In a decision, slammed by fair use fans, that could extract big bucks from Googles big pockets, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has once again ruled that Google infringed Oracle copyrights in its Android operating system and has remanded the case back to the lower court for a trial on damages.
Wikimedia Commons
A California district court trial had resulted in a finding that Google had infringed Oracle Java copyrights, but deadlocked on whether that infringement was covered by fair use. The court then decided that the application programming interfaces (APIs) were not copyrightable fair use. Google celebrated. Oracle appealed.
The Federal Circuit reversed the decision of the United States District Court for the Northern District of California on appeal and remanded with instructions to restore the infringement jury finding and hold further proceedings on the Google Fair use defense, and damages for Oracle if appropriate.
Google appealed that decision to the Supreme Court, which declined to hear the case after the Solicitor General recommended it deny review. In that second trial (in 2016), Google actually won on its fair use defense. Oracle appealed that decision to the Federal Circuit, too, which brings the case up to the present day.
Related: Googles Fair Use Victory Draws Crowd
"{w]e conclude that Google's use of the 37 Java API packages was not fair as a matter of law," a three-judge panel of the court found. "We therefore reverse the district court's decisions denying Oracle's motions for JMOL [Judgment as a matter of law motion claiming the does not have the evidence to support its case] and remand for a trial on damages," the Federal Circuit panel said in a decision released Tuesday (March 27). "The district court may determine the appropriate vehicle for consideration of infringement allegations regarding additional uses of Android."
We are disappointed the court reversed the jury finding that Java is open and free for everyone," said Google spokesman Patrick Lenihan. "This type of ruling will make apps and online services more expensive for users." Asked whether Google will appeal this decision as well, Lenihan said: "We are considering our options.
The Copyright Alliance, representing TV and online content producers and others, has backed Oracle, saying the district court got it wrong that Googles use of the Java programming language in its Android phones was fair use and not copyright violation, as Oracle had contented in suing the search giant, with consequences for the protection of copyrighted content that reaches beyond smart devices.
Among the alliances key points was that the lower court had made a mistake in ruling that simply "transporting" a work from one medium to another--in this case computers to mobile phones--is "transformative" under the fair use exception to copyright protections.
The alliance said that was particularly problematic for smaller content creators who "who may not have the resources to enter all potential or derivative markets at one time."
Copyright Alliance members include TV studios and their workers, TV and radio stations, sports leagues, news outlets and many more. Board members include representatives of NBCUniversal, Viacom, Time Warner and the Motion Picture Academy of America.
Fair Use fans Public Knowledge said the decision could be devastating.
"The Federal Circuit first erred in finding that application programming interfaces ( APIs ), which are functional means by which software programs communicate with each other, are subject to copyright protection," said Public Knowledge Policy Counsel Meredith Rose. "It has compounded this error by substituting its own judgment for that of a jury, which found that Google's use of Java APIs was fair, and explicitly ignoring Supreme Court precedent in doing so.
Taken together, these decisions -- which run counter to decades of software industry practice -- could have devastating effects on the competitiveness, openness, and development of the technology industry. This could lead to higher prices, fewer choices, and worse products for consumers. If the Supreme Court does not reverse the Federal Circuit's repeated errors, Congress must act to prevent the misuse of copyright to create a monopoly on progress, interoperability, and competition.
Most recent headlines
17/12/2025
Investigative journalists across the Western Balkans and T rkiye continue to con...
17/12/2025
Sports Broadcasting Hall of Fame Inducts 10 Industry Icons During Unforgettable ...
17/12/2025
ESPN to Debut MNF Playbook with Next Gen Stats, a New AI-Driven NFL Data-AltCastThe series, powered by Adrenaline TruPlay AI, launches Dec. 22 and runs through ...
17/12/2025
Inaugural Optum Golf Channel Games Debut Under the Lights' in Primetime on ...
17/12/2025
The right playlist is essential on New Year's Eve, building the energy as you get ready and keeping it high as you count down to midnight. This year, Spotif...
17/12/2025
eds3_5_jq(document).ready(function($) { $(#eds_sliderM519).chameleonSlider_2_1({...
17/12/2025
Audiences Watched Over 103 Billion Minutes of TV on Thanksgiving Day
NFL Games ...
17/12/2025
Share Share by:
Copy link
Facebook
X
Whatsapp
Pinterest
Flipboard...
17/12/2025
Share Share by:
Copy link
Facebook
X
Whatsapp
Pinterest
Flipboard...
17/12/2025
Share Share by:
Copy link
Facebook
X
Whatsapp
Pinterest
Flipboard...
17/12/2025
Share Share by:
Copy link
Facebook
X
Whatsapp
Pinterest
Flipboard...
17/12/2025
Share Share by:
Copy link
Facebook
X
Whatsapp
Pinterest
Flipboard...
17/12/2025
Share Share by:
Copy link
Facebook
X
Whatsapp
Pinterest
Flipboard...
17/12/2025
Share Share by:
Copy link
Facebook
X
Whatsapp
Pinterest
Flipboard...
17/12/2025
Share Share by:
Copy link
Facebook
X
Whatsapp
Pinterest
Flipboard...
17/12/2025
Share Share by:
Copy link
Facebook
X
Whatsapp
Pinterest
Flipboard...
17/12/2025
Share Share by:
Copy link
Facebook
X
Whatsapp
Pinterest
Flipboard...
17/12/2025
Share Share by:
Copy link
Facebook
X
Whatsapp
Pinterest
Flipboard...
17/12/2025
KPop Demon Hunters Stars Visit Berklee for Weeklong Celebration Andrew Choi and EJAE, who voiced the film's main characters and contributed to its soundtr...
17/12/2025
Wednesday 17 December 2025
Heated Rivalry will be coming to Sky and streaming service NOW on 10 JanuaryTurn on cookies to view this content. Go to Privacy opti...
17/12/2025
Back to All News
Inside The Unseen World Of Indian Customs: Netflix Reveals The...
17/12/2025
Back to All News
Netflix announces PAPARAZZI KING: the docu series coming to Ne...
17/12/2025
Back to All News
Netflix Unveils First Look at Jo Nesbo's Detective Hole Pr...
17/12/2025
Back to All News
Netflix Welcomes Warner Bros. Discovery Board Recommendation
Business
17 December 2025
Global
Link copied to clipboard
After Careful Revi...
17/12/2025
RT has announced that Kathy Fox has been appointed Commissioning Editor with re...
17/12/2025
The Hao AI Lab research team at the University of California San Diego - at the forefront of pioneering AI model innovation - recently received an NVIDIA DGX B...
17/12/2025
Editor's note: This post is part of Into the Omniverse, a series focused on ...
17/12/2025
With the new season of Dancing with the Stars shimmering in the not-too-distant future this New Year, the celebrity and dancer pairings of the twelve couples ha...
16/12/2025
Hawkins has landed on Spotify, just in time for Stranger Things Season 5, Volume...
16/12/2025
Wherever you are, your favorite music and audio content should go seamlessly with you. That's why Spotify has partnered with NAVER Corp, Korea's leading...
16/12/2025
2025 Wrapped arrived bigger and bolder than ever. This year's experience is designed to be ultra personal and shareable, with new features like Wrapped Part...
16/12/2025
Three 12-kilowatt Advanced Electric Propulsion System thrusters, supplied by L3Harris Technologies, form the core of Gateway's propulsion system. Pictured i...
16/12/2025
The challenge facing America's defense industrial base is not just about speed - its about rebuilding the foundation that makes speed possible. Our nations ...
16/12/2025
Share Share by:
Copy link
Facebook
X
Whatsapp
Pinterest
Flipboard...
16/12/2025
SEVILLE, Spain Canal Sur, the public broadcasting service for Andalusia, Spain, has completed a total technology refresh based on Pebble's resilient, softwa...
16/12/2025
NEW YORK Teleprompting hardware provider Telescript International has acquired all software code and intellectual property previously owned by Telescript West. ...
16/12/2025
As cable operators face increased competition from 5G fixed wireless access providers, a new report from Ookla Research finds that T-Mobile is the FWA speed lea...
16/12/2025
Apple has announced a major upgrade to the Apple TV app for device owners outside the Apple ecosystem with news that the Apple TV app for Android now supports G...
16/12/2025
Space42 grows Direct-to-Device partner ecosystem through a Memorandum of Underst...
16/12/2025
16 Dec 2025
VEON Announces Release Date for Full Year and Fourth Quarter 2025 R...
16/12/2025
16 Dec 2025
VEON's Kyivstar Invests in Renewable Energy in Ukraine with Acq...
16/12/2025
Back to All News
Emma Appleton, Fares Fares, Frida Gustavsson and Jakob Oftebro...
16/12/2025
Back to All News
Docu-reality My Korean Boyfriend Gets a Trailer and Premiere D...
16/12/2025
Harmonic's XOS Advanced Media Processor Improves Streaming Video Quality and Boosts Viewer Engagement SAN JOSE, Calif. - Dec. 16, 2025 - Harmonic (NASDAQ: ...
16/12/2025
RT Sport Awards 2025 live on RT One and RT Player at 8:05pm on Saturday 20 December.
On Saturday 20 December live on RT One and RT Player at the earlier t...
16/12/2025
Singer -songwriter Brian Kennedy has been announced as the final celebrity dance...
15/12/2025
Harlem Globetrotters Celebrate 100th Anniversary With New Brand Campaign From Th...
15/12/2025
Top L-R: La Tierra Del Valor (The Home of the Brave), Mangittatuarjuk (The Gnawe...
15/12/2025
L3Harris will leverage 15 years of experience supporting the E-4B Nightwatch and...
In a decision, slammed by fair use fans, that could extract big bucks from Googles big pockets, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has once again ruled that Google infringed Oracle copyrights in its Android operating system and has remanded the case back to the lower court for a trial on damages.
