
Ben Schwarz, independent consultant, expert, and author, argues that the majority of use cases dont need ultra-low latency, except maybe during the World Cups four-week duration, once every four years
By Contributor
Published: January 12, 2023
Ben Schwarz, independent consultant, expert, and author, argues that the majority of use cases don't need ultra-low latency, except maybe during the World Cup's four-week duration, once every four years
target=_blank title=Share on LinkedIn class=share-linkedin>
With J r me Blanc, I had the honour of writing a whitepaper on the subject for Anevia, now part of Ateme. Our plan in 2017 was to talk to some operators, get their enthusiastic support and go from there. Things, unfortunately, didn't pan out, as none of the six operators I spoke to at the time were that interested. Sure, they liked the idea if it was free. However, we made a strong case that reducing latency from all too familiar 30-second times to below 10 seconds could be one of the critical enablers to letting live OTT streaming become mainstream. And it looks like the market is saying we might have been right.
Zoom forward to the beginning of 2023, and ultra-low latency (ULL) is considered a must-have by all and sundry. What has changed?
Well, one thing is five solid years of aggressive marketing by vendors with ULL solutions.
This ongoing onslaught reminded me of over 15 years ago when Microsoft was still in the game. Vast bouquets of linear TV channels were still critical to the TV business, and getting to the desired channel could be challenging for viewers. The firm had invented a fast-channel change solution that enabled zapping from channel to channel well under a second. Microsoft's marketing machine convinced the industry that it was a vital need.
Rewind to when remote controls first appeared. It was an analogue world. As long as radio reception was stable, channel-change times were instantaneous. When digital TV appeared at the end of the last century, latency crept in between pushing the P button and the channel changing on the set. This delay was due to the need to decode the new channel's compressed digital stream. After some early hits and misses - I remember one of the world's first IPTV deployments in the early noughties with an 8-second zapping time MPEG2's average two-second GOP time created the standard for this. For over a decade, when you pressed P or P-, something would happen within about 2 seconds, and that was fine. Sure, it's always nice when things happen even faster. Users noticed it and perhaps would have churned away from services with 8s zapping time, but nobody cared about the difference between one second and two seconds.
What we wrongly call latency today - in reality, it is delay also has a gold standard, set by decades of broadcast at around five seconds. So, for the bulk of use cases, i.e. watching live TV, when you are close to those five seconds, reducing is nice, but, say, even ten seconds will not be a deal breaker for most viewers. Sports fans have long known they can get a score a few seconds earlier on the radio, and we've always lived with that. When someone on the ground tweets a live score, that too has a few seconds of delay, but it seems real-time enough to the community bounded by the 5s delay of the main live video feed.
There's also an elephant in the low latency room have you guessed? sustainability. Lower latency means more and faster caches. Client-side video buffering may be considered undesirable from a user perspective. Still, it has proven to be the best way to ensure robust delivery without deploying significant resources in the network. That was ABR's secret sauce that enabled the internet's video revolution in the first place. As with all aspects of our lives that generate carbon emissions, we must also ask ourselves what is good enough.
Of course, some exceptional video use cases will require ULL, such as betting or professional uses like yes, you've heard it before telemedicine. Still, we're talking of live TV for the most part, and here, it's only once every four years that the World Cup is broadcast simultaneously over different platforms and people care about those few seconds. The rights of most other major sports events that attract substantial live viewership are owned by a single broadcaster.
The use case when part of the family is watching a DTT broadcast while others are streaming the same content in the same house is too marginal to consider. A delay of 30 seconds is becoming untenable for live sports, but mainstream video consumption doesn't have to go lower once we're in the single-digit delays. I doubt users would flock from 7-second delay services to a 5-second delay one. Note that this opinion piece is just about the video use case; in other situations, ULL will enable new services that would otherwise have been impossible; just ask any 5G equipment vendor!
More from TVB Europe
31/03/2023
Universal Pixels Dan Edmonds talks to TVBEurope about the companys work on major...
31/03/2023
Zixis Elizabeth Utting-Quereuil reveals how she found herself working in the media tech industry, and why attending industry events and learning from colleagues...
30/03/2023
Dejeros Ivy Cuervo considers how the evolution of remote production and blended ...
30/03/2023
The Avid NEXIS | F2 Sold State Drive can be used with 4K, 8K and HDR content, with capacity to scale from 38.4TB to 307.2TB per engine
By Jenny Priestley
Pub...
30/03/2023
The facility is powered by Unreal Engine 5, with 3D environments displayed on 800m2 of fully modular LED volumes in real-time
By Jenny Priestley
Published: M...
30/03/2023
Martin van Aalderen has been tasked with focusing the company on its goal of accelerating global growth
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 30, 2023
Marti...
30/03/2023
DAZN's coverage would include more behind-the-scenes footage, watchalongs, stats, in-play betting and better camera angles and production
By Jenny Priestle...
30/03/2023
Broadcaster has published its Annual Plan 2023/24, which also sets out its plans for technological innovation
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 30, 2023
...
29/03/2023
The global streamers could face fines of up to £250,000 or be restricted in the UK entirely if they are found to have broken rules around harmful material
By J...
29/03/2023
ARRI Solutions designs, engineers, builds, and operates virtual production environments of all sizes
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 29, 2023 Updated: ...
29/03/2023
The appointments follow Riedels recent acquisitions of Simplylive and SDNsquare
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 29, 2023
The appointments follow Riede...
28/03/2023
Black joins the company from NBC Universal, where he led the companys media technology strategy across a host of digital properties
By Jenny Priestley
Publis...
27/03/2023
Vizrt's Viz Engine 5 and GhostFrame will bring unprecedented multi-angle virtual graphics and video wall control to the show floor
By TVBEurope Staff
Pub...
27/03/2023
Atomos has launched its cloud-based control room, Atomos Studio, which makes live video production and remote collaboration affordable, accessible and easy, the...
27/03/2023
VFX studio Moonraker VFX has announced the appointment of Lucas Pozzey as its head of 3D
By TVBEurope Staff
Published: March 27, 2023 Updated: March 28, 20...
24/03/2023
The company has established the new CTO Office to drive innovation and deliver on its strategic goals
By TVBEurope Staff
Published: March 24, 2023 Updated...
23/03/2023
Ampere Analysis Neil Anderson discusses how European broadcasters are playing ca...
23/03/2023
disguise has announced a collaboration between the two companies that will see it integrate with NVIDIA Omniverse for end-to-end M&E workflows
By TVBEurope Sta...
23/03/2023
Ofcom introducing more than 70 quotas on the BBCs TV and radio services to ensure it delivers a minimum volume of content such as news and current affairs, and ...
23/03/2023
Pixotopes Kate Watson talks about how her job lets her go behind the curtain on major virtual production projects, and why now is the perfect time to get involv...
23/03/2023
The next auction of Premier League rights is due to take place next year, and will cover 2025-28
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 23, 2023 Updated: Marc...
22/03/2023
Bad Sisters, The English, The Essex Serpent, and This is Going to Hurt lead the nominations
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 22, 2023 Updated: March 31,...
22/03/2023
The studio will be led by Milk VFX supervisor and Dublin native, Ciaran Crowley
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 22, 2023
The studio will be led by Mil...
21/03/2023
Cinematographer Ksenia Sereda explains why she chose to use the lenses on the hit HBO series
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 21, 2023 Updated: March 22...
21/03/2023
Agreement also coincides with Jigsaw24 Media's first pixitmedia integration project, for London-based facility Fifty Fifty
By Jenny Priestley
Published: ...
21/03/2023
Based at Bristols Bottle Yard Studios, Cinewest provides customers with cine camera, lens and grip rentals
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 21, 2023 Upd...
20/03/2023
OTT TV episode and movie revenues in the region are predicted to reach $45 billion in 2028
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 20, 2023 Updated: March 21, ...
20/03/2023
The inaugural event is scheduled for 20-21st June and will take place virtually
By TVBEurope Staff
Published: March 20, 2023 Updated: March 31, 2023
The...
20/03/2023
Edgios Grant MacLeod tells TVBEurope about a role that involves problem-solving for customers, and why its important to get hands-on experience in the media tec...
20/03/2023
ITV will continue to embed sustainability criteria into its selection processes and contracts in order to ensure it works with suppliers that align to the compa...
17/03/2023
Owners Stage Fifty say they also plan to build live broadcast sound stages for homebound unscripted television
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 17, 2023 ...
17/03/2023
Among the technology used by creatives were the companys digital film cameras, DaVinci Resolve editing, grading, visual effects (VFX) and audio post production ...
16/03/2023
Bitmovins Markus Hafellner talks to TVBEurope about the companys update to its VoD Encoding solution, and how it will create better visual quality for viewers
...
16/03/2023
Content from BBC Cymru Wales, ITV Cymru Wales and S4C has been digitised for the archive
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 16, 2023
Content from BBC Cym...
16/03/2023
The new 7750 ssq ft stage features a 26 x 4.5m ROE BPV2 semicircular volume at Garden Studio's Park Royal studio complex
By Jenny Priestley
Published: Ma...
16/03/2023
Together Poland and Russia will account for 61 per cent of the region's 2028 total revenues
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 16, 2023 Updated: March...
16/03/2023
Chancellor Jeremy Hunt has held the qualifying threshold for high-end TV shows at £1 million
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 16, 2023 Updated: March 17...
15/03/2023
All three models can be mounted in an equipment room and accessed via KVM or WebRTC network connectivity, making them available for live and remote production o...
15/03/2023
The award recognises someone who consistently goes above and beyond the expectations of the role and shows a genuine curiosity and passion for post production
...
14/03/2023
CUBE Studio includes a 10.5x5.5m LED volume, crafted with Unilumin Upad IV LED panels, which feature HDR image quality
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 14...
14/03/2023
ELMNTL includes suites for colour grading, VFX and CG/motion graphics, with multiple support stations for production planning, ingest, QC and delivery
By Jenny...
14/03/2023
Appears Annette Hopland on why the media tech industry is a trifecta of amazing people, innovative technology, and an always-evolving industry, and what advice ...
13/03/2023
Greg Burns, head of media products, Arqiva looks at the ways streaming media providers (including traditional broadcasters) are looking to improve their approac...
13/03/2023
The companys technology was used on Best Picture winner Everything Everywhere Al...
13/03/2023
Outside broadcast specialist Riverside Television has chosen Calrec Brio 36 for its bigger outside broadcast (BOB) truck
By TVBEurope Staff
Published: March...
13/03/2023
The company has promoted Patxi Monedero to the position of chief technology officer
By TVBEurope Staff
Published: March 13, 2023 Updated: March 31, 2023 ...
13/03/2023
The UK and France will both see revenue drops of almost $1 billion each
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 13, 2023 Updated: March 14, 2023
The UK and ...
10/03/2023
Editor Sven Budelmann discusses his work on the Oscar-nominated drama, and how his close collaboration with director Edward Berger led to creating a film that i...
10/03/2023
The companys technology was used on Best Picture frontrunner Everything Everywhe...
10/03/2023
The company will be back with stands at both NAB 2023 and IBC 2023
By Jenny Priestley
Published: March 10, 2023
The company will be back with stands at bo...