The changing face of service provision in the broadcast & media business. As another production and media content supply chain operator files for bankruptcy and with some big names rushing out of the market, Julian Wright examines what went wrong for outsourcing in media and broadcast and what the emerging business models look like.
This article first appeared in Content & Technology Asia magazine, the original version is available here: Outsource - Insource
The Rise of Outsourcing Outsourcing is the slightly ugly portmanteau of outside' and resourcing' which has sadly, and probably wrongly, become synonymous with large, private firms making lots of money by providing services to publicly funded government bodies. Actually, it's unlikely that these outsourced capabilities would be any more cost effective if they were managed internally as a public service function, but broadly there is the perception that the outsourced service provider has the best end of the deal.
In our industry, broadcasters started outsourcing the linear playout function in the 90's - leading to a significant number of service providers springing up or divesting from the bigger broadcasters. These new service providers could make a simple economies of scale business case to investors - because playout is largely the same for broadcaster A as it is for broadcaster B, by centralising the function they could provide services to both broadcaster A and B without a proportional rise in cost.
This model also offered the potential for external service providers to increase their earnings by providing additional services, particularly mandated services - including subtitling, audio description and visual signing The unspoken view was that, once broadcaster A was signed up for five-year term for playout, they would also be locked in for the provision of as-yet unforeseen and, crucially, un-priced ancillary services which may be mandatory in the future. This opportunity has grown significantly in recent years with commercially motivated ancillary services from red button' to OTT (Over the Top) becoming an increasingly important part of the broadcaster's offering.
The outsourcing model quickly spread further up the production chain - to content preparation, compliance, versioning, format conversion etc. - and the industry perception was that these service providers had a lucrative business model. But now, as more operators flee the market or go into administration, the question is why did such apparently robust, indeed lopsided, business models fail and what is replacing them?
An Overly Competitive Market Many of the problems stemmed from the basic issue that the supply-side of the market rapidly became too crowded and is, therefore, now overly competitive. The broadcasters, aware that they have the upper hand in the service tendering process, are able drive down the price to barely sustainable levels with one hand, whilst setting out punitive measures for transgressions of operational service levels (which they themselves were unable to achieve when they directly owned the operational function) with the other. Perhaps relying on the promise of the ancillary services upsell opportunity and economies of scale, the service providers accede to these pressures and agree deals that have an attractive top line but a dangerously open-ended set of costs.
Not only do the service providers sign up to tight-margin deals, they also allowed their broadcaster customers to dictate even the technology that is to be used in the provision of service. This has resulted in facilities being forced to run different playout engines and different transmission automation systems for different clients. This completely negates the economy of scale business case and actually drives up costs for resourcing and training. Some of these costs are passed back to the broadcasters so the model in part represents an equipment financing package.
Rushed Implementations = Sub-Optimised Workflows = High Operational Costs Invariably the contract negotiations and award run late, but the commencement of service date does not move - either for a new operation or migration of services. This puts extraordinary pressure on the service provider who can either agree to a compressed implementation schedule or risk losing the deal. Having spent potentially tens of thousands on the bid process already, invariably the service provider will convince themselves that by throwing resources' at the problem they can get the operation on-air in time.
The first casualty of this approach is always the operational business modelling in the context of people, process and data mapped to the services that have been sold. Without a service and operating model there is a rush to buy kit due to those (false) long delivery lead times. But without an operating model the only way to build an operational workflow which can service the contract is with humans, potentially lots of them. The stance on this is that we will build properly defined and automated process as soon as we are in operation and generating revenue, the staffing level is only temporary. In reality, having spent money to get into service, there is reluctance to spend more on what is seen as re-engineering, particularly if this highlights that some of the must-have equipment purchased only weeks before is inappropriate. The staff - usually highly experienced and therefore fairly expensive contractors - are retained and the business model is further compromised. The operation enters service with the provider on the back foot, and then the real pressure starts.
Genuine Partnerships are More Effective than Asymmetric Master / Servant Relationships A modern broadcast' operation, from raw material arrivals to consumer delivery, is complex and becoming increasingly so. But the
More from Blue Lucy Media
11/04/2024
Blue Lucy, has hired accomplished industry expert Alison Pavitt as chief marketing officer. Pavitt's appointment into the newly created role concludes a per...
06/08/2023
I was quite pleased to be asked recently by a Canadian colleague what our theme would be for the upcoming IBC. For me, theme reflects the ethos of the Blue Lu...
06/08/2023
I was quite pleased to be asked recently by a Canadian colleague what our theme would be for the upcoming IBC. For me, theme reflects the ethos of the Blue Lu...
13/06/2023
Media technology suppliers have been complaining about the tendering and Request for Proposal (RFP) process for a long time. Many of their grievances have been ...
17/03/2023
Blue Lucy announced today that they will not be launching any new products at NAB 2023, April 16-19, at the Las Vegas Convention Centre. The company will, howe...
17/03/2023
Blue Lucy announced today that they will not be launching any new products at NAB 2023, April 16-19, at the Las Vegas Convention Centre. The company will, howe...
17/03/2023
Blue Lucy announced today that they will not be launching any new products at NAB 2023, April 16-19, at the Las Vegas Convention Centre. The company will, howe...
24/08/2022
The balloon cloud installation at IBC 2018, the cloud in the Rai, as it was known at Blue Lucy Towers, was intended to mark the end of Blue Lucy's participa...
20/07/2022
On reading our recent article on the Blue Lucy implementation at A E Networks UK, available here, I was reminded that the project was extremely well received by...
06/04/2022
Here at Blue Lucy towers, we are constantly intrigued by industry buzz phrases, particularly how even the helpful ones are devalued by overuse and misappropriat...
15/01/2022
Cloud native, software defined, the metaverse; the media technology sector is awash with buzz phrases. And, as with all popular terms which are used too libera...
06/12/2021
Imagine if TV companies charged consumers by the minute to watch a football match. Or if your office rent increased when you had a particularly busy month. S...
06/12/2021
Imagine if TV companies charged consumers by the minute to watch a football match. Or if your office rent increased when you had a particularly busy month at w...
09/03/2021
There has been widespread discussion of new, fully digital and cloud based content supply chains, in the media industry since about 2016. Some innovators have p...
27/11/2020
There are probably more cloud-based services providing functional capability for media operations than for any other commercial sector. These services range fr...
24/11/2020
As the complexity of media supply chain operations increases, the requirement for an integrated, business focused approach is vital. ATEME and Blue Lucy expert...
19/10/2020
The need for content distributors and broadcasters to deliver media to an ever-growing range of consumer platforms has led to a significant rise in the number o...
19/10/2020
In my recent post The Automation Paradox I highlighted the risks associated with developing a workflow orchestration platform in-house'. Cloud based servi...
15/10/2020
The need for content distributors and broadcasters to deliver media to an ever-growing range of consumer platforms has led to an exponential rise in the number ...
07/09/2020
Off the Fence (OTF), an award-winning producer and distributor of factual television and feature-length theatrical documentaries, has recently migrated their co...
04/09/2020
Off the Fence (OTF), an award-winning producer and distributor of factual television and feature-length theatrical documentaries, has recently migrated their co...
07/05/2020
One of the key requests from our operational focus groups during the early design phase of BLAM-3 was the ability to prioritise workflows, particularly delivery...
30/04/2020
If your content catalogue isn't already in the cloud, you're probably wishing it was right now. Despite the dramatic growth in the media industry's...
07/04/2020
The use of cloud-based storage in the media industry has seen dramatic growth in recent years; more recently the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic is driving the ...
07/04/2020
Tracking costs, ideally in real time, is an increasingly important consideration for operators in the era of software-as-a-service. While the ability to use hi...
25/03/2020
Content Catalogue too Big to Migrate to Cloud? Try Snowballs, Really One of the principal perceived barriers to migrating a content catalogue to the cloud...
06/12/2019
The changing face of service provision in the broadcast & media business. As another production and media content supply chain operator files for bankruptcy and...
06/12/2019
The changing face of service provision in the broadcast & media business. As another production and media content supply chain operator files for bankruptcy and...
06/12/2019
The changing face of service provision in the broadcast & media business. As another production and media content supply chain operator files for bankruptcy and...
06/11/2019
As an organisation Blue Lucy tends to focus on the business of media operations. The BLAM platform is operationally focused and every function of the platform ...
06/10/2019
As we covered in our pre-show blog, this year we decided against taking up our usual spot in Hall 7 of the RAI in favour of attending IBC 2019 as a visiting ven...
28/08/2019
It's that time of year again, the late bank holiday is just behind us and thoughts turn to the city of Amsterdam, particularly beautiful in the early autumn...
06/12/2018
Global content services provider, TVT Media, has integrated Blue Lucy's BLAM Adobe Premiere plug-in into their media management service and software platfor...
25/10/2018
We are recruiting for software developers and test engineers to help us grow the capabilities of our market leading cloud based media operations management plat...
06/07/2018
MAM remains one of the top investments that media operators make each year. As we have blogged previously we do not think that MAM, as an acronym or concept is...
24/05/2018
Blue Lucy has enhanced their BLAM plug-in for Adobe Premiere with new features focused on reducing administrate overhead for creative operators. The new functio...
06/04/2018
Its NAB time again. As you make your way to Las Vegas this year spend a little time thinking about your MOM. No really.
You may be planning to assess Media Ass...
05/04/2018
New BLAM features allow media businesses to create bespoke operational management systems.
Blue Lucy's media operations management software, BLAM, is under...
06/02/2018
To the joy of delivery managers everywhere, media technology and agile development methodologies have reduced the need for hard launches and enabled lower risk ...
05/12/2017
Like national rugby teams we too have been international this Autumn having taken in a beautiful new cloud in Frankfurt and the ins, outs and round-abouts of as...
05/12/2017
Blue Lucy's recent project with Banijay Rights is featured in the MAM Supplement of December's TVB Europe. A PDF version also available.
Banijay is the...
04/12/2017
Blue Lucy's recent project with Banijay Rights is featured in the MAM Supplement of December's issue of TVB Europe. PDF version also available.
Banijay...
25/10/2017
Blue Lucy announced that the British Academy of Film and Television Arts (BAFTA) is using the Blue Lucy Asset Manager (BLAM) to manage their content archive and...
05/09/2017
Weybridge, UK and Broomfield, CO., USA, March 6th, 2017 - Leading automation and integrated playout specialist Pebble Beach Systems today announced that it has ...
11/07/2017
Continuing their theme of quick and easy implementation for MAM, the Blue Lucy team will launch a range of pre-packed entry level solutions focused on specific ...
15/06/2017
In our 6th year exhibiting at IBC Blue Lucy will have a full, end-to-end demonstration of the Blue Lucy Asset Manager the BLAM. BLAM is a 3rd generation asset...
15/06/2017
BLAM provides media organisations with an affordable, scalable solution to their asset and operations management needs - delivering workflow efficiencies and bu...
28/03/2017
BLAM provides media organisations with an affordable, scalable solution to their asset and operations management needs - delivering workflow efficiencies and bu...
11/07/2016
At IBC 2016 the Blue Lucy team will demonstrate how the BLAM Core product meets a broad range of business and operational requirements in the end-to-end media p...
The changing face of service provision in the broadcast & media business. As another production and media content supply chain operator files for bankruptcy and with some big names rushing out of the market, Julian Wright examines what went wrong for outsourcing in media and broadcast and what the emerging business models look like.
