The Sacramento River | Photo: Zach Behrens/KCET
Commentary: Last week, Northern and Southern California state legislators had a rare breakthrough over one of the state's most divisive issues - water.
The Joint Legislative Audit Committee voted to instruct the State Auditor to launch an audit of Governor Jerry Brown's proposed Delta Tunnels. Recent revelations show the project has murky funding and even supporters know the tunnels cannot be built on a financial house of cards.
The Delta Tunnels would be 40-foot tall, 35-mile long tunnels dug beneath the San Francisco Bay-Delta estuary. They would deliver fresh Sacramento River water to state and federal projects that send water to agriculture in the San Joaquin Valley and Southern California cities. California voters rejected the Peripheral Canal proposal in 1982.
Now rebranded the CA WaterFix, the project would cost $17 billion, with interest and operational costs bringing the total payback amount to over $50 billion. CA WaterFix maintains the project will be paid for entirely by those water districts who would get the water, not state or federal taxpayers. To date, $248 million has been spent on the Delta Tunnels planning.
--
--
Documents recently released under the Public Records Act reveal potentially improper transactions involving public funds within the California Department of Water Resources, Westlands Water District, San Luis Delta-Mendota Water Authority, Metropolitan Water District of Southern California (MWD), and Santa Clara Valley Water District. Meanwhile, the Deputy Inspector for the U.S. Department of Interior is investigating whether the California Department of Water Resources siphoned off millions of Federal taxpayer dollars meant for improving fish habitat to instead pay for the Delta Tunnels' environmental impact report.
The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association said the project's funding had become a shell game.
Who Will Pay for the Delta Tunnels?
So far, none of the water districts have committed to paying their fair share of the $17 billion project.
MWD has said they wont pay for the project if their ag partners, Westlands Water District and the San Luis Delta-Mendota Water Authority, do not participate financially. The agricultural water districts announced they would not pay to complete the current preliminary work on the tunnels unless the project first won regulatory approval. The agricultural parties don't seem entirely convinced the investment will bring enough water to be worth the expense. Meanwhile, the Fitch Credit rating services has issued a negative credit rating to San Luis and Westlands due to their outstanding debt load and a little Enron accounting.
If big agricultural users who will most benefit from the water cannot afford their 40 percent of a $17 billion project, who will subsidize these users?
Most likely state and federal taxpayers, in violation of the original funding agreement for the project. AP has reported that state officials told Metropolitan that any additional funding needs to complete the planning phase will be provided by state or federal sources.
No wonder legislators want an audit!
Who Would Benefit?
An estimated 70 percent of the water from the Delta Tunnels will flow to farms in the southern San Joaquin Valley. These farms represent just .3 percent of the state's GDP.
Mother Jones recently reported Stewart and Lynda Resnick's firm The Wonderful Company has cornered the market in pistachios, pomegranates, and even water sales. They hope to expand their holdings with Delta Tunnels water and are funding PR efforts supporting the Tunnels.
Metropolitan Water District officials (some of the highest paid public officials in California) would also benefit from a project that helps them continue selling imported water as Southern California's water wholesaler.
Who Would Be Harmed?
The science is clear. Water exports from the San Francisco Bay-Delta are killing off endangered species and causing encroaching saltwater that harms Delta farms that have been producing food for more than a century. Native salmon and smelt are on the edge of extinction and water quality in the Bay-Delta has plummeted. Already 90 percent of the fisheries in the San Francisco Bay-Delta have vanished. Famed chef Alice Waters is the latest to speak up on behalf of the state's salmon population and what we stand to lose.
The burden of proof that the Tunnels won't further harm to the estuary, endangered fish, or Bay-Delta communities, now lies in the hands of the California Department of Water Resources and the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation. The EPA has rejected their plan twice already.
Are the Tunnels a Good Investment?
Climate scientists predict less Sierra snowpack and fewer rainstorm events in the future. There may be no reliable water source to fill the Tunnels.
Sea-level rise also presents a huge problem for the proposal. The lead engineer recently testified at State Water Board hearings that the Delta Tunnels have a lifespan of 100 years, while the lead operations officer testified a few days later that they have only planned for 18 inches of sea level rise based on the first year of impact - 2030. Actual sea level rise could give the project a lifespan of only 30 years.
KCET's Chris Clarke described the Delta Tunnels as teetering on the edge of obsolescence before the first shovel of earth is dug.
Is There a Better Way to Spend $17B on Water Infrastructure?
Opponents warn that when interest and operation costs are included, the Tunnels could cost up to $60 billion. Ratepayers and taxpayers would then end up paying as much as $2 billion per year for a thirty-year project and no additional water.
We support major investments in California's water infrastructure. But the Delta Tunnels are a 20th Century solution that will n
Most recent headlines
11/12/2025
Dalet, a leading provider of cloud-native, end-to-end media workflow solutions, ...
06/12/2025
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. A new survey from Pixitmedia by Datacore revealed a major shift in the Media & Entertainment industry in media archiving, with 85% of resp...
06/12/2025
HACKENSACK, N.J. LiveU has announced that the national public broadcaster Czech Television has completed one of the largest LiveU live production deployments fo...
06/12/2025
NEW YORK The National Academy of Television Arts and Sciences (NATAS) presented the Excellence in Production Technology Emmy Award to NASA+ and Dr. Tom Leight...
05/12/2025
2025 Sports Broadcasting Hall of Fame: Curt Gowdy Jr. - Master Storyteller, Nati...
05/12/2025
SVG Sit-Down: Veritone's Sean King on the Power of Mining Video, Audio DataThe company's Data Refinery offers users total control and governance over da...
05/12/2025
Platinum White Paper: Inside the Nashville Predators' Unified, Flexible, Sca...
05/12/2025
Netflix Reaches Agreement To Acquire Warner Bros. Following Planned WBD SplitThe deal does not include WBDs sports assets like TNT Sports (US, UK, LatAm), Euros...
05/12/2025
FOX Sports Returns to Indianapolis for Primetime Broadcast of Big Ten Championsh...
05/12/2025
SVG Summit 2025 Preview: Digital Engagement & Monetization Workshop Tackles the ...
05/12/2025
Atlanta United Lights Up New Emory Healthcare Studio With First Live Broadcast f...
05/12/2025
As Messi Takes the Pitch, MLS, Apple, NEP Roll Out Largest MLS Cup Production Ev...
05/12/2025
ESPN Enters College Football's Most Intense Month With Elevated Workflows fo...
05/12/2025
It's about that time! Awards season is in full swing, and the Film Independe...
05/12/2025
Every year, Spotify Wrapped offers a personalized look back at the audio that defined your year. It's a snapshot of your listening habits, designed to tell ...
05/12/2025
In 2025, Spotify's EQUAL, GLOW, and RADAR programs celebrated women, LGBTQIA , and emerging artists who turned moments into milestones. From breaking record...
05/12/2025
In our latest blog, we explain how Wi-Fi 7 rollouts can drive consumer loyalty with value-add services such as consumer cybersecurity. We also explore how this ...
05/12/2025
LOS ANGELES Netflix announced it has entered into an agreement to acquire the assets of Warner Bros. for $82.7 billion....
05/12/2025
NEW YORK Nielsens Gracenote has launched Gracenote Content Connect, a new ad platform that provides agencies, brands, supply-side platforms (SSPs) and demand-si...
05/12/2025
NEW YORK In an most important update to the workings of deal-based programmatic advertising, IAB Tech Lab has released version 1.0 of its Deals API for public c...
05/12/2025
NEW YORK Pass the turkey. Pass the stuffing. Pass the cranberry sauce. All are common requests of Americans celebrating Thanksgiving Day with family and f...
05/12/2025
NEW YORK Iris, the new cloud-connected camera control platform, has officially launched with features that turn virtually any PTZ camera into a software-connect...
05/12/2025
HOLLYWOOD, Calif. Netflix announced today that it has entered into an agreement to acquire the assets of Warner Bros. for $82.7 billion....
05/12/2025
NEW YORK Iris, the new cloud-connected camera control platform, has officially launched with features that turn virtually any PTZ camera into a software-connect...
05/12/2025
WASHINGTON The Federal Communications Commission has approved AT&T's $1.02 billion acquisition of spectrum from UScellular in a decision that was issued sho...
05/12/2025
The Best Coldplay Songs: 21 Tracks That Shoot for the Stars From Yellow to Viva La Vida, Fix You to Paradise, this playlist goes back to the start.
December ...
05/12/2025
Zafris Lecture Series Brings Nabil Ayers to Berklee The 32nd annual James G. Zafris Distinguished Lecture series was held on Thursday, November 13, with guest...
05/12/2025
Friday 5 December 2025
A new Game of Thrones Tale: Official trailer for Sky Exc...
05/12/2025
Back to All News
Don Lee, Lee Jin-uk, and Lalisa Manobal to Star in Netflix Act...
05/12/2025
Tis the season of giving once again and this year we've taken our Give Back Fridays' concept and turned it on its head.
In the autumn we were approach...
05/12/2025
Brayden Gogis doesn't remember a time when he wasn't completely fixated on games in all forms. In preschool, when they asked us to dress up as what we ...
05/12/2025
The Grinch steals the spotlight as the theme for The Late Late Toy Show 2025
Tune in tonight at 9:35pm on RT One and worldwide on RT Player
#LateLateToyShow...
05/12/2025
RT Announces New Presenters of Flagship News Programmes
New RT Six One News co-presenter Tommy Meskill
Sarah McInerney & Justin McCarthy join Morning Ir...
04/12/2025
ToolsOnAir Blackmagic Design HyperDeck Event Presets for just:in mac pro 2025 & ...
04/12/2025
ToolsOnAir AJA Ki Pro Event Presets for just:in mac pro 2025 & just:in linux
More Details:Starting with version 5.5, both just:in mac pro and just:in linux sol...
04/12/2025
Wangu Kanuri from Kenya and Godwin Asediba from Ghana are two of this years finalists for Thomsons Young Journalist of the Year Award. The pair are runners-up i...
04/12/2025
SVG Sit-Down: ProximaVision's Claudio Lisman on Why Tethered Drones Could Be...
04/12/2025
SVG Campus Shot Callers: Imry Halevi, Senior Associate Director of Athletics, Co...
04/12/2025
Platinum White Paper: LiveU Lightweight Sports Production: A Step Change in Spor...
04/12/2025
London to Riyadh: DAZN brings the boxing glamour to new production levels for Be...
04/12/2025
Analysis: Paramount bets on the battering ram' with Champions League play By Callum McCarthy, Editor-at-Large
Tuesday, December 2, 2025 - 10:12
Print ...
04/12/2025
Space City Home Network Launches SCHN DTC App for Astros and RocketsThe Rockets and Astros were previously the lone NBA and MLB teams without a DTC appBy Jason...
04/12/2025
SVG Summit 2025 Preview: Content Workflows Workshop Spotlights Evolution of Spor...
04/12/2025
New Sponsor Spotlight: Geotech's Patrick Wambold On the Unreal Engine Revolu...
04/12/2025
Curt Gowdy Jr. - Master Storyteller, Nationally and RegionallyBy Jason Dachman, Editorial Director, U.S.
Thursday, December 4, 2025 - 1:52 pm
Print This Sto...
04/12/2025
(L-R) Rebecca Lichtenfeld, Mohammadreza Eyni, Sara Khaki, and Judith Helfand att...
04/12/2025
SBS launches Future Frames initiative to support emerging First Nations video ed...
04/12/2025
Coronal mass ejections caused by eruptions on the surface of the sun can have fa...
04/12/2025
Gracenote Content Connect enables media ecosystem to precisely align ad campaigns and programming based on rich content signals
NEW YORK - December 4, 2025 - N...
The Sacramento River | Photo: Zach Behrens/KCET 
