Here's what the Guptas' naturalisation ruling really means for South Africa
18/03/2019
As TimesLive stated, the committee also recommended that Ashu Chawla's SA citizenship be revoked, as he was the central person in the manipulation of the application process for the early naturalisation of the Guptas. He was also responsible for the facilitation of illegal visas for Gupta-linked Indian nationals.
Acting in cahoots with a less-than-honest Malusi Gigaba, the alleged mastermind' behind the Gupta clan's infiltration into South Africa skipped the country back in September 2018. So where exactly does that leave us? We're on hand to try and clean up this mess:
What the ruling on Ajay Gupta and his brothers really means: What is Ajay Gupta's citizenship status? Ajay, a recent fugitive of South African law, never managed to complete his citizenship application. In India, no-one is allowed to possess dual citizenship. So this ruling doesn't strip him of South African status, because he never had it in the first place despite Gigaba's statements to the contrary.
Ajay did not provide evidence to Home Affairs that he had relinquished his Indian citizenship, therefore he could not be naturalised. He remains the only member of his immediate family not to have gained his South African citizenship.
New criminal charges The committee recommended that the judiciary add more criminal charges to the Guptas' rap sheet. They advise that the brothers along with Mr Chawla must be indicted for submitting false information to back up their applications for early naturalisation.
That's obviously going to be extremely difficult with all four of them taking refuge in Dubai at the moment. But, hope springs eternal: With Ajay's fugitive status being lifted earlier in the year and his vague promise to come back to SA and take on the state capture inquiry being issued he may just face justice one day.
And if that doesn't get him, perhaps a new extradition treaty with the UAE will.
Family members whose citizenship will be revoked Rajesh Gupta
His name appears on the voter's register, and Rajesh - who also goes by the name Tony , for some reason - became a permanent citizen of the state in 2008.
Atul Gupta
This is where the confusion begins. Gigaba infamously got his Guptas mixed up, and referred to both Atul and Ajay as the same person. Maybe Tony's alias had thrown him, who knows?
Ajay Gupta's wife
Mrs Shivani Gupta was successfully granted her citizenship in 2015, but this came just months after the family had their request for naturalisation as a unit turned down. It is believed they applied to Malusi Gigaba - due to their exceptional circumstances - who overturned the decision personally.
The Guptas' parents and Ajay's children
His actions also meant that the rest of the family could become naturalised. That includes Ajay Gupta's mother, Mrs Angoori Gupta and his sons Mr Kamal Kant Singhala and Mr Surya Kant Singhala.
Guptas returning to the country So without citizenship, will they be allowed to stay in South Africa if they so wish? Legally speaking, the answer is yes. They just would not be afforded the same luxuries as a naturalised citizen would. Looks like that's a few votes for the ANC that have gone down the toilet, then.
What does this mean for Malusi Gigaba? Somewhere down the line, it spells trouble. A cloud hangs over Gigabyte ever since his infamous resignation from office in 2018. He has been added back to the ANC Parliamentary List, suggesting he will run as an MP for the 2019 Elections. However, his return to the National Assembly could see him hauled in front of the Ethics Committee.
Gigaba only dodged an inquiry into perjury charges by quitting as an MP. If or when he returns as one, he will be under enormous pressure to face the music. Monday's decision doesn't exactly go down as an achievement he can put on his CV. In fact, this naturalisation debacle just shows him up to be a terrible liar again.
Tags: Ajay GuptaDual CitizenshipMalusi GigabaSouth AfricaThe Gupta Family
LINK: | https://www.thesouthafrican.com/heres-what-the-guptas-naturalisation-r... |
See more stories from thesouthafrican |
Most recent headlines
03/06/2024
Dalet and Veritone Reach Agreement to Distribute, Transact and Monetize Media Archives
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, a...
18/03/2024
USC Basketball Star Juju Watkins on Fashion, Film, Friendship Bracelets, and More
Listeners turn to Spotify to connect with their favorites-from artists and album...
18/03/2024
Young professionals successfully complete vocational training at SGL's Meitingen site
Seven young professionals completed their vocational training at SGL Carbon in M...
18/03/2024
Vintage Allure
Released this past January, the music video for Ariana Grande's yes, and? brings a modern approach to vintage allure. The video was directed by Christian ...
18/03/2024
ST Engineering iDirect Unveils Intuition at SATELLITE 2024 Conference and Exhibition
Global satellite communications leader gives market a first look at its next-gen...
18/03/2024
Box to Box Films shares with MediaSilo
Box to Box Films Shares with MediaSilo Amy and Drive to Survive producer updates collaborators simply and securely Boston, MA, March 18, 2024 - Box to Box Fi...
18/03/2024
Telestream Introduces AI-Powered Tools for Rapid Content Delivery at NAB Show 2024
Telestream Introduces AI-Powered Tools for Rapid Content Delivery at NAB Show 20...
18/03/2024
Docufiction Film Bringing Down a Mountain Edited with DaVinci Resolve Studio
Docufiction Film Bringing Down a Mountain Edited with DaVinci Resolve Studio Brie Clayton March 18, 2024 0 Comments Blackmagic Design today announced ...
18/03/2024
FingerWorks Telestrators Releases Enhancements to Computer Vision Live Tracking Software at NAB 2024
FingerWorks Telestrators Releases Enhancements to Computer Vision Live Tracking ...
18/03/2024
DirecTV to Allow Subscribers to Opt Out of Local Stations
DirecTV announced a new feature over the weekend that will allow its subscribers to opt out of their local stations in return for a discount. Customers who ch...
18/03/2024
Logging and reviewing: Moving towards a sustainable workflow
Jane Sung, COO at Cinedeck, explains how broadcasters and content production companies can achieve the goal of moving towards creating a more sustainable, effic...
18/03/2024
Altice Media sold to French shipping tycoon for 1.55 billion
The deal includes BFM TV, one of the country's largest 24-hour news channels, as well as documentary channel RMC D couverte, and RMC Story By Jenny Priestl...
18/03/2024
Meet the CEO and founder
By TVBEurope Staff Published: March 18, 2024 Nick Franco tells TVBEurope how he went from being a master plasterer and refurbishing the ornate plasterwork ...
18/03/2024
Master the Avatar State: Glowing Eyes in Adobe After Effects
Master the Avatar State: Glowing Eyes in Adobe After Effects Levi Borland March 18, 2024 0 Comments In this step-by-step tutorial, learn how to recrea...
18/03/2024
Next Season of Doctor Who' on Disney Plus May 10
The next season of Doctor Who, with Ncuti Gatwa as the 15th Doctor, premieres on Disney Plus and around the world May 10. It is the first season to launch on Di...
18/03/2024
Screen Australia and VicScreen launch new Screen Careers initiative
18 03 2024 - Media release Screen Australia and VicScreen launch new Screen Careers initiative LTR Denise Eriksen, Esther Coleman Hawkins, Caroline Pitcher, K...
18/03/2024
CBC/WRAL Night Helps Bring in Over $26k for PBS NC
Capitol Broadcasting and WRAL-TV continued a decades-long tradition of supporting PBS North Carolina, our state's public television station, to good result ...
18/03/2024
Banglalink Gets Unified Licence to Deliver Superior Digital Services in Bangladesh
18 Mar 2024 Banglalink Gets Unified Licence to Deliver Superior Digital Service...
18/03/2024
Thuraya partners with Niflink to deliver telemedicine and eLearning to users across its network
Abu Dhabi, 18 March, 2024 : Abu Dhabi, 18 March 2024: Thuraya Telecommunication...
18/03/2024
Thuraya partners with Niflink to deliver telemedicine and eLearning to users across its ne...
Abu Dhabi, 18 March, 2024 : Abu Dhabi, 18 March 2024: Thuraya Telecommunication...
18/03/2024
Major League Soccer: IMG on Capturing Fan Rituals and Delivering Consistent Coverage
Major League Soccer: IMG on capturing fan rituals and delivering consistent cove...
18/03/2024
Smashing Padel: Inside Aurora's Innovative Production of the Inaugural Hexagon Cup
Smashing padel: Inside Aurora's innovative production of the inaugural Hexag...
18/03/2024
Airspeeder Teams Up With EMG for World's First Live Broadcast of Flying Car Series
Airspeeder teams up with EMG for world's first live broadcast of flying car ...
18/03/2024
Netflix Announces News About 26 Upcoming Nordic Titles - Including 12 Brand New Titles
Back to All News Netflix Announces News About 26 Upcoming Nordic Titles - Inclu...
18/03/2024
Final sprint in the AS4 market communication
Final Sprint in the AS4 Market Communication: All Arvato Systems Customers Are Ready to Go Customers for market communication AS4-ready Arvato Systems is now...
18/03/2024
Tonight on Uzalo: Nkunzi takes a drastic decision
Tonight on Uzalo: Nkunzi takes a drastic decisionDon't miss Monday, 18 March's riveting episode of South African soapie Uzalo on SABC 1 on DStv channel ...
18/03/2024
Thales to modernize Montreal Mtro blue Line,improving passengers' punctuality and train reliability
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Following a call for tenders, the Soci t de tra...
18/03/2024
Streaming today: Vida the Vet' on Netflix - 18 March 2024
Streaming today: Vida the Vet' on Netflix - 18 March 2024Looking for something to watch tonight? Check out all the new streaming releases from all your fav...
18/03/2024
Skeem Saam': Is Tobias Maswahla Evelyn's son?
Skeem Saam': Is Tobias Maswahla Evelyn's son?Is actor Sicelo Buthelezi's character Tobias Maswahla related to Deputy Principal Evelyn Maswahla in S...
18/03/2024
Tonight on Generations: Khensani tries to mend his friendship with Sphe
Tonight on Generations: Khensani tries to mend his friendship with SpheDon't miss Monday, 18 March's riveting episode of South African soapie Generation...
18/03/2024
Question: Did George Lucas rip off Dune?
Question: Did George Lucas rip off Dune?Miles Phillips explores Dune's Legacy and its echo in Star Wars, claiming that the former is among the best science ...
18/03/2024
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Jacobeth kicks Bullet to the curb
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Jacobeth kicks Bullet to the curbDon't miss Monday, 16 March's riveting episode of South African soapie Skeem Saam on SABC 1 on D...
18/03/2024
Tonight on Muvhango: Matshidiso finds incriminating information on Nkele
Tonight on Muvhango: Matshidiso finds incriminating information on NkeleDon't miss Monday, 18 March's riveting episode of South African soapie Muvhango ...
18/03/2024
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: In a haze of alcohol, Sakhile knocks down Fanyana
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: In a haze of alcohol, Sakhile knocks down FanyanaDon't miss Monday, 18 March's riveting episode of South African soapie Sm...
18/03/2024
Tonight on Scandal: Jojo's bad PR costs him more than he can afford
Tonight on Scandal: Jojo's bad PR costs him more than he can affordDon't miss Monday, 18 March's riveting episode of South African soapie Scandal! o...
18/03/2024
Tonight on Champions: Lebo's family are tearing him apart
Tonight on Champions: Lebo's family are tearing him apartDon't miss Monday, 18 March's riveting episode of South African soapie Champions on Mzansi ...
18/03/2024
Tonight on Gqeberha: Msimelelo lays down the rules at the Tshisa Nyama
Tonight on Gqeberha: Msimelelo lays down the rules at the Tshisa NyamaDon't miss Monday, 18 March's riveting episode of South African soapie Gqeberha: T...
18/03/2024
Tonight on Umkhokha: Zisebenzele makes a bet with Khululiwe that Siphamandla will do it within a week
Tonight on Umkhokha: Zisebenzele makes a bet with Khululiwe that Siphamandla wil...
18/03/2024
Cyberani and Thales enter a strategic alliance to strengthen the Kingdom's cybersecurity
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Mr. Saeed Al Saeed, CEO of Cyberani, and Mr. Pie...
18/03/2024
Thales to equip Cibao International Airport in Dominican Republic with new Air Traffic Control Radar System
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Instituto Dominicano de Aviaci n Civil (IDAC) se...
17/03/2024
WATCH: Highlights from the 2024 Cape Town Carnival [video]
WATCH: Highlights from the 2024 Cape Town Carnival [video]The Mother City's biggest annual street parade returned to Green Point on Saturday with the Cape T...
17/03/2024
WATCH: Highlights from the 2024 Cape Town Carnival
WATCH: Highlights from the 2024 Cape Town CarnivalThe Mother City's biggest annual street parade returned to Green Point on Saturday with the Cape Town Carn...
17/03/2024
Young Papi leaves Big Brother Mzansi'
Young Papi leaves Big Brother Mzansi'Young Papi was the thirteenth housemate to get evicted from the Big Brother Mzansi' reality TV show on Sunday, 17...
17/03/2024
Smoke and Mirrors': Why Thandiswa might dump Caesar
Smoke and Mirrors': Why Thandiswa might dump Caesar Smoke and Mirrors' spoilers reveal that Caesar will propose marriage to Thandiswa. Will she stay wit...
16/03/2024
Josh Brolin Drama Outer Range' Returns To Prime Video May 16
Western drama Outer Range is back with season two on Prime Video May 16. Josh Brolin stars and executive produces. He also directs the season's penultimate ...
16/03/2024
Kristen Wiig Lined Up to Host SNL' for Fifth Time
Kristen Wiig hosts Saturday Night Live for the fifth time on April 6. Wiig stars in and executive produces Palm Royale, which premieres March 20 on Apple TV Plu...
16/03/2024
Magnite, Mediaocean Join To Make Buying CTV Campaigns Easier
Media buyers using Mediaocean's Prisma platform will be able to plan, execute and reconcile ad campaigns on connected TV directly from programmers who work ...
16/03/2024
Bitmovin, Yospace Combine To Insert Ads Into Live Streams
Streaming infrastructure company Bitmovin is teaming up with ad-insertion vendor Yospace to enable broadcasters to put commercials in live-streaming programming...
16/03/2024
Bumble Engages Peacock's The Traitors' To Promote Dating Deception Detector'
Bumble, the dating service, has tapped into Peacock's murder-mystery competi...
16/03/2024
Gerald Levin, Former Time Warner CEO, Has Died
Gerald Levin, former CEO of Time Warner, died March 13. He was 84 and had battled Parkinson's disease....