Sony Pixel Power calrec Sony

Opinion: Why it's important to give broadcast engineers support in the move to IP


Ed Calverley, manager at large, SMPTE UK, discusses how organisations can help their engineers as they make the move from SDI to IP workflows

By Contributor

Published: May 14, 2024 Updated: May 15, 2024

Ed Calverley, manager at large, SMPTE UK, discusses how organisations can help their engineers as they make the move from SDI to IP workflows

target=_blank title=Share on LinkedIn class=share-linkedin>

Any engineer who has worked in broadcast systems in the last 20 years will have at some point configured an IP address. Understanding the logic behind the numbers entered as part of that address, and what mechanisms are in place, are becoming as important to broadcast as understanding how signals travelling down wires represent audio and video signals.

Until recently, all most broadcast engineers needed to worry about was baseband' signals (a term with many varied meanings but generally referring to real-time signals carried in an uncompressed form over dedicated wires - e.g. SDI or Analogue/AES3 Audio). Modulated RF and compressed/multiplexed signals were the domain of specialist teams - much like the computer and networking hardware that has been powering post production systems were supported, in part, by dedicated IT teams.

With the move away from centralised SDI routing infrastructures, those uncompressed signals are now being carried as packets of IP data over complex networks. In order to diagnose connectivity issues, engineers can no longer trace signals flowing down coaxial cables but instead need to embrace a new set of tools providing visibility of what data is flowing down the shared pipes between network switches and routers.

Now that's not to say that all engineers need to be enrolled on Cisco CCNA training. On the contrary, that sort of education is generally only needed for those specialist Network Engineers who will directly configure and administer the networks. Broadcast engineers need to know what they don't know' enough to appreciate the design choices being made by the specialist network designers. Broadcast engineering teams should be given appropriate access to interface with the networked systems, this may include the full ability to make architectural changes as the nature of issues in a broadcast setting often demands engineers are empowered to do what needs to be done' - though in most cases, strict change management processes are essential which will allow time for the specialists to get involved and ultimately call the shots.

So back to IP media training - the world of standards published by SMPTE and others has always been a complex landscape. People can build their knowledge about standards through reading them (or being trained by someone who has), but to properly understand them people need hands-on experience, or at least to see real systems in action, especially ones which have issues. Engineers truly learn by solving problems - that's why the older generation of engineers are so valued - they've seen so many things break and have been involved in figuring out how to fix them. Nobody wants to face issues in their day-to-day work, but when they do occur, confident engineers who have some basic knowledge of how systems interoperate will do their best to poke and prod until something they do makes the situation better. Over time, engineers learn what poking and prodding has the best effect and some may fully square the circle in understanding exactly why an issue occurred and was resolved.

So, don't expect any training course to be a silver bullet that magically makes engineering teams able to support the new systems being built - but it is an important part of the journey to knowledge. Exposure to real systems and discussions between colleagues willing to openly share experiences are even more important - opportunities for this internally within companies is given (though sadly not always prioritised). External groups such as SMPTE UK promote engagement and discussion between colleagues from across the industry and should be encouraged and supported, as often a little bit of insight or a new perspective can be the key to solving long-open issues.

Changing gears a bit to talk a bit more about my experience through Q3 Media Training. I've personally delivered our standard IP Media Networks course well over 20 times now, as well as some variants based upon it. No two courses have ever been exactly the same as I keep learning more and more - both from the SMPTE standards, which keep evolving, but also from the questions and discussions I have with people through the training. Even the so-called experts' in the field are still learning. How different manufacturers implement things varies significantly and making sense of it all can be a real challenge. The IP rack in our #BigPinkDemoKit has IP Media systems (2110/PTP/NMOS) from 10+ different vendors and can demonstrate both the good and the bad. Understanding the cause of the bad behaviours has been a struggle - but one that has lead to a better understanding of what's actually going on inside the devices and the networks.

From a general training point of view we see a wide range of clients, from those who are willing to invest in giving their staff the grounding that will lay the foundation for further learning, to those with more unrealistic expectations as to what can be achieved by a short course. We aim to pack a lot into our training sessions as the concept of know what you don't know' is our number one belief as to what makes a great engineer. All our sessions are recorded, and we hear from some how useful it is to re-visit the topics we covered at a later date, possibly with hindsight of a recent project or operational discussion. Learning is a continuous process. SMPTE's free access to self-paced learning online is hugely
See more stories from tvb

More from TVB Europe


DI4D sees double in new short film

Double uses the companys PURE4D 2.0 solution to faithfully transfer actor Neil Newbon's facial performance onto his digital double By Jenny Priestley Pub...


Lawo: Dunn climbing the corporate ladder

Dunns new role brings additional management responsibilities under German law By Matthew Corrigan Published: June 21, 2024 Dunn's new role brings addi...


Opinion: How harnessing automation fosters innovation and agility

David Edwards, product manager at Net Insight, looks at ways in which automation drives agility and enables creativity to flourish By Contributor Published: ...


UK's largest new TV and film studio fully operational

The site also includes workshops, offices and a post production/screening facility By Jenny Priestley Published: June 19, 2024 Updated: June 20, 2024 Th...


The quay to Downing Street: how dock10 produced the leaders' debates

Playing a part in the democratic process, dock10 was able to work to very tight deadlines to bring the leaders debates to the screen By Matthew Corrigan Publ...


ARD's Michael Eberhard appointed chair of EBU Technical Committee

The 13 members of the technical committee shape the direction of the work carried out by the EBU's Technology and Innovation department By Jenny Priestley ...


How Eurosport captures the spectacle of the world's best-known motor race

Capturing the sights, sounds and sensation of the Le Mans 24 Hour motor race places unique demands on the team behind the TV production. Ahead of this year'...


Meet the executive producer

Phil Delaney, executive producer at UNIT, explains how building a broad skill set has helped his career journey By TVBEurope Staff Published: June 17, 2024 ...


Ready for kick-off: RTL unveils one of most modern studios in Europe' for Euro 2024

Paul Hering, head of studio and field production at RTL Deutschland tells TVBEur...


Elvis, JFK cinematographers among judges for FilmLight Colour Awards

This years awards include Emerging Talent, which celebrates the work of young colourists (age 18-35) in commercial and music video creation By Jenny Priestley ...


Meet the product specialist, newsroom solutions

David Cardinale, product specialist, newsroom solutions at CGI tells TVBEurope about the importance of keeping skills up to date in the rapidly evolving media i...


Whisper boosts storage with EditShare

The new installation adds three EditShare EFS-300 storage systems, each of which has a capacity of 256 TB By Matthew Corrigan Published: June 13, 2024 The...


Niklas Brambring steps down from Zattoo

Zattoo has begun the search for a successor, said the company By Matthew Corrigan Published: June 13, 2024 Zattoo has begun the search for a successor, sa...


Private equity firm Clearhaven Partners acquires Zixi

Zixis executive team has also invested in the company to help drive it toward the next stages of growth By Jenny Priestley Published: June 13, 2024 Updated...


Blackmagic Design unveils world's first camera and editing system for Apple Vision Pro

The company has also introduced an updated version of DaVinci Resolve which incl...


No deal! Shari Redstone pulls plug on Skydance/Paramount Global merger

The company said it had not been able to reach mutually acceptable terms regarding the potential transaction with Skydance Media By Jenny Priestley Published...


Creating George Miller's graphic prequel Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga

Colourist Eric Whipp discusses the challenges of creating the look for George Millers epic blockbuster By Contributor Published: June 11, 2024 Updated: Jun...


Canon reels in fisheye lens for capturing immersive content

According to Canon, the RF-S 3.9mm F3.5 STM Dual Fisheye provides users with a new 144-degree recording angle producing a narrower field of view compared to VR1...


Jeff Rosica departs Avid

Rosica described his time at Avid as an incredible journey, adding his time at the company has surely been the pinnacle of my career By Jenny Priestley Publi...


Opinion: overcoming Olympic hurdles with technology

As Paris counts down to the 2024 Olympics, Stephane Guez, co-founder and principal, Dalet, explains how technological innovation will deliver an engaging experi...


Meet the commercial director

Daniel Pagan, commercial director at SCENESIS Pictures, tells TVBEurope why working in the media industry is exhilarating By Matthew Corrigan Published: June...


Eugene Sarmiento joins Ateliere as company expands European presence

The company said he will play a critical role in driving growth and strengthening its position in the region By Matthew Corrigan Published: June 5, 2024 T...


Canal+ begins process of acquiring Multichoice

The CEO of Canal said the company wants to combine the scale, geographies and content portfolios of the two companies to create an entertainment group with int...


Panalux appoints Michele Channer as MD

Channer replaces retiring MD, Mark Furssedonn By Matthew Corrigan Published: June 4, 2024 Channer replaces retiring MD, Mark Furssedonn target=_blank ti...


Opinion: is super aggregation still the way forward for pay-TV operators?

Steve Russell, vice president, video entertainment solutions at Irdeto, looks at ways to meet the challenges of super-aggregation in a fragmented content enviro...


Investment fuels growth for Dimension Studio

Next month, Dimension will officially open a new virtual production complex in West London, in collaboration with DNEG 360 and Sunbelt Rentals By Matthew Corri...


Paramount's special committee to recommend Skydance deal'

Paramounts board is expected to vote on the Skydance deal on Tuesday (June 4th) as part of the companys annual meeting By Jenny Priestley Published: June 3, ...


Presteigne Broadcast Hire officially closes its doors

The companys administrators confirmed to TVBEurope this morning that they were unable to find a buyer for the business as a going concern By Jenny Priestley ...


Marlow Film Studios considering next steps' as council blocks plans

The proposal had received support from James Cameron, Andy Serkis, Paul Greengrass, Richard Curtis, and Jeremy Irons By Matthew Corrigan Published: May 31, 2...


Skydance submits new Paramount Global bid, Sony talks still progressing'

According to multiple reports, the new bid from Skydance offers a better deal to Paramounts Class B shareholders, who were said to be unhappy with the companys ...


2024 Rise Awards open for entries

The awards recognise women and companies who are stand-out performers, innovators and leaders in the broadcast media technology industry By Matthew Corrigan ...


Finding the sustainability balance with personalised video streaming

As the expansion of personalised video streaming continues apace, JUMPs CEO and co-founder, Jer nimo Macan s and Fran ois Polarczyk, sustainability director at ...


SMPTE/RIS-OSVP tests model for circle of confusion'

According to Camera and Lens Metadata committee, modern digital cinema cameras are not accurately representing the usable depth of field achieved with various l...


Meet the vice president of product management

Dave MacKinnon, vice president of product management at Clear-Com, explains the value of collaboration and networking in building a media career By Matthew Cor...


Dune Part 2 and Avatar colourists to take part in DaVinci Resolve Live Tour

The events are for filmmakers, editors, colourists, and visual effects artists, whether theyre beginners and experienced users By Jenny Priestley Published: ...


Meet the head of sound

1185 Films Mark Hodgkin explains his journey from studying classic guitar and piano to working on the sound of TV adverts, films and documentaries By TVBEurope...


UK's Media Bill heads towards Royal Assent

An amendment to the Bill includes retaining the Reithian principles of public service broadcast, ensuring PSBs continue to inform, educate and entertain By Jen...


BCE appoints Sylvain Merle as CTO

Merle joins BCE following a 30 year career including roles at Orange/Globecast and beIN Media Group By Matthew Corrigan Published: May 24, 2024 Merle join...


Virtual feelings: how haptic technology is creating immersive environments

Philippe Guillotel, senior director of metavideo group, InterDigital, explains how haptic technology could be the next big thing in watching everything from spo...


Meet the senior vice president, enterprise solutions architecture

Zeenal Thakare, senior vice president, enterprise solutions architecture at Ateliere Creative Technologies, explains why shes enjoying a front row seat to the o...


UK broadcast CEOs call on parliament to pass Media Bill before dissolution

The Bill is currently at its third reading stage in the House of Lords By Jenny Priestley Published: May 23, 2024 The Bill is currently at its third re...


The industry is at a tipping point': World Skills Caf to address media's skills gap

Carrie Wootten talks to TVBEurope about a new initiative aiming to understand wh...


Report: Media businesses facing HMRC R&D tax relief challenges

Research suggests media businesses are struggling to make successful claims for research and development tax reliefs By Matthew Corrigan Published: May 22, 2...


Avid partners with Post Super on post production training course

The programme aims to provide those working in post with a comprehensive understanding of their role within the broader post production ecosystem By Jenny Prie...


Stephen van Rooyen appointed VodafoneZiggo CEO

He joins VodafoneZiggo following the retirement of Jeroen Hoencamp and will be based at the companys offices in Utrecht By Jenny Priestley Published: May 21,...


TVBEurope May/June 2024 issue out now

Our latest issue hears from France T l visions about their plans for Paris 2024, we also celebrate the winners of our NAB 2024 Best of Show Awards and explore c...


Meet the VFX producer

Angus Berryman, VFX producer at UNIT studio tells TVBEurope how perseverance paid off as his career progressed By Matthew Corrigan Published: May 20, 2024 ...


Sony signs NDA with Paramount Global but is reticent about earlier plan

The New York Times said the move was a significant step forward in their effort to court Paramount By Matthew Corrigan Published: May 20, 2024 Updated: May...


Meet the product manager

Muster Ngobi, product manager at LYNX Technik tells TVBEurope how the ever-evolving media industry provides a truly dynamic working environment By Matthew Corr...


A year in live HDR production

John Mailhot, senior vice president, product management at Imagine Communications, gives an insight into how HDR is impacting live production today, as well as ...