Recent updates to the HTTP Live Streaming (HLS) standard have made new ways of standard-compliant low-latency streaming possible. But how low can the latency be, by how much do different low-latency flavours of HLS differ and what will the future of HLS bring in terms of delay? NativeWaves Andreas Unterweger and Bartosz Ziemski investigate
By Contributor
Published: April 22, 2021
Recent updates to the HTTP Live Streaming (HLS) standard have made new ways of standard-compliant low-latency streaming possible. But how low can the latency be, by how much do different low-latency flavours of HLS differ and what will the future of HLS bring in terms of delay? NativeWaves' Andreas Unterweger and Bartosz Ziemski investigate
target=_blank title=Share on LinkedIn class=share-linkedin>
Live streaming over the internet is an increasingly popular supplement to traditional broadcasting. With ever increasing demands regarding fast and scalable streaming, the widely adopted HTTP Live Streaming (HLS) standard has undergone recent (draft) revisions to enable lower end-to-end latencies. This version of the standard is commonly referred to as Apple Low-Latency HLS (LLHLS). It is different from previous efforts to supplement the old HLS standard with low-latency capabilities, commonly referred to as Community Low-Latency HLS (LHLS).
Simply put, Community LHLS advertises the most recent (edge) media segment to the receiver while it is still being produced, whereas Apple LLHLS advertises only those portions of it which are already available. Both approaches have their own upsides and downsides. Most prominently, Community LHLS breaks Adaptive Bit Rate (ABR) streaming due to chunked transfer and is already phased out in most implementations in favor of Apple LLHLS. The latter, however, makes caching through Content Delivery Network (CDNs) very hard due to very frequent and potentially client-dependent playlist updates.
While the choice of HLS flavour seems to boil down to the technical, logistical and practical pros and cons, it does not appear to be a question of delay - low latency is low latency after all, or is it not? Perhaps surprisingly, the practical delay bounds for each HLS flavour are not the same and their relative impact on end-to-end delay is larger than one might think. Let us investigate.
End-to-end delay comprises of many different factors, only some of which the sender (operating the live streaming source) can influence directly. Even the most creative engineers have very limited means against, for example, the transmission delay itself - the speed of light is quite a tough barrier to break in our Universe. However, accepting the physical limits of our Universe and thus our global network connections as they come, the remaining delay that can be influenced directly is worth analysing.
To explore the limits of HLS in terms of (influenceable) delay, engineers at NativeWaves set up a streaming server, a distribution (caching) server and a client (player) in a local network. The setup depicted in the image below is based on typical real-world setups for live events: The server captures a known Serial Digital Interface (SDI) input signal with a capture card, encodes it in hardware (on a Graphics Processing Unit (GPU)) and sends the encoded data via HLS directly to a distribution server which streams it to the client. Standard software (including FFmpeg with nvenc support) and typical settings (e.g., six seconds segment size) are used to make the results representative and as close as possible to practice.
data-src=https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/1-726x143.png alt= width=726 height=143 data-srcset=https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/1-726x143.png 726w, https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/1-353x69.png 353w, https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/1-768x151.png 768w, https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/1-1536x302.png 1536w, https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/1-2048x403.png 2048w data-sizes=(max-width: 726px) 100vw, 726px />Setup used for testing consisting of a streaming server, a distribution server and a clientThe end-to-end delay is measured - from the time of capture at the streaming server to the earliest possible playback time at the client in the same local network. The measurements are analysed statistically, but instead of reporting the mean or median delay values, the 95th percentiles are presented. Reasoning about the worst-case delay that 95 per cent of users encounter portrays practical latency experiences much more accurately than focusing only on the better half of experiences.
data-src=https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/2.png alt= width=198 height=148 data-srcset=https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/2.png 554w, https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/2-353x263.png 353w, https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/2-160x120.png 160w data-sizes=(max-width: 198px) 100vw, 198px />Comparison of delay between classical HLS, Apple LLHLS and Community LHLS with a segment size of 6 sSo, what do the results look like? The image on the right shows a comparison of the measured delay values for classical (non-low-latency) HLS (left), Apple LLHLS (middle) and Community LHLS (right). As expected, classical HLS produces orders of magnitude higher delay than the two low-latency flavours. The latter are nearly indistinguishable at this scale, but their differences will be broken down in more detail later. First, let us find out what causes the big difference between classical HLS and the two low-latency flavours.
data-src=https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/3.png alt= width=253 height=189 data-srcset=https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/3.png 554w, https://www.tvbeurope.com/wp-content/upl
Europe Stories
05/01/2027
Worlds first 802.15.4ab-UWB chip verified by Calterah and Rohde & Schwarz to be ...
06/09/2026
June 9 2026, 23:00 (PDT) Dolby and MagentaTV Bring Fans Closer to the FIFA Worl...
04/08/2026
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, t...
04/07/2026
April 7 2026, 19:00 (PDT) Detective Conan: Fallen Angel of the Highway Opens in...
10/06/2026
Get Hands-On with Interfaces & Mic Preamp Brands
If youre after a new interface or preamp, then GearExpo UK is the place to be! Well have a whole host of au...
10/06/2026
November 13-14 2026, The Midway, San Francisco
Following their recent rebranding, MONO Music Conference (formerly Music Expo) have officially announced thei...
10/06/2026
Debut instrument free for limited time
deFORM is the debut release from newly founded developer ebbandflow, and it's being offered as a free download fo...
10/06/2026
Rohde & Schwarz and TRUMPF advance laser-based drone defense with THORIS LCS Rohde & Schwarz is showcasing THORIS at ILA 2026: A sovereign, end to end counter...
10/06/2026
MAHLE and Rohde & Schwarz develop application for sensor testing of modern drive...
10/06/2026
10 Jun 2026
VEON's Banglalink Brings Every World Cup 2026 Match to Football...
10/06/2026
Wednesday 10 June 2026
How to watch every ICC Women's T20 World Cup 2026 match live on Sky Sports
Where is the ICC Women's T20 World Cup 2026 availabl...
10/06/2026
Wednesday 10 June 2026
P RLA brings first-ever Beautifully Clean Oral Care'...
10/06/2026
Wednesday 10 June 2026
Sky reveals pulse-pounding first teaser trailer for upco...
10/06/2026
Wuppertal June 10, 2026
Riedel Artist at the Heart of the 14th World Live Neurovascular ConferenceAt the 14th World Live Neurovascular Conference (WLNC) in Li...
09/06/2026
Last month, Spotify hosted PURE FLOWERS LIVE, a special event celebrating the re...
09/06/2026
Last month, RADAR U.K. artist Skye Newman took the stage in East London for a sp...
09/06/2026
Company to cease operating on 30 June 2026
Australian loudspeaker and amplifier manufacturer Wayne Jones Audio have announced that after much consideration,...
09/06/2026
Increases low-end weight and character
The latest plug-in release from Sheffield-based fedDSP aims to offer an all-in-one solution for users in search of mo...
09/06/2026
Introduces AI Studio Assistant, Moises Studio integration & more
Fender Studio have just announced the launch a significant update that brings an array of n...
09/06/2026
The BBC has found its Hercule Poirot.
After Deadline revealed last month that t...
09/06/2026
Filming to take place in Holmfirth
9th June 2026, London: U&GOLD is heading bac...
09/06/2026
X-Rite Pantone Launches Offset360 to Modernize Color Control Across Existing Pre...
09/06/2026
09 Jun 2026
VEON Appoints Serkan Ozturk as Chief of Staff & Strategy Officer Dubai and New York, June 9, 2026 - VEON Ltd. (NASDAQ: VEON), a global digital oper...
09/06/2026
Tuesday 9 June 2026
Katie Price: Nothing to Hide, a candid and unfiltered accou...
09/06/2026
Enni Continues to Rely on Arvato Systems - And Will Be Using AEP.EnerS4 Billing Solution
Arvato Systems to implement transformation project for SAP S/4HANA Ut...
09/06/2026
These special programmes will highlight RT 's connection with the Irish diaspora
This year, RT is marking 100 years of public broadcasting in Ireland with...
08/06/2026
At Spotify, our commitment to the LGBTQIA community is year-round. Through GLOW, our global music program, we celebrate and amplify the contributions of queer ...
08/06/2026
Get Hands-on With Keyboard & Synth Brands
GearExpo UK wouldn't be complete without some synth action, and we've got some of the industry's most ...
08/06/2026
50 popular in-ear monitoring system profiles added
The latest update for IK Multimedia's headphone-correction system has just arrived, and introduces ca...
08/06/2026
Manny Marroquin signature cans upgraded with SLAM Technology
The flagship model in Audeze's Manny Marroquin Signature Series has just been treated to an...
08/06/2026
Air domain supremacy redefined - New counter UAS, space solutions and directiona...
08/06/2026
he BBC and BritBox have announced that Edward Bluemel (We Might Regret This, My ...
08/06/2026
Plus, 20% off TVs ahead of kick-offMonday 8 June 2026
Sky introduces Real Time...
08/06/2026
FOX Secures Live NFL Game Package in Mexico Starting in Fall 2026 Agreement Features Thursday Night Football, Sunday Games Package, Thanksgiving Day Games, al...
08/06/2026
FOX One, FOX Sports and Indeed Name Austin Franklin and Kevin Akoto as FOX One C...
08/06/2026
Meet us on the show floor
Stand #286310 Discover Nara, the media management tool used by major facilities including Harbor and Molinare.
Nara v2 introduces re...
08/06/2026
L'art de l'Image dans Reflet dans un diamant mort' Une conversation avec le directeur de la photographie Manuel Dacosse, SBC et l' talonneur Pe...
08/06/2026
Embracing today's modern media workflows: FilmLight presents Nara 2.0, with FilmLight API Designed to support the growing demands of today's production ...
08/06/2026
Moderated by Andy Minuth, FilmLight's Colour Workflow Specialist
Wednesday 18 February
6:00pm / Doors open
7:00pm / Presentation in German
8:00pm / Drin...
08/06/2026
Join us on April 14 at 10:00am for a technical roundtable with the Filmlight dev...
08/06/2026
You're invited to FLAPI Classroom The fundamentals of coding and machine-assisted development
These sessions will help you build the skills needed to cre...
08/06/2026
With Sylvain Canaux (St Louis, Paris) and J r me Cloutier (MELS, Montreal)
Wednesday 6 May
Pick your time: 1:00PM / 5:00PM
Note: The presentation will be hel...
08/06/2026
FilmLight, 1107 N El Centro Ave, Los Angeles
Doors open at 3:30pm
Join the FilmLight team on June 9th at 4pm to learn how FilmLight products and APIs can stre...
08/06/2026
The Creators List launched to Help Brands Connect With Top Creators In CannesThe curated directory launched by Tubefilter, Comscore, Whalar Group and Gospel Sta...
08/06/2026
Irish YouTube star DavidMC joins Aisling O'Reilly to tackle all things socce...
07/06/2026
Company introduce 21 new protective covers
Decksaver have just announced their Sping 2026 Drop, which sees a total of 21 new models added to their ever-grow...
07/06/2026
Sunday 7 June 2026
Dynamo Vs Houdini comes to Sky later this year
The last time the world saw Dynamo, he buried himself alive. This weekend, he returned.
Mom...
06/06/2026
Check Out Leading Monitor Brands
We'll have monitors of all shapes and sizes at GearExpo UK, so whether you're looking to upgrade or expand your set...
Recent updates to the HTTP Live Streaming (HLS) standard have made new ways of standard-compliant low-latency streaming possible. But how low can the latency be, by how much do different low-latency flavours of HLS differ and what will the future of HLS bring in terms of delay? NativeWaves Andreas Unterweger and Bartosz Ziemski investigate
