEW YORK The Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) today released a new industry guide that discusses the urgency of adopting new standards that will help advert...
31/10/2025
While some analysts have questioned the ongoing economic viability of late night shows on broadcast TV amid ongoing declines in linear viewing, new data from Tu...
31/10/2025
Berklee Celebrates the Inauguration of President Jim Lucchese In his inaugural address, Lucchese shared an optimistic vision for Berklee's future as a for...
31/10/2025
Back to All News
Family, Food, and Films: Netflix's Dining with the Kapoors...
31/10/2025
The review highlights DPA 4055 Kick Drum Microphone for its compact design, ease of placement, and authentic tone that captures the true character of the drum p...
31/10/2025
The RT Raidi na Gaeltachta Award 2025 will be presented to journalist P il n N Chiar in at the Oireachtas na Samhna in Belfast tomorrow, Saturday 1 November,...
31/10/2025
RT lyric fm is calling for choirs across Ireland to share their festive music-m...
31/10/2025
Three awards were presented to RT Raidi na Gaeltachta broadcasters at the Oire...
31/10/2025
RT continues its proud tradition of championing Ireland's vibrant arts and cultural landscape through its RT Supporting the Arts initiative. This November...
31/10/2025
RT selects Irish independent production company to produce Christian Worship on...
31/10/2025
Amidst Gyeongju, South Korea's ancient temples and modern skylines, Jensen H...
30/10/2025
Midwich has signed a UK and Ireland distribution deal with X2O Media, a worldwid...
30/10/2025
SVG Students To Watch: Sam Newitt, Kansas State UniversityThe South Dakota native thrives in many roles behind the scenes at K-StateHD.TVBy Brandon Costa, Direc...
30/10/2025
SVG Sit-Down: Swerve Sports' Christy Tanner Explores the Young FAST Channel&...
30/10/2025
SVG Campus Shot Callers: Andy Liebsch, Senior Director, Video Services, Kansas S...
30/10/2025
Diversified Names Paul Lidsky CEO, Expanding Leadership Role After Serving as Bo...
30/10/2025
NBA, Cosm Enter Long-Term Partnership for Shared Reality Production, Distributio...
30/10/2025
SVG New Sponsor Spotlight: FanConnect's Brett Crossley on Reimagining the Ga...
30/10/2025
FanDuel Sports Network to Deliver Select Live NBA, NHL Games to Major Streaming ...
30/10/2025
As the year comes to a close, we can feel the invigorating wind sweeping in for ...
30/10/2025
By Bailey Pennick
One of the most exciting things about the Sundance Film Festi...
30/10/2025
The SGL Carbon site in Bonn has a long tradition of training. For many years, young talent has been successfully trained here, regularly achieving excellent exa...
30/10/2025
SBS, NITV and Screen Australia announce 2025 Digital Originals Shortlist
29 October, 2025
Media releases
SBS, NITV and Screen Australia are excited to unve...
30/10/2025
Jon Rambeau, President of Integrated Mission Systems at L3Harris Technologies, speaks about industrial collaboration at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (A...
30/10/2025
MELBOURNE, Fla., October 30, 2025 - L3Harris Technologies (NYSE: LHX) reports th...
30/10/2025
WASHINGTON Federal Communications Commission Chair Brendan Carr said he has circulated a proposal for the agency to auction additional midband spectrum in the U...