Sony Pixel Power calrec Sony

Finding a Balance as AI Advances

23/07/2024

Brussels was the location of our third Thomson Talks with Madhav Chinnappa held on 25 June 2024, focused on the specific subject of AI/News & Regulation. Four kick-off speakers framed the topic from their respective perspectives before the open-ended discussion took place.

The event was held under the Chatham House Rule so where someone is named, it is with their explicit permission.

Claus Grewenig, Chief Corporate Affairs Officer at RTL Deutschland co-hosted and shared the perspective of a large broadcasting and streaming company's as well as a news organisation's perspective around:

despite the pros of AI, the need for a robust (copyright) framework to protect and negotiate when content is used

the need for improvements in levelling the playing field and findability for value media

a focus on financial sustainability of the media sector (e.g. no ad restrictions)

Dan Nechita, Head of Cabinet for Dragos Tudorache, MEP with Renew Europe, spoke about how the European Parliament (EP) insisted on provisions for transparency regarding input data to increase our knowledge of how models are trained, about how AI labelling helps combat disinformation and electoral interference, and about the next steps in the AI Act implementation, for which the European Commission (EC), and in particular the AI Office, is in charge.

Kilian Gross, Head of Unit in the AI Office at the EC followed with outlining how the AI Office is a transversal organisation, not just a regulator and is trying to balance innovation and regulation while being inclusive, fast and conscious that actions need to be done with the global context in mind.

Ariane Bernard, a news industry and digital innovation leader who currently advises many News CEOs, spoke about the reality from the trenches where her current clients often express anxiety about the lack of clarity about where things are going which has led many news organisations to be slow or to fall back on a dependency on Big Tech so as not to fall foul of any interpretation of regulation.

Postive role for AI? Participants expressed a series of concerns about the AI world in terms of media sustainability, trust and disinformation as well as copyright concerns. There were many open questions about how regulation could or would play a positive force in the ecosystem overall.

It was acknowledged that AI tools could be positive and help freedom of expression and legitimate news organisations but this was tempered by concerns of how bad actors would use these tools and ignore any regulations. This led to a discussion about journalisms role in explaining AI to a wider audience, while things are moving so quickly - no easy task!

Sonja Schwetje of RTL Deutschland observed that while most media organisations have shown an immense effort catering to the preferences of younger audiences in terms of how and where to provide their content, there remains an ambiguity between balanced, impartial journalistic information and polarising, opinion-based content, with the latter being promoted much more via algorithms.

-- Play

-- --

Dialogue between all parties Some participants felt that the regulation system had failed news organisations by not protecting IP enough and worried that this would lead to a collapse of more news organisations which would then lead to undermining the AI models themselves. A point was made that much of news is based on so-called derivative content and thus based on the work of others, so news organisations have always done this and therefore need to acknowledge that first, before lecturing to tech companies.

The importance of dialogue between regulators, news organisations and tech companies was a recurring theme, especially as existing regulations may not be sufficient to address the challenges and speed of developments posed by AI. Is there a way to co-regulate holistically? Alexandru Giboi of The European Alliance of News Agencies made the point that more mutual understanding between tech & media companies could lead to better problem-solving in the future.

-- Play

-- --

There was a sidebar on the value of news: to society and also to tech companies. An observation was made that tech companies value news using the metric of revenue to them (which is de minimis) while news organisations judge their value in terms of societal value and importance to democracy. Thus, if the two sides are using different measures, they will never agree.

If news organisations believed they were so important to democracy, then they were challenged to try to speak with one voice to regulators as otherwise, their perspectives would not be understood nor factored in well enough. The difficulty is that there are multiple views on the multiple issues, including from within a single news organisation so getting to a singular would be very, very hard. But perhaps the potential existential challenge faced by the news ecosystem would drive different, more collaborative behaviour than in the past. And news organisations were also advised not to be slow, as it had been in the past.

In terms of solutions, a few were discussed, including:

Public education initiatives to raise awareness of AI and its potential pitfalls.

Investment in media literacy programs to help people critically evaluate information online.

Development of new economic models for the media industry that can thrive in the digital age.

Finding a balance between technological advancement, ethical considerations, and media viability will be crucial in the years to come in finding the right regulation to regulate AI and the news ecosystem.

Madhav Chinnappa Thomson Talks

Madhav Chinnappa, the former Director of News Ecosystem Development at Google and veteran news executive, leads our Thought Leadership events Thomson Talks.

Explore our projects across the globe
LINK: http://www.thomsonfoundation.org/latest/finding-a-balance-as-ai-advanc...
See more stories from thompsonfoundation

Most recent headlines

05/01/2027

Worlds first 802.15.4ab-UWB chip verified by Calterah and Rohde & Schwarz to be demoed at CES 2026

Worlds first 802.15.4ab-UWB chip verified by Calterah and Rohde & Schwarz to be ...

04/08/2026

Dalet Announces Commercial Availability of Dalia, Bringing Media-Aware Agentic AI to Enterprise Productions

Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, t...

04/07/2026

Detective Conan: Fallen Angel of the Highway Opens in Dolby Cinemas Across Japan, Presented in Dolby Atmos and Dolby ...

April 7 2026, 19:00 (PDT) Detective Conan: Fallen Angel of the Highway Opens in...

01/06/2026

Dolby Sets the New Standard for Premium Entertainment at CES 2026

January 6 2026, 05:30 (PST) Dolby Sets the New Standard for Premium Entertainment at CES 2026 Throughout the week, Dolby brings to life the latest innovatio...

02/05/2026

Dalet Flex LTS Delivers Smarter Search, Faster Editing, and an AI-Ready Foundation for Modern Media

Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, t...

01/05/2026

NBCUniversal's Peacock to Be First Streamer to Integrate Dolby's Full Suite of Premium Picture and Sound Innovations

January 5 2026, 18:30 (PST) NBCUniversal's Peacock to Be First Streamer to ...

13/04/2026

TikToK, Major Ad Groups Back Influencer Certification Program

Share Copy link Facebook X Linkedin Bluesky Email...

13/04/2026

DHD Marks 30th Anniversary with Brand Relaunch

DHD audio, developer and manufacturer of digital audio systems for professional broadcast, has launched a comprehensive brand update to mark its 30th anniversar...

13/04/2026

Stegawave Debuts Real-Time Forensic Watermarking to Tackl...

Stegawave, an Irish technology company specialising in forensic watermarking for video content, today announced the launch of its anti-piracy platform for live ...

13/04/2026

Synamedia PowerVu cuts broadcast distribution costs by up...

New version of Quortex PowerVu delivers a standards-based approach to satellite-to-IP transitions, eliminating the need for baseband workflows and complex infra...

13/04/2026

Studio Berlin Invests in Cinematic Live Production with G...

Grass Valley LDX camera systems enable leading German production company to support broadcast and cinematic live production within a single environment. Grass ...

13/04/2026

Techex and MediaKind partner to bring resilient IP transp...

London, UK, 13 April 2026 Techex and MediaKind today announced a partnership to integrate Techexs IP transport and orchestration technology, tx edge, directly...

13/04/2026

Transforming modern education environments with Lightware...

In today's hybrid education environments, there is no one-size-fits-all' AV solution. Lightware's extensive AV portfolio addresses this challenge, ...

13/04/2026

Mediaproxy adds AI toolset to LogServer for brand and adv...

Mediaproxy, the global standard for software-based IP compliance monitoring and multiviewing solutions, has developed a new suite of AI-powered tools designed t...

13/04/2026

Freelance Video Cameraman - Los Angeles

Freelance Video Cameraman - Los Angeles Brie Clayton April 13, 2026 0 Comments Freelance Video Cameraman April 8, 2026COW Jobs: Director Needed for ...

13/04/2026

Atomos to Acquire Flanders Scientific

Atomos to Acquire Flanders Scientific Brie Clayton April 13, 2026 0 Comments Strengthening commitment to precision monitoring, from camera to delivery...

13/04/2026

Digital Anarchy Announces ShotNotes, A Notepad and Task Tracking Panel for Premiere Pro

Digital Anarchy Announces ShotNotes, A Notepad and Task Tracking Panel for Premi...

13/04/2026

NAB 2026 Live Demo at HP Booth Highlights JALI Powered Interactive AI Character Experience

NAB 2026 Live Demo at HP Booth Highlights JALI Powered Interactive AI Character ...

13/04/2026

Manifold Introduces AT300 Multiviewer Support at NAB 2026

Manifold Introduces AT300 Multiviewer Support at NAB 2026 Brie Clayton April 13, 2026 0 Comments and adds HDR-SDR conversion to the recently announced...

13/04/2026

RT Radio 1 unveils new audio identity

RT Radio 1 has today launched a significant step in its ongoing strategic evolution. Following the launch of its brand-new schedule late last year, RT Radio 1...

13/04/2026

The Late Late Show offers a once-in-a-lifetime prize to the winner of next week's Opening Act compet

The Late Late Show Opening Act, the search for Ireland's newest country musi...

13/04/2026

RT appoints new Chief Financial Officer

RT has today announced the appointment of Annemarie Britz to the position of Chief Financial Officer, RT following a public competition. Annemarie Britz is c...

12/04/2026

Areal unveil the SR1

Headphone system designed for immersive monitoring With the demand for immersive audio showing no signs of slowing down, lots of companies are turning their...

12/04/2026

Beeble expands AI production workflow ahead of NAB 2026 with background remover

Beeble expands AI production workflow ahead of NAB 2026 with background remover Brie Clayton April 11, 2026 0 Comments Ahead of its upcoming participa...

12/04/2026

Like and Transcribe

Like and Transcribe Mei Semones BM '22 blends languages and techniques to create her singular style. April 10, 2026 By Bryan Parys Mei Semones BM '...

12/04/2026

Cue the Change

Cue the Change Nicknamed the Converse Conductor, Jonathon Heyward BM '14 is making classical music more relatable. April 10, 2026 By Sarah Godcher Murp...

12/04/2026

Heat Wave

Heat Wave Inside Miamis sizzling, boundary-blurring Latin music scene. April 13, 2026 By Ricardo Herrera Bandrich Image by Stella Levi Down there: Thats ...

11/04/2026

Infrasonic launch Infrasonic Berlin

Engineer collective welcome Freddy Knop Infrasonic, an award-winning collective of audio engineers operating out of Nashville and Los Angeles with credits r...

11/04/2026

L3Harris' Red Wolf and SKY RAIDER II INTERNATIONAL Showcase Adaptability for Evolving Missions

Combining launched effects with a proven mission aircraft, Red Wolf and SKY RAI...

11/04/2026

Accelerating Production of National Security Space Assets with Additive Manufacturing

3D printed RL10 rocket engine combustion chambers shown in the manufacturing are...

11/04/2026

Sachtler Highlights Comprehensive Camera Support Solutions at NAB 2026

Sachtler Highlights Comprehensive Camera Support Solutions at NAB 2026 Brie Clayton April 11, 2026 0 Comments Sachtler showcases advanced camera suppo...

11/04/2026

Sohonet Launches Media Fabric: A Unified Managed Infrastructure Suite for Film, Television and Post-Production

Sohonet Launches Media Fabric: A Unified Managed Infrastructure Suite for Film, ...

11/04/2026

AJA Unveils BRIDGE LIVE IP with SMPTE ST 2110 I/O

AJA Unveils BRIDGE LIVE IP with SMPTE ST 2110 I/O Brie Clayton April 11, 2026 0 Comments New IP video solution streamlines modern productions, providi...

11/04/2026

InSync Unveils Advanced Video Processing and Frame Rate Conversion Solutions at NAB 2026

InSync Unveils Advanced Video Processing and Frame Rate Conversion Solutions at ...

11/04/2026

Amagi Launches Newspulse: An Agentic AI Platform That Autonomously Turns Live Newscasts into Multi-Format Digital Content

Amagi Launches Newspulse: An Agentic AI Platform That Autonomously Turns Live Ne...

11/04/2026

Federal Judge Extends Nexstar/Tegna TRO, Softens Some Provisions

Share Copy link Facebook X Linkedin Bluesky Email...

11/04/2026

Sling TV Launches $19.99 a Month Sling Essentials with ESPN

Share Copy link Facebook X Linkedin Bluesky Email...

11/04/2026

NAB Show Launches Content Creator VIP Program

Share Copy link Facebook X Linkedin Bluesky Email...

11/04/2026

FCC Announces Tentative Agenda for April Open Meeting

Share Copy link Facebook X Linkedin Bluesky Email...

11/04/2026

GARR and Cubbit launch the first geo-distributed storage...

Pilot phase begins for a new national infrastructure designed to safeguard academic and research data with full local data control, sovereignty, resilience, and...

11/04/2026

How to Stream Coachella 2026 at Home

How to Stream Coachella 2026 at Home Check this years stacked schedule for the annual music festivals full lineup, including when Berklee artists from Laufey ...

11/04/2026

Time Travel

Time Travel As Berklee on the Road programs in Puerto Rico and Italy mark decades-long anniversaries, we journey into the past and step into the future. Apri...

11/04/2026

April 10, 2026

Improving vaccine design for Ebola, HIV and more Scripps Research scientists and colleagues develop a nanodisc platform that offers a clearer view of how key vi...

10/04/2026

The Invisible OPEX Killer: Is Your Server Room Dragging You Down?

The Invisible OPEX Killer: Is Your Server Room Dragging You Down? In the broadcast world, we talk a lot about uptime. We talk about talent retention, latency...

10/04/2026

NAB 2026: Imagine Communications to Showcase Expanded Multiviewer Portfolio

Imagine Communications will showcase its multiviewer portfolio at NAB Show 2026 (April 19-22, Booth N1328, Las Vegas Convention Center), including Prismon and t...

10/04/2026

NAB 2026: Chyron Releases PRIME VSAR 2.3 with Updated Unreal Engine Integration

Chyron has released PRIME VSAR 2.3, an update to its virtual set and augmented reality solution for broadcast. The release adds compatibility with Unreal Engine...

10/04/2026

NAB 2026: Techex to Showcase New tx darwin Capabilities

Techex will exhibit at NAB Show 2026 (Booth W2267, April 19-23, Las Vegas Convention Center), demonstrating new tx darwin features including consumer multiview,...

10/04/2026

NAB 2026: NDI to Showcase Ecosystem and NDI 6.3

NDI will exhibit at NAB Show 2026, demonstrating its IP video ecosystem through live partner integrations, NDI 6.3 features, AI metadata workflows, and creator ...

10/04/2026

FOR-A Acquires Tamura Corporations Information Equipment Business

FOR-A has announced the acquisition of all shares of Tamu Radiance Corporation, a new company spun off from the Information Equipment Business of Tamura Corpora...

10/04/2026

NAB 2026: InSync Technology to Unveil New Video Processing and Frame Rate Conversion Products

InSync Technology will showcase new and updated video conversion products at NAB...