Sony Digital Rapids Pixel Power calrec Sony

Judge Rejects VidAngel Antitrust Claim Against Disney Et Al.

12/08/2017

In a victory for Hollywoods major studios and yet another setback for a video editing operation, a California Central District Judge has dismissed VidAngels counterclaim of antitrust violations against the studios, who are suing the company over its online delivery of filtered content.

VidAngel said it was disappointed and was considering its legal options.

Judge Andr Birotte Jr. also rejected VidAngels defense of Copyright misuse, which would have required VidAngel to make the case that the studios were restraining the development of competing products.

Related: VidAngel Flies Again, With Different Wings

The studios named in the suit are Disney, Lucasfilm, Twentieth Century Fox Film, and Warner Bros., and it was just the latest in a string of court decisions stretching over many months.

The studios had asked the judge to throw out VidAngels antitrust counterclaim on the grounds that it had failed to make a plausible claim either for a horizontal or vertical conspiracy or intentional interference with prospective economic advantage. They had also asked the judge to reject the Copyright misuse defense since it was tied to the antitrust counterclaims.

The judge agreed with the studios and granted the motion to dismiss. He also said they could not amend their claim.

VidAngel had alleged that the Directors Guild of American agreement on motion picture editing prohibits alteration of a work without director approval, which is an unreasonable restraint of trade. The judge instead concluded that while the language limits editing without initial consultation with the director, it is not a mandate to obtain permission.

The judge also concluded that VidAngel had mischaracterized an email from a Google representative, which it alleged informed VidAngel that Google was concerned that directors would block content filtering.

VidAngel had asserted that the studios would not all have rejected a licensing agreement if they had not agreed collectively to refuse to allow filtering, but the judge instead concluded that their refusal to engage in licensing discussions with a company that they allege is operating an infringing service is a rational business decision and does not support a plausible inference of an agreement to eliminate filtering.

VidAngel had also argued that the refusal to sell VidAngel their DVDs-VidAngel buys a copy of a DVD, filters out the swearing and nudity, and streams it to a subscriber-was counter to their economic self-interest since they were cutting out the retailer middleman. But VidAngel also said that the studios had an economic motive in subverting VidAngels business model because VidAngel DVDs are re-sold and streamed to new cuteroms, from which the studios get no money. VidAngel seemingly concedes that Plaintiffs have rational economic motives not to deal with VidAngel, said Birotte.

As to Copyright misuse, the judge said: VidAngel has not, and cannot allege that their filtering service is a competing product to Plaintiffs' movie production studios.

Just last week, the same judge denied a motion by VidAngel to declare that its new app-based online stream scrubbing business model does not violate an injunction it is under from operating under its previous model of buying, scrubbing and streaming DVDs.

We are once again disappointed by another decision by Judge Birotte that badly misconstrued VidAngel's allegations, said VidAngel CEO Neal Harmon. During the more than seven months it took the Court to rule, there were a number of highly-publicized events showing that VidAngel's antitrust allegations are correct, including the Directors Guild of America's assertion of its collective bargaining agreement with the studios to force Sony to cease offering clean content to home viewers. Such events notwithstanding, the Court inexplicably denied VidAngel's request for leave to amend its counterclaim to allege additional facts in support of its claim. We are conferring with our attorneys and will announce VidAngels legal response to the Court's ruling as soon as possible.
LINK: http://www.broadcastingcable.com/news/programming/judge-rejects-vidang...
See more stories from bandc

Most recent headlines

19/07/2018

Grassmark Oy Scores with Sonifex Commentary Units

18 July 2018 The Finnish AV Production company Grassmark Oy, founded in 2007, specialises in broadcast & event video productions and streaming. They offer turn...

19/07/2018

Lawo crystal on the Roof of the World for Nepal's HITS FM 91.2

Replacing an outdated console that no longer met the requirements of its programming, HITS FM 91.2, Nepal's no. 1 radio station, has installed a Lawo crysta...

19/07/2018

DAZN Coming to U.S. on Sept 10; Boxing, MMA Center Stage for $9.99 a Month

DAZN Coming to U.S. on Sept 10; Boxing, MMA Center Stage for $9.99 a Month By Brandon Costa, Director of Digital Tuesday, July 17, 2018 - 12:40 pm Print Th...

19/07/2018

Live From MLB All-Star: Inside Fox Sports' Innovation With Francisco Contreras

Live From MLB All-Star: Inside Fox Sports Innovation With Francisco Contreras Sk...

19/07/2018

Live From MLB All-Star: Fox Sports Takes Flight With SkyCam, Most High-Speed Cameras Ever

Live From MLB All-Star: Fox Sports Takes Flight With SkyCam, Most High-Speed Cam...

19/07/2018

Live From MLB All-Star: Boom in Digital Content Spurs Boost in MLB Network Ops

Live From MLB All-Star: Boom in Digital Content Spurs Boost in MLB Network Ops MLBN leverages at-home workflows for parade of live shows By Jason Dachman, Chie...

19/07/2018

MLB All-Star Wrap-Up: CP Communications Logs Its Largest All-Star Presence

MLB All-Star Wrap-Up: CP Communications Logs Its Largest All-Star Presence 27-person crew handled 14 RF cameras, 50,000 ft. of fiber, comms connectivity By Jas...

19/07/2018

MLB All-Star Wrap-Up: SMT Brings Back Batter's Eye Virtual Signage for Fox

MLB All-Star Wrap-Up: SMT Brings Back Batter's Eye Virtual Signage for Fox By Jason Dachman, Chief Editor Wednesday, July 18, 2018 - 1:04 pm Print This...

19/07/2018

MLB All-Star Wrap-Up: Filmwerks Supplies Onsite Sets for Fox Sports, MLB Network

MLB All-Star Wrap-Up: Filmwerks Supplies Onsite Sets for Fox Sports, MLB Network By Jason Dachman, Chief Editor Wednesday, July 18, 2018 - 1:32 pm Print Th...

19/07/2018

SVG Announces Esports Production Forum in Los Angeles on Nov. 6

SVG Announces Esports Production Forum in Los Angeles on Nov. 6 By SVG Staff Wednesday, July 18, 2018 - 2:45 pm Print This Story Story Highlights SVG has...

19/07/2018

Live From MLB All-Star: MLB Network Takes Social-Media Efforts to the Next Level

Live From MLB All-Star: MLB Network Takes Social-Media Efforts to the Next Level Increased social-first content resulted in sizable audience growth on Twitter a...

19/07/2018

Portugal Relies on Arvato Systems as Its Serialization Partner for the Pharmaceutical Industry

Arvato Systems implements IT solution for verifying medication in Portugal 8 in...

19/07/2018

Focusrite Guitar Masterclass

Focusrite Guitar Masterclass 18 Jul 2018 Sithu Aye and Ola Englund to host London event Musicians have been announced for Focusrite Guitar Masterclass, the fr...

19/07/2018

Medialuso relies on VSN solutions for the creation of the new theme-based channel S+ in Portugal

Medialuso chose VSN solutions to create, launch and ensure the proper functionin...

19/07/2018

Inbound News Production: the innovative news production concept focused on the journalist

The new VSN Inbound News Production solution places its focus on the user and on...

19/07/2018

Entertainment One Renews First Look Deal with Datari Turner for Unscripted Television Programming

BACKEntertainment One Renews First Look Deal with Datari Turner for Unscripted T...

19/07/2018

ENTERTAINMENT ONE TO ADAPT GRAPHIC COMIC SKIN&EARTH BY ALT POP MUSICIAN LIGHTS FOR TELEVISON AND DIGITAL CONTENT

BACKENTERTAINMENT ONE TO ADAPT GRAPHIC COMIC SKIN&EARTH BY ALT POP MUSICIAN LIGH...

19/07/2018

First Look at Michael Pea and Diego Luna in Narcos: Mexico

Narcos: Mexico will launch as a new Netflix original series later this year. Shifting away from Colombia, where Narcos spent three seasons, Narcos: Mexico will ...

19/07/2018

TONY WINNER BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN COMING TO NETFLIX

Hollywood, Calif., (July 18, 2018) - Springsteen on Broadway will launch globally on Netflix on December 15, 2018, which is also the final night of Springstee...

19/07/2018

TV streaming services overtake pay TV for first time

TV streaming services overtake pay TV for first time 18 July 2018 There are now more UK subscriptions to Netflix, Amazon and NOW TV than to traditional&...

19/07/2018

Broadcast TV viewing declines in Northern Ireland

Broadcast TV viewing declines in Northern Ireland 18 July 2018 Broadcast TV viewing down by almost an hour since 2010 Year-on-year decline bigger than f...

19/07/2018

Scotland leads the UK for time spent watching TV

Scotland leads the UK for time spent watching TV 18 July 2018 Scots spend more time watching broadcast television than any other UK Nation But viewing t...

19/07/2018

Broadcast TV viewing declines in Wales

Broadcast TV viewing declines in Wales 18 July 2018 Broadcast TV viewing is on the decline down 17% since 2010 Viewing moving online, with BBC iPlayer...

19/07/2018

Six Takeaways from Songwriting Clinic with Charlie Puth

A day after his biggest show ever, in front of 15,000 people in Toronto, Charlie Puth B.M. 13 returned to the first stage he played, the Red Room at Cafe 939. ...

19/07/2018

Charlie Puth Discovers Berklee Genesis of Hit See You Again

Sitting on the Red Room stage where he played his first live show, and where he had returned on July 12 to talk to three dozen students about songwriting, Charl...

18/07/2018

Verimatrix Announces Veriteem Distributed Ledger Technology to Address Security Gaps for Blockchain Applications

San Diego, Jul. 18, 2018 - Verimatrix, a specialist in securing and enhancing re...

18/07/2018

Riedel Recruits Marco Kraft to Head of Sales Germany

Wuppertal July 18, 2018 Riedel Recruits Marco Kraft to Head of Sales Germany Riedel Communications today announced the appointment of Marco Kraft as Head of ...

18/07/2018

Hitachi Rail Italy signed a contract worth 87 million Euros for further 12 Leonardo trains for Milan metro.

Naples (Italy), July 2018 --- Hitachi Rail Italy signed a co16 ntract worth 87 m...

18/07/2018

NOKIA: Globe Telecom partners with Nuage Networks from Nokia to bring cloud-native business services to the Philippines

Press Release Globe Telecom partners with Nuage Networks from Nokia to bring cl...

18/07/2018

Yospace and Medialaan solution for reducing ad loads in Live Simulcast recognised by the IBC2018 Innovation Awards

Breakthrough in server-side ad insertion technology sets a new standard for broa...

18/07/2018

AES to Exhibit at the Loudspeaker Sourcing Show in Nansha, China

The Audio Engineering Society will be exhibiting at the Loudspeaker Sourcing Show to be held in Nansha, China on October 16 - 18, 2018 at the Nansha Grand Hotel...

18/07/2018

CAPITAL BUILDS LARGEST OPTOCORE NETWORK FOR ROGER WATERS IN HYDE PARK

Surround sound extravaganza kicks off 10-day BST 2018 festival As the Barclaycard Presents British Summer Time festival in London's Hyde Park has continued...

18/07/2018

Prime Day 2018 Update: Small and Medium-Sized Businesses Worldwide Have Exceeded More Than $1 Billion in Sales on Amazon Since Yesterday

Prime Day 2018 Update: Small and Medium-Sized Businesses Worldwide Have Exceeded...

18/07/2018

Prime Members Again Enjoyed the Biggest Global Shopping Event in Amazon History this Prime Day

Prime Members Again Enjoyed the Biggest Global Shopping Event in Amazon History ...

18/07/2018

WGBH in Boston Selects Routers, Multiviewers and Infrastructure from Grass Valley for Station Upgrade

WGBH in Boston Selects Routers, Multiviewers and Infrastructure from Grass Valle...

18/07/2018

Ericsson reports second quarter results 2018

Second quarter highlights Sales as reported and sales adjusted for comparable units and currency both decreased by -1% YoY. Segment Networks showed a sales g...

18/07/2018

NAB Statement on Introduction of READI Act

NAB Statement on Introduction of READI Act WASHINGTON, D.C. - In response to today's introduction of the Reliable Emergency Alert Distribution Improvement ...

18/07/2018

SCARY PROPERTY PRICES

Barri Ghai, Sandy Lakdar and Chris Fleming 18 June 2018 In the midst of peak house buying season, a new study reveals that haunted houses sell for 17% less ...

18/07/2018

Stampede bought by DCC...

Stampede president & CEO Kevin Kelly Global AV distributor Stampede has been acquired by the technology division of DCC plc, a 14.3 billion revenue group that...

18/07/2018

Two new appointments for integrator Reflex

Sam Smith UK integrator Reflex has added two members of staff to its roster. Tony Patterson has been appointed as senior account manager and has more than 20 y...

18/07/2018

Bosch to run Connected...

Bosch is to run a series of events entitled Connected Buildings - turning ideas into reality. It will take place on five dates at an equal number of venues acro...

18/07/2018

LG pro displays to integrate with Cisco video...

Six models of LG UHD displays and 20 models of LG Full HD displays are now fully compatible with the Cisco Room Kit, Room Kit Plus and Cisco SX series, which in...

18/07/2018

Facebook introduces augmented reality ads

Facebook is to test augmented reality advertisements in its News Feed. Michael Kors was the first brand to use AR ads in News Feed, enabling people to try on a ...

18/07/2018

Avid Wins 2018 Microsoft US Partner Award for Helping the Communications and Media Industry Leverage the Cloud

-- Avid (Nasdaq:AVID), the leading technology provider of software tools and ...

18/07/2018

Streamer subscriber numbers overtake pay-TV in the UK

Ofcom also reveals average daily broadcast viewing on a TV set fell by nine minutes in 2017 Author: Jenny PriestleyPublish date: Jul 18, 2018 Subscribers to...

18/07/2018

Insight tv pens distribution deal with KPN

Dutch viewers can watch the broadcaster's 4K UHD HDR and HD content via KPN's IPTV service Author: Colby RamseyPublish date: Jul 18, 2018 Insight tv...

18/07/2018

PRESS RELEASE: MagStor Announce the Appointment of Polar Graphics as Their Exclusive UK European Distributor

MagStor Announce the Appointment of Polar Graphics as Their Exclusive UK & Europ...

18/07/2018

Globecast partners with JungoTV to distribute English language content in Indonesia

Globecast, the global solutions provider for media, has partnered with JungoTV t...

18/07/2018

TV 2 expands use of IDS at Bergen and Oslo facilities

Norway's largest commercial broadcaster, TV 2, has extended its use of IPE's Intelligent Display System (IDS) to its sister broadcast and production fac...