Sony Digital Rapids Pixel Power calrec Sony

Friday Tip - Panning Laws: Why They Matter

05/07/2019

Spoiler alert: We'll get into some rocket science stuff here, which probably doesn't affect your projects much anyway so if you prefer something with a more musical vibe, come back next week. But to dispel some of the confusion regarding an oft-misunderstood concept, keep reading.

You pan a mono signal from left to right. Simple, right? Actually, no. In the center, there's a 3 dB RMS volume buildup because the same signal is in both channels. Ideally, you want the signal's average level-its power-to have the same perceived volume, whether the sound is panned left, right, or center. Dropping the level when centered by 3 dB RMS accomplishes this. As a result, traditional hardware mixers tapered the response as you turned a panpot to create this 3 dB dip.

However, there are other panning protocols. (Before your head explodes, please note you don't need to learn all this stuff-it's just to give you an idea of the complexity of pan laws, because all we really need to do is understand how things work in Studio One.) For example, some engineers preferred more of a drop in the center, so that audio panned to the sides would pop more due to the higher level, and open up more space in the center for vocals, kick, and bass. You could accomplish the same result by adjusting the channel level and pan, but the additional drop was sort of like having a preference you didn't need to think about. To complicate matters further, some mixers lowered the center signal compared to the sides, while others raised the side signals compared to the center. If a DAW does the latter, when you import a normalized file and pan it hard left or hard right, it will go above 0 and clip.

But wait! There's more. Some engineers didn't want equal power over the panpot's entire travel, but a slightly different curve. Others wanted a linear change that didn't dip the signal at all.

Fortunately, Studio One has a rational approach to pan laws, namely

The panpots in Studio Once's channels default to the traditional 3 dB dip, so there's perceived constant level as you pan a mono signal from left to right. For stereo, they act as a balance control.

Although most programs set the pan law as a global preference, Studio One includes the Dual Pan plug-in, which offers five different pan laws. This lets different channels follow different pan laws.

THE WHAT-THE-HECK-DO-PAN-LAWS-DO TEST SETUP

To see how the different panning laws affect signal levels, I created a test setup (Fig. 1) with a mono track fed by the Tone Generator set to a sine wave. Two pre-fader sends went to two buses, each with a Dual Pan inserted and linked for mono. That way, one bus's Dual Pan could be set for hard pan and the other bus's Dual Pan for center, to compare what happens to the signal level.

Figure 1: Test setup to determine how different pan laws affect signal levels.

In all the following test result images, Track 1 shows the mono sine wave at 0 dB, Bus 1 shows the result of panning the Dual Pan full left, and Bus 2 shows the result of panning the Dual Pan to center.

Fig. 2 uses the -3dB Constant Power Sin/Cos setting for the Dual Pans. Note that the centered version in Bus 2 is 3 dB below the same signal panned full left. This is the same setting as the default for the channel panpots. However, if you collapse the output signal to mono, you'll get a 3 dB center-channel buildup. (A fine point: setting the Main bus mode to mono affects signals leaving the main bus; the meters still show the incoming signal. To see what's happening when you collapse the Main out to mono, you need to insert a Dual Pan in the Main bus, click on Link, and set all controls to center.)

Figure 2: -3dB Constant Power Sin/Cos pan law.

Fig. 3 uses the -6 dB linear curve. Here, the centered signal is -6 dB below the signal panned hard left. Use this curve if the signal is going to be collapsed to mono after the main bus, because it keeps the gain constant when you collapse stereo to mono by eliminating the +3 dB increase that would happen otherwise.

Figure 3: The -6 dB linear curve is often preferable if you're mixing in stereo, but also anticipate that the final result will end up being collapsed to mono.

Fig. 4 shows the resulting signal from the 0dB Balanced Sin/Cos setting. There's no bump or decrease compared to the centered signal, so this acts like a balance control with a constant amount of gain as you pan from left to right.

Figure 4: 0dB Balanced Sin/Cos acts like a balance control.

Sharp-eyed readers who haven't dozed off yet may have noticed we haven't covered two variations on the curves described so far. -3dB Constant Power Sqrt (Fig. 5; Sqrt stands for Square Root) is like the 3 dB Constant Power Sin/Cos, but the curve is subtly different.

Figure 5: -3dB Constant Power Sqrt bends the curve shape slightly compared to the other Constant Power curve.

In this example, the panpot is set to 75% left instead of full left. Bus 1 shows what happens with -3dB Constant Power Sin/Cos, while Bus 2 is the Sqrt version. The Sqrt version is in less of a hurry to attenuate the right channel as you pan toward the left. Some engineers feel this more closely the situation in a space that's not acoustically treated, so there's a natural acoustic center buildup.

Finally, Fig. 6 compares the 0 dB Balance variations, sin/cos and linear.

Figure 6: Comparing the two 0 dB Balance pan law options.

The difference is similar to the Constant Power examples, in that the basic idea is the same, but again, the linear version doesn't attenuate the right channel as rapidly when you pan left.

I HAVEN'T FALLEN ASLEEP YET, SO PLEASE, JUST TELL ME WHAT I SHOULD USE!

The bottom line is when using the channel panpot with a mono track, if you live in a stereo mixdown world the above is
LINK: https://blog.presonus.com/index.php/2019/07/05/friday-tip-panning-laws...
See more stories from presonus

Most recent headlines

12/11/2019

Xilinx Announces the Worlds Highest Performance Adaptive Devices for Advanced ADAS and AD Applications

Xilinx Announces the Worlds Highest Performance Adaptive Devices for Advanced AD...

12/11/2019

Xilinx Vitis Unified Software Platform Now Available for Download

Xilinx Vitis Unified Software Platform Now Available for Download Nov 12, 2019 THE HAGUE, Netherlands, Nov. 12, 2019 /PRNewswire/ -- Xilinx Developer Forum E...

12/11/2019

Video newsletter: What are you thankful for? At WeVideo we're thankful for educators like you

alt= aria-hidden=true data-lazy-src=https://fast.wistia.com/embed/medias/zleac7z...

12/11/2019

CHRISTIAN SERRATOS TO STAR AS LEGENDARY ICON SELENA QUINTANILLA IN NETFLIX'S SELENA: THE SERIES

CHRISTIAN SERRATOS TO STAR AS LEGENDARY ICON SELENA QUINTANILLA IN NETFLIX'...

12/11/2019

NAGRA and KAON introduce Android TV streaming solution for pay-TV operators

Collaboration to accelerate time-to market of hybrid Android TV-based services for pay-TV operators, as part of the NAGRA Android Fast Track program NAGRA...

12/11/2019

Endemol Shine Italy whips up brand new food format Cook Academy

Global producer, distributor and content creator Endemol Shine Group today announces that Endemol Shine Italy is creating a brand-new cookery format for Sky whi...

12/11/2019

ENDEMOL SHINE INTERNATIONAL SECURES DRAMA PROGRAMMING PACKAGE WITH SBS TELEVISION AUSTRALIA

Endemol Shine International today announced they have secured a programming pack...

12/11/2019

Clear-Com Appoints DWR Distribution as Authorized Partner in South Africa

Company specializes in installations for live events and houses of worship Clear-Com has appointed DWR Distribution as a new Authorized Partner in South Afric...

12/11/2019

Our 2019 Workforce Diversity Report

Our 2019 Workforce Diversity Report Published on Nov 12, 2019 LinkedIn Corporate Communications Team Share LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Today, Li...

12/11/2019

The truth about fake news in Africa

What's the best to way deal with fake news? Should TV and radio give equal airtime to every candidate in a presidential election? And how can we be sure jou...

12/11/2019

Akamai Technologies Inc. Named One of Americas Most Just Companies by Forbes and Just Capital

Akamai Technologies Inc. Named One of Americas Most Just Companies by Forbes and...

12/11/2019

Lawo stars at Suzhou Folk Orchestra Concert Hall

Solid German engineering and innovative state-of-the-art IP technology are behind the Suzhou Municipal Government's selection of a Lawo mc 36 mixing desk an...

12/11/2019

Durban Christian Centre team wins National Steel Award

Durban Christian Centre team wins National Steel Award Share Just three years after its predecessor was burnt down, the Christian Centre's Jesus Dome r...

12/11/2019

Ukraine's Nash TV chooses two Artemis' for 24/7 news

Ukraine news TV channel Nash TV has purchased two 32-fader Artemis Light audio consoles for its Kiev-based 24/7 programming. Nash TV is a new customer and is a ...

12/11/2019

A Choir Performance In Kuala Lumpur Achieved Crystal Clear Sound Thanks To DPA Microphones

A Choir Performance In Kuala Lumpur Achieved Crystal Clear Sound Thanks To DPA M...

12/11/2019

Ukraine's Nash TV channel chooses two Calrec Artemis consoles for 24/7 news programming

Ukraine's Nash TV channel chooses two Calrec Artemis consoles for 24/7 news ...

12/11/2019

Busted Pilot Podcast: NYC TV Week, Apple TV+ and Disney+, Chris Matthews on 2020 Election, and More

Kent Gibbons and Michael Malone talk about NYC TV Week highlights, Apple TV+ and...

12/11/2019

OTT market penetration hits 38 per cent

OTT services are moving into the mainstream Dan Meier 4 hours ago OTT services are moving into the mainstream target=_blank title=Share on LinkedIn c...

12/11/2019

How does the Disney empire strike back against space piracy?

Analysts assess the risk of fans pirating the new Star Wars TV series Jenny Priestley 6 hours ago Analysts assess the risk of fans pirating the new Star...

12/11/2019

ITV travels to Planet V with new addressable advertising platform

Will launch in February Jenny Priestley 5 hours ago Will launch in February target=_blank title=Share on LinkedIn class=share-linkedin> Will launch i...

12/11/2019

How can newsrooms stop Wreathgate' happening?

TVBEurope asks the experts how news producers can ensure theyre using the correct footage Jenny Priestley 3 hours ago TVBEurope asks the experts how news...

12/11/2019

Mediaset raises stake in ProSieben, could go further

Italian broadcaster now ProSiebens largest investor Jenny Priestley 5 hours ago Italian broadcaster now ProSieben's largest investor target=_blank ...

12/11/2019

UK rugby team Harlequins...

Philips Professional Display Solutions has landed a three-year deal as display provider to UK rugby club Harlequins. Integrator IVC Technologies has already i...

12/11/2019

Promotion for Nicola Cutting at GV Multimedia

UK systems integrator GV Multimedia has announce the appointment of Nicola Cutting to the role of commercial director. Cutting has spent 16 years with the compa...

12/11/2019

Lang Iberia signs...

Rental company Lang Iberia has signed a distribution deal with Panasonic, this expands the deal Lang already has with Panasonic in Germany and Switzerland to th...

12/11/2019

TIG hosts Dubai Crestron elite partner event

The Technological Innovations Group (TIG) hosted more than 65 AV industry representatives from across EMEA at its Crestron Elite Partners Summit in Dubai, Unite...

12/11/2019

AVIXA releases new CTS...

AVIXA has released its third edition of its certified technology specialist exam guide, providing an inside look at the topics covered in the latest release of ...

12/11/2019

Clear-Com signs distributor in South Africa

Clear-Com is pushing into live events and house of worship applications with the addition of DWR Distribution as an authorised partner in South Africa. DWR Di...

12/11/2019

PIX and CODEX Brands to unite under X2X Media Group

PIX and CODEX have announced that the two companies are to be brought under a single unified brand identity with the establishment of the X2X Media Group. This ...

12/11/2019

NewTek TriCaster Mini Brings UHD Digital Media Production and Streaming to Schools, Businesses, and Professional AV

Today NewTek introduced the next generation TriCaster Mini, the newest addition...

12/11/2019

PMC Appoints Vintage Studios As Its Thai Distributor For All Pro Audio Monitors

PMC Speakers is delighted to announce that Vintage Studios has been appointed as its official distributor in Thailand, with responsibility for the company's...

12/11/2019

Black Box Inks Distribution Agreement With Hypertec

Black Box, an industry-leading provider of IT connectivity solutions, has signed a distribution agreement with global technology provider Hypertec Ltd. Through ...

12/11/2019

Puthiya Thalaimurai TV use Quicklink TX for bureaucrat, politician and journalist interviews

Puthiya Thalaimurai TV, part of New Gen Media Corporation, are using the Quickli...

12/11/2019

NBN Co Launches Groundbreaking Business Satellite Service Created, Designed and Managed by Speedcast

Speedcast, the world s most trusted provider of highly reliable, fully managed, ...

12/11/2019

LAURA PODOLAK WADDELL JOINS GRAVITY MEDIA TO MANAGE ITS NORTH AMERICAN STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIPS

Gravity Media, the leading global provider of complex live broadcast facilities ...

12/11/2019

Derana TV Selects LiveU Technology for its Entire Newsgathering Operations

Derana TV, Sri Lanka's premium entertainment channel, has deployed LiveU technology throughout its news operations Ada Derana for ongoing newsgathering,...

12/11/2019

Nash TV channel in Ukraine chooses two Calrec Artemis consoles for 24 7 news programming

Ukraine news TV channel Nash TV has purchased two 32-fader Artemis Light audio c...

12/11/2019

Imperial College London and Three Media implement and ldquo;near and rdquo; real time platform optimisation

Three Media, media specialist and product provider of XEN:Pipeline, today announ...

12/11/2019

A Choir Performance In Kuala Lumpur Achieved Crystal Clear Sound Thanks To DPA Microphones

DPA Microphones' recently launched 4097 CORE Supercardioid Choir Microphone ...

12/11/2019

VANTEC to Provide ETIC Virtual +AR+MOCAP Studio

VANTEC to Provide ETIC Virtual AR MOCAP Studio posted: 12/11/2019 ETICs New Studio Combines Virtual Sets With Motion-Capture The integration of an innov...

12/11/2019

Primetime Ratings: NBC Wins With Vikings-Cowboys

NBC was the big winner in Sunday ratings, as Sunday Night Football paced the net to a 4.8 in viewers 18-49, per the Nielsen overnights, and a 20 share. That top...

12/11/2019

CBS Shares Mid-Season Schedule

CBS has shared its mid-season schedule, with new programs FBI: Most Wanted, from Dick Wolf, starting Jan. 7 and Tommy, starring Edie Falco, kicking off Feb. 6. ...

12/11/2019

"Catch me if you can": Wings for Life World Run registration opens November 13!

"Catch me if you can": Wings for Life World Run registration opens November 13! posted: 11/11/2019 On November 13, the time has come to sign up for the Wing...

12/11/2019

The future of your meetings looks bright! ClickShare research reveals how technology can drive business transformation

The future of your meetings looks bright! ClickShare research reveals how techno...

12/11/2019

November 11, 2019

American Chemical Society honors translational medicine pioneer Paul Schimmel as a life-changing entrepreneur Schimmel will receive the 2020 Kathryn C. Hach Awa...

12/11/2019

Record-Breaking Number of Votes Cast in WRAL.com Voters' Choice Awards

There are only a few weeks left for voters to support their favorite people, businesses and services in the area. As of Saturday, more than 82,000 votes (a new...

12/11/2019

Brits family arguments get worse with age

11 November 2019 Kids, finances and in-laws cited as key triggers - tensions peak after a mere 48hrs in the company of extended family Christmas named core seas...

12/11/2019

Nielsen Associates Fight Hunger and Help Shape a Smarter Market by Donating Meals and Data

As part of our work to shape a smarter market, we're committed to donating o...

12/11/2019

Viacom and CBS Announce Content and Digital Leadership

Nov 11 2019 NEW YORK - (BUSINESS WIRE) - CBS (NYSE: CBS.A, CBS) and Viacom (NASDAQ: VIAB, VIA) today announced senior appointments for ViacomCBS' content ...

12/11/2019

NAGRA, SDMC and Amlogic collaborate on Android TV solution for pay-TV operators

Collaboration to give pay-TV operators more choice when it comes to Android TV based deployments Joint end-to-end solution to be delivered in full compliance...