Question: Did George Lucas rip off Dune?
18/03/2024
by The South African
18-03-2024 15:35
in Entertainment
Miles Phillips explores Dune's Legacy and its echo in Star Wars, claiming that the former is among the best science fiction films he's seen. Image: Flickr Wikimedia Commons
Miles Phillips explores the sands of influence : Dune's Legacy and its echo in Star Wars claiming that the former is one of the best of science fiction films he's seen in a long time.
--
The words epic probably fall slightly short as watching it on the big screen really immerses you in the sandy world of giant worms and breathing tubes!
This new film, Dune: Part Two, is the latest big-screen extract from Frank Herbert's Dune.
First published in 1965, this seminal novel not only established a benchmark for the genre but also sowed the seeds of inspiration for countless narratives to follow.
--
Among these, George Lucas's Star Wars saga is often cited as drawing considerable influence from Herbert's desert world of Arrakis.
As Dune once again captures the imagination of audiences with its 2020 film adaptation, divided into two epic parts, it did make me think all too often that I was watching a rip off of Star Wars.
But on looking it up, Dune was published 10 year prior to Star Wars, so did George step into the darkside and copy Dune?
--
From Novel to Film Epic: The Journey of Dune Before diving into the parallels between Dune and Star Wars, it's essential to acknowledge Dune's journey from a novel to a cinematic epic. Frank Herbert's Dune is not just a story; it's an intricate universe detailed with complex social, political, and ecological themes. It's a tale of power, prophecy, and survival set against the backdrop of a desert planet whose sole valuable resource, the spice Melange, is the linchpin of interstellar travel and power dynamics.
The novel's richness and depth made it a challenging prospect for adaptation, yet it has seen several iterations, including David Lynch's 1984 film and a miniseries in 2000. However, it wasn't until 2020 that Dune found a new life in the hands of director Denis Villeneuve. His adaptation, planned in two parts to do justice to the novel's breadth, has been praised for its visual grandeur and faithful rendition of the source material.
Let's break it down and look at the major similarities, and you can make your own minds up.
Dune and Star Wars: A Desert of Similarities The comparisons between Dune and Star Wars are manifold and intriguing. Both narratives unfold in vast, interstellar settings and revolve around young protagonists destined for greatness, embroiled in the larger conflict of good versus evil. However, the similarities extend beyond these broad strokes into more specific parallels.
The Battle of Good vs. Evil At their core, both Dune and Star Wars explore the eternal conflict between good and evil. In Dune, Paul Atreides battles against the corrupt forces that seek to control the spice production on Arrakis. In Star Wars, Luke Skywalker rises against the tyranny of the Empire. Both protagonists are driven by a sense of destiny and a need to restore balance and justice.
The Force vs. The Voice The concept of a mystical power that can be harnessed by a select few is central to both universes. In Star Wars, the Force is an energy field created by all living things, used by the Jedi and the Sith to perform feats beyond the bounds of physical possibility. Dune presents a similar concept through the Voice, a power that allows its users to control others through tone and command. The Bene Gesserit, a secretive sisterhood to which Paul's mother belongs, are masters of this technique.
Spice and the Economy of Power Spice Melange, the most precious resource in the Dune universe, is crucial for space travel, extending life, and enhancing mental abilities. It draws a parallel to the importance of resources in Star Wars, albeit less directly. The struggle for control over resources, whether it's spice in Dune or planets and systems in Star Wars, underscores the economic underpinnings of power in both narratives.
But we have seen Spice feature more prominently in the spin-off series of Boba Fett and the Mandalorian.
The Desert as Character Arrakis, or Dune, is a desert planet whose harsh environment shapes its inhabitants and the story's dynamics. Similarly, Star Wars introduces us to Tatooine, Luke Skywalker's home planet, also a desert world with its own sand people, the Tusken Raiders. These desert settings are not mere backdrops but active elements that influence the plot and character development.
Echoes and Inspirations: The Debate Given these similarities, the question arises: did George Lucas rip off Dune to create Star Wars? While it's clear that Star Wars shares thematic and narrative elements with Dune, it's also evident that Lucas drew inspiration from a wide array of sources, including mythology, samurai films, and Flash Gordon serials. Rather than viewing Star Wars as a derivative work, it can be seen as part of a dialogue among science fiction and fantasy narratives, each borrowing, adapting, and reimagining elements from its predecessors to create something new and unique.
Concluding thoughts The second part of Dune, is a real feast for the eyes and ears. Watching it on the big screen is a must. I know that part two was the concluding part, but for me, it's only just starting, and I hear rumours that Denis Villeneuve has started writing, so watch this space for part 3.
Miles Phillips runs Miles Marketing, an international marketing agency focusing on marketing strategy and delivering sensible
LINK: | https://www.thesouthafrican.com/culture/entertainment/question-did-geo... |
See more stories from thesouthafrican |
Africa Stories
26/04/2024
Tonight on House of Zwide: Faith learns disturbing truths about Zola from his mom
Tonight on House of Zwide: Faith learns disturbing truths about Zola from his mo...
26/04/2024
Skeem Saam' May Spoiler: Has Lehasa killed Khwezi?
Skeem Saam' May Spoiler: Has Lehasa killed Khwezi?The Skeem Saam' May teasers mention Lehasa being apologetic about killing someone. Is it his baby mam...
26/04/2024
Skeem Saam: Thursday's episode, 25 April 2024 [video]
Skeem Saam: Thursday's episode, 25 April 2024 [video]Missed an episode of Skeem Saam? No problem! Watch the latest episode of your favourite South African s...
26/04/2024
Prison Journalism: Some issues to consider
Prison Journalism: Some issues to considerWesley Leong was incarcerated at the age of 15 in 1996 at Pollsmoor Prison. He is currently part of Restore's rese...
26/04/2024
Tonight on Scandal: A line is crossed and a mother starts to lose focus
Tonight on Scandal: A line is crossed and a mother starts to lose focusDon't miss Friday, 26 April's riveting episode of South African soapie Scandal! o...
25/04/2024
Tonight on Scandal: Dintle makes a hair-raising decision
Tonight on Scandal: Dintle makes a hair-raising decisionDon't miss Thursday, 25 April's riveting episode of South African soapie Scandal! on e.tv on DSt...
25/04/2024
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: Caesar comes looking for Thandiswa at Nomeva's and promises to be there for Leroy
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: Caesar comes looking for Thandiswa at Nomeva's...
25/04/2024
Tonight on House of Zwide: A furious Bra Zakes unleashes his anger on Sphamandla
Tonight on House of Zwide: A furious Bra Zakes unleashes his anger on SphamandlaDon't miss Thursday, 25 April's riveting episode of South African soapie...
25/04/2024
Prison Journalism: Understanding recidivism in South African prisons
Prison Journalism: Understanding recidivism in South African prisonsDean Mashimbwe, a Zimbabwean migrant residing in Cape Town, was incarcerated at Pollsmoor Co...
25/04/2024
Prison Journalism: A glimpse inside Barberton Prison
Prison Journalism: A glimpse inside Barberton PrisonJean-Pierre Le-Roux is a divorced father of two beautiful children. He was incarcerated for 20 months for po...
25/04/2024
Riverside Studios presents world premiere of MOFFIE' stage play
Riverside Studios presents world premiere of MOFFIE' stage play MOFFIE delves into toxic masculinity and trauma in post-apartheid South Africa, reflecting...
25/04/2024
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Kobus assigns Pretty a big case
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Kobus assigns Pretty a big caseDon't miss Thuresday, 25 April's riveting episode of South African soapie Skeem Saam on SABC 1 on ...
24/04/2024
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Someone makes the call to have Lehasa killed
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Someone makes the call to have Lehasa killedDon't miss Wednesday, 24 April's riveting episode of South African soapie Skeem Saam ...
24/04/2024
Tonight on House of Zwide: Sphamandla and his goons force Keletso into their car at gunpoint
Tonight on House of Zwide: Sphamandla and his goons force Keletso into their car...
24/04/2024
Tonight on Scandal: A man smiles in the face of his friend while he deceives him
Tonight on Scandal: A man smiles in the face of his friend while he deceives himDon't miss Wednesday, 24 April's riveting episode of South African soapi...
24/04/2024
Endearing character from The Simpsons' is killed off' after 35 years, fans in shock
Endearing character from The Simpsons' is killed off' after 35 years, ...
24/04/2024
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: Caesar continues to ask questions about Thandiswa
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: Caesar continues to ask questions about ThandiswaDon't miss Wednesday, 24 April's riveting episode of South African soapie...
24/04/2024
Skeem Saam: Tuesday's episode, 23 April 2024 [video]
Skeem Saam: Tuesday's episode, 23 April 2024 [video]Missed an episode of Skeem Saam? No problem! Watch the latest episode of your favourite South African so...
24/04/2024
Endearing Simpsons character killed off' after 35 years, fans in shock
Endearing Simpsons character killed off' after 35 years, fans in shockAn often-seen yet seldom-discussed character from the popular show The Simpsons drops...
23/04/2024
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Pretty is shocked by what she finds out about Lehasa
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Pretty is shocked by what she finds out about LehasaDon't miss Tuesday, 23 April's riveting episode of South African soapie Skeem...
23/04/2024
Tonight on House of Zwide: Bra Zakes asks Isaac to hold off going to the cops until he's spoken to Sphamandla
Tonight on House of Zwide: Bra Zakes asks Isaac to hold off going to the cops un...
23/04/2024
Skeem Saam: Monday's episode, 22 April 2024 [video]
Skeem Saam: Monday's episode, 22 April 2024 [video]Missed an episode of Skeem Saam? No problem! Watch the latest episode of your favourite South African soa...
23/04/2024
Skeem Saam' May Spoiler: Inside Mr Kgomo, Eunice's romance?
Skeem Saam' May Spoiler: Inside Mr Kgomo, Eunice's romance? Skeem Saam' May teasers reveal that Melita will be jealous of Mr Kgomo and Eunice's ...
23/04/2024
Tonight on Scandal: Dintle takes a huge risk on her quest to save her daughter
Tonight on Scandal: Dintle takes a huge risk on her quest to save her daughterDon't miss Tuesday, 23 April's riveting episode of South African soapie Sc...
22/04/2024
WATCH: Artists covering their favourite classics
WATCH: Artists covering their favourite classicsArtists often watch other performers to get some of their inspiration. Check out some of these classic famous so...
22/04/2024
WATCH: Queen of hip-hop Lil2Hood thanks Paris
WATCH: Queen of hip-hop Lil2Hood thanks ParisProducer and DJ Lil2Hood (Flash.Wrldwide) has proved that she's a queen of modern hip-hop. Lil2Hood thanked Par...
22/04/2024
Tonight on House of Zwide: Funani informs Isaac about Nkosi seeing his hijacker in Tembisa
Tonight on House of Zwide: Funani informs Isaac about Nkosi seeing his hijacker ...
22/04/2024
Tonight on Scandal: The carpet is pulled out from under Nhlamulo
Tonight on Scandal: The carpet is pulled out from under NhlamuloDon't miss Monday, 22 April's riveting episode of South African soapie Scandal! on e.tv ...
22/04/2024
LGBTQ+ writers asked to submit their stories
LGBTQ writers asked to submit their storiesWriters have been asked to submit their short stories (up to 20, 000 words) for an upcoming anthology called Just LG...
22/04/2024
[Watch] Queen of hip-hop Lil2Hood thanks Paris
[Watch] Queen of hip-hop Lil2Hood thanks ParisProducer and DJ Lil2Hood (Flash.Wrldwide) has proved that she's a queen of modern hip-hop. Lil2Hood thanked Pa...
22/04/2024
Isaac Mutant: HemelBesem gave me R2, 500'
Isaac Mutant: HemelBesem gave me R2, 500'Cape town rapper Isaac Mutant claims he was paid less than everyone else's fee for the use of his music in Sho...
22/04/2024
Afrikaans (free) television shows you can STILL watch
Afrikaans (free) television shows you can STILL watchAfrikaans television shows are making a comeback through AfriForumTV. However, not everyone wants to see sh...
22/04/2024
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: Virginia learns Sonto and Sakhile slept together
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: Virginia learns Sonto and Sakhile slept togetherDon't miss Monday, 22 April's riveting episode of South African soapie Smo...
22/04/2024
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Kgosi reveals the details of what he witnessed Lehasa doing
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Kgosi reveals the details of what he witnessed Lehasa doi...
21/04/2024
Gqeberha: The Empire' loses more viewers on DStv
Gqeberha: The Empire' loses more viewers on DStvTshedza Pictures' isiXhosa telenovela Gqeberha: The Empire' lost more viewers in March and was plac...
21/04/2024
Youngins' fans praise actor Thabiso Ramotshela as Mahlatse
Youngins' fans praise actor Thabiso Ramotshela as MahlatseSouth Africans praise former The River' actor Thabiso Ramotshela, who plays Mahlatse in Showm...
20/04/2024
Skeem Saam: Friday's episode, 19 April 2024 [video]
Skeem Saam: Friday's episode, 19 April 2024 [video]Missed an episode of Skeem Saam? No problem! Watch the latest episode of your favourite South African soa...
19/04/2024
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: Thandiswa panics when she learns of possible evidence in Mthetho's office
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: Thandiswa panics when she learns of possible evide...
19/04/2024
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Khwezi stares death in the face
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Khwezi stares death in the faceDon't miss Friday, 19 April's riveting episode of South African soapie Skeem Saam on SABC 1 on DSt...
19/04/2024
Tonight on House of Zwide: Faith refuses to talk to Zola and to discuss the matter with Zanele further
Tonight on House of Zwide: Faith refuses to talk to Zola and to discuss the matt...
19/04/2024
Skeem Saam: Thursday's episode, 18 April 2024 [video]
Skeem Saam: Thursday's episode, 18 April 2024 [video]Missed an episode of Skeem Saam? No problem! Watch the latest episode of your favourite South African s...
19/04/2024
Prison Journalism: Tragic story of Jerry's life and crimes
Prison Journalism: Tragic story of Jerry's life and crimesDavid van Nek was incarcerated in Pollsmoor Prison from 2013 until 2015 and participated in the re...
19/04/2024
House of Zwide' Spoiler: Soka dates Mampho and Ona
House of Zwide' Spoiler: Soka dates Mampho and OnaThe House of Zwide' May teasers reveal that Soka will date both Ona and Mampho and get caught. Will h...
19/04/2024
Beer: Seven celebrities talk about their love
Beer: Seven celebrities talk about their loveBeer is one of the world's most popular beverages. We asked several celebrities about their favourite brews or ...
19/04/2024
Tonight on Scandal: Tlhogi cannot believe what she hears from Taps
Tonight on Scandal: Tlhogi cannot believe what she hears from TapsDon't miss Friday, 19 April's riveting episode of South African soapie Scandal! on e.t...
18/04/2024
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: Caesar almost finds Thandiswa with the bloody wedding dress
Tonight on Smoke and Mirrors: Caesar almost finds Thandiswa with the bloody wedd...
18/04/2024
Taylor Swift's The Tortured Poets Department' set to drop on FRIDAY
Taylor Swift's The Tortured Poets Department' set to drop on FRIDAYTaylor Swift will release her highly anticipated record The Tortured Poets Departme...
18/04/2024
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Lehasa puts his plan to eliminate Khwezi in motion
Tonight on Skeem Saam: Lehasa puts his plan to eliminate Khwezi in motionDon't miss Thursday, 18 April's riveting episode of South African soapie Skeem ...
18/04/2024
Prison Journalism: April's experiences of black boudoir
Prison Journalism: April's experiences of black boudoirThabo Mthembu was incarcerated in Pollsmoor Prison from 2014 to 2019. Read Thabo's story by Tha...
18/04/2024
Prison Journalism: Can gangsterism and violence be reduced in prison?
Prison Journalism: Can gangsterism and violence be reduced in prison?Dean Mashimbwe, a Zimbabwean migrant residing in Cape Town, was incarcerated at Pollsmoor C...