The controversy about whether people can tell the difference on playback between audio recorded at 96 kHz that's played back at 44.1 kHz or a higher sample rate (such as 96 kHz) has never really been resolved. However, under some circumstances, recording at a higher sample rate can give an obvious, audible improvement in sound quality. In this week's tip we'll investigate why this happens, and in next week's tip, tell how to obtain the benefits of recording at a higher sample rate in Studio One with 44.1 and 48 kHz projects.
REALLY? CONVINCE ME!
A Song's sample rate can make a difference with sounds generated in the box, for instance using a virtual instrument plug-in that synthesizes a sound, or distortion created by an amp simulator. Any improvement heard with high sample rates comes from eliminating foldover distortion, also known as aliasing.
Theory time: A digital system can accurately represent audio at frequencies lower than half the sampling rate (e.g., 22.05 kHz in a 44.1 kHz project). If an algorithm within a plug-in generates harmonic content above this Nyquist limit-say, at 40 kHz-then you won't hear a 40 kHz tone, but you will hear the aliasing created when this tone folds down below the Nyquist limit (to 4.1 kHz, in this case). Aliasing thus appears within the audible range, but is harmonically unrelated to the original signal, and generally sounds pretty ugly.
Foldover distortion can happen with synthesized waveforms that are rich in harmonics, like pulse waves with sharp rise and fall times. (Amp sims can also be problematic; although their harmonics may be weak, if you're applying 60 dB of gain to create overdrive or distortion, the harmonics can be strong enough to cause audible aliasing).
SO IS IT A PROBLEM, OR NOT?
Not all plug-ins will exhibit these problems, for one of four reasons:
The audio isn't rich enough in harmonics to cause audible aliasing.
The plug-in itself can oversample, which means that as far as the plug-in is concerned, the sample rate is higher than that of the Song. So, any foldover distortion occurs outside the audio range.
The project sample rate is high enough to provide the same kind of environment as oversampling.
The plug-in designers have built appropriate anti-alias filtering in to the algorithms.
Many modern virtual instruments and amp sims oversample, and DAWs can handle higher sample rates, so you'd think that might be the end of it. Unfortunately, there can be limitations with oversampling and higher project sample rates.
Recording an entire project at a higher sample rate stresses out your computer more, reduces the number of audio channels you can stream, and won't allow you to run as many plug-ins.
Oversampling requires more CPU power, so even if all your instruments are oversampling internally, you may not be able to use as many instances of them.
Although some instruments may perform 2x oversampling, that still might not be sufficient to eliminate aliasing on harmonically rich sources-so oversampling an oversampled instrument can still make a difference.
Furthermore, with plug-ins that oversample, the sound quality will be influenced by the quality of the sample-rate conversion algorithms. It's not necessarily easy to perform high-quality sample-rate conversion: check out comparisons for various DAWs at http://src.infinitewave.ca (where, incidentally, Studio One rates as one of the best), and remember that the conversion algorithms for a plug-in might be more relaxed than what's used in a DAW.
So what's a musician to do? In next week's Friday Tip of the Week, we'll cover how to do upsampling in Studio One to reap the benefits of high-sample-rate recording at lower sample rates. Meanwhile, if you still need to be convinced recording at different sample rates makes a difference, check out this audio example of a synthesizer recorded in Studio One first at 44.1 kHz, and then at 96 kHz:
Most recent headlines
23/06/2018
All five BPswitch models are now shipping and ready to help you Take Control of your live productions.
More than a switch, BPswitch is a fully integrated live...
23/06/2018
Board Votes in 2018-2019 Officers
The American Society of Cinematographers (ASC) has re-elected Kees van Oostrum as president, who will serve his third consecu...
23/06/2018
by Jyotsna Kadimi, Technical Product Manager, YBVR
I was almost nostalgic when I walked into Los Angeles Convention Center for VRLA. The event brought back mem...
23/06/2018
Avid welcomes Ken Gayron as Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President and elevates Jason Duva to Chief Legal and Administrative Officer & Executive Vic...
23/06/2018
Blackmagic Design recently announced that Sky News UK has integrated a series of Ultimatte 12 compositing processors and an Ultimatte Smart Remote 4 to produce ...
23/06/2018
Senior Colorist Steve Porter collaborates with Cinematographer Carmen Cabana on new drama series that paints a bold picture of Latinx life in Los Angeles.
Post...
23/06/2018
Dan Judy has joined DigitalFilm Tree as a Senior Colorist. He has already begun working on the hit show Roseanne as well as the CW's The 100 and Fox'...
23/06/2018
Avid Maestro graphics systems give first-ever augmented reality capabilities for...
23/06/2018
OWNZONES Media Network, the EntTech company, recently announced the continued expansion of its European operations. With the move to a new and larger headquarte...
23/06/2018
Object Matrix has been awarded Object Storage Vendor of the Year by the Storage Awards. The awards, run by Storage Magazine, reward outstanding products, servic...
23/06/2018
Nine Honorees Selected from 105 Submissions to Screen in Los Angeles, Sept. 30.
The International Cinematographers Guild (ICG, IATSE Local 600) has named nine ...
23/06/2018
--
IHSE USA announced the introduction of new dual-screen capabilities with th...
23/06/2018
ABC's decision to order a spinoff of Roseanne last season's top-rated new comedy without its controversial star was welcomed by media buyers still worki...
23/06/2018
Love Ire & Song for Frank Turner & Robe posted: 23/06/2018
Folk punk singer songwriter Frank Turner recently played four vibrant and fully sold-out nights...
23/06/2018
AVIWEST Enables Broadcasters to Deliver Live Coverage of French Polynesian Elect...
23/06/2018
Presteigne Announces Two Appointments posted: 23/06/2018
Presteigne Broadcast Hire today announced the appointment of Danielle Fletcher and Lee Rowe as cl...
23/06/2018
Macau City's Dazzling House of Dancing Water' posted: 23/06/2018
Riedel Comms with Bolero Wireless Intercom improves the Infrastructure
The House ...
22/06/2018
Global producer and distributor Endemol Shine Group today announce they have sig...
22/06/2018
Sony today announced the winners of its RX0 Video Challenge. Open since the end of January 2018, the competition challenged video makers across Europe to push b...
22/06/2018
Pat is a comic-book-reading scientist who worked with Mark, his best friend. With Mark gone, Pat makes a big effort to be there for Nicole and Dion, and loves t...
22/06/2018
Directed by: McG
Cast:Jack Gore (The Kids Are Alright, Billions), Miya Cech (The Darkest Minds), Benjamin Flores Jr. (Game Shakers (TV), Transformers: The Last...
22/06/2018
Hollywood, CA - June 21, 2018 -- Netflix has entered into a multi-year overall deal with writer, director and producer Steven S. DeKnight for series and other p...
22/06/2018
S o Paulo - June, 20th, 2018 - Netflix, the worlds leading internet entertainmen...
22/06/2018
S o Paulo - June, 21st, 2018 - Netflix, the worlds leading internet entertainment service, announces Brazilian actor Marco Pigossi has joined Netflix for a seri...
22/06/2018
Amazon Announces First Fulfillment Center in Alabama, Creating 1,500 Full-Time J...
22/06/2018
San Diego, Jun. 22, 2018 - Verimatrix, a specialist in securing and enhancing re...
22/06/2018
NexPlayer and Edgeware Form Strategic Partnership to Bring Low Latency Streaming...
22/06/2018
3G Wireless, KMH Audio-Visual Integration, Metrovision, CTG Renew SVG Sponsorshi...
22/06/2018
Artel Video Systems, Professional Wireless Systems, Reality Check Systems, Gerli...
22/06/2018
Behind the Mic: Fox Sports Assigns Broadcast Teams for 2018 FIFA World Cup Group...
22/06/2018
Live From the NBA Draft: ESPN Embraces Seaport Studios for NBA Draft Coverage; N...
22/06/2018
NHL Draft: NBC, NHL Network Roll Out Big-Production Guns at American Airlines Ce...
22/06/2018
There are still too few women rising in leadership within the creative industry....
22/06/2018
Photo Credit: Aiden Monaghan/AMC
AMC has renewed its anthology series The Terror for a second season. The next season will be set during World War II and cente...
22/06/2018
CBS and Fox were the winners in Thursday prime ratings, on a night when no network exceeded a 0.7. Both CBS, in repeats, and Fox, with The Four, scored a 0.7/3....
22/06/2018
Timeless on NBC
(Photo by: Ron Batzdorff/NBC)
NBC has cancelled drama Timeless after two seasons. The network did not comment, but executive producer Shawn Ry...
22/06/2018
community
Jun 22, 2018
Seven-year-old Rex Johnson delivers this year's cutest performance in our newest GoPro Award-winning video, Rex the BMX Kid. Th...
22/06/2018
We covered tempo changes previously, with an emphasis on using tempo changes to add dramatic pauses, and also doing longer changes that are useful with DJ sets ...
22/06/2018
--
Blackmagic Design today announced that Guangzhou based RGBworks Studio, a p...
22/06/2018
TSL Products Partners with DNF Controls To Enhance Control Systems Functionality posted: 22/06/2018
TSL To Use DNF's Products as Standalone Hardware a...
22/06/2018
-- --
Facebook
Twitter
Google
Pinterest
Nominees for the 2018 Africa Magic Viewers' Choice Awards (AMVCAs) will be announced via a televised broadc...
22/06/2018
-- --
Facebook
Twitter
Google
Pinterest
The National Film and Video Foundation (NFVF) has announced the call for filmmakers to attend the Nature Enviro...
22/06/2018
Promises just +/-0.9dB difference across different devices
Software > Processor
Mixing
Among its host of users, the Sonarworks Reference plug-in has become ...
22/06/2018
Image: Jason Dorfman/MIT CSAIL
In the healthcare world, the ability to see through walls, could monitor diseases and help elderly people live longer in their o...
22/06/2018
Scientists have designed a nanolaser that can change colour in the same the way that chameleons are able to change the colour of their skin. Scientists at North...
22/06/2018
Ahmad Bsat - Regional sales manager ME, Exterity
Exterity, a provider of IP video and digital signage technologies, has announced several enhancements to its g...
22/06/2018
Peter Mathia as been added to the management board of German rental company Lang. Starting from July 1, Mathia will share this responsibility with chair Tobias ...
22/06/2018
L-R: Emre Defne (Elit), Tom Back (Alcons) and nsal ak r (Elit)
Alcons Audio has appointed Elit Light and Sound Technologies, based in Besiktas, Istanbul, as ...
22/06/2018
22 06 2018 - Media release Superwog to forge new ground with a series for ABC COMEDY and YouTube
Superwog
The ABC and Screen Australia are excited to announc...
The controversy about whether people can tell the difference on playback between audio recorded at 96 kHz that's played back at 44.1 kHz or a higher sample rate (such as 96 kHz) has never really been resolved. However, under some circumstances, recording at a higher sample rate can give an obvious, audible improvement in sound quality. In this week's tip we'll investigate why this happens, and in next week's tip, tell how to obtain the benefits of recording at a higher sample rate in Studio One with 44.1 and 48 kHz projects.
