Testimony of Rick Kaplan at DOJ Advertising Competition Workshop WASHINGTON, D.C. -- NAB Executive Vice President of Legal and Regulatory Affairs Rick Kaplan testified this morning at a Department of Justice public workshop on competition in television and digital advertising.
Below is his testimony as prepared for delivery.
* * *
Good morning.
On behalf of the National Association of Broadcasters, I would like to thank Assistant Attorney General Delrahim, Lee Berger, and the antitrust division staff for holding this workshop and inviting us to participate.
Few issues are as vexing to television broadcasters as how narrowly the Department of Justice defines the video advertising marketplace.
DOJ has the same view of the broadcast TV marketplace today as it did in the 1970s, 80s, and 90s. Never mind that cable and satellite providers now offer hundreds of channels of high-quality content. Never mind that the internet has thoroughly upended the way consumers access and engage with video offerings.
And never mind that, if we polled the first 100 people walking past this building as to whether they could distinguish between broadcast TV and cable, satellite, or OTT video, we'd be lucky to find even just one.
So where is the disconnect?
I thought it might be helpful for us to briefly look at DOJ's stated rationale for its unwavering view. Perhaps then we can assess why, despite changing times, DOJ's position is the only thing that has managed to remain the same.
Sight and Sound
DOJ typically begins its complaints by noting that broadcast TV is unique because its spot advertising combines sight, sound, and motion in a way that makes television advertisements particularly memorable and impactful.
Of course, this premise, while flattering, would be very difficult for DOJ to demonstrate in court. But even if it could, one would think that the same rationale would apply to cable, telco, and DBS advertisements, right?
Reach
DOJ says no, while those are technically TV, too, those alleged competitors don't count because TV stations have a greater reach than these other platforms.
The term reach, however, in this context is tricky. DOJ is not saying that the entire market watches broadcast TV; rather, reach describes how many people can theoretically watch broadcast TV. The relevance of this metric escapes me, because theoretical viewers don't sell spots or earn ad revenues; only actual viewers do.
In fact, MVPDs also reach nearly 100% of homes in most DMAs. You can subscribe anywhere you live, just like you can purchase an antenna in most areas of the country and receive broadcast TV. So, reach isn't really the issue.
Brand Awareness
DOJ uses a broadcaster's purported reach to argue that broadcast TV advertisements more effectively introduce and establish the image of a product. This is DOJ's way of suggesting that broadcast advertisements serve a different purpose than say, cable ads. If everyone in a DMA can see an ad, perhaps that is a good way to generate brand awareness. But again, DOJ conflates reach with viewers . DOJ never addresses the fact that only a small percentage of potential viewers watch in the first instance.
Beyond this incongruity, DOJ's view is also noticeably lacking in support. Upon what does it base this social scientific claim? Also, why ignore other forms of advertising that might achieve that purpose as well? Wouldn't a guerilla street marketing campaign do the same? How about a widespread local media buy on Google? What about naming rights to the local high school football stadium? DOJ ignores these other available options that undoubtedly broaden the relevant the marketplace.
Ratings Points
DOJ does separately get around to discussing actual viewership and claims that broadcast TV has superior ratings points. This statement, however, tells us nothing about who participates in the relevant product market. For advertisers, the bottom line is getting quality impressions at the best price. A highly-rated TV program may be more expensive. Think about the Super Bowl. However, since there is fierce competition in the marketplace, if that program is too expensive, advertisers can and would reach the same number of - if not more - people with a plethora of less expensive options. MVPDs and digital advertising alone offer seemingly endless cost-effective opportunities for advertisers.
Digital Media
Speaking of digital, digital advertising on its own has completely changed the game. Digital takes things to a whole new level: it's ubiquitous, targeted, has low barriers to entry, and it runs the same advertisements broadcasters do.
Unfortunately, to date, DOJ has refused to budge even in the face of the digital revolution. Without missing a beat, DOJ has already repeatedly rejected requests to include digital in the broadcast TV marketplace, explaining that online ads can be skipped, minimized, or blocked.
I will let you in on a little secret: you can also do those things with broadcast TV. It's called grabbing a snack from the fridge, disappearing to the bathroom, or even just hitting fast forward on your DVR remote. In fact, in most cases, it is harder to do an end-around a digital ad, because often you can't even get to the highly-desired content without first playing one or more advertisements.
So far, DOJ has failed to recognize what droves of advertisers have: digital advertising can provide quality impressions less expensively because the targeting and tracking capabilities of digital ads make them more cost effective. After all, advertisers have limited and finite ad budgets and today can spend them on digital platforms targeting the consumers they really want to reach.
Hopefully, DOJ's decision to hold today's workshop suggests that it is finally pois
Most recent headlines
04/08/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, is excited to announce Santiago Solanas as its new Chief Executive Officer (CEO)....
03/06/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, a...
03/05/2024
An innovative learning tool to help media and civil society better understand ho...
03/05/2024
PARK CITY, UTAH - JANUARY 21: (L-R) Actors K stutis Cic nas and Greta Grinevi i t , Director Marija Kavtaradze and Producer Marija Razgute attend the 2023 Sunda...
03/05/2024
If you aren't familiar with Danny Ocean's music, it's only a matter ...
03/05/2024
Spotify has an unwavering commitment to supporting emerging artists across all genres, to helping them launch and thrive in their careers, and to connecting the...
03/05/2024
Como uno de los sonidos de mayor expansi n en el mundo, la M sica Mexicana va m ...
03/05/2024
As one of the fastest-growing sounds worldwide, M sica Mexicana is more than jus...
03/05/2024
NEW YORK FuboTV reported that it lost 110,000 subs in Q1 2024 but it exceeded its guidance for the quarter with double digit year-over-year increases across key...
03/05/2024
Only 3 Weeks Left To Enter The Creative Industries Most Award
Brie Clayton May 3, 2024
0 Comments
Creativepool is giving a last call to the creative i...
03/05/2024
WePlay Studios Transforms the Future of Live Event Storytelling with AJA Gear
Brie Clayton May 3, 2024
0 Comments
By 2032, the esports market is expec...
03/05/2024
WASHINGTON Shannon Bream, Fox News Sunday anchor and chief legal correspondent, sat for a keynote chat at The Business of TV News, with Tom Umstead, senior co...
03/05/2024
WASHINGTON Asked how important is local news, Martha Raddatz, who has covered foreign conflicts for decades and moderated presidential debates for ABC News, s...
03/05/2024
Sony Pictures and Apollo Global Management have made a $26 billion cash offer fo...
03/05/2024
CBS announced its 2024-2025 primetime schedule, which features the new dramas NCIS: Origins, Matlock and Watson, and new comedies Poppa's House and Georgie ...
03/05/2024
Sports-focused streaming service Fubo said it reduced its red ink in the first quarter, despite losing 110,000 subscribers since the end of the year....
03/05/2024
Walmart is reportedly about to release a new 4K streaming box/smart speaker hybrid device for Google TV that could retail for as low as $50, according to a repo...
03/05/2024
Enhancements to its Delivery Workspace solution provide increased content delivery robustness and security
By Matthew Corrigan
Published: May 3, 2024
Enha...
03/05/2024
According to reports, if the bid is successful, Sony would be the significant majority shareholder of the new private company
By Jenny Priestley
Published: M...
03/05/2024
Located in Manchesters Spinningfields district, the course aims to equip students with the skills, knowledge and industry insight for a career in the creative s...
03/05/2024
Lightbridge has created a new Cine Reflect Lighting System kit, dedicated to enabling artistic lighting with consideration of today's productivity practical...
03/05/2024
Broadcast media systems integrator BeckTV and Lawo worked together on a large-scale AES67 build of radio control rooms at KPBS, San Diego's NPR and PBS memb...
03/05/2024
Raleigh, NC, April 12, 2024 SmallHD announces PageOS 6, a powerful software update free for owners of SmallHD monitors, featuring increased functionality, exp...
03/05/2024
SmallHD announces the Quantum 32 a new 31.5 OLED monitor designed to provide reference HDR/SDR images for post-production final color grading, as well as cri...
03/05/2024
By 2032, the esports market is expected to grow to $9.29 billion, bolstered by a global player count and fan following that both continue to climb. The 2023 Lea...
03/05/2024
Amagi, the global leader in cloud-based SaaS technology for broadcast and connected TV (CTV), today announced that the 11th edition of the Amagi Global FAST Rep...
03/05/2024
Riedel Communications today announced that Westdeutscher Rundfunk (WDR) is relying on a media and intercom network based on Riedel technology for the renewal of...
03/05/2024
Broadpeak , a leading provider of content delivery network (CDN) and video streaming solutions for content providers and pay-TV operators worldwide, announced t...
03/05/2024
Media technology innovator Limecraft will exhibit the latest updates to its online platform on stand G79 at the 15-16 May 2024 Media Production & Technology Sho...
03/05/2024
Audio interface specialist Prism Sound is partnering with console manufacturer Solid State Logic, professional monitor manufacturer PMC and acoustic panel and d...
03/05/2024
Intinor, Sweden's leading developer of products and solutions for high-quality video over the internet, is set to join forces with its UK partner Zest Techn...
03/05/2024
NAKIVO Inc., a fast-growing software company dedicated to protecting physical, virtual, cloud, and SaaS environments, announced its Q1 2024 financial results to...
03/05/2024
Hiltron Communications announces an addition to its range of satellite communication products and systems: a field-upgradable motorisation kit specifically desi...
03/05/2024
Visit LiveU at Stand D30
With this year an exceptional one for major sporting events alongside multiple, key elections, the power and flexibility of LiveU'...
03/05/2024
Agile Content, the leader in the development of technology and solutions for the provision of television services over the Internet, announces Koldo Unanue as i...
03/05/2024
Eight co-signers representing streaming services, pay TV operators and public interest groups have sent a letter to Congressional leaders urging their Committee...
03/05/2024
BOSTON Brightcove has announced that it has implemented Amazon Q Business, a new generative AI assistant on Amazon Web Services (AWS)....
03/05/2024
NEW YORK CBS has declared that it will finish the 2023-24 season as Americas Most-Watched Network in primetime for the 16th consecutive season....
03/05/2024
A new survey indicates that U.S. businesses and consumers had an overall positive attitude towards their technology spending plans in the first quarter of 2024,...
03/05/2024
Sony and Apollo Global Management have sent an offer letter to Paramount Global's board of directors making an $26 billion all cash offer for Paramount Glob...
03/05/2024
EMG / Gravity Media has appointed Charlie Cubbon chief operating officer (COO) and Jamie Hindhaugh regional CEO for the U.K., U.S., Australia and the Middle Eas...
03/05/2024
Final 2024 Season Games to Air Saturdays on WRAL at 10:30am in May, Championship on June 1
Taping for the final episodes of the 2024 season of WRAL-TV's Br...
03/05/2024
Estrella MediaCo said it is expanding its connected TV portfolio by launching three new channels with Curiosity that will first appear on Samsung TV Plus....
03/05/2024
Nielsen said that actors' union SAG-AFTRA has selected Nielsen as its third-party provider of streaming content measurement....
03/05/2024
Cineverse said it has released a public beta version of cineSearch, its artificial intelligence-based system designed to help users find content to watch....
03/05/2024
Court TV said that its series Accomplice to Murder with Vinnie Politan is returning for a second season beginning May 5....
03/05/2024
Paramount Advertising said it is working with Mastercard and research and analytics company EDO to measure the impact of advertising campaigns and improve their...
03/05/2024
WASHINGTON The panel The Growth of Local Programming happened at The Busines...
03/05/2024
Katz Media Group said that Craig Broitman will become president of the company, succeeding Leo MacCourtney, who announced that he is retiring effective July 1....
Testimony of Rick Kaplan at DOJ Advertising Competition Workshop WASHINGTON, D.C. -- NAB Executive Vice President of Legal and Regulatory Affairs Rick Kaplan testified this morning at a Department of Justice public workshop on competition in television and digital advertising.
