
Parents jailed for over two years after bringing their daughter to hospital for a crime that never happened
40 cases involving same interpreter across 19 locations nationwide were held after the successful appeal judgments
Cost of providing translation services doubles between 2020-2024
Tonight, a major RT investigation into the conviction and imprisonment of a couple for a crime that leading medical experts now say didn't happen, reveals the ongoing and far-reaching consequences for the Irish system that jailed them.
Wednesday night's RT Investigates: First Conviction, reveals a court interpreter - who worked on a landmark female genital mutilation (FGM) case that was overturned on appeal over translation errors - assisted in more than 240 other cases for the Irish Court Services.
The interpreter was involved in the 2019 trial of a couple, originally from French-speaking regions of Africa, convicted of and imprisoned for the FGM of their young daughter. News of their conviction made headlines everywhere. The defence argued throughout the trial that the child's injury was accidental, caused by falling on a toy in the home.
The Court of Appeal later found serious, and potentially far-reaching, inaccuracies in the interpretation at that criminal trial, and set the convictions aside in 2021.
Despite this ruling, RT is aware the interpreter continued to assist in criminal proceedings until December 2023.
The appeal was brought on two grounds - medical evidence and interpretation - but the Court of Appeal found the interpretation issues alone were serious enough to cause the convictions to be unsafe. This decision to set aside the conviction was the first time in Irish legal history that translation issues were grounds for a successful Circuit Court appeal.
The Courts Service confirmed to RT that the interpreter had assisted in at least 246 court cases across the country between December 2016 and late December 2023. Of these cases, 146 were for the District Court, 62 for the Circuit Court, 26 for the High Court, predominantly in the Central Criminal Court.
RT is further aware that at least 40 of these cases were held across 19 locations nationwide, after the appeal court judgment.
These revelations, among others, came to light in a new joint investigation from RT Documentary on One and RT Investigates titled First Conviction, a six-part podcast series narrated by Oscar-nominated actor Ruth Negga, now available on all streaming services, and a television documentary which airs tonight on RT One and RT Player at 9.35pm.
The series tells the story of how in 2016 a couple are accused of injuring their daughter and put on trial, the first of its kind, for a crime they maintain never even happened. They're found guilty and jailed. Over the next couple of years, there are many court hearings, a second, inconclusive trial, and all the while this couple continue to say they never injured their child. The Director for Public Prosecutions (DPP) eventually abandoned the case. Now, facing the power of the State, the couple continue to fight for justice through the courts.
The RT team interviewed the couple at the heart of this story for more than a year and spoke with legal teams and experts to understand fully what the family has gone through over nearly 10 years. Crucially, this includes world-renowned medical experts in the area of FGM, who eventually turned the State's case upside down.
First Conviction marks the first time Sayeed and his wife Halawa (whose names have been changed to protect the anonymity of their children) have spoken publicly about what happened to their family. Their children were placed in the care of relatives, with State agencies monitoring them after their parents are imprisoned. When the family reunites, the young children don't recognise their mother and father.
After the couple were released from prison in November 2021, there was a second trial in 2023, but the jury's decision was inconclusive. At the same time, new medical evidence emerges to support the couple's story and the medical expert for the prosecution becomes unavailable. In 2024, the DPP entered a nolle prosequi in respect of all charges, meaning that the State was no longer proceeding with the prosecution, but the couple had not been acquitted. The couple's legal teams subsequently applied to the Court of Appeal on 14 January 2025 for a certificate of miscarriage of justice. This application will now be heard on the 22 and 23 of January 2026.
Dr Mary Phelan of DCU, and Chair of the Association of Translators and Interpreters Ireland, is one of the preeminent experts in the country on translation, particularly in legal settings like courtrooms and garda stations.
Dr Phelan and her colleagues analysed 100 minutes of the interpreted testimony from Sayeed and compiled a 150- page report for his appeal. Dr Phelan said the interpreter made numerous basic errors during the trial: There were so many opportunities lost where the defendant could have had an opportunity to tell his side of the story, and he wasn't able to do that. The family was totally failed, really, by the poor interpreting in this trial.
Dr Phelan's report found that almost all of Sayeed's evidence was affected by interpretation issues: Nobody really knows what happened. The defendant can't give his side of the story properly or in a way that everybody in the courtroom, including the jury, can actually understand. The report, compiled by Dr Phelan following her analysis, led to the Court of Appeal deciding the conviction was unsafe in 2021.
The European Parliament and the Council of Europe allow for the right to interpretation and translation in criminal proceedings. This came into effect in Ireland in December 2013.
Dr Phelan said she belie
Most recent headlines
11/12/2025
Dalet, a leading provider of cloud-native, end-to-end media workflow solutions, ...
10/12/2025
Sound-Alike Commercials Are Part of Sports' Soundtrack Johnny Cash for Coca-Cola is the latest in a long litany of sonic approximationsBy Dan Daley, Audio ...
10/12/2025
Immersive Sound Is Logical Next Step for Sports VenuesSound-systems suppliers are sanguine, but the market has its challengesBy Dan Daley, Audio Editor
Wednes...
10/12/2025
The Romans Built Arenas for Immersive Sound 2,000 Years AgoThe historic Arena of Nimes in France is still in use todayBy Dan Daley, Audio Editor
Wednesday, De...
10/12/2025
SVG Summit 2025 Preview: Audio Workshop Hits on Immersive, Virtualized, and Next...
10/12/2025
SVG Summit 2025 Technology Exhibits Preview: Audio SpotlightBy SVG Staff
Wednesday, December 10, 2025 - 8:21 am
Print This Story | Subscribe
Story Highlig...
10/12/2025
SVG Europe Audio: Listening to the sounds of powder and ice at Milano Cortina wi...
10/12/2025
Advancements in audio technology: Capturing the atmosphere of live sports By David Davies
Tuesday, November 25, 2025 - 09:27
Print This Story
Although wor...
10/12/2025
Everything smelled of popcorn: The art of bringing the complex sound of esports ...
10/12/2025
Top L-R: Ha-Chan, Shake Your Booty!, Hanging by a Wire, Broken English, Buddy
C...
10/12/2025
For the first time, Spotify is giving users the power to steer the algorithm. Gustav S derstr m, Spotify's Co-President, CPO, and CTO, shares the vision beh...
10/12/2025
L3Harris' new contract for Guided Multiple Launch Rocket System Insensitive ...
10/12/2025
L3Harris Meadowlands system has been designed with an open architecture software system that allows for more flexible and efficient software updates. This capab...
10/12/2025
During this interval, streaming comprised the majority of ad supported TV (46.4%...
10/12/2025
NEWPORT BEACH, Calif. Bitcentral, a provider of production, asset management, playout and streaming workflow solutions, has named technology veteran Rick Arnold...
10/12/2025
TV Tech is delighted to reveal the winners of the 2025 Media & Entertainment: Best in Market Awards....
10/12/2025
BOTHELL, Wash. The Alliance for IP Media Solutions (AIMS), the Video Services Forum (VSF), the Advanced Media Workflow Association (AMWA) and the European Broad...
10/12/2025
In a notable example of how pay TV operators are integrating streaming services into their lineup and using those services to retain or attract subscribers, Dir...
10/12/2025
Today, Chaos builds instant feedback into the viewport, connecting Maya and Houdini to Chaos Vantage's real-time path tracer. Artists can now assess 3D asse...
10/12/2025
Smeup, a key partner for companies engaged in digital transformation, today announced the expansion of its adoption of Cubbit, the first geo-distributed cloud s...
10/12/2025
Mediagenix, a global leader in smart content solutions to profitably connect the right content to the right audience, today announced two significant milestones...
10/12/2025
BEAVERTON, Ore. HDR10+ Technologies, LLC has announced that they will soon begin the licensing and certification of devices, content, and services that support ...
10/12/2025
SMPTE has joined forces with the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) and Entertainment Technology Center (ETC) to publish an updated report on AI and its impact o...
10/12/2025
Clear-Com is pleased to announce the appointment of Kris Koch as Director of Sales - North & South America. In this expanded leadership role, Kris will oversee...
10/12/2025
Mavis today announced the latest version of Mavis Camera (v7.4), a major update to its professional iOS camera app, headlined by the launch of Film Kit - an opt...
10/12/2025
Creamsource, renowned for its Vortex series of cinematic lighting, is laying the groundwork for its next phase of growth with the addition of Markus Zeiler as G...
10/12/2025
Digital Alert Systems, a global leader in emergency communications solutions for media providers, today announced that the DAS3-DC-PS, a new DC power supply opt...
10/12/2025
Riedel Communications today announced it has formed a strategic partnership with Racing Electronics, a premier provider of motorsport communication equipment in...
10/12/2025
#GALSNGEAR is launching two signature leadership retreats in early 2026, designed to equip women in media, entertainment, and technology with the tools to lead...
10/12/2025
Providing worldwide customers with total confidence through transparent, all-inclusive pricing
CVP, one of Europe's leading suppliers of professional video...
10/12/2025
With the Federal Communications Commission working on new rules for the deployment of NextGen TV, next year promises to be an important one for both the future ...
10/12/2025
DENVER Tom Rutledge, director emeritus and former president and CEO of Charter Communications, will be honored with the 2026 Bresnan Ethics in Business Award by...
10/12/2025
NEW YORK Novocap's Cadent has acquired VuePlanner, a YouTube video ad planning, optimization, and measurement company in a deal that will help Cadent expand...
10/12/2025
In preparation for the madness of March, here are some important reminders for scheduling back-to-back Special Playlists.
The first Special Playlist MUST end b...
10/12/2025
10 Dec 2025
VEON's Rising Capital Markets Profile Strengthened by Inclusion...
10/12/2025
10 Dec 2025
VEON Recognized for JazzCash, Kyivstar and Jazz at the World Commun...
10/12/2025
December 10th, 2025
TRIBECA FILMS TO RELEASE THE INDEPENDENT DOCUMENTARY FILM...
10/12/2025
Wednesday 10 December 2025
Sky extends partnership with the Ladies European Tour for a landmark 30th year
Sky and the Ladies European Tour (LET) have announce...
10/12/2025
Wednesday 10 December 2025
Walk-on if you love the darts: James Maddison, Luke ...
10/12/2025
Rohde & Schwarz presents world's first RF power sensor with 0.80 mm RF conne...
10/12/2025
Back to All News
2026 Starts With a Swoon: Kim Seon-ho and Go Youn-jung Lead C...
10/12/2025
Back to All News
Berlin and the Lady with an Ermine Arrives to Netflix on May 15
Entertainment
10 December 2025
GlobalSpain
Link copied to clipboard
THE N...
10/12/2025
It's out of the frying pan and into the sequins for comedian and actor Micha...
10/12/2025
Born That Way airs Thursday 18 December on RT One and RT Player
Born That ...
09/12/2025
2025 Sports Broadcasting Hall of Fame: Pam Oliver, Sideline Icon Who Redefined t...
09/12/2025
SVG Summit 2025 Technology Exhibits Preview, Part 2By Jason Dachman, Editorial Director, U.S.
Tuesday, December 9, 2025 - 7:17 am
Print This Story | Subscr...
09/12/2025
SVG Summit 2025 Preview: Cloud Production Workshop Spotlights Live and Non-Live ...
09/12/2025
Next-generation content protection: Multi-technology security is integral to com...
09/12/2025
CBS Sports Provides One-of-a-Kind Production' for UEFA Champions League Cro...
09/12/2025
Spanish Professional Basketball League Relies on NETGEAR AV, MAM Tech for Seamle...