I was recently listening to a podcast by Jon Toigo (the podcast is currently sponsored by Iron Mountain) where he talks about cloud vs tape backup. The talk covered many interesting considerations about backup and most importantly, recovery and the choice of those two different protection mechanisms. Jon also mentioned IP over Avian Carrier (IPoAC) which is a topic I found intriguing and wanted to explore further in this blog post.
Disaster recovery (DR) is a critical requirement for all companies. Put simply, customers need to copy their information offsite in a timely and reliable manner to protect against significant outages. However, the ability to transfer data to a DR site depends on bandwidth. The less bandwidth, the longer the information movement will take and the more risk a business faces. Similarly, recovery requires data to be transferred back and the slower the transmission speeds, the greater the outage. In short, bandwidth is a critical consideration. Jon Toigo talks about different technologies to address the issue including IPoAC, tape and cloud and I wanted to look at the DR bandwidth implication of each of these.
IPoAC
The idea of IPoAC is to use a carrier pigeon as a medium to send data to a remote site. Amazingly, people have actually tested IPoAC and you can read about it in this Wikipedia article. While IPoAC appears comically complex and entirely unusable in the real world, it is interesting to look at the bandwidth potential of said approach.
The key question that every DR professional has to ask is how long it will take to get your data transferred in the case of a disaster. With IPoAC, we would attach a small USB flash drive to our pigeon and send him/her on his/her way. The good news is that flash drives keep growing in size and the largest I found was 512GB. If we assume that the pigeon flies at about 40 miles per hour and that our DR site is about 80 miles away, it will take 2 hours for our 512GB of data to arrive at the DR site. This equates to about 550 Mb/sec bandwidth. Not bad, really.
We may also want to be extra cautious in our transfers and so we could consider redundant pigeons. A nice benefit is that pigeons require limited power and minimal cooling so the economics would work well too, but we must remember the cost associated with feed and medical care. Furthermore, in certain parts of the country, we have to be concerned that some people may try to shoot down the bird and cook him/her for dinner. (Hence the need for redundancy.)
Cloud
Jon discusses the benefits and potential pitfalls of cloud protection and specifically highlights bandwidth. In the world of cloud, bandwidth is everything since all backups run through the Internet. Thus the time required to backup and recover data is inversely related to the amount of bandwidth. To make matters worse, the amount and availability of bandwidth can also vary based of time of day and network traffic. If we assume that a customer has a T3 (45 Mb/sec) and 512GB of data, then it would take more than a day to transfer the information. Hmmm, the carrier pigeon looks better from a timing standpoint. However, this assumes no data reduction technology.
Iron Mountain's cloud-based backup solutions use unique data reduction algorithms to reduce the required bandwidth. Factoring these technology benefits, the backup and recovery times can be reduced to about 1:20. Clearly that is much better especially when you include the enterprise class security and availability of Iron Mountain's datacenters. Security with IPoAC? Good luck, you are on your own with that one.
Tape
Tape provides a proven methodology for transferring large quantities of data between sites. It has been used consistently for years and the question of bandwidth makes it clear why tape delivers such compelling business value. Simply put, let's run the numbers and see why.
A full Iron Mountain van can hold approximately 5,000 tapes and if we assume LTO-5 (we are being conservative) then we get an effective capacity of 15PB per truck. Assuming that the driver needs to go 80 miles and averages 50 MPH, the resulting travel time is about 1:40 or an equivalent throughput of about 20,000 Gb/sec! Clearly, the bandwidth is massive and is larger than what you can get from virtually anywhere else. (To further blow your mind, we could send two or more vans or even upgrade to LTO-6!) Furthermore, Iron Mountain is on call 247 and so the team is available to deliver this bandwidth on demand at any time.
In summary, there is no doubt that bandwidth is critical when it comes to disaster recovery and users must consider all options to ensure that they can get their businesses back online the case of a disaster. IPoAC provides meaningful bandwidth with significant added complexity and while it is a solution that Mother Nature and perhaps The Audubon Society would love, it is rarely practical. (Maybe if you live on a deserted island, although I question why you would have a datacenter there to begin with.) Cloud and tape-based DR provide meaningful alternative protection solutions that are suited for enterprises of all sizes. It is also clear that tape provides bandwidth that far exceeds other technologies and this is an important illustration why tape maintains its leadership as the DR medium of choice.
Most recent headlines
04/08/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, is excited to announce Santiago Solanas as its new Chief Executive Officer (CEO)....
03/06/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, a...
23/05/2024
Alone Australia continues to build as it movies towards finale
23 May, 2024
Media releases
The program continues to deliver for SBS with significant uplift...
23/05/2024
As the 2023 HPA Awards were taking shape last year, in the aftermath of the pand...
23/05/2024
By HPA Staff
The call for submissions for the HPA Engineering Excellence Awards is already open, and closes soon on June 14; but the submission period for crea...
23/05/2024
PHILADELPHIA Comcast is reporting that it has reduced the electricity it takes to deliver each byte of data across its network by 40% since 2019....
23/05/2024
CARY, N.C. The UKs largest commercial broadcaster ITV has released new details on how it is using an API-driven first-party ad server developed by SAS, to deliv...
23/05/2024
LEAWOOD, Kan. While technology is central to making ATSC 3.0 a success as a means to deliver wireless data, it's only a part of the story....
23/05/2024
MELVILLE, N.Y. Chyron today unlocked a unveiled sweeping improvements to its newsroom portfolio that enable broadcasters to deploy a complete newsroom workflow ...
23/05/2024
Philippe Guillotel, senior director of metavideo group, InterDigital, explains how haptic technology could be the next big thing in watching everything from spo...
23/05/2024
How to color match broadcast cameras
Brie Clayton May 23, 2024
0 Comments
Ever wondered how to color match on two different high end broadcast cameras...
23/05/2024
Chyron Unlocks a Complete Newsroom in the Cloud With News Portfolio Updates
Brie Clayton May 23, 2024
0 Comments
Based on a long-term, coordinated dev...
23/05/2024
NBA legends Dwayne Wade and Carmelo Anthony are helping to promote Inside Out 2, the new film from Disney and Pixar, in commercials that are appearing during th...
23/05/2024
The CW drama Walker will not see a fifth season on the network. Inspired by the 90s crime drama Walker, Texas Ranger, the show premiered in 2021. Jared Padalec...
23/05/2024
The E.W. Scripps Co. named Robin Davis senior VP, chief distribution officer, effective immediately....
23/05/2024
Season two of Mulligan, an animated comedy about people struggling to rebuild the planet after an alien attack, with a star-studded cast and producer group, deb...
23/05/2024
NewsNation expands to a 24/7 programming schedule starting June 1. The network, part of Nexstar Media Group, will launch the final portion of its live news line...
23/05/2024
BrightLine, which provides interactive and shoppable advertising formats, said it launched StreamLine, a self-service system for creating dynamic commercials th...
23/05/2024
Nick Cannon will host a talk show on Prime Video and Amazon Freevee. Called Counsel Culture and based on his podcast of the same name, it premieres June 6. Ther...
23/05/2024
YOKOHAMA, Japan Leader Electronics has expanded the capabilities of its LVB440 IP Analyzer with extended support for the latest standards relating to object-bas...
23/05/2024
Zeenal Thakare, senior vice president, enterprise solutions architecture at Ateliere Creative Technologies, explains why shes enjoying a front row seat to the o...
23/05/2024
The Bill is currently at its third reading stage in the House of Lords
By Jenny Priestley
Published: May 23, 2024
The Bill is currently at its third re...
23/05/2024
SOUTHPORT, Conn. Diamond Sports Group has reached a multi-year renewal of its distribution agreement with FuboTV Inc. for the continued carriage of Diamond'...
23/05/2024
AUSTIN, Texas Brainstorm, a provider of real-time 3D graphics and virtual studio solutions, has opened a new office and Demo Studio in Austin, Texas in a move t...
23/05/2024
WASHINGTON, D.C. As concerns grow about the potential impact of fake AI-generated photos and videos being used to influence elections, Federal Communications Co...
23/05/2024
NEW YORK BrightLine has announced the launch of StreamLine, the self-service, automated tool for clients to design, build, and publish interactive and dynamic a...
23/05/2024
With NCAA college football moving to a new, greatly expanded playoff format for the National Championship this year, ESPN and TNT Sports have reached a five-yea...
23/05/2024
Advanced Systems Group, LLC (ASG), a technology and services provider for media creatives and content owners, launched its AI and Advanced Analytics practice,...
23/05/2024
Glensound, industry leader in high quality audio systems, is exhibiting for the first time at InfoComm 2024. The company is demonstrating why it has such an env...
23/05/2024
Shotoku Broadcast Systems, international manufacturer of high-quality, easy-to-use, robust and reliable camera support systems, has announced plans to exhibit b...
23/05/2024
Based in Scalby Village, Scarborough, Beckview Studios is one of North Yorkshire's largest, one-stop recording studios in the area. Since its opening in May...
23/05/2024
Pixellot, the global leader in AI-automated video and data solutions for sports, is proud to announce a partnership with Tximist Foundation to broadcast all Txi...
23/05/2024
Global video solutions provider, Accedo, has worked with ITV, the UK's largest commercial broadcaster, to bring its streaming service, ITVX to PlayStation 4...
23/05/2024
The Global Media and Entertainment Talent Manifesto, an organisation working to address the skills shortage across the media technology sector, today announces ...
23/05/2024
A trio from WRAL-TV has been honored with a 2024 Regional Edward R. Murrow Award for the WRAL documentary Ghosts in the Stadium. The Radio Television Digital Ne...
23/05/2024
May 23rd, 2024 Press Materials Available Here
TRIBECA FESTIVAL 2024 ANNOUNCES ...
23/05/2024
7 minute read
Share
alt=Telenor Group's Board of Directors has appointed Benedicte Schilbred Fasmer as new President & CEO class=lazyload main main-l...
23/05/2024
Game Pres Glitz: How Allegiant Stadium and the Las Vegas Raiders Shine in the En...
23/05/2024
TNT Sports to Present College Football Playoff Games Through Sublicense with ESP...
23/05/2024
PGA TOUR's Anthony Renda on the Role of Cloud-Based Workflows in Every Shot...
23/05/2024
NCAA Women's Lacrosse National Championship: ESPN To Integrate Goal Cams Int...
23/05/2024
SVG College Sports Media Awards 2024: Winners in Outstanding Social Media Video,...
23/05/2024
Back to All News
Trailer for Joko Anwars Nightmares and Daydreams' Explore...
23/05/2024
Back to All News
What We Watched the Second Half of 2023
Entertainment
23 May 2024
Global
Link copied to clipboard
Today we published our second edition o...
23/05/2024
IBM Security's Martin Borrett shares his thoughts on how cybersecurity will be impacted in the age of generative AI. Please see the full article here in AI ...
23/05/2024
By Christine Purse
One of the most compelling discussions at the 2024 HPA Tech Retreat happened off stage with no audience present. After hours, while the room...
23/05/2024
Photo credit: GETTY IMAGES
Press release - 23 May 2024 10:07
Eutelsat Ku-ba...
23/05/2024
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
The Mauritius Prime Ministers Office (PMO) has c...
23/05/2024
All candidates invited to debate live on the night
As part of RT 's extensi...
I was recently listening to a podcast by Jon Toigo (the podcast is currently sponsored by Iron Mountain) where he talks about cloud vs tape backup. The talk covered many interesting considerations about backup and most importantly, recovery and the choice of those two different protection mechanisms. Jon also mentioned IP over Avian Carrier (IPoAC) which is a topic I found intriguing and wanted to explore further in this blog post.
