Finding a Balance as AI Advances
23/07/2024
The event was held under the Chatham House Rule so where someone is named, it is with their explicit permission.
Claus Grewenig, Chief Corporate Affairs Officer at RTL Deutschland co-hosted and shared the perspective of a large broadcasting and streaming company's as well as a news organisation's perspective around:
despite the pros of AI, the need for a robust (copyright) framework to protect and negotiate when content is used
the need for improvements in levelling the playing field and findability for value media
a focus on financial sustainability of the media sector (e.g. no ad restrictions)
Dan Nechita, Head of Cabinet for Dragos Tudorache, MEP with Renew Europe, spoke about how the European Parliament (EP) insisted on provisions for transparency regarding input data to increase our knowledge of how models are trained, about how AI labelling helps combat disinformation and electoral interference, and about the next steps in the AI Act implementation, for which the European Commission (EC), and in particular the AI Office, is in charge.
Kilian Gross, Head of Unit in the AI Office at the EC followed with outlining how the AI Office is a transversal organisation, not just a regulator and is trying to balance innovation and regulation while being inclusive, fast and conscious that actions need to be done with the global context in mind.
Ariane Bernard, a news industry and digital innovation leader who currently advises many News CEOs, spoke about the reality from the trenches where her current clients often express anxiety about the lack of clarity about where things are going which has led many news organisations to be slow or to fall back on a dependency on Big Tech so as not to fall foul of any interpretation of regulation.
Postive role for AI? Participants expressed a series of concerns about the AI world in terms of media sustainability, trust and disinformation as well as copyright concerns. There were many open questions about how regulation could or would play a positive force in the ecosystem overall.
It was acknowledged that AI tools could be positive and help freedom of expression and legitimate news organisations but this was tempered by concerns of how bad actors would use these tools and ignore any regulations. This led to a discussion about journalisms role in explaining AI to a wider audience, while things are moving so quickly - no easy task!
Sonja Schwetje of RTL Deutschland observed that while most media organisations have shown an immense effort catering to the preferences of younger audiences in terms of how and where to provide their content, there remains an ambiguity between balanced, impartial journalistic information and polarising, opinion-based content, with the latter being promoted much more via algorithms.
-- Play
-- --
Dialogue between all parties Some participants felt that the regulation system had failed news organisations by not protecting IP enough and worried that this would lead to a collapse of more news organisations which would then lead to undermining the AI models themselves. A point was made that much of news is based on so-called derivative content and thus based on the work of others, so news organisations have always done this and therefore need to acknowledge that first, before lecturing to tech companies.
The importance of dialogue between regulators, news organisations and tech companies was a recurring theme, especially as existing regulations may not be sufficient to address the challenges and speed of developments posed by AI. Is there a way to co-regulate holistically? Alexandru Giboi of The European Alliance of News Agencies made the point that more mutual understanding between tech & media companies could lead to better problem-solving in the future.
-- Play
-- --
There was a sidebar on the value of news: to society and also to tech companies. An observation was made that tech companies value news using the metric of revenue to them (which is de minimis) while news organisations judge their value in terms of societal value and importance to democracy. Thus, if the two sides are using different measures, they will never agree.
If news organisations believed they were so important to democracy, then they were challenged to try to speak with one voice to regulators as otherwise, their perspectives would not be understood nor factored in well enough. The difficulty is that there are multiple views on the multiple issues, including from within a single news organisation so getting to a singular would be very, very hard. But perhaps the potential existential challenge faced by the news ecosystem would drive different, more collaborative behaviour than in the past. And news organisations were also advised not to be slow, as it had been in the past.
In terms of solutions, a few were discussed, including:
Public education initiatives to raise awareness of AI and its potential pitfalls.
Investment in media literacy programs to help people critically evaluate information online.
Development of new economic models for the media industry that can thrive in the digital age.
Finding a balance between technological advancement, ethical considerations, and media viability will be crucial in the years to come in finding the right regulation to regulate AI and the news ecosystem.
Madhav Chinnappa Thomson Talks
Madhav Chinnappa, the former Director of News Ecosystem Development at Google and veteran news executive, leads our Thought Leadership events Thomson Talks.
Explore our projects across the globe
LINK: | http://www.thomsonfoundation.org/latest/finding-a-balance-as-ai-advanc... |
See more stories from thompsonfoundation |
More from Thomson
23/09/2024
Courageous journalism showcased as shortlist for Young Journalist Award 2024 announced
Reporting from a female journalist who is working in secret due to Taliban restr...
30/07/2024
Yara El Murr: A year on from winning the Young Journalist Award
We caught up with Yara El Murr, winner of the Young Journalist Award 2023, to find out how her life has changed since scooping the main prize for her investigat...
23/07/2024
Finding a Balance as AI Advances
Brussels was the location of our third Thomson Talks with Madhav Chinnappa held on 25 June 2024, focused on the specific subject of AI/News & Regulation. Four k...
03/07/2024
AI in Central European Newsrooms: Thomson s New Study Reveals Insights
AI's integration into journalism has sparked a mix of enthusiasm and scepticism across Central Europe, according to research led by Thomson Foundation in co...
01/07/2024
Entry Opens for Young Journalist of the Year 2024
This was such a confidence boost and so much motivation to keep pushing forward in my work and public service journalism. Yara El Murr from Lebanon recollecti...
21/06/2024
Competition to achieve trusted newsroom status as new campus is launched
A new platform dedicated to helping journalists win audience trust and tackle disinformation has been launched and with it a competition offering newsrooms (fro...
30/05/2024
Empowering Media Leaders: Transformative Insights from the Executive Learning Series
Navigating Strategy, Ethics, and Innovation in the evolving European media lands...
28/05/2024
AI and Disinformation in Taiwan's 2024 Election
This is a summary of the report commissioned by Thomson on AI Disinformation Attacks during Taiwans 2024 Presidential Elections, written by Professor Chen-ling ...
13/05/2024
Entry opens for EU Award for Investigative Journalism 2024
Journalists from the Western Balkans and T rkiye can now submit their investigative stories published in 2023 for the EU Award for Investigative Journalism 2024...
03/05/2024
Sudan: New WhatsApp Course Equips Journalists to Report on Conflict Related Sexual Violence
An innovative learning tool to help media and civil society better understand ho...
29/04/2024
She Speaks Sudan': Thomson launches programme to empower women journalists and civil society actors in exile
A groundbreaking initiative offering training and mentoring to 30 women journali...
23/04/2024
Tackling lies online: the answer may be all in the mind
Psychology can play an important role in helping us understand what audiences respond to (Dr Jon Roozenbeek, Cambridge Social Decision-Making Lab) For newsroo...
10/04/2024
AI and Regulation: Advocating for an Informed and Collaborative Approach
A regulator, a technologist and a politician walking into a conference room - the beginning of a very geeky joke - or more accurately, the start of the second T...
09/04/2024
AI and Disinformation in Taiwan s 2024 Election
This is a summary of the report commissioned by Thomson on AI Disinformation Attacks during Taiwans 2024 Presidential Elections, written by Professor Chen-ling ...
04/04/2024
Rethinking how we tackle disinformation in the age of AI
This fantastic course will help you understand and fight disinformation, an absolutely essential skill to acquire during this global election season. Sign up an...
02/04/2024
Transformative Technology in challenging media landscapes
Thomson's work in captive, closed and repressive media landscapes has long been about making sure we get the best possible idea of what people really need f...
28/03/2024
No votes for all
Out of an estimated 20,000 journalists in Pakistan, less than one thousand are women according to a recent Gender Disparity Report published by the Internationa...
15/03/2024
Connecting and training Sudanese journalists-in-exile
To help empower Sudanese journalists living in exile amidst the ongoing conflict in their homeland, Thomson trainers have been delivering workshops designed to ...
01/03/2024
Award winning young journalists get their mojo in London
MoJo is something I want to pursue further and include, not as a last thought, but as a one of the components of my daily work. Michelle Banda Vodacom Young Jou...
23/01/2024
Open Call: Executive Learning Programme For Media Professionals in the Western Balkans
A chance to apply for the new learning programme specifically designed for media...
16/01/2024
AI and Disinformation: why collaboration and culture change matter
This is a summary of the inaugural Thomson Talks with Madhav Chinnappa held on 30 November 2023 focused on the specific subject of AI/News & Disinformation. Th...
22/12/2023
Enhancing minority representation in run-up to Pakistan s elections
Pakistan is one of more than 65 countries where decisive elections will take place in 2024 in what will be the biggest election year in history. Thomson Media ...
19/12/2023
Rwanda: High-impact investigative journalism celebrates success
An innovative investigative training programme for Rwandan journalists has resulted in the publication of 15 impactful stories which have prompted widespread ch...
18/12/2023
Head of Development: New role for Thomson
As 2023 draws to a close, a new chapter begins for Thomson with the appointment of a new member of the team. Anton Artemyev joins us in January in a new role a...
24/11/2023
In the news - media insights for Young Journalist finalists
The three finalists for the Thomson Foundation Young Journalist of the Year 2023 enjoyed an action-packed trip to London which included meeting the Queen, visit...
21/11/2023
Yara El Murr wins Young Journalist Award 2023
Yara El Murr from Lebanon is Thomson Foundation's Young Journalist of the Year 2023. Yara received the honour at the Foreign Press Association Media Award...
17/11/2023
Yashraj Sharma: The 2022 YJA winner on a year of opportunity
Yashraj Sharma has seen big changes in his life since he won the Thomson Foundation Young Journalist Award in 2022. In the run up to the 2023 winner being anno...
10/11/2023
Paris Charter on AI and Journalism unveiled
Thomson Foundation has joined 16 partner organisations to launch the Paris Charter on AI and Journalism'. The first of its kind, the charter defines crucia...
01/11/2023
Zuha Siddiqui, Young Journalist Award finalist 2023
Zuha Siddiqui from Pakistan is a labour and tech reporting fellow for the global non-profit publication Rest of World. She's one of three finalists nominate...
01/11/2023
Jamaima Afridi, Young Journalist Award finalist 2023
Jamaima Afridi is a freelance journalist based in north-west Pakistan on the edge of the Khyber Pass. Her stories focus on injustices faced by women and vulne...
01/11/2023
Yara El Murr, Young Journalist Award finalist 2023
Yara El Murr is a 25-year-old journalist and documentary filmmaker from Lebanon. She is a finalist in Thomson Foundations Young Journalist Award 2023. The awar...
01/11/2023
Announcing the 2023 Young Journalist Award finalists
Young journalists from more than 60 countries entered this years prestigious Thomson Foundation Young Journalist Award 2023. Countries from across Africa, Asia...
26/10/2023
Investigative journalism exposes new scandals
The 2023 EU Award for Investigative Journalism has proven to be an exceptional showcase of talent, diversity and shifting journalistic priorities. More than 20...
16/10/2023
Thomson Foundation announces new trustees
Thomson Foundation is delighted to announce the appointment of two new members to its Board of Trustees - investment expert, author and former financial journal...
12/10/2023
Unique training courses to help create the definitive account of the Ukraine War
Some of the world's leading foreign correspondents and war crimes investigators have contributed to a set of major new training courses for journalists cove...
05/10/2023
Thomson joins Partnership on AI
Thomson Foundation is delighted to be one of five new organisations to join Partnership on AI. Thomson is now one of 114 partner organisations from around the ...
28/09/2023
Shortlist for Young Journalist Award 2023 revealed
An astonishing array of talented journalists from around the world have made it through to the shortlist for the Thomson Foundation Young Journalist Award 2023....
18/09/2023
Thomson Talks: Former Google director to lead Thomson Foundation Thought Leadership events.
Madhav Chinnappa, the former Director of News Ecosystem Development at Google an...
14/09/2023
Strengthening the media s role in promoting democracy
Thomson works with journalists in some of the toughest places in the world. Their work and livelihoods are frequently under threat. Thomson Foundation believes ...
05/09/2023
Disarming disinformation: piloting new proof technology
A pioneering system aimed at preventing the spread of disinformation and creating verifiable content from capture to publication is being road tested in a serie...
15/08/2023
Connect 6: The magic of mentoring
To mark the Thomson Foundation's 60th year of nurturing and training journalists globally, we matched six talented young journalists with six of the best in...
07/08/2023
Backing brave journalism in challenging places long-term
In the autumn of 2022, I was introduced to a young Afghan journalist in London. Zahra Joya had fled Kabul a year before as the Taliban swept through the city. A...
27/07/2023
Award winning inspiration from young journalists
Pursuing independent journalism is more important than ever. Right now, we are not just facing one or two crises. The crises that journalists are facing are not...
05/07/2023
From trainee to trainer: The man who brought Mojo to Sri Lanka
KC Saranga has trained more than 1,000 journalists, students and people in marginalised communities in Sri Lanka on how to tell stories using their mobile phone...
04/07/2023
Top quality entries for EU Investigative Journalism Award
A total of 267 applications from 7 countries, representing 125 media outlets and featuring a diverse group of authors (both individuals and groups), have been s...
03/07/2023
Young Journalist Award 2023 is open for entries
Since 2013 our Young Journalist Award has celebrated the outstanding young talent in the media profession. The award is an opportunity for those brilliant young...
28/06/2023
Transforming cultural journalism in the Western Balkans
A new project is underway in the Western Balkans to transform digital storytelling and engage public audiences with creative and culture-related content. Aroun...
19/06/2023
Reaching the million+ Ukrainian refugees in Germany
Staying informed about everyday life and events in Ukraine is crucially important for the refugees who have fled the war. By April 2023, 1.06 million Ukrai...
14/06/2023
Rwandan journalists awarded funds to support investigations
Equipped with new investigative journalism skills and financial support after recently completing a training programme, 15 Rwandan journalists are empowered to ...
22/05/2023
Unveiling a seminal course on AI ethics in the newsroom
The Thomson Foundation is proud to unveil a pioneering free, online training course designed to help newsrooms address a defining issue of the modern age: the e...