![](//www.4rfv.com/images/no_image.jpg)
This is a summary of the inaugural Thomson Talks with Madhav Chinnappa held on 30 November 2023 focused on the specific subject of AI/News & Disinformation.
The event was kicked off with three expert stimulators' from the fields of academia, technology and publishing respectively.
The academic made the point that AI is not the primary driver of misinformation, and that we should focus on strengthening norms and technological solutions to mitigate the risk of misinformation.
The technologist discussed the potential for AI to be used for autonomous systems and data systems to build agents that seek rewards and gain systems they interact with, which could pose new challenges for news organisations.
The publisher highlighted the dangers of AI deepening polarisation, polluting the idea of whats true, and polluting the question of who to believe.
These summaries were aided by the use of AI via Google's Bard
The group discussion touched many different subjects:
Polarisation Given that in many elections/countries existing polarisation is such that one only needs to swing 2% of an electorate to change the outcome that AI will end up being a negative force overall and that AI could also super-charge and reinforce existing polarisation in society.
The counter to this is that many countries have a multi-party system unlike the US and thus this mitigates this somewhat.
Also, have publishers themselves embraced enough social media and micro-formats (like TikTok) which their audiences are consuming?
Tech While there was much discussion of bad actors, there was also concern about neutral actors where there is a belief that so-called hallucinations are a feature of the system not a bug.
A point was made that we should stop using the word hallucination as it anthropomorphises the tech and dodges responsibility; bad outputs are mis-information - all else is dis-information.
Additionally as the AI systems are predominately being built by white men in California, this will exacerbate the concentration of power there, continuing the Californication of technologies.
Journalism This should be an opportunity to move out of a defensive mode that has crept in since the beginning of the internet age, into a more attack mode which proudly makes the case for human-based journalism.
In a world where the majority of content is AI-produced, human-made content could/should have a premium.
A true culture change in the news ecosystem is needed, especially around news senior management who, until ChatGPT launched, underinvested and undervalued AI tech.
Outcomes What do we want the outcome to be and how do we get there? Believing in governments alone to mitigate the harms is not enough.
We should be creating new products that include collaborations between tech companies, journalists, NGOs and governments.
JournalismAI is a good start but needs more support and publicity throughout the ecosystem.
-- Play
-- --
Diversity Strong points were made about how AI tech and LLMs in particular are not diverse enough and contain existing societal biases.
For example, the Slovenia AI-faked audio talked about buying the Roma vote which feeds on anti-Roma prejudices or how can small languages be part of LLMs while retaining agency and not be disintermediated/de-powered?
A counter point was made that actually AI can help address more minority audiences who may not have been catered to or focused on by mainstream output due to the operational burden.
Small Newsrooms There were two differing views on small newsrooms and AI.
Smaller newsrooms may not have the bandwidth, expertise nor time to engage as they are doing all they can simply to keep the lights on. However, they have an advantage over larger newsrooms in that the decision-making is quicker and commitment can see positive change much quicker as a result.
The event concluded by returning to the point that this should be an opportunity to go into attack mode around the value of human-based journalism.
The next Thomson Talks is scheduled for February 2024 around AI/News and Regulation.
Madhav Chinnappa Thomson Talks
Madhav Chinnappa, the former Director of News Ecosystem Development at Google and veteran news executive, leads our Thought Leadership events Thomson Talks.
Explore our projects across the globe
More from Thomson
23/07/2024
Brussels was the location of our third Thomson Talks with Madhav Chinnappa held on 25 June 2024, focused on the specific subject of AI/News & Regulation. Four k...
03/07/2024
AI's integration into journalism has sparked a mix of enthusiasm and scepticism across Central Europe, according to research led by Thomson Foundation in co...
01/07/2024
This was such a confidence boost and so much motivation to keep pushing forward in my work and public service journalism.
Yara El Murr from Lebanon recollecti...
21/06/2024
A new platform dedicated to helping journalists win audience trust and tackle disinformation has been launched and with it a competition offering newsrooms (fro...
30/05/2024
Navigating Strategy, Ethics, and Innovation in the evolving European media lands...
28/05/2024
This is a summary of the report commissioned by Thomson on AI Disinformation Attacks during Taiwans 2024 Presidential Elections, written by Professor Chen-ling ...
13/05/2024
Journalists from the Western Balkans and T rkiye can now submit their investigative stories published in 2023 for the EU Award for Investigative Journalism 2024...
03/05/2024
An innovative learning tool to help media and civil society better understand ho...
29/04/2024
A groundbreaking initiative offering training and mentoring to 30 women journali...
23/04/2024
Psychology can play an important role in helping us understand what audiences respond to (Dr Jon Roozenbeek, Cambridge Social Decision-Making Lab)
For newsroo...
10/04/2024
A regulator, a technologist and a politician walking into a conference room - the beginning of a very geeky joke - or more accurately, the start of the second T...
09/04/2024
This is a summary of the report commissioned by Thomson on AI Disinformation Attacks during Taiwans 2024 Presidential Elections, written by Professor Chen-ling ...
04/04/2024
This fantastic course will help you understand and fight disinformation, an absolutely essential skill to acquire during this global election season. Sign up an...
02/04/2024
Thomson's work in captive, closed and repressive media landscapes has long been about making sure we get the best possible idea of what people really need f...
28/03/2024
Out of an estimated 20,000 journalists in Pakistan, less than one thousand are women according to a recent Gender Disparity Report published by the Internationa...
15/03/2024
To help empower Sudanese journalists living in exile amidst the ongoing conflict in their homeland, Thomson trainers have been delivering workshops designed to ...
01/03/2024
MoJo is something I want to pursue further and include, not as a last thought, but as a one of the components of my daily work. Michelle Banda Vodacom Young Jou...
23/01/2024
A chance to apply for the new learning programme specifically designed for media...
16/01/2024
This is a summary of the inaugural Thomson Talks with Madhav Chinnappa held on 30 November 2023 focused on the specific subject of AI/News & Disinformation.
Th...
22/12/2023
Pakistan is one of more than 65 countries where decisive elections will take place in 2024 in what will be the biggest election year in history.
Thomson Media ...
19/12/2023
An innovative investigative training programme for Rwandan journalists has resulted in the publication of 15 impactful stories which have prompted widespread ch...
18/12/2023
As 2023 draws to a close, a new chapter begins for Thomson with the appointment of a new member of the team.
Anton Artemyev joins us in January in a new role a...
24/11/2023
The three finalists for the Thomson Foundation Young Journalist of the Year 2023 enjoyed an action-packed trip to London which included meeting the Queen, visit...
21/11/2023
Yara El Murr from Lebanon is Thomson Foundation's Young Journalist of the Year 2023.
Yara received the honour at the Foreign Press Association Media Award...
17/11/2023
Yashraj Sharma has seen big changes in his life since he won the Thomson Foundation Young Journalist Award in 2022.
In the run up to the 2023 winner being anno...
10/11/2023
Thomson Foundation has joined 16 partner organisations to launch the Paris Charter on AI and Journalism'. The first of its kind, the charter defines crucia...
01/11/2023
Zuha Siddiqui from Pakistan is a labour and tech reporting fellow for the global non-profit publication Rest of World. She's one of three finalists nominate...
01/11/2023
Jamaima Afridi is a freelance journalist based in north-west Pakistan on the edge of the Khyber Pass.
Her stories focus on injustices faced by women and vulne...
01/11/2023
Yara El Murr is a 25-year-old journalist and documentary filmmaker from Lebanon. She is a finalist in Thomson Foundations Young Journalist Award 2023.
The awar...
01/11/2023
Young journalists from more than 60 countries entered this years prestigious Thomson Foundation Young Journalist Award 2023.
Countries from across Africa, Asia...
26/10/2023
The 2023 EU Award for Investigative Journalism has proven to be an exceptional showcase of talent, diversity and shifting journalistic priorities.
More than 20...
16/10/2023
Thomson Foundation is delighted to announce the appointment of two new members to its Board of Trustees - investment expert, author and former financial journal...
12/10/2023
Some of the world's leading foreign correspondents and war crimes investigators have contributed to a set of major new training courses for journalists cove...
05/10/2023
Thomson Foundation is delighted to be one of five new organisations to join Partnership on AI.
Thomson is now one of 114 partner organisations from around the ...
28/09/2023
An astonishing array of talented journalists from around the world have made it through to the shortlist for the Thomson Foundation Young Journalist Award 2023....
18/09/2023
Madhav Chinnappa, the former Director of News Ecosystem Development at Google an...
14/09/2023
Thomson works with journalists in some of the toughest places in the world. Their work and livelihoods are frequently under threat. Thomson Foundation believes ...
05/09/2023
A pioneering system aimed at preventing the spread of disinformation and creating verifiable content from capture to publication is being road tested in a serie...
15/08/2023
To mark the Thomson Foundation's 60th year of nurturing and training journalists globally, we matched six talented young journalists with six of the best in...
07/08/2023
In the autumn of 2022, I was introduced to a young Afghan journalist in London. Zahra Joya had fled Kabul a year before as the Taliban swept through the city. A...
27/07/2023
Pursuing independent journalism is more important than ever. Right now, we are not just facing one or two crises. The crises that journalists are facing are not...
05/07/2023
KC Saranga has trained more than 1,000 journalists, students and people in marginalised communities in Sri Lanka on how to tell stories using their mobile phone...
04/07/2023
A total of 267 applications from 7 countries, representing 125 media outlets and featuring a diverse group of authors (both individuals and groups), have been s...
03/07/2023
Since 2013 our Young Journalist Award has celebrated the outstanding young talent in the media profession. The award is an opportunity for those brilliant young...
28/06/2023
A new project is underway in the Western Balkans to transform digital storytelling and engage public audiences with creative and culture-related content.
Aroun...
19/06/2023
Staying informed about everyday life and events in Ukraine is crucially important for the refugees who have fled the war.
By April 2023, 1.06 million Ukrai...
14/06/2023
Equipped with new investigative journalism skills and financial support after recently completing a training programme, 15 Rwandan journalists are empowered to ...
22/05/2023
The Thomson Foundation is proud to unveil a pioneering free, online training course designed to help newsrooms address a defining issue of the modern age: the e...
12/05/2023
Sixty years after it was founded Thomson Foundation - now joined by the Berlin based Thomson Media, continues to innovate. Its blended approach to life-long lea...
09/05/2023
Journalists from Western Balkans countries and T rkiye are invited to submit their investigative stories for the EU Award for Investigative Journalism 2023.
On...