Sony Pixel Power calrec Sony

A philosopher's perspective on being gay in Africa

27/06/2022

A philosopher's perspective on being gay in AfricaBeing gay in Africa is usually not easily accepted by the dominant heterosexual culture who argue that same sex marriages are unnatural.

by The Conversation

27-06-2022 13:15

in LGBTQIA

A philosopher's perspective on being gay in Africa: Image: Pixabay

--

Most African countries are constitutional democracies that afford extensive rights and freedoms to their citizens, and safeguard their dignity.

It is arbitrary, to say the least, to exclude from these the right to express sexuality or gender identity. But opponents of homosexuality would like to do just that. They often invoke public interest , protection of community and morals to violate the dignity of homosexuals.

Ghana's current constitution, for example, is widely hailed as an inspiring model of a state's observance of these freedoms. Yet, on 29 June 2021, The Promotion of Proper Human Sexual Rights and Ghanaian Family Values Bill 2021 was introduced in parliament. It aims to promote proper human sexual rights and Ghanaian family values, and proscribe the promotion of and advocacy for LGBTQ practice .

--

The bill's supporters claim to be motivated by religious and cultural values and ideals. The trend of the discussion of homosexuality in Africa since the 1980s suggests that this view is not uniquely Ghanaian, and that homosexuality nags at the conscience of Africans.

From religious perspectives, homosexuality is problematic because it is sinful, and sinful because it offends against God's will. Several theologians deny this.

But whether or not religions condemn same-sex relationships, my position is that in many African societies the problem has to do less with sinfulness than with an existential and moral commitment.

--

To put it more plainly, I believe that many people oppose homosexuality because they feel they have a culturally sanctioned moral commitment to have children. And that commitment stems from the ultimate goal of promoting community welfare. In my view, this is a value which can accommodate same-sex relationships and protect homosexual people.

ALSO READ: MEN HAVE TAKEN OVER': US POLITICIAN BLAMES TRANS MEN FOR TAMPON SHORTAGE

Culture and nature I start by accepting that being African is a culturally distinct mode of being. I mean merely that certain values are more prevalent in sub-Saharan Africa than in other geographical locations. I don't mean that all Africans share one culture. And African cultures evolve all the time. I also start from the position that a person does not choose to be gay.

Being gay in Africa can pose culturally specific problems which the dominant, heterosexual culture may find hard to accept. But I think African culture can also offer a solution to this nonacceptance - a moral theory that allows people to embrace both their sexual being and their cultural being. Being gay and being African need not be seen as a contradiction.

First let's look at the dominant African culture I'm talking about.

In African societies, an important factor in anti-gay agitation is the moral weight assigned to having children, and emphasis on heterosexual intercourse as a way to achieving this. Procreation ensures continuation of biological heritage, through which the history of society unfolds.

Hence raising children and contributing to a lineage is upheld as a vitally important good for community. In this way, biological reproduction through heterosexual sex becomes a moral responsibility.

To write off the preference for heterosexuality as pre-modern and as biased against homosexuals is insulting and unimaginative. Rather than condemning this preference, it's more productive to find a way for culture to make room for homosexuality.

Some people describe homosexuality as unnatural , anti-social or un-African . This is not true. Several studies, including one on 50 societies in every region of the continent, decisively support the conclusion that homosexual relationships constitute a consistent and logical feature of African societies and belief systems.

The argument that same-sex practice is unnatural because it violates human nature also overlooks the fact that sexuality is a natural feature of human beings. Sexuality is part of what it is to be human. To be human is to be a sexually oriented being.

The tendency in Africa to relegate sexuality to a relatively minor part of human life - to the drive to procreate - tends to treat homosexual expressions as inappropriate. But sexual orientation is central to every person's entire sense of self, and not just to a small part of it which can be lopped off or put on hold at will.

Accepting the centrality of a person's sexual orientation to their humanity has significant moral implications which do not square with the existential and moral commitments of African societies I've described.

Opponents of homosexuality put more emphasis on the duty to have children, and overlook a deeper value, that of building and sustaining community. They gloss over the role that homosexuals can play in achieving the latter task.

A moderate communitarian solution My view is that the rights of homosexuals can be better protected by an African moral theory than by the standard constitutional safeguards.

The African moral theory that can achieve this is the Ghanaian philosopher Kwame Gyekye's moderate communitarianism. This theory holds that an action is intrinsically good if it serves the communal good - namely the social conditions that will enable each individual to function satisfactorily in a human society.

Moderate communitarianism gives equal value to what is good for individuals and what is good for community - as long as individuals and community serve and protect each other's value and dignity.

From this perspective, hom
LINK: https://www.thesouthafrican.com/culture/lgbtqia/being-gay-in-africa/...
See more stories from thesouthafrican

More from The South African

12/08/2022

The Isley Brothers reimagine a 1975 classic with Beyonc [listen]

The Isley Brothers reimagine a 1975 classic with Beyonc [listen] R&B legends The Isley Brothers have teamed up with Beyonc on a duet of their 1975 classic, M...

12/08/2022

Actress Nomzamo Mbatha researched Nandi while filming Isibaya'

Actress Nomzamo Mbatha researched Nandi while filming Isibaya' Shaka Ilembe' producer and actress Nomzamo Mbatha says she's always wanted to play Q...

12/08/2022

Skeem Saam' September Spoilers: Kwaito leaves, Alfred is bribed

Skeem Saam' September Spoilers: Kwaito leaves, Alfred is bribedThe Skeem Saam' teasers reveal that Clement Maosa, who plays Kwaito Seakamela-Maputla wi...

12/08/2022

WATCH: Skeem Saam - Tonight's teaser E30 S11

WATCH: Skeem Saam - Tonight's teaser E30 S11Find out what's going on tonight on Skeem Saam! by SA TV and Soapies 12-08-2022 16:00 in SkeemSaam Fri...

12/08/2022

WATCH: Generations - The Legacy, tonight's teaser E190 S8

WATCH: Generations - The Legacy, tonight's teaser E190 S8Keen to know what's happening on the latest episode of Generations: The Legacy? by SA TV and ...

12/08/2022

WATCH: Uzalo- Tonight's teaser E115 S8

WATCH: Uzalo- Tonight's teaser E115 S8Don't get left behind, catch up on Uzalo now! by SA TV and Soapies 12-08-2022 16:05 in Soapies Friday's ...

12/08/2022

WATCH: Imbewu - The Seed, tonight's teaser E87 S5

WATCH: Imbewu - The Seed, tonight's teaser E87 S5Catch up on what's going on to night on Imbewu by SA TV and Soapies 12-08-2022 16:08 in Soapies F...

12/08/2022

WATCH: Diep City - Tonight's teaser E95 S2

WATCH: Diep City - Tonight's teaser E95 S2We've got you covered on what's happening tonight. by SA TV and Soapies 12-08-2022 16:10 in Soapies ...

12/08/2022

WATCH: The River - Tonight's teaser E135 S5

WATCH: The River - Tonight's teaser E135 S5Watch tonight's episode of The River and catch the latest episode every weekday at 20:00 on 1 Magic, don'...

12/08/2022

WATCH: Scandal - Tonight's teaser E96 S14

WATCH: Scandal - Tonight's teaser E96 S14Get to know what's happening on tonight's episode! by SA TV and Soapies 12-08-2022 16:15 in Scandal F...

12/08/2022

WATCH: Gomora - Tonight's teaser E80 S3

WATCH: Gomora - Tonight's teaser E80 S3Don't miss out on what's happening on tonight's episode of Gomora, and watch the latest episode every wee...

12/08/2022

WATCH: Muvhango - Tonight's teaser E419 S22

WATCH: Muvhango - Tonight's teaser E419 S22Don't miss out on the latest drama in Muvhango! by SA TV and Soapies 12-08-2022 16:20 in Muvhango Frida...

12/08/2022

WATCH: 7de Laan - Tonight's teaser E425 S22

WATCH: 7de Laan - Tonight's teaser E425 S22Don't miss out on what's happening on tonight's episode of 7de Laan and Catch the latest episode ever...

12/08/2022

Belinda the Bok anthem singer': Who is SA's Whitney Houston?

Belinda the Bok anthem singer': Who is SA's Whitney Houston?Belinda Davids has been tasked with singing the national anthem at the Springboks vs All Bla...

12/08/2022

Daily devotion: Your bible verse and prayer for 12 August 2022

Daily devotion: Your bible verse and prayer for 12 August 2022GOOD MORNING! Here's your daily bible verse and prayer to get you ready and excited about your...

12/08/2022

Actor Arthur Masoma discusses playing Phuthi in Skeem Saam'

Actor Arthur Masoma discusses playing Phuthi in Skeem Saam' Actor Arthur Masoma recently joined Skeem Saam' after auditioning for the role of Phuthi L...

12/08/2022

From the Garden of Eden to the promised land: IT IS WRITTEN

From the Garden of Eden to the promised land: IT IS WRITTENOur Father is preparing a new heaven and a new earth, built for His bride, beautifully dressed for he...

11/08/2022

UZALO: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]

UZALO: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]Missed an episode of Uzalo? No problem! Watch all the latest episodes of Uzalo soapie right here,don&#...

11/08/2022

MUVHANGO: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]

MUVHANGO: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]Missed an episode of Muvhango? No problem! Watch all the latest episodes of Muvhango soapie right h...

11/08/2022

SKEEM SAAM: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]

SKEEM SAAM: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]Missed an episode of Skeem Saam? No problem! Watch all the latest episodes of Skeem Saam soapie r...

11/08/2022

HOUSE OF ZWIDE: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]

HOUSE OF ZWIDE: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]Missed an episode of House of Zwide ? No problem! Watch all the latest episodes of House of Z...

11/08/2022

SCANDAL: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]

SCANDAL: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]Missed an episode of Scandal ? No problem! Watch all the latest episodes of Scandal soapie right her...

11/08/2022

GOMORA: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]

GOMORA: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]Missed an episode of gomora? No problem! Just watch all the latest episodes of gomora soapie right he...

11/08/2022

GENERATIONS: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]

GENERATIONS: Watch tonight's episode, 11 August 2022 [VIDEO]Missed an episode of Generation The Legacy? No problem! Watch all the latest episodes of Generat...

11/08/2022

Joburg Film Festival to return in 2023 with stellar new programme

Joburg Film Festival to return in 2023 with stellar new programmeFollowing a two-year hiatus, the Joburg Film Festival is returning to the City of Gold with an ...

11/08/2022

BU opens up about life after #BBMzansi and his Ayeye' gig

BU opens up about life after #BBMzansi and his Ayeye' gig Ayeye' and The Executives' actor Luthando BU' Mthembu says life has been very good ...

11/08/2022

Meet The Queens of Mzansi' reality TV stars

Meet The Queens of Mzansi' reality TV starsThe SABC1 new reality TV show The Queens of Mzansi' premiers 15 August and follows five black women who'...

11/08/2022

WATCH: Skeem Saam - Tonight's teaser E29 S11

WATCH: Skeem Saam - Tonight's teaser E29 S11Find out what's going on tonight on Skeem Saam! by SA TV and Soapies 11-08-2022 16:00 in SkeemSaam Thu...

11/08/2022

WATCH: Generations - The Legacy, tonight's teaser E189 S8

WATCH: Generations - The Legacy, tonight's teaser E189 S8Keen to know what's happening on the latest episode of Generations: The Legacy? by SA TV and ...

11/08/2022

WATCH: Uzalo- Tonight's teaser E114 S8

WATCH: Uzalo- Tonight's teaser E114 S8Don't get left behind, catch up on Uzalo now! by SA TV and Soapies 11-08-2022 16:05 in Soapies Thursday'...

11/08/2022

WATCH: Imbewu - The Seed, tonight's teaser E86 S5

WATCH: Imbewu - The Seed, tonight's teaser E86 S5Catch up on what's going on to night on Imbewu by SA TV and Soapies 11-08-2022 16:08 in Soapies T...

11/08/2022

WATCH: Diep City - Tonight's teaser E94 S2

WATCH: Diep City - Tonight's teaser E94 S2We've got you covered on what's happening tonight. by SA TV and Soapies 11-08-2022 16:10 in Soapies ...

11/08/2022

WATCH: The River - Tonight's teaser E134 S5

WATCH: The River - Tonight's teaser E134 S5Watch tonight's episode of The River and catch the latest episode every weekday at 20:00 on 1 Magic, don'...

11/08/2022

WATCH: Scandal - Tonight's teaser E95 S14

WATCH: Scandal - Tonight's teaser E95 S14Get to know what's happening on tonight's episode! by SA TV and Soapies 11-08-2022 16:15 in Scandal T...

11/08/2022

The Wife': Are you the next Bonko Khoza or Bokang Phelane?

The Wife': Are you the next Bonko Khoza or Bokang Phelane?Showmax has partnered with Actor Spaces to bring YouTube masterclasses starring Bonko Khoza, Ayand...

11/08/2022

WATCH: Gomora - Tonight's teaser E79 S3

WATCH: Gomora - Tonight's teaser E79 S3Don't miss out on what's happening on tonight's episode of Gomora, and watch the latest episode every wee...

11/08/2022

WATCH: Muvhango - Tonight's teaser E418 S22

WATCH: Muvhango - Tonight's teaser E418 S22Don't miss out on the latest drama in Muvhango! by SA TV and Soapies 11-08-2022 16:20 in Muvhango Thurs...

11/08/2022

WATCH: 7de Laan - Tonight's teaser E424 S22

WATCH: 7de Laan - Tonight's teaser E424 S22Don't miss out on what's happening on tonight's episode of 7de Laan and Catch the latest episode ever...

11/08/2022

CANCELLED: SABC2's Motswako' ends after 21 seasons

CANCELLED: SABC2's Motswako' ends after 21 seasonsProducer and TV host Carol Bouwer confirms her popular talk show Motswako' has come to an end af...

11/08/2022

Young, Famous & African' returns: 5 bombshells from season one

Young, Famous & African' returns: 5 bombshells from season oneHere's five bombshells from season one of Young, Famous & African' ahead of the relea...

11/08/2022

Birth of Stars': Flying the pride flag high with new reality TV series

Birth of Stars': Flying the pride flag high with new reality TV seriesReality series Birth of Stars' aims to benefit the LGBTQI community through full...

11/08/2022

SAMA28: First-ever Viral Song of the Year nominees announced

SAMA28: First-ever Viral Song of the Year nominees announcedThe likes of Costa Titch, Major League DJz and Nomfundo Moh have been nominated for the TikTok Viral...

11/08/2022

Daily devotion: Your bible verse and prayer for 11 August 2022

Daily devotion: Your bible verse and prayer for 11 August 2022GOOD MORNING! Here's your daily bible verse and prayer to get you ready and excited about your...

11/08/2022

Muvhango' actress Azwimmbavhi Rambuda gets married [VIDEO]

Muvhango' actress Azwimmbavhi Rambuda gets married [VIDEO] Muvhango' actress Azwimmbavhi Rambuda, who plays Mpho on the SABC2 soapie has married her lon...

10/08/2022

MUVHANGO: Watch tonight's episode, 10 August 2022 [VIDEO]

MUVHANGO: Watch tonight's episode, 10 August 2022 [VIDEO]Missed an episode of Muvhango? No problem! Watch all the latest episodes of Muvhango soapie right h...

10/08/2022

UZALO: Watch tonight's episode, 10 August 2022 [VIDEO]

UZALO: Watch tonight's episode, 10 August 2022 [VIDEO]Missed an episode of Uzalo? No problem! Watch all the latest episodes of Uzalo soapie right here,don&#...

10/08/2022

SKEEM SAAM: Watch tonight's episode, 10 August 2022 [VIDEO]

SKEEM SAAM: Watch tonight's episode, 10 August 2022 [VIDEO]Missed an episode of Skeem Saam? No problem! Watch all the latest episodes of Skeem Saam soapie r...

10/08/2022

Gomora' actress Sannah Mchunu is unwell, requests prayers

Gomora' actress Sannah Mchunu is unwell, requests prayersMulti-award-winning Gomora' actress Sannah Mchunu, who plays Zodwa is asking for fans to pray ...

10/08/2022

I was scared': Miss SA contestant on gender reassignment surgery

I was scared': Miss SA contestant on gender reassignment surgeryShe made history as the first trans woman to make the Miss SA top 16, now Lehlogonolo Machab...

10/08/2022

HOUSE OF ZWIDE: Watch tonight's episode, 10 August 2022 [VIDEO]

HOUSE OF ZWIDE: Watch tonight's episode, 10 August 2022 [VIDEO]Missed an episode of House of Zwide ? No problem! Watch all the latest episodes of House of Z...