Sony Pixel Power calrec Sony

Judge throws Romeo and Juliet' child nude scene lawsuit

26/05/2023

Judge throws Romeo and Juliet' child nude scene lawsuitA California judge has thrown out a child abuse lawsuit over a nude scene filed by actors who played in Franco Zeffirelli's 1968 Romeo and Juliet .

by Agence France-Presse

26-05-2023 09:54

in Entertainment

Image from Flickr by enokilover.collection

A child abuse lawsuit over a nude scene filed by actors who played star-crossed lovers in Franco Zeffirelli's 1968 Romeo and Juliet will be thrown out, a California judge said Thursday.

--

Olivia Hussey was 15 and Leonard Whiting 16 when they starred in the Oscar-winning film of William Shakespeare's tragedy from Hollywood studio Paramount Pictures.

The film featured a brief bedroom scene in which Whiting's buttocks and Hussey's bare breasts were visible, and the actors now both in their 70s claimed in a lawsuit filed in December that the movie amounted to sexual exploitation.

ALSO READ | Romeo and Juliet' child actors sue for more than $500M over 1968 nude scene

--

But a judge Thursday granted Paramount's motion to throw out the suit, rejecting its argument that the scene amounted to child pornography and noting that the award-winning film was covered under freedom of speech protections.

Plaintiffs have not put forth any authority showing the film here can be deemed to be sufficiently sexually suggestive as a matter of law to be held to be conclusively illegal, wrote Judge Alison Mackenzie, according to Variety.

Disqualified lawsuit The statute of limitations had also expired, she ruled, determining that the lawsuit had not qualified for a California measure temporarily unlocking historic child abuse claims.

--

ALSO READ | Child victims of sexual violence aren't heard or understood

Variety reported that during a 2018 interview with Hussey, she had defended the nude scene, which she insisted Zeffirelli had done tastefully.

(FILES) Leonard Whiting and Olivia Hussey attend the 50th Anniversary World Premiere Restoration of The Producers' presented as the Opening Night Gala of the 2018 TCM Classic Film Festival at the TCL Chinese theatre in Hollywood, California on April 26, 2018. A child abuse lawsuit over a nude scene filed by actors who played star-crossed lovers in Franco Zeffirelli's 1968 Romeo and Juliet will be thrown out, a California judge said May 25, 2023. (Photo by CHRIS DELMAS / AFP) It was needed for the film, she told the outlet at the time.

But the suit filed last December said Zeffirelli who died in 2019 cajoled the teenage pair into performing the scene, telling them without it the picture would fail.

ALSO READ | Journalist who accused Trump of rape in 1990s files new LAWSUIT

It alleged that the director had originally insisted there would be no actual nudity, with both actors covered by flesh-colored underwear.

Defendants were dishonest and secretly filmed the nude or partially nude minor children without their knowledge, in violation of the state and federal laws regulating indecency and exploitation of minors for profit, the suit said.

Exploitation and sexualization of minors' The complaint, which claimed damages of hundreds of millions of dollars, said the two performers suffered mental anguish and emotional distress, and had only limited professional success following its release.

ALSO READ | Ed Sheeran, singer and song writer wins US trial lawsuit

Hussey and Whiting's lawyer Solomon Gresen strongly denounced the ruling, in a statement sent to AFP, and said he plans to file the claims before a federal court within weeks.

We firmly believe that the exploitation and sexualization of minors in the film industry must be confronted and legally addressed to protect vulnerable individuals from harm and ensure the enforcement of existing laws, he wrote.

Agence France-Presse

How much of a rugby fanatic are you? Answer these 5 simple rugby questions and stand the chance of winning R1 000 in cash!
LINK: https://www.thesouthafrican.com/culture/entertainment/judge-throws-rom...
See more stories from thesouthafrican

Most recent headlines

09/11/2025

Dalet Unveils Agentic AI Media Workflows at IBC2025

Dalet today announced a transformative leap forward for media operations: Agentic Artificial Intelligence (AI) that unifies the Dalet ecosystem under one natura...

30/10/2025

SVG Students To Watch: Sam Newitt, Kansas State University

SVG Students To Watch: Sam Newitt, Kansas State UniversityThe South Dakota native thrives in many roles behind the scenes at K-StateHD.TVBy Brandon Costa, Direc...

30/10/2025

SVG Sit-Down: Swerve Sports' Christy Tanner Explores the Young FAST Channel's Early Success

SVG Sit-Down: Swerve Sports' Christy Tanner Explores the Young FAST Channel&...

30/10/2025

SVG Campus Shot Callers: Andy Liebsch, Senior Director, Video Services, Kansas State University

SVG Campus Shot Callers: Andy Liebsch, Senior Director, Video Services, Kansas S...

30/10/2025

Diversified Names Paul Lidsky CEO, Expanding Leadership Role After Serving as Board Chairman

Diversified Names Paul Lidsky CEO, Expanding Leadership Role After Serving as Bo...

30/10/2025

NBA, Cosm Enter Long-Term Partnership for Shared Reality Production, Distribution

NBA, Cosm Enter Long-Term Partnership for Shared Reality Production, Distributio...

30/10/2025

FanDuel Sports Network to Deliver Select Live NBA, NHL Games to Major Streaming Services for In-Market Viewers

FanDuel Sports Network to Deliver Select Live NBA, NHL Games to Major Streaming ...

30/10/2025

If I Had Legs, I'd Kick You, East of Wall, and More Sundance Institute-Supported Films Nominated for 35th Gotham Awards

As the year comes to a close, we can feel the invigorating wind sweeping in for ...

30/10/2025

Give Me the Backstory: Get to Know Max Walker-Silverman, the Writer-Director of Rebuilding

By Bailey Pennick One of the most exciting things about the Sundance Film Festi...

30/10/2025

Excellent training at SGL Carbon's Bonn site

The SGL Carbon site in Bonn has a long tradition of training. For many years, young talent has been successfully trained here, regularly achieving excellent exa...

30/10/2025

SBS, NITV and Screen Australia announce 2025 Digital Originals Shortlist

SBS, NITV and Screen Australia announce 2025 Digital Originals Shortlist 29 October, 2025 Media releases SBS, NITV and Screen Australia are excited to unve...

30/10/2025

Remarks for the 2025 APEC CEO Roundtable

Jon Rambeau, President of Integrated Mission Systems at L3Harris Technologies, speaks about industrial collaboration at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (A...

30/10/2025

L3Harris Technologies Reports Strong Third Quarter 2025 Results, Increases 2025 Guidance

MELBOURNE, Fla., October 30, 2025 - L3Harris Technologies (NYSE: LHX) reports th...

30/10/2025

FCC's Brendan Carr Issues Draft Proposal for More C-Band Spectrum Sales

WASHINGTON Federal Communications Commission Chair Brendan Carr said he has circulated a proposal for the agency to auction additional midband spectrum in the U...

30/10/2025

Diversified Names Paul Lidsky as CEO

PLANO, Texas Technology solutions provider Diversified has named Paul Lidsky as CEO, tasked with guiding the company's next stage of growth, driving market ...

30/10/2025

Interra Adds Stream Recording, BATON Integration to ORION

CUPERTINO, Calif. Interra Systems today unveiled ORION stream recording support and seamless integration with BATON Media Player, a combination that lets broadc...

30/10/2025

InterDigital Buys AI-Driven Video Codec Startup Deep Render

WILMINGTON, Del. InterDigital today announced the acquisition of Deep Render, an artificial intelligence startup with a team of AI experts focused on video code...

30/10/2025

TAG Video Systems Earns Two ESG Recognitions

NEW YORK TAG Video Systems has earned a higher-rated Digital Product Passport (DPP) Committed to Sustainability badge and the Aclymate Climate Wise Silver Tier ...

30/10/2025

Nexstar Extends Employment Agreement with Perry Sook Through 2029

IRVING, Texas As station groups move into an era that promises rapid tech, regulatory and economic changes, the Nexstar Media Group, Inc. has announced that its...

30/10/2025

Samba TV: 60% Of TV Time Spent Viewing Streaming Content

Television viewers are spending more time watching streaming content than linear TV, but sports continues to be a bright spot for broadcasters, according to the...

30/10/2025

Operative Media Names Mike Napadano as CEO

NEW YORK Advertising technology company Operative Media has named Mike Napadano as its new CEO....

30/10/2025

Walmart Selects Marshall Cameras to Power New Campus Broa...

Walmart Inc. has chosen Marshall Electronics cameras for use across its brand-new corporate campus studios and event center. The installation includes Marshall ...

30/10/2025

NETGEAR Academy Expands Into Industry-Wide IP Training Pl...

NETGEAR, Inc. (NASDAQ: NTGR), a global leader in intelligent networking solutions designed to power extraordinary experiences, today announced the launch of its...

30/10/2025

Clear-Com Gen-IC Virtual Intercom Connects Students World...

Clear-Com recently contributed its award-winning Gen-IC virtual intercom solution to power real-time communications for On-Air Student TV, a 24-hour global st...

30/10/2025

Maxon Strengthens Growth Strategy with Appointment of Kse...

Maxon, maker of powerful, approachable software solutions for creators working in 2D and 3D design, motion graphics, visual effects, and more, today announced t...

30/10/2025

Studio Technologies Dante Enabled Model 394 GPI Interface...

Studio Technologies, a leading manufacturer of high-quality audio, video, and fiber-optic solutions, announces that its new Model 394 GPI Interface and Model 39...

30/10/2025

Astro selects Broadpeak for high performance streaming an...

Broadpeak , a leader in streaming and monetization at scale, has been selected by leading Malaysian content and entertainment company Astro to enable two major ...

30/10/2025

Riedel Communications Appoints Ulrich Voigt as Director L...

Riedel Communications is pleased to announce that Ulrich Voigt has joined the company as Director Live Production Solutions, taking over the SimplyLive business...

30/10/2025

LiveU and Kinetiq Launch Cloud Native Watermarking Integr...

LiveU, the global leader in live IP-video contribution, production, and distribution, today announced a new partnership with Kinetiq, the AI-powered platform un...

30/10/2025

FCC Plans Nov. 20 Open Meeting, Provides Shutdown Update

WASHINGTON Federal Communications Commission Chair Brendan Carr has called for an end to the government shutdown while providing some updates on the agency'...

30/10/2025

Carr Issues Draft Proposal for More C-Band Spectrum Sales

WASHINGTON Federal Communications Commission Chair Brendan Carr has announced that he has circulated a proposal for the FCC to auction additional mid-band spect...

30/10/2025

U&GOLD LAUNCHES ITS ANNUAL SEARCH FOR THE UK'S BEST CHRISTMAS CRACKER' JOKES

TIS THE SEASON TO GET PUNNY! U&GOLD LAUNCHES ITS ANNUAL SEARCH FOR THE UK'S...

30/10/2025

Rohde & Schwarz enables MediaTeks 6G waveform verification with CMP180 radio communication tester

Rohde & Schwarz enables MediaTeks 6G waveform verification with CMP180 radio com...

30/10/2025

Fox Corporation Reports First Quarter Fiscal 2026 Financial Results

Fox Corporation Reports First Quarter Fiscal 2026 Financial Results NEW YORK, NY, October 30, 2025 - Fox Corporation (Nasdaq: FOXA, FOX; FOX or the Company...

30/10/2025

Tubi Media Group and Audiochuck Announce Exclusive Partnership

Tubi Media Group and Audiochuck Announce Exclusive Partnership Tubi Media Group Enters into a Multi-Year Ad Partnership Deal with Ashley Flowers' Award-Wi...

30/10/2025

Comscore Appoints a new Country Manager for APAC

Comscore Appoints a new Country Manager for APACNEW DELHI, INDIA, October 30, 2025 Comscore (Nasdaq: SCOR), a global leader in measuring and analysing consum...

30/10/2025

October 29, 2025

Scripps Research professor awarded $3.2 million to advance type 1 diabetes research Support from the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Dis...

30/10/2025

RT Concert Orchestra November/December 2025

RT Concert Orchestra in November and December Collaborations with RT Radio 1's Sunday Miscellany (2 December) and RT 2FM's Late Breakfast (9 Decembe...

30/10/2025

MUIREANN O' CONNELL, NEIL DELAMERE AND MICHAEL CONLON JOIN THE LADS FOR THE 2 JOHNNIES LATE NIGHT LOCK IN

Johnny B and Johnny Smacks are back tonight for the second episode of the new se...

30/10/2025

Jon Bon Jovi, Miriam O'Callaghan, Davy Fitzgerald and Donncha O'Callaghan join the Late Late Show Halloween Line-Up

First look of Jon Bon Jovi's interview with Patrick Kielty Jon Bon Jovi is ...

30/10/2025

AI-Powered Mobile Clinics Deliver Breast Cancer Screening to India's Rural Communities

An unassuming van driving around rural India uses powerful AI technology that...

30/10/2025

Join the Resistance: ARC Raiders' Launches in the Cloud

Get ready, raiders - the wait is over. ARC Raiders is dropping onto GeForce NOW and bringing the fight from orbit to the screen. To celebrate the launch, gamer...

29/10/2025

MLS, EDGE Sound Research To Debut Immersive Embodied Sound' at LAFC vs. Austin FC Playoff Match

MLS, EDGE Sound Research To Debut Immersive Embodied Sound' at LAFC vs. Aus...

29/10/2025

SVG Remote Production Forum 2025: All Sessions Now Available to Watch on SVG PLAY

SVG Remote Production Forum 2025: All Sessions Now Available to Watch on SVG PLA...

29/10/2025

World Series 2025: How Audio Is Transported Around the Sites and Beyond

World Series 2025: How Audio Is Transported Around the Sites and BeyondThe signals also move not just between two countries but around the globeBy Dan Daley, Au...

29/10/2025

Inside the Archives: Celebrating Archives Month Through Sundance Film Festival Films

A still from 306 Hollywood, a film by sibling filmmakers Jonathan Bogar n and El...

29/10/2025

New research shows sense of belonging is growing stronger among multilingual Australians

New research shows sense of belonging is growing stronger among multilingual Aus...

29/10/2025

SBS, NITV and Screen Australia announce2025 Digital Originals Shortlist

SBS, NITV and Screen Australia announce2025 Digital Originals Shortlist 29 October, 2025 Media releases SBS, NITV and Screen Australia are excited to unvei...