Timing Tails of Truth
12/09/2018
By Simen K. Frostad, Chairman at Bridge Technologies
Recognising the extremities of the bell curve distribution and the impact large jitter variances have on picture and sound stability is critical. Only when this is understood, do we hope to be able to build reliable, flexible, IP infrastructures that will meet the demands of real-time broadcast facilities.
A bell curve is the most natural representation of distribution of variables and is here depicting a typical IP packet flow.
A broadcaster's primary choice of IP transport is Ethernet. Affordable network speeds from 10Gb/s have been creeping up year on year to 25Gb/s, 40Gb/s, 50Gb/s, and now 100Gb/s. Native 4K is already achievable in IP and 8K will soon follow as adoption of higher interface speeds continue to increase.
SMPTE's recently released ST2110 specification abstracts away the essence from the underlying bit clocks of synchronous SDI. Using RTP (Real Time Protocol) packet transport, ST2110 uniquely timestamps each video, audio, and metadata packet, to facilitate independent essence stream processing.
PTP Subsystem
For the RTP packet transport to work reliably in ST2110, each connected device must be synchronised to the same absolute time source. Borrowing from the IT industry, SMPTE chose the IEEE-1588:2008 standard called ST2059-2 in SMPTE lingo. Otherwise also known as PTP (Precision Time Protocol), this standard ensures all connected devices, such as cameras, monitor-walls, and sound consoles, have the same clock counter to within a microsecond, allowing events to be synchronised to microsecond accuracy.
Consequently, engineers now have two timing planes to consider; the underlying PTP synchronisation sub-system and the time-stamping of the essence packet streams.
Jitter is inherent in an IP network and cannot be avoided as single Ethernet connections may carry packets from different sources and destinations. The act of forwarding packets, buffering them and multiplexing and demultiplexing them in an asynchronous way, causes jitter.
Packet Distribution Varies
Devices sending IP Packets cannot be assumed to evenly distribute the packets of data in a timely fashion. Generally, the transmit software will output data as fast as possible to free the Ethernet driver for other services within the device.
An IP monitor-wall fed via a switch will receive many sources of video, audio, VANC data and the PTP data simultaneously on the same link. The switch must prioritise PTP packets to keep video and audio in sync.
An Ethernet switch will prioritise some packets over others using the Quality of Service mechanism. An IP monitor-wall connected to a switch would receive many sources of video, audio, VANC data and the PTP data simultaneously on the same link. To keep the monitor-walls local PTP clock accurate, hence keep the video and audio in sync, the network administrator will have configured the switch to prioritise PTP packets resulting in the video stream being held back in favour of the PTP traffic, again potentially resulting in jitter.
Small amounts of jitter are expected, and the IP monitor-wall would use a FIFO (First in First out) buffer to overcome jitter by storing enough data for the decoders in the monitor-wall to construct the video packets and reliably display them in sync with audio.
Data Bursts
A well behaved 1080p/25 HD source sends around 270,000 IP packets per second or 270 IP packets every millisecond to achieve an average data rate of around 2.5Gbit/s in real world ST2110 terms compared to the static SDI specification of 3Gbit/s. However, if the source developed a fault, or was incorrectly configured, and suddenly started bursting data, it is entirely possible that peak bursts up to double that rate, 4Gbit/s or more could occur as microbursts with just a few hundred milliseconds of duration. This is still within the link specification for a typical 10GbE link but the average bandwidth measured over one second is still 2.5Gbit/s.
If the monitor-wall's packet buffer is configured to store up to 32 packets of HD video for each of the six multicast subscriptions, its buffer size per flow would be approximately 110 microseconds.
For normal operation this is fine. As the packets are evenly gapped, the buffers write-rate equals the read-rate and packets sent to the internal video decoder are completed in a timely manner.
Buffer Overflow
When the source starts bursting, the short-term write-rate is significantly higher than the read-rate and the buffer will overflow in fractions of a second, potentially blocking PTP traffic and holding back the other video streams causing visual breakup and stuttering.
But how do we see this problem? The source is sending the correct average data rate and the switch is not dropping frames as the data rates are within the link limits. Is it the PTP grand-master? Or has the monitor-wall gone faulty?
It's entirely possible that another monitoring device with a large buffer would be able to deal with the short-term bursts, and display stable pictures from the bursting camera. So why would you suspect the camera?
Tails Tell the Answer
Whilst looking at the average we're only seeing half of the information. If we were to plot the temporal data distribution we would see an average at 2.5Gbit/s. But tellingly, we would see packets way beyond the second and third standard deviation from the average, well into the tails of the bell curve distribution.
Investigating timing related conditions is not as easy as it may first seem. Network Interface Cards (NIC's) found in servers use buffers to receive data from the Ethernet wire to avoid packet loss. As soon as the packet is received it is written into a FIFO resulting in any temporal information being destroyed. Even looking at the packets in Wireshark (a free and open source packet
More from Bridge Technologies
07/02/2022
Bridge Technologies Upgrades ASI Monitoring with VB246
New blade facilitates continuous parallel monitoring of six inputs Bridge Technologies announces today the release of its VB246, an ASI input option card for r...
13/12/2021
Bridge Technologies Brings Audio Enhancements to VB440
Facilitating immersive production on a distributed basis Bridge Technologies, a leading provider of end-to-end monitoring solutions in the broadcast field, to...
28/11/2021
Bridge Technologies HDR Blog Post
How we see HDR Are you seeing what I'm seeing? In this month's blog we unpack the miracle of colour, and explain how we're bringing incredible HDR...
28/11/2021
Bridge Technologies Integrates JPEG XS to VB330 Appliance
For continuous real-time monitoring and metadata recording On the back of Bridge Technologies' recent announcement regarding support of the JPEG XS compres...
31/10/2021
Bridge Technologies to Showcase its VB440 with HDR Capability at IBC2021
Provides a localised preview of an HDR output image for remote production Bridge Technologies today announces its intention to demonstrate the new HDR capabili...
28/10/2021
Bridge Technologies announces its HDR Capability on the VB440
Provides a localised preview of an HDR output image for remote production Bridge Technologies today announces its intention to demonstrate the new HDR capabili...
13/10/2021
TVB Case Study
Bridge Technologies supplies Hong-Kong broadcaster TVB with full redundancy switching through business partner Mediatech. Covering most of the HK terrestrial b...
13/10/2021
Bridge Technologies Equips VB440 with JPEG XS Compression Analysis
Ensures the probe remains at the forefront of developing production and contribution standards Bridge Technologies, a leading provider of end-to-end monitoring...
13/10/2021
Bridge Technologies Adds Closed Caption and Packet Capture to its VB440
The new functionalities secure probe as an indispensable production tool Bridge Technologies, a leading provider of end-to-end monitoring solutions in the broa...
13/10/2021
Data driven decision making - what does it really mean?
IABM Journal Article By Simen K. Frostad Chairman, Bridge Technologies What is a decision? It seems like a simple question, but it's one worth considerin...
13/10/2021
The Magic of Monitoring and Measurement in Movie Making
Article for The Future.TV By Simen K. Frostad, Chairman of Bridge Technologies Why mistakes make for great movie plots, but terrible productions In the world...
25/06/2021
Finding the perfect platform
What do the terms embedded, appliance and software-based mean to you? One of the difficulties - but also pleasures - of working in the broadcast industry is kn...
16/06/2021
Ziggo Case Study
Challenge To minimize network downtime and maintain reputation by providing a high-level, cost-effective monitoring solution that could identify in-the-momen...
27/04/2021
Bridge Technologies' VB440 Underpins Densitron's UReady 4RU Solution
The collaborative product takes broadcast operator control to new levels After cementing their working relationship together in September 2019, Bridge Technolo...
30/03/2021
Bridge Technologies Wins Tech Leadership's Best Production Technology' Award
The win recognizes the contribution of the VB440's new Audio Metering functi...
10/02/2021
Bridge Technologies Partners with North American 2110 Solutions
Together they aim to facilitate creative excellence through innovative production technologies Bridge Technologies today announces its partnership with 2110 So...
22/01/2021
Bridge Technologies January Blog
Can Procrastination be Productive? A key challenge of working from home has been the issue of procrastination. Even the most grown-up and disciplined of us fin...
21/12/2020
Bridge Technologies September Blog Post
Wired for sound (or maybe not ) The evolution of audio engineering that should be recorded' in history One of life's great annoyances is teenagers th...
08/12/2020
Bridge Technologies Partners with Germany's Broadcast Solutions
United by a focus on IP-based, future-proof production environments, and a commitment to customer service Bridge Technologies today announces partnership with...
30/11/2020
Ziggo Upgrades its Cable Network With the Help of Bridge Technologies
Burst Video, the Dutch Business Partner has completed the installation Bridge Technologies today announced that it has delivered forty VB120 probes to Ziggo, t...
18/11/2020
Bridge Technologies Joins the Grass Valley Technology Alliance
Further enhancing confidence for broadcast providers seeking multi-vendor network solutions Bridge Technologies is proud to announce its membership of the Gra...
02/10/2020
Our Virtual Experience with IBC2020 Through Video Content
The psychology of a deadline The times they are a' changin' Have you noticed that something seems a little off this year? A little different? Maybe i...
30/09/2020
Bridge Technologies Wins 2020 TV Technology Best of Show Award
PoE for accessible and meaningful visual IP network analytics Bridge Technologies today announced that ii has received the TV Technology Best of Show' a...
24/09/2020
Bridge Technologies Announces PoE+ Tabletop Aluminum Kit
A unique form factor for accessible anywhere' analytics Bridge Technologies today announces a new range of data display options; the PoE Tabletop Aluminu...
22/09/2020
Bridge Technologies to Support Australian Nine's Greenfield IP Site
The VB440 will enable production teams to continuously survey all layers of media transportation Bridge Technologies, through Australian business partner Tech...
17/09/2020
Bridge Technologies Shows Mosaic and Multiviewer Created Within Its Widglets API
The distinction between studio and real-time remote production becomes blurred In time for the virtual IBC2020 this year, Bridge Technologies announces the mo...
15/09/2020
Bridge Technologies Announces VB330 v6 with Dramatic Increase of Monitoring Capacity
It supports a tenfold increase of monitoring OTT traffic, TS IPTV ETR290 and add...
28/08/2020
Simplifying Monitoring
Tony Orme, Editor at The Broadcast Bridge As IP, COTs and IT systems advance through broadcast infrastructures, monitoring continues to play a critical role in...
18/07/2020
Bridge Technologies July Blog Post
Why being silly matters Find your probes in our music At Bridge, we're quite a fan of being transparent. You'll often find in our blogs that we dive ...
14/05/2020
Thought leadership: Bridge Tech on simplicity and complexity in sport broadcast
As published by SVG Europe Simen K Frostad, chairman at Bridge Technologies The world of sport embodies a beautiful contrast between ideas of simplicity and co...
14/05/2020
Bridge Technologies Partner with Appear TV to Provide Advanced IP-based Production and Distribution
End-to-end delivery and monitoring of uncompressed to compressed content deliver...
24/03/2020
Integrated Services Monitoring Capability Launched by Bridge Technologies
Delivers invaluable network performance insights from production, contribution and distribution Bridge Technologies today announced ISM Integrated Services M...
24/01/2020
Bridge Technologies January Blog Post
Where We Have Been Dunno where I'm going, Dunno where I've been When guitar legend Rory Gallagher sang that, he obviously hadn't been keeping me...
17/01/2020
Bridge Technologies Appoints DVEO as Business Partner
Brings in-depth technical knowledge, extensive experience, total commitment to customer service OSLO, Norway - 15 January, 2020 Bridge Technologies today anno...
17/12/2019
Bridge Technologies December Blog Post
The end-of-year roundup. Is it already? How can you possibly do a roundup of the year when January was just a few weeks ago? Yes, to say that this year seems t...
09/12/2019
SatNews: Year in Review 2019
By Simen K. Frostad Every year, the broadcast industry descends en masse on the RAI Convention Centre in Amsterdam. Once again, IBC provided invaluable insight...
29/11/2019
Bridge Technologies November Blog Post
Media streaming: it's an OTTortunity If you're old enough to remember dial-up access to the Internet, you'll recall that even downloading a simple ...
31/10/2019
Bridge Technologies October Blog Post
IBC 2019: a great recognition of what we are doing By Simen K. Frostad Even if you're a pretty confident person, and you're fairly sure that what you...
01/10/2019
Bridge Technologies Wins IBC2019 Best of Show Award
Widglets API has the potential to revolutionise and transform many aspects of the broadcast industry Bridge Technologies today announced that it had received ...
20/09/2019
NRK Case Study: Making the difficult easy
Making the difficult easy This case study describes how Bridge Technologies and Norway's NRK worked together to help the transition to the use of CDNs even...
07/09/2019
Bridge Technologies to Demonstrate 8K IP Network Probe at IBC
VB440 represents an entirely future-proof solution Bridge Technologies today announced that, at IBC (stand 1.A71), the company will demonstrate its VB440 IP n...
03/09/2019
Bridge Technologies August Blog Post
Bridge Technologies - the mad hatters of the broadcast world In this month's blog, we find out how the Bridge baseball caps we gifted in May have found th...
30/08/2019
Bridge Technologies Joins SRT Alliance and Supports SRT Open Source Protocol
Enormously enthusiastic about the SRT Alliance and what it is trying to achieve Bridge Technologies today announced that it has become a member of the SRT All...
30/08/2019
The Widglets API: the most exciting thing we've done to date!
By Simen K Frostad Did you know that Facebook has had 250 billion photos uploaded to it since the company started in 2004? Or that 700 million hours of video a...
21/08/2019
Bridge Technologies to Showcase Transformative' Technology for Remote Production at IBC
New Widglets API for VB440 probe puts full-motion, low-latency video/audio HTML5...
12/08/2019
Bridge Technologies' Presence at IBC to be Bigger, Better Than Ever Before
Company also teases exciting announcement for opening day of show OSLO, Norway - 12 August, 2019 At IBC 2019, Bridge Technologies will have its largest and ...
09/07/2019
Bridge Technologies Wins Prestigious SCTE Award
VB330 Probe is voted Technological Innovation of the Year Bridge Technologies has announced that its VB330 Probe with support for Remote PHY received two award...
02/07/2019
Bridge Technologies June Blog Post
How IP-based remote production was the star of our 15 year celebration By Simen K. Frostad In 2004, the EU underwent its single largest expansion at the time,...
15/06/2019
Sports Production Companies Embracing Remote Production
Sports Production Companies Embracing Remote Production Bridge Technologies has long been a fervent proponent of IP technology and the benefits it brings to th...
03/06/2019
Showcasing Video Service Monitoring and Analytics Solutions at Broadcast Asia
Enabling broadcasters and content distributors to ensure operational efficiency and Quality of Experience OSLO, Norway - 2 June, 2019 At Broadcast Asia (18 Ju...