The facts of the case
The case concerns the use of a 2-minute long promotional video clip about water pollution, created by BestWater International, which produces and sells water filters. The video appeared on YouTube, apparently without knowledge or authorisation by BestWater, and was used by a competitor, who linked to the clip by means of framing , thereby making the clip visible on its own website. BestWater claimed copyright infringement of its clip and sought an injunction from the German courts. The defendant had meanwhile voluntarily ceased the use of the clip and the procedure was therefore limited to the restitution of damages.
The question referred to the CJEU by the German Supreme Court
Does the embedding, within one's own website, of another person's work made available to the public on a third-party website, in circumstances such as those in the main proceedings, constitute communication to the public within the meaning of Article 3(1) of the 2001 Copyright Directive (2001/29/EC), even where that other person's work is not thereby communicated to a new public and the communication of the work does not use a specific technical means which differs from that of the original communication?
In the Svensson case (C 466/12), where the European Court ruled on (mere) hyperlinking, the question of whether the link created the impression that the framed work would be appearing on the third party's website (thus concealing its original website) was held as not relevant. The Court held the decisive issue to be the same in the BestWater case, prompting it to answer negatively.
The framing of a work (or other protected material) which is freely available on a publicly accessible website is thus allowed, unless it is directed at a different audience than originally intended or is communicated (to the same audience or not) by using different technical means.
Comments
The Courts decision raises several issues and questions remain unaddressed.
First of all, one would have hoped that the Court had seized this opportunity to differentiate its reasoning in the Svensson case and clearly distinguish between (mere) hyperlinking and framing. In the Svensson case, the Court determined that any form of hyperlink is in principle subject to the communication to the public right unless there is no new public . This reasoning seems very far-reaching given that a hyperlink is, as such, no more than a technical tool to switch from one URL address to another. By contrast, the framing technique (in particular of audio or video streams provided by another website) is markedly different from hyperlinking, because in this case the end-user is not directed to the webpage where the original content is placed. That makes this type of communication more clearly an economic form of exploitation, which is a crucial distinction. This follows on from the Courts decision in the TVCatchup case (C-607/11), where for the question whether the third-party's re-use of a broadcast programme was a communication under Art. 3 of the 2001 Copyright Directive the question of a "new public" was not held relevant.
Moreover, it is difficult to accept the idea that a general allowance for embedding or framing protected material found elsewhere on the Internet would create the possibility of unauthorised usage, going far beyond the boundaries of any limitation or exception under copyright. In particular, the lawful quotation of another's work is subject to relatively strict conditions. These are tested by the special characteristics of the Internet, but the careful legislative balance underlying the quotation exception is bypassed entirely if third-party use is simply not held to be a relevant act of communication. It would have been more appropriate to consider that embedding or framing are always copyright relevant communications and lawful only to the extent that their use is in line with the requirements of the quotation exception.
Secondly, the question of whether embedding copyrighted videos available on the Internet would ever be tantamount to copyright infringement remains open in cases where the source video was uploaded without permission of the right owner.
In this particular context, it is remarkable that the Court recognised, but did not validate, the BestWater's claim that it had not authorised the clip to be uploaded on YouTube, as this fact could, and arguably should, have been taken into account for the question of a new public . Also, the wording of the request for a preliminary ruling by the German Supreme Court explicitly referred to the given circumstances of the actual case. Did the Court wish to indicate that as long as the copyright owner had not ordered YouTube to take the clip down it was considered tolerated and thereby lawfully available for everyone's free (embedding) use? And what if, though such a take-down order had been given, the clip re-appeared on YouTube or any other social network, as is often the case? It is difficult to imagine that the Court wished to suggest that the lawfulness of the first uploading of the original content is entirely irrelevant.
Finally, the lawfulness of embedding copyright-protected content subject to conditional access, e.g. the website hosting the source video was protected by a technological measure designed to prevent or restrict access, was not addressed. The C More Entertainment case (C-279/13) which involves such situation is still pending before the European Court.
Share this page on
--
Most recent headlines
04/08/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, is excited to announce Santiago Solanas as its new Chief Executive Officer (CEO)....
03/06/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, a...
08/05/2024
NEEDHAM, Mass. The International Data Corporation is predicting that worldwide spending on telecom services and pay TV services will increase by 1.4% in 2024 to...
08/05/2024
CUPERTINO, Calif. In a notable development for news and live video production, Apple has unveiled a number of significant upgrades to its Final Cut Pro software...
08/05/2024
Pliant Technologies has announced that it will be presenting its new SmartBoom LITE Headset at InfoComm 2024 (Booth C5116). The latest updates include enhanceme...
08/05/2024
SAN FRANCISCO Fox's ad-supported streaming service Tubi has launched Stubios, a fan-fueled studio for aspiring filmmakers and their fans that the company sa...
08/05/2024
SAN ANTONIO, Texas Five more stations have launched NextGen TV service, bringing to nine the number of local TV services on-air with ATSC 3.0....
08/05/2024
TYSONS, Va. Tegna Inc. has announced that Greg Retsinas has been named president and general manager at KGW, Tegna's NBC affiliate serving the Portland area...
08/05/2024
08 05 2024 - Media release Olivia Colman and John Lithgow Star in Sophie Hyde's New Project JIMPA
Olivia Coleman and John Lithgow in JIMPA. Photo credit: ...
08/05/2024
OpenDrives Joins AWS Partner Network
Brie Clayton May 7, 2024
0 Comments
Atlas software-defined platform now available via AWS trusted partner network...
08/05/2024
Animate AI Matte Paintings in After Effects
Graham Quince May 7, 2024
0 Comments
Arguably the best video use for AI generated images is Matte Painting...
08/05/2024
Throw Expression in Adobe After Effects
Andy Ford May 7, 2024
0 Comments
The Throw expression is a time-saver in After Effects. It allows you to mov...
08/05/2024
Join FilmLight in Toronto: Baselight 6.1, Nara and more
Brie Clayton May 7, 2024
0 Comments
Thursday 30th May, from 2:30PM, Hosted by Alter Ego 488 ...
08/05/2024
Gray Television reported a first-quarter profit as advertising revenues rebounded to above pre-COVID-19 levels....
08/05/2024
The Today show shared the performers on its summer concert series, which feature...
08/05/2024
Lewis Dodley, longtime anchor for Spectrum News NY1, will retire at the end of May. He's been on the air at the Charter Communications-owned local news chan...
08/05/2024
Scripps Sports said it plans to air a new studio show when a new season of WNBA Friday Night Spotlight starts May 24....
08/05/2024
Advertisers are looking to reach the right audiences and tell their stories inside compelling content, Karen Kovacs, president of client partnerships at NBCUniv...
08/05/2024
Professor emeritus John (Jack) Johnson elected to the National Academy of Sciences Johnson's multi-disciplinary research has been instrumental in shaping ou...
08/05/2024
zweiB updates to latest version of R&S CLIPSTER Specialist in deliverables for cinema, events and trade shows
Rohde & Schwarz, a global leader in broadcast...
07/05/2024
NAB Show 2024
Utah Scientific rocked the 2024 NAB Show in Las Vegas, unveiling two new game-changers in video signal management.
Our primary focus this yea...
07/05/2024
7th May 2024 The nations favourite comedy channel Gold has teamed up with the ma...
07/05/2024
There's something special about summer. We're not sure whether it's the warmer weather, the longer days, or something else a bit more magical, but s...
07/05/2024
NITV appoints Michael Rennie as Presenter and Senior Producer for NITV News
Media releases
NITV has announced the appointment of Michael Rennie as Presenter...
07/05/2024
The ability for line-of-site tactical voice and data networks to seamlessly traverse over Satellite Communications is an emerging requirement to assure warfight...
07/05/2024
On April 5, 2024, the L3Harris Avionics Products Repair Station (NN2R037L) in Gr...
07/05/2024
eds3_5_jq(document).ready(function($) { $(#eds_sliderM519).chameleonSlider_2_1({ content_source:......
07/05/2024
Share this article
width=32 height=32 loading=lazy data-lazy-src=https://apogeedigital.com/app/themes/juniper-theme/src/img/icons/facebook-purple.svg />
wid...
07/05/2024
BURBANK, Calif. The Walt Disney Company has finally delivered some from profits from its hefty streaming investments, with the second quarter of its fiscal year...
07/05/2024
Bonnie Hammer, vice chair of NBCUniversal, and Jen Psaki, MSNBC host, read from their new books at the 92nd Street Y in Manhattan Wednesday, May 8. Hammer's...
07/05/2024
Paramount Plus has ordered the series Crutch, a comedy that is a spinoff of CBS comedy The Neighborhood. Tracy Morgan stars....
07/05/2024
Edward J. and Melody Thomas Scott and Lidia Bastianich will receive Lifetime Achievement honors at the 51st annual Daytime Emmy Awards in June, the National Aca...
07/05/2024
The 2024 Giants of Broadcasting & Electronic Arts luncheon and awards ceremony happens in New York November 12, and the honorees are Al Roker, weather and featu...
07/05/2024
Dabl Network has added The Wayans Bros., The Jamie Foxx Show, Living Single and Everybody Hates Chris to its weekday and weekend lineups. Those shows join the l...
07/05/2024
After winning a proxy fight, The Walt Disney Co. said its entertainment business turned a profit and added subscribers in its fiscal second quarter....
07/05/2024
NBA Entertainment is closing out the second season of its series Pass the Rock with a look at Victor Wembanyama of the San Antonio Spurs, the league's rooki...
07/05/2024
Syncbak, which provides stations with streaming capabilities, said it is rebranding as Zeam Media....
07/05/2024
Samsung has made a deal with Magnolia Pictures that will bring titles from Magnolia to the Samsung TV Plus free streaming platform....
07/05/2024
Amazon, which has added commercials to Amazon Prime Video, is rolling out new interactive ad formats that will enable advertisers to engage streamers and sell s...
07/05/2024
Syncbak, a 15 year-old provider of streaming tech for local broadcast stations has rebranded itself, adopting the name of its streaming service launched in Febr...
07/05/2024
POST Luxembourgs journey with TAG Video underscores how finding a vendor who und...
07/05/2024
PORTSMOUTH, N.H. New findings from Hub Entertainment Research provides extensive data showing that the majority of consumers will opt for lower cost ad-supporte...
07/05/2024
NEW YORK The Library of American Broadcasting Foundation (LABF) has announced th...
07/05/2024
CBS News has named Lindsey Reiser an anchor and correspondent for CBS News 24/7, the network's live, streaming news service. Reiser, who was most recently a...
07/05/2024
NEEDHAM, Mass. After more than two years of decline, worldwide tablet shipments posted modest year-over-year growth of 0.5% in the first quarter of 2024 (1Q24),...
07/05/2024
ESPN is reporting that April was a record-setting month as the network delivered its best April prime time audience on record, dating back more than 30 years....
07/05/2024
WASHINGTON, D.C. The National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) has announced that Kirsten Donaldson has joined NAB as vice president of public policy. Donaldso...
07/05/2024
The Bulls are back home again this week from May 7-12! Don't miss out on any...
07/05/2024
Tonight on House of Zwide: Mampho cautions Maria against making a move on IsaacDon't miss Tuesday, 7 May's riveting episode of South African soapie Hous...
The facts of the case
