Sony Pixel Power calrec Sony

The Battle over Bilingual Education Continues

22/09/2016

Sponsored by Sheppard Mullin, a full service, global law firm with 750 attorneys. The firm handles corporate and technology matters, high stakes litigation and complex financial transactions. Visit www.sheppardmullin.com.

What would Prop 58 do?

Prop 58 deals with how we teach English to non-English speaking students in our public schools. Most of the students affected by this are Spanish-speakers. There 1.4 million of them in California, so this would impact many children.

Prop 58 would:

Give schools districts more flexibility in how they teach English learners.

It would make it easier for schools to offer both bilingual and English immersion classes.

It would require schools to get input from parents and their communities about what languages they would like taught and what methods should be used.

It would encourage school districts to provide classes in foreign languages to English speaking students, including dual immersion programs. That's when classes are taught in two languages to students who want to learn both languages.

--

--

How did Prop 58 come about?

You may be wondering Why can't schools offer bilingual classes now? Because back in 1998 voters passed Prop 227. It required English immersion classes. Supporters said too many Spanish-speaking students were not learning English fast enough or well enough in bilingual classes. They said English-only classes would serve students better. So bilingual classes, for the most part, went away.

That was almost 20 years ago. Supporters of Prop 58 say it's time for some changes.

Who supports Prop 58 and what are their arguments?

Prop 55 - Extension of Income Tax on Wealthy to Fund Education

Prop 58 was put on the ballot by the state legislature. The key sponsor is State Senator Ricard Lara from Bell Gardens. The initiative passed mainly along party lines with Democrats supporting it and Republicans against it.

Prop 58 is also supported by Los Angeles and San Francisco school districts, the LA Chamber of Commerce and the California Teachers Association, among other groups.

Supporters say:

Prop 227 is nearly two decades old and restricts schools from using newer methods to teach English.

Prop 58 still assures that students master the English language.

Prop 58 lets schools choose between bilingual classes or English-immersion classes when appropriate.

It gives parents and communities a greater say in which languages are taught and the methods used to teach them.

Research shows students taught in more than one language do better academically.

Being multi-lingual is an advantage in today's global economy and California is home to 100's of multinational businesses.

Prop 58 also encourages school districts to offer all students - including native English speakers -- more opportunities to learn a 2nd language.

Who opposes Prop 58 and what are their arguments?

The main opponent of Prop 58 is Ron Unz. He a well-known conservative who succeeded in getting Prop 227 passed. Prop 227 was the anti-bilingual education initiative that passed with 61% of the vote in 1998.

Opponents say:

Prop 58 would repeal the requirement that students be taught English in public schools.

It would overturn teaching requirements that have improved language education.

It would lift restrictions on the California legislature giving it authority to re-institute classes conducted almost entirely in Spanish.

English-only classes are the best way for immigrant children to learn English. Since Prop 227 took effect, test scores have risen and more Latino students have been admitted to colleges.

Even famed teacher, Jaime Escalante, was a big supporter of Prop 227 that rescued students from a Spanish-only ghetto.

The parents of immigrant students also prefer immersion classes because their children learn English faster.

What kind of money is involved?

Supporters of Prop 58 have raised $628,000 as of the mid-August.

Opponents have not reported any donations.

What does a yes or no vote mean?

A yes vote would make it easier for public schools to offer language instruction in bilingual and English-immersion classes.

A no vote means things stay as they are, requiring English-immersion as the primary way to teach English learners.
LINK: https://www.kcet.org/ballot-brief/prop-58-english-language-education...
See more stories from kcet

Most recent headlines

18/12/2025

CES: NBCU Unveils New Cross-Platform Ad Tech Solutions, Capabilities

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

18/12/2025

2026 NAB Show Opens Registration, Unveils Major Program Enhancements

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

18/12/2025

YouTube Wins Global Rights to Stream the Oscars

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

18/12/2025

PGA TOUR Studios Teams up with SES for Hybrid Content Distribution

Long-term agreement includes the SES SCORE platform and hybrid distribution worldwide to deliver more than 5,000 hours of golf tournaments annually featuring th...

17/12/2025

The EU Investigative Journalism Award 2025: bold reporting, regional impact, and rise in public-interest journalism

Investigative journalists across the Western Balkans and T rkiye continue to con...

17/12/2025

Sports Broadcasting Hall of Fame Inducts 10 Industry Icons During Unforgettable Night

Sports Broadcasting Hall of Fame Inducts 10 Industry Icons During Unforgettable ...

17/12/2025

ESPN to Debut MNF Playbook with Next Gen Stats, a New AI-Driven NFL Data-AltCast

ESPN to Debut MNF Playbook with Next Gen Stats, a New AI-Driven NFL Data-AltCastThe series, powered by Adrenaline TruPlay AI, launches Dec. 22 and runs through ...

17/12/2025

Inaugural Optum Golf Channel Games Debut Under the Lights' in Primetime on Golf Channel and USA Network

Inaugural Optum Golf Channel Games Debut Under the Lights' in Primetime on ...

17/12/2025

Ring In the New Year With New Playlists Mixed by Artists, and More Spotify Hacks

The right playlist is essential on New Year's Eve, building the energy as you get ready and keeping it high as you count down to midnight. This year, Spotif...

17/12/2025

Clear-Com's Arcadia Central Station Links Toledo Walleye and Mud Hens Venues with...

eds3_5_jq(document).ready(function($) { $(#eds_sliderM519).chameleonSlider_2_1({...

17/12/2025

Broadcast and Streaming Serve Up a Historic Month of TV in Nielsen's The Gauge

Audiences Watched Over 103 Billion Minutes of TV on Thanksgiving Day NFL Games ...

17/12/2025

EdgeBeam Wireless Makes Initial Sale, Expands Executive Team

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

17/12/2025

Warner Bros. Discovery Tells Shareholders to Reject Paramount Bid

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

17/12/2025

NDI, Zoom Collaborate on Seamless Connectivity

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

17/12/2025

Broadcasters Mark Momentous Year of Challenges Amid Viewing Fragmentation

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

17/12/2025

Tennessee Public Broadcaster to Trial AI Metadata

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

17/12/2025

Chyron Unveils New AXIS Maps

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

17/12/2025

Broadcast Solutions Group Acquires PMT Professional Motion Technology

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

17/12/2025

Study: U.S. Pay TV, Video Revenue to Total $190.7B in 2030

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

17/12/2025

Texas Attorney General Takes Aim at 5 TV Manufacturers

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

17/12/2025

DirecTV Wins Appeal in Retransmission Price-Fixing Suit

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

17/12/2025

E.W. Scripps Rejects Sinclair Takeover Bid

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

17/12/2025

KPop Demon Hunters Stars Visit Berklee for Weeklong Celebration

KPop Demon Hunters Stars Visit Berklee for Weeklong Celebration Andrew Choi and EJAE, who voiced the film's main characters and contributed to its soundtr...

17/12/2025

Dolby and LG Unveil a New Era of Home Audio With the World's First Soundbar Audio System Powered by Dolby Atmos FlexC...

December 17 2025, 17:00 (PST) Dolby and LG Unveil a New Era of Home Audio With ...

17/12/2025

Heated Rivalry will be coming to Sky and streaming service NOW on 10 January

Wednesday 17 December 2025 Heated Rivalry will be coming to Sky and streaming service NOW on 10 JanuaryTurn on cookies to view this content. Go to Privacy opti...

17/12/2025

Inside The Unseen World Of Indian Customs: Netflix Reveals The Brave Heroics Of The Customs Officers In Taskaree

Back to All News Inside The Unseen World Of Indian Customs: Netflix Reveals The...

17/12/2025

Netflix announces PAPARAZZI KING: the docu series coming to Netflix on January 9th

Back to All News Netflix announces PAPARAZZI KING: the docu series coming to Ne...

17/12/2025

Netflix Unveils First Look at 'Jo Nesbo's Detective Hole' Premiering on March 26, 2026

Back to All News Netflix Unveils First Look at Jo Nesbo's Detective Hole Pr...

17/12/2025

Netflix Welcomes Warner Bros. Discovery Board Recommendation

Back to All News Netflix Welcomes Warner Bros. Discovery Board Recommendation Business 17 December 2025 Global Link copied to clipboard After Careful Revi...

17/12/2025

RT announces appointment of Kathy Fox to role of Commissioning Editor, Documentaries and Features

RT has announced that Kathy Fox has been appointed Commissioning Editor with re...

17/12/2025

UC San Diego Lab Advances Generative AI Research With NVIDIA DGX B200 System

The Hao AI Lab research team at the University of California San Diego - at the forefront of pioneering AI model innovation - recently received an NVIDIA DGX B...

17/12/2025

Into the Omniverse: OpenUSD and NVIDIA Halos Accelerate Safety for Robotaxis, Physical AI Systems

Editor's note: This post is part of Into the Omniverse, a series focused on ...

17/12/2025

The Glitterball awaits: Dancing with the Stars unveils dance pairings for 2026

With the new season of Dancing with the Stars shimmering in the not-too-distant future this New Year, the celebrity and dancer pairings of the twelve couples ha...

16/12/2025

Stranger Things' Playlist Takeover Challenges Fans to Decode Clues and Unlock Exclusive Volume 2' Content

Hawkins has landed on Spotify, just in time for Stranger Things Season 5, Volume...

16/12/2025

Spotify and NAVER Bring Music Integrations and Premium Benefits to Korea

Wherever you are, your favorite music and audio content should go seamlessly with you. That's why Spotify has partnered with NAVER Corp, Korea's leading...

16/12/2025

Around the World With Spotify Wrapped: 2025 Fan Destinations You Had to See

2025 Wrapped arrived bigger and bolder than ever. This year's experience is designed to be ultra personal and shareable, with new features like Wrapped Part...

16/12/2025

L3Harris Delivers Most Powerful Thrusters for NASA's Lunar Gateway

Three 12-kilowatt Advanced Electric Propulsion System thrusters, supplied by L3Harris Technologies, form the core of Gateway's propulsion system. Pictured i...

16/12/2025

Palantir and L3Harris: Reindustrializing Defense Through AI-Powered Production

The challenge facing America's defense industrial base is not just about speed - its about rebuilding the foundation that makes speed possible. Our nations ...

16/12/2025

NFL Boosts Broadcast, Streaming Viewing Share in November

Share Share by: Copy link Facebook X Whatsapp Pinterest Flipboard...

16/12/2025

Spanish Broadcaster Updates Playout With Pebble Solutions

SEVILLE, Spain Canal Sur, the public broadcasting service for Andalusia, Spain, has completed a total technology refresh based on Pebble's resilient, softwa...

16/12/2025

Telescript International Buys Prompter Software Company

NEW YORK Teleprompting hardware provider Telescript International has acquired all software code and intellectual property previously owned by Telescript West. ...

16/12/2025

Ookla: T-Mobile Is Fastest Fixed Wireless Access Provider

As cable operators face increased competition from 5G fixed wireless access providers, a new report from Ookla Research finds that T-Mobile is the FWA speed lea...

16/12/2025

Apple TV App for Android Now Supports Google Cast

Apple has announced a major upgrade to the Apple TV app for device owners outside the Apple ecosystem with news that the Apple TV app for Android now supports G...

16/12/2025

PT Telkom Satelit Indonesia and Space42 Explore Partnership to Extend 5G Direct-to-Device Services

Space42 grows Direct-to-Device partner ecosystem through a Memorandum of Underst...

16/12/2025

VEON Announces Release Date for Full Year and Fourth Quarter 2025 Results of Both VEON and Kyivstar

16 Dec 2025 VEON Announces Release Date for Full Year and Fourth Quarter 2025 R...

16/12/2025

VEON's Kyivstar Invests in Renewable Energy in Ukraine with Acquisition of Solar Power Company

16 Dec 2025 VEON's Kyivstar Invests in Renewable Energy in Ukraine with Acq...

16/12/2025

Emma Appleton, Fares Fares, Frida Gustavsson and Jakob Oftebro Star in Swedish Thriller Series Bytet'

Back to All News Emma Appleton, Fares Fares, Frida Gustavsson and Jakob Oftebro...

16/12/2025

Docu-reality 'My Korean Boyfriend' Gets a Trailer and Premiere Date: January 1st. Is Real Life Really like a K-drama?

Back to All News Docu-reality My Korean Boyfriend Gets a Trailer and Premiere D...

16/12/2025

Czech TV Elevates Video Streaming with Harmonic

Harmonic's XOS Advanced Media Processor Improves Streaming Video Quality and Boosts Viewer Engagement SAN JOSE, Calif. - Dec. 16, 2025 - Harmonic (NASDAQ: ...