AoIP and the road to true IP interoperability
29/08/2019
As IP connectivity becomes increasingly widespread and more accessible to all sectors of our industry, those with their sights set on the true goals of interoperability are working hard to play together. AES67 defines a common language for the streaming of live, high-quality low-latency audio over IP. But what are we doing to manage the transition from traditional connectivity, and how do we achieve the full benefits that have been promised with IP workflows?
A key touted advantage of moving to IP is the ability to use existing network infrastructures and COTS (Commercial-Off-The-Shelf) hardware. Broadcasters want to be able to pass audio, video, control and other data over shared IP networks, and they want to use open standards to do so between devices made by different manufacturers. Standardised IP connectivity eradicates much of the cost, space, system complexity and cabling overhead of having a multitude of interfaces for analogue, AES3, MADI, SDI, etc. This is the goal of both AES67 and ST2110.
AoIP has been around for many years, with lots of broadcasters already relying on it daily to produce live on-air content. In many cases, it's been radio stations that have been pioneering the way in terms of full IP system-wide integration, as well as the linking of geographically remote facilities, with flagship examples like the BBC's Virtual Local Radio (ViLoR) project. This is in part because radio has not been held back by the video over IP debate of ST2022-6 (SDI over IP) vs ST2110 (separate RTP streams for video, AES67-audio and metadata) that has been going on in the TV world. Also, the bandwidth requirements of audio are negligible compared to that of video, making the network infrastructure considerably more affordable.
Although AoIP networking is on the increase, there's still a tendency to go for single-manufacturer solutions, ensuring all the devices have the same parameter set and interpretation of AES67, with the same discovery and connection management methods. This makes successful deployment easier and provides a clear line of technical support from the vendor. However, this leaves broadcasters feeling tied to their investment and it isn't the true goal of IP; if you've bought 10 HP PCs, you would not be concerned about going out and buying a Dell, at least in terms of whether it will be able to access, edit and share the same files. IP broadcast equipment should be no different.
In TV, audio equipment has to interface with a wider range of kit from vendors in different fields, which has highlighted the challenges of interoperability further.
So what's missing? AES67 gives us a standardised protocol and parameter set that means for example a Wheatnet device can exchange audio streams with a Livewire device as both can be configured to operate within the bounds of AES67, though it's not necessarily simple to connect stream connections between different vendors. It typically requires an engineer to configure output streams on each device and often manually entering complex configuration details to be able to receive streams from other devices. While this works reliably, it relies on engineers to set up and it results in a static streaming configuration. For dynamic routing of audio, providing the operational workflows needed for live broadcast, we're still relying on expensive broadcast routers, albeit IP. This is not the goal of using COTS IP.
With AES3, you plug in a BNC, and the receiving device knows it is expecting two channels of audio on that connection. With AoIP, a single connection to a network allows for the exchange of lots of channels of audio with lots of different pieces of equipment, but you can only receive that audio if you know it exists in the first place. The fundamental part missing from both AES67 and ST-2110 is advertisement and connection management. In the absence of an agreed standard, many, but not all vendors have followed the Ravenna approach, which is helpful for advertising AoIP streams between those vendors, but this still leaves us with labour intensive configuration and static streaming connections.
This is where the likes of AIMS (Alliance for IP Media Solutions) and the JT-NM (Joint Task Force on Networked Media) become very important. They are promoting full interoperability including NMOS, a standardised mechanism for not only discovery/advertisement (NMOS IS-04), but also connection management (NMOS IS-05), from a centralised point, meaning you do not have to log in to each device on a network to configure its connections, but instead have a user-friendly UI capable of dynamically routing streams between devices from different manufacturers - using the network to perform the routing function.
NMOS has gained strong buy-in across the industry, from both manufacturers and broadcasters. It's widely seen as the route to true interoperability, but its uptake has been slow in some areas.
As broadcast equipment manufacturers, true interoperability could be perceived as a threat because it increases competition. We defend our market share by making reliable, high performing and easy-to-use products with a feature set designed for live broadcast applications, not by needlessly implementing proprietary or unique methods. To unlock the full potential of IP and give broadcasters the workflows, costs and efficiency savings they need to compete in the modern broadcast era, we must all work together, fully and properly implementing the agreed standards to provide proven multi-vendor systems that are easy for operational staff to use. At Calrec we are working with our partners and following the JT-NM roadmap - our Type R, IP-native radio system being a prime example working towards the ultimate goals of making life better for our customers.
LINK: | https://calrec.com/blog/aoip-and-the-road-to-true-ip-interoperability/... |
See more stories from calrec |
More from Calrec
25/03/2024
NEP Australia expands IP and remote production with Calrec Argo
NEP Australia expands its IP and remote production capabilities with first install of Calrec Argo consoles NEP Australia, a division of NEP Group and a prominen...
25/03/2024
NAB 2024 Preview | Why attend NAB 24?
NAB 2024 Preview | April 14 -17 | Booth C6307 | Las Vegas Convention Center We're looking forward to meeting up with customers and partners at the 2024 NAB ...
11/12/2023
How I won a Sports Emmy Award for supporting FOX Sports
The show must go on: How I won a Sports Emmy Award for Calrec's work supporting FOX Sports' presentation of FIFA World Cup Qatar 2022 By Elliot Rober...
16/11/2023
Calrec's Argo Wins 2023 NAB Show Product of the Year Award
Calrec's Argo Wins 2023 NAB Show Product of the Year Award Calrec has won the 2023 NAB Show Product of the Year Award for its configurable Argo audio contr...
27/10/2023
An Insightful Look into the World of Calrec
An Insightful Look into the World of Calrec By Will Wayman Before going to Calrec I was excited and looking forward to the many experiences I would be able to...
08/10/2023
Calrec finds new zeal and expertise with Protel
Calrec finds new zeal and expertise with Protel...
08/10/2023
Group One partners with AVL Group in Puerto Rico
Group One extends its relationship with Puerto Rico's AVL Group Calrec distribution partner Group One has teamed up with supply and service specialists AVL ...
08/10/2023
Group One invest in IP with new Calrec technical support hires
Expanding on its already robust technical support team and further investing in IP, Group One, professional audio and lighting distributor of Audiotonix brands ...
08/10/2023
IP specialist Tim Casey joins Group One
Group One expands its Support team with IP specialist Tim Casey Group One has hired Tim Casey to join its growing team of Calrec Customer Support Technicians in...
08/10/2023
EMG UK chooses Calrec for ROC
EMG UK flexes with Calrec for its Stratford Remote Operations Centre Expanding on its 30-year relationship with Calrec to satisfy its complex audio needs, OB an...
08/10/2023
IBC 2023: 6 reasons to join Calrec at IBC
IBC 2023 Preview | 15 18 September | Hall 8, Booth D60 | RAI, Amsterdam We're looking forward to meeting up with friends, customers and partners at the I...
08/10/2023
Calrec launches into the German market via a new partnership with Cerberus
IBC 2023 sees Calrec announce its launching into German market for the first time via a new partnership with Cerberus Media Solutions At IBC 2023, Calrec, a lea...
07/10/2023
EMG Stratford ROC
EMG UK flexes with Calrec for its Stratford Remote Operations Centre Expanding on its 30-year relationship with Calrec to satisfy its complex audio needs, OB an...
07/10/2023
NEP goes remote with ImPulse
NEP flexes its remote capabilities with Calrec's IP ImPulse engine NEP Group, the leading media technology partner for content creators around the globe, is...
07/10/2023
INA TV kick off world cup with Calrec
Greece-based INA TV used Calrec's Summa console and Hydra2 networking technology to satisfy the complex UEFA technical specifications to broadcast European ...
07/10/2023
Calrec partners with AV Worx to expand its presence in South Africa
Calrec partners with AV Worx to expand its presence in South Africa Calrec, a leading designer and supplier of broadcast audio mixing consoles and equipment, a...
05/10/2023
NAB New York 2023 Preview
NAB New York 2023 Preview |October 25 -26 | Level 3, Booth 217 | Javits Center, New York We're looking forward to meeting up with customers and partners at...
04/10/2023
Inside Broadcast Hungary's 4K Outside Broadcast Truck
Inside Broadcast Hungary's 4k Outside Broadcast Truck Last month at IBC, KitPlus sat down with Calrec's International Sales Manager, Michael Reddick to ...
03/08/2023
Join our quest
We have big news! Calrec has always been on a quest to solve tomorrow's audio challenges, and we have some big news to share on the Calrec booth in Hall 8, ...
03/08/2023
NAB 2023 Preview
NAB 2023 Preview | April 16 -19 | Booth C6107 | Las Vegas Convention Center We're looking forward to meeting up with customers and partners at the 2023 NAB ...
01/06/2023
Inside SuperSport's New 4K Outside Broadcast Truck
Inside SuperSport's New 4K Outside Broadcast Truck Take a look inside one of the most advanced outside broadcast (OB) trucks in the world! SuperSport's...
28/04/2023
Join Calrec at MPTS 2023
Join Calrec at MPTS 2023 | May 10-11 | Stand A40 | Olympia, London We're looking forward to meeting up with customers and partners at this year's Media ...
27/03/2023
Calrec Wins Media & Entertainment Best in Market 2022 Awards
Calrec Wins Media & Entertainment: Best in Market 2022 Awards for Argo We are delighted to have been selected as one of the winners in this year's Media & ...
15/03/2023
The Super Bowl by Shawn Peacock
The Super Bowl by Shawn Peacock Shawn Peacock, Broadcast Audio Engineer A1 for over 20 years, encompassing college football, X Games, tennis and motorsports inc...
21/02/2023
Calrec makes switching to ST2110 more affordable with ImPulse1
Calrec makes switching to ST2110 more affordable with ImPulse1 IP engine Following on from its new Argo audio mixing control platform launched at IBC 2022, Cal...
23/12/2022
The Audio Checklist by Freelance A1 Andrew Stoakley
The Audio Checklist by Freelance A1, Andrew Stoakley Over the course of interviewing, recording and editing my podcast series, Idle Hands: Conversations with T...
03/10/2022
Audiotonix Gets Even More Creative with Slate Digital Acquisition
About Audiotonix Audiotonix is a global market leader in the design, engineering and manufacturing of professional audio mixing consoles and ancillary products...
02/09/2022
IBC 2022: 10 reasons to join Calrec at IBC
IBC 2022: 10 reasons to join us at IBC We're back! It's been three years since we've been to IBC 2022, and we can't wait to get back into it w...
15/07/2022
A Statement from Calrec
Statement from Calrec July 2022 Recently we have received many comments via social media that mistakenly claim Calrec are in some way supporting Russian state...
14/07/2022
NAB 2022 Preview
We're excited to be back at the NAB Show in Las Vegas on 23-27th April. Here is a sneak preview of what we will be unveiling!...
08/07/2022
Sounding out the future
Sounding out the future I don't know what the future may hold, but I know who holds the future. Ralph Abernathy By Madison O'Reilly...
30/05/2022
ABEX 2022
One of our International Sales Managers recently attended the ABEX 2022 Morava Montreux 2022, an international electronic media and television conference in M...
01/04/2022
Star Acadmie TVA
Jean-S bastien Roy, Sound Engineer at Headroom Productions talks to Calrec about his work on Star Acad mie on TVA in Montreal, Canada. As a Sound Engineer and ...
31/03/2022
Craft Interview: Myles Carlyle, Audio Engineer
Canada-based Myles Carlyle was exposed to the world of broadcast audio at a young age. As an audio engineer, he mixes a variety of live sports and worked at the...
17/03/2022
Audio in 2021: The future is now
Audio in 2021: The future is now By Dave Letson, VP of Sales, Calrec 2020 was a year of necessity; of using technology in ways it had been designed for and so...
16/03/2022
Calrec IP Primer
IP Primer Welcome to Calrec's eight-part primer on AoIP! The IP Primer builds up your knowledge of IP and will enable you to create reliable AoIP networks...
09/03/2022
Calrec IP Primer: Network Design
Calrec IP Primer Part 8: Network Design Welcome to the final chapter in an eight-part series of articles on AoIP! Over the last 7 weeks, we have released an I...
03/03/2022
Calrec IP Primer: Network Switches
Calrec IP Primer Part 7: Network Switches Welcome to the seventh in an eight-part series of articles on AoIP! Over the last 6 weeks, we have released an IP ch...
23/02/2022
Calrec IP Primer: Quality of Service QoS
Calrec IP Primer Part 6: Quality of Service (QoS) Welcome to the sixth in an eight-part series of articles on AoIP! Over the next three weeks, we will be rele...
16/02/2022
Calrec IP Primer: Latency and Jitter
Calrec IP Primer Part 5: Latency/Jitter Welcome to the fifth in an eight-part series of articles on AoIP! Over the next four weeks, we will be releasing an I...
10/02/2022
Calrec IP Primer: Bandwidth
Calrec IP Primer Part 4: Bandwidth Welcome to the fourth in an eight-part series of articles on AoIP! Over the next five weeks, we will be releasing an IP cha...
02/02/2022
Calrec IP Primer: Precision Time Protocol PTP
Calrec IP Primer Part 3: PTP Welcome to the third in an eight-part series of articles on AoIP! Over the next six weeks, we will be releasing an IP chapter eve...
26/01/2022
Calrec IP Primer: Multicast
Calrec IP Primer Part 2: Multicast Welcome to the second in an eight-part series of articles on AoIP! Over the next seven weeks, we will be releasing an IP ch...
19/01/2022
Calrec IP Primer: Introduction
Calrec IP Primer Part 1: Introduction Welcome to the first in an eight-part series of articles on AoIP! Over the next eight weeks, we will be releasing an IP ...
06/01/2022
Calrec's IP solution selected for state-of-the-art Sportsnet Studios
Calrec's IP solution selected for state-of-the-art Sportsnet Studios Two Calrec Artemis consoles with AoIP ImPulse cores and Gateway technology lie at the h...
16/12/2021
Ross Production Services choose Calrec for all live and esports output
Ross Production Services (RPS) recently purchased its fifth 96-channel Calrec Brio audio console to standardize on Calrec technology. The new Brio is installed ...
26/11/2021
IBC 2021 Cancelled: Calrec's 7 Key Focuses
IBC 2021 Cancelled: Although we can't meet in person, we can still have a chat Get in touch for a catch-up, or book a remote demo with Calrec's broadca...
24/11/2021
IBC 2021: 7 magnificent reasons to speak to Calrec
Not travelling to IBC 2021? We can still have a chat. Get in touch, or book a remote demo with Calrec's broadcast specialists, to get up close and personal...
23/11/2021
7 magnificent reasons to speak to Calrec
Not travelling to IBC 2021? We can still have a chat. Get in touch, or book a remote demo with Calrec's broadcast specialists, to get up close and personal...