
FilmOn X Says Broadcasters Likely To Lose Copyright Battle Online video company FilmOn X is arguing that it should be allowed to continue operating while a lawsuit against the company is pending in federal court in Washington, D.C.
The startup is asking U.S. District Court Judge Rosemary Collyer to reject a request by TV broadcasters to prohibit the service from operating. FilmOn says in its court papers, filed on Thursday, that the broadcasters cant show that they are likely to succeed on the merits -- which is necesary in order to obtain an injunction before there has been a trial.
FilmOn X, formerly called Aereokiller, filed the papers in response to a lawsuit brought in May by a coalition of broadcasters. FilmOn, like rival company Aereo, allows users to stream over-the-air TV to iPhones and other devices. Subscribers also are able to use the service like a DVR by recording programs for later viewing.
Both startups are facing several legal challenges from broadcasters; they argue that the companies are transmitting copyrighted material without a license. So far, Aereo has prevailed in federal court in New York, where the company defeated the TV networks request for an injunction, but the broadcasters won a preliminary round in California. FilmOn has appealed that order to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, which is considering the matter.
The legal arguments in all of the lawsuits are virtually identical. The broadcasters argue that the companies shouldnt be able to give public performances of copyrighted material without paying retransmission fees.
But FilmOn X and Aereo say their services are legal on the ground that they only provide the technology that enables consumers to engage in legal activity -- watching and recording free over-the-air TV. Both companies rely on thousands of dime-size antennas to capture the TV broadcasts, then stream shows to users on an antenna-to-subscriber basis.
FilmOn and Aereo argue that anyone is allowed to install an antenna to view over-the-air TV, and that the one-to-one nature of the streams means they are not public performances.
FilmOn X's technology only enables transmission to individual users at their direction, which constitutes private (not public) performance, the company argues in its most recent papers. Through FilmOn X's technology, a user may remotely record and privately view television programming the user indisputably has the right to record and view.
Both Aereo and FilmOn X say that a 2008 court decision out of New York involving remote DVRs supports their argument. In that case, the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Cablevisions remote DVRs dont infringe copyright. The appellate court specifically rejected an argument that Cablevisions act of sending shows from its servers to users TV sets was a public performance. That decision paved the way for Aereos victory in New York, but judges in other jurisdictions need not follow it.
Most recent headlines
10/02/2025
With more than 1.6 million Valentine's Day playlists created globally on Spo...
10/02/2025
New series Memory Bites with Matt Moran stirs up nostalgia with a taste of the p...
10/02/2025
MELBOURNE, Fla., Feb. 10, 2025 - L3Harris Technologies (NYSE: LHX) has introduced AMORPHOUS , its new software that features a single user interface to operate ...
10/02/2025
NEW YORK and MEXICO CITY Spanish-language media conglomerate TV Azteca has inked a two-year deal with WSC Sports for the AI-powered sports content technology pr...
10/02/2025
TORONTO Jordan Bartow, a 15-plus-year industry veteran with a history of driving artificial intelligence, media and enterprise cloud transformations, has joined...
10/02/2025
LA Wildfire Victims Fundraiser - Entertainment Industry
Erik Smalls February 10, 2025
0 Comments
Join us for an exclusive networking event designed fo...
10/02/2025
OWC and ARCHIWARE Partner to Deliver Seamless Shared Storage, Cloning, Backup, a...
10/02/2025
Berklee's Signature Series Celebrates the Music of Fleetwood Mac The concert will feature a global cast of over 90 students performing a career-spanning s...
10/02/2025
Adam Downey, director of post production at Sky, tells TVBEurope how seeing a harmonious team working to deliver a project is like watching a ballet
By Matthew...
10/02/2025
The association aims to support the media technology industry by identifying vulnerabilities in media systems and solutions
By Jenny Priestley
Published: Feb...
10/02/2025
A Dusseldorf court ruling on a patent dispute warned the company could face heavy fines
By Matthew Corrigan
Published: February 10, 2025
A Dusseldorf cour...
10/02/2025
The teams at Mikros Animation extend its heartfelt congratulations to DreamWorks...
10/02/2025
Super Bowl LIX: Tubi Leads All Streaming Platforms in Least Lag Time, According ...
10/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: Sports Broadcasting Hall of Fame Camera Operator Don C...
10/02/2025
Official trailer released for upcoming Sky Documentaries series David Frost VsComing to Sky and NOW on 23rd FebruaryMonday 10 February 2025
To view this conten...
10/02/2025
SPEAG combines CMX500 OBT with the DASY8-3D system for automated SAR testing of ...
10/02/2025
Back to All News
Netflix ISP Speed Index for January 2025
Mulitcolor streaks on a black background curved right to foreground with the Netflix logo N at the t...
10/02/2025
Back to All News
Dive into the 1960s and 80s Korean Music Scene with Upcoming S...
10/02/2025
John Nallen Named President and Chief Operating Officer of Fox Corporation in Ne...
10/02/2025
Fox Corporation Acquires Red Seat Ventures Los Angeles, CA - February 10, 2025 - Fox Corporation ( FOX or the Company ) (Nasdaq: FOXA, FOX) today announced ...
10/02/2025
Article courtesy of Digital Media World
Read the article
Ross Baker, senior colourist and head of grading at Molinare in London, talks about building his care...
10/02/2025
Article courtesy of Digital Cinema Report
Read the article
Light Iron has selected Nara for its New York and Los Angeles facilities - streamlining its workflo...
10/02/2025
Article courtesy of postPerspective
Read the article
If you've seen the show, you've likely noticed its distinctive look, part of which could be attri...
10/02/2025
Article courtesy of Televisual
Read the article
The series was shot by cinematographers Emmanuel Lubezki, ASC, AMC ( Chivo') and Bruno Delbonnel, ASC, AFC...
10/02/2025
Article courtesy of Post
Read the article
The feature brought together a familiar team that included Guadagnino, DP Sayombhu Mukdeeprom and colorist Claudio D...
10/02/2025
Article courtesy of Digital Media World
Read the article
Colourist Daniel Pardy talks about building a working LUT for this film with a distinctive 16mm film ...
10/02/2025
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Thales has delivered the first drone system for ...
10/02/2025
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Thales At a time when much is expected of AI and its contribution to the security and sovereignty of nations, Thales offers a ...
10/02/2025
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Cannes, February 10th, 2025 - Space Norway, Northern Europe's leading satellite operator, and Thales Alenia Space, a joint v...
09/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: FOX Sports Highlights Celebrity Fashion With Productio...
09/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: NEP Specialty Capture Adds Key Cameras for Game Broadc...
09/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: Augmented-Reality Graphics Play Starring Role in FOX S...
09/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: Telemundo Deportes Goes All Out in Miami for Spanish-L...
09/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: FOX Sports Highlights Celebrity Fashion With Productio...
09/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: Augmented Reality Graphics Play Starring Role in FOX S...
09/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: NFL Tech Ops Rides Years of Experience for Biggest, Mo...
08/02/2025
The American Forces Network (AFN), the U.S. government's television and radio broadcast service for military personnel and their families stationed overseas...
08/02/2025
In his Joshua Tree studio, cinematographer Timur Civan recently lensed a new music video Resurrection for gothic country artist Blood Nebraska. Working in col...
08/02/2025
DoPchoice debuts Spill Killer designed to prevent light leakage and ensure a clean, professional look for set or location lighting.
The elegantly designed butt...
08/02/2025
ESPN and Major League Rugby (MLR) have announced a multiyear media rights agreement that will bring MLR games to ESPN platforms. Under the new deal, live covera...
08/02/2025
Grammy-Nominated Alum Shares Berklee Wisdom with His Student Sister I thought graduating with a double major would be the key to success, Carlos Perez de An...
08/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: Inside the SkyCam and Sony Efforts To Make 4K 240-fps ...
08/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: Inside the 10,000-Sq.-Ft. Tech Center With FOX Sports ...
08/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: CMSI Uses the Big Game To Push Workflows Forward The company is providing edit support for pregame, Tubi Red Carpet Show By Ken Kersc...
08/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: Inside SkyCam and Sony's Efforts to Make 4K 240 fp...
08/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: FOX Sports Digital Leans on Vizrt's TriCaster Vizi...
08/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: ESPN Studio Ops Spreads Across Big Easy From Fulton St...
08/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: Verizon's Joe Russo on How 5G Can Get to the Next ...
08/02/2025
Live From Super Bowl LIX: Inside the 10,000 sq. ft. Tech Center with Fox Sports ...