Sony Digital Rapids Pixel Power calrec Sony

Friday Tip - Panning Laws: Why They Matter

05/07/2019

Spoiler alert: We'll get into some rocket science stuff here, which probably doesn't affect your projects much anyway so if you prefer something with a more musical vibe, come back next week. But to dispel some of the confusion regarding an oft-misunderstood concept, keep reading.

You pan a mono signal from left to right. Simple, right? Actually, no. In the center, there's a 3 dB RMS volume buildup because the same signal is in both channels. Ideally, you want the signal's average level-its power-to have the same perceived volume, whether the sound is panned left, right, or center. Dropping the level when centered by 3 dB RMS accomplishes this. As a result, traditional hardware mixers tapered the response as you turned a panpot to create this 3 dB dip.

However, there are other panning protocols. (Before your head explodes, please note you don't need to learn all this stuff-it's just to give you an idea of the complexity of pan laws, because all we really need to do is understand how things work in Studio One.) For example, some engineers preferred more of a drop in the center, so that audio panned to the sides would pop more due to the higher level, and open up more space in the center for vocals, kick, and bass. You could accomplish the same result by adjusting the channel level and pan, but the additional drop was sort of like having a preference you didn't need to think about. To complicate matters further, some mixers lowered the center signal compared to the sides, while others raised the side signals compared to the center. If a DAW does the latter, when you import a normalized file and pan it hard left or hard right, it will go above 0 and clip.

But wait! There's more. Some engineers didn't want equal power over the panpot's entire travel, but a slightly different curve. Others wanted a linear change that didn't dip the signal at all.

Fortunately, Studio One has a rational approach to pan laws, namely

The panpots in Studio Once's channels default to the traditional 3 dB dip, so there's perceived constant level as you pan a mono signal from left to right. For stereo, they act as a balance control.

Although most programs set the pan law as a global preference, Studio One includes the Dual Pan plug-in, which offers five different pan laws. This lets different channels follow different pan laws.

THE WHAT-THE-HECK-DO-PAN-LAWS-DO TEST SETUP

To see how the different panning laws affect signal levels, I created a test setup (Fig. 1) with a mono track fed by the Tone Generator set to a sine wave. Two pre-fader sends went to two buses, each with a Dual Pan inserted and linked for mono. That way, one bus's Dual Pan could be set for hard pan and the other bus's Dual Pan for center, to compare what happens to the signal level.

Figure 1: Test setup to determine how different pan laws affect signal levels.

In all the following test result images, Track 1 shows the mono sine wave at 0 dB, Bus 1 shows the result of panning the Dual Pan full left, and Bus 2 shows the result of panning the Dual Pan to center.

Fig. 2 uses the -3dB Constant Power Sin/Cos setting for the Dual Pans. Note that the centered version in Bus 2 is 3 dB below the same signal panned full left. This is the same setting as the default for the channel panpots. However, if you collapse the output signal to mono, you'll get a 3 dB center-channel buildup. (A fine point: setting the Main bus mode to mono affects signals leaving the main bus; the meters still show the incoming signal. To see what's happening when you collapse the Main out to mono, you need to insert a Dual Pan in the Main bus, click on Link, and set all controls to center.)

Figure 2: -3dB Constant Power Sin/Cos pan law.

Fig. 3 uses the -6 dB linear curve. Here, the centered signal is -6 dB below the signal panned hard left. Use this curve if the signal is going to be collapsed to mono after the main bus, because it keeps the gain constant when you collapse stereo to mono by eliminating the +3 dB increase that would happen otherwise.

Figure 3: The -6 dB linear curve is often preferable if you're mixing in stereo, but also anticipate that the final result will end up being collapsed to mono.

Fig. 4 shows the resulting signal from the 0dB Balanced Sin/Cos setting. There's no bump or decrease compared to the centered signal, so this acts like a balance control with a constant amount of gain as you pan from left to right.

Figure 4: 0dB Balanced Sin/Cos acts like a balance control.

Sharp-eyed readers who haven't dozed off yet may have noticed we haven't covered two variations on the curves described so far. -3dB Constant Power Sqrt (Fig. 5; Sqrt stands for Square Root) is like the 3 dB Constant Power Sin/Cos, but the curve is subtly different.

Figure 5: -3dB Constant Power Sqrt bends the curve shape slightly compared to the other Constant Power curve.

In this example, the panpot is set to 75% left instead of full left. Bus 1 shows what happens with -3dB Constant Power Sin/Cos, while Bus 2 is the Sqrt version. The Sqrt version is in less of a hurry to attenuate the right channel as you pan toward the left. Some engineers feel this more closely the situation in a space that's not acoustically treated, so there's a natural acoustic center buildup.

Finally, Fig. 6 compares the 0 dB Balance variations, sin/cos and linear.

Figure 6: Comparing the two 0 dB Balance pan law options.

The difference is similar to the Constant Power examples, in that the basic idea is the same, but again, the linear version doesn't attenuate the right channel as rapidly when you pan left.

I HAVEN'T FALLEN ASLEEP YET, SO PLEASE, JUST TELL ME WHAT I SHOULD USE!

The bottom line is when using the channel panpot with a mono track, if you live in a stereo mixdown world the above is
LINK: https://blog.presonus.com/index.php/2019/07/05/friday-tip-panning-laws...
See more stories from presonus

More from PreSonus

24/01/2020

Komplete Kontrol Integration in Studio One, Part 2/3: General-Purpose MIDI Control

In Part 1 ( A New Hope ) of the NI Kontroller trilogy, we covered how to integra...

21/01/2020

Paul Drew + The Studio (One) Rats

The Studio Rats The Studio Rats are a band hailing from the UK, led by none other than our good friend Mr. Paul Drew; a longtime Studio One user. About the man...

17/01/2020

Komplete Kontrol Integration in Studio One, Part 1/3

Studio One 4.53 introduced integration with Native Instruments' Komplete series of keyboards, which is a big deal. Although these keyboards are theoreticall...

16/01/2020

Introducing ioStation24c

ioStation24c: The collaborative partner for the solo artist. When you're a solo artist, you have to be more than just creative to realize your vision-you m...

15/01/2020

Celebrating 25 years of PreSonus

Let's take a minute to look at all the firsts PreSonus has had in our first 25 years, from 1995-2020. It's been quite a ride, and we've been glad to...

14/01/2020

Using StudioLive Series III in the Studio

Let's take a closer look at the Studio in StudioLive, with special guest host Matt Osgood! In this six-video series, Matt covers everything from basic s...

13/01/2020

Welcome Joe Gilder to the PreSonus Fam!

Please join us in welcoming the esteemed Joe Gilder to the PreSonus family! He has a new Studio One playlist full of tips started with more episodes to come! C...

11/01/2020

How to Play Faster-By Playing Slower

In the comments for last week's tip on varipseed-type formant changes, reader Randy Hayes asked if it was possible to change the tempo similarly so that you...

10/01/2020

FREE CDL Speaker Covers!

Starting now through the month of March 2020, get a FREE speaker cover when you buy any CDL Loudspeaker! Our award-winning CDL Loudspeakers come with a six-yea...

03/01/2020

Varispeed-Type Formant Changes

Back in the days of tape, when dinosaurs ruled the earth and gas station attendants checked your oil, variable-speed tape recorders allowed changing the pitch o...

30/12/2019

Bi-Amping the Ampire

I'm still wrapping my head around PreSonus giving us amp sims that are light years beyond the original Ampire in a free update and also making them availabl...

28/12/2019

Notion WINS KVR Readers' Choice Award!

We're honored to close out the decade with a win from KVR Audio for Favorite Notation Software voted on by their readers! Thanks to everyone who voted. Chee...

26/12/2019

Notions WINS KVR Readers' Choice Award!

We're honored to close out the decade with a win from KVR Audio for Favorite Notation Software voted on by their readers! Thanks to everyone who voted. Chee...

24/12/2019

The Force is (Studio) One with Maarten Vorwerk

We had the recent opportunity to talk with Maarten Vorwerk about how he's been using Studio One for his studio work and he was kind enough to share these in...

20/12/2019

The Vinyliser FX Chain

Nostalgic for vinyl? Miss the glorious sound of dragging a rock through yards of plastic, the wild frequency response gyrations of analog RIAA curve filters, th...

18/12/2019

Hzel Talks Studio One

H zel is a Grammy-nominated producer, sound designer and mixer based in Melbourne, Australia who has been in the music industry for about 15 years and have work...

14/12/2019

Resonator FX Chain

This FX Chain complements the Tightener FX Chain presented in the October 25, 2019 Friday Tip. Whereas the Tightener reduces the presence of the key center in a...

10/12/2019

Studio One 4.6-what's new

Studio One 4.6 is here! To get it, launch Studio One and click check for updates from the help drop-down menu. What's new in 4.6 We've responded to...

06/12/2019

Track Matching with the Project Page

Okay, this is an unusual one. Please fasten your seat belts, and set your tray tables to the upright and locked positions. Personal bias alert: With pop and ro...

06/12/2019

Tommy Finke Talks Theater, EDM and Studio One!

Tommy Finke, also known as T.D. Finck von Finckenstein, is a singer-songwriter as well as a composer of electronic computer music, theatre music, and modern dan...

03/12/2019

Friday Studio One Tip: Virtual Nashville Tuning

Nashville tuning is a popular sound for rhythm guitar parts, and not just in country music: a few hit songs with Nashville tuning include Wild Horses (Rolling S...

29/11/2019

Christmas CashBack 2019

Christmas CashBack Promo 29th Nov 31st Dec. Happy Holidays! We're extending a special Christmas Cashback offer to customers in Austria, Belgium, Eston...

25/11/2019

Studio One Black Friday Sale! (and Notion)

This offer includes upgrades but excludes crossgrades and EDU licensing-ends December 1, 2019. Available worldwide right out of the PreSonus Shop and at your fa...

25/11/2019

Black Friday - Biggest Savings of the Year!

It's finally here! Take advantage of the deepest discounts of the year during Black Friday week. Click here to shop! 50% Off Studio One and Notion. Novemb...

22/11/2019

The Studio One Stereo Separator

A couple previous tips dealt with how to give mono instruments, like guitar, a stereo image that won't degrade when collapsed to mono. Widen Your Mono Guita...

22/11/2019

Ari Ahrendt's Pure Synthetic Drums

Photo: Matthias Baumgartner Hi, mein Name ist Ari Ahrendt und ich bin der Macher der Pure Synthetic Drums. Bei PreSonus tagsu ber als Quality Specialist, ku m...

22/11/2019

Introducing Ari Ahrendt's Pure Synthetic Drums

Photo: Matthias Baumgartner Hi, My name is Ari and I'm the creator of Pure Synthetic Drums. In my day job, I'm a Quality Assurance Specialist at PreSo...

16/11/2019

HD7 Promo

From Nov. 1 2019 until Dec. 31, 2019, we're offering a free set of HD7 Headphones with new purchases of Studio C Series Interfaces to customers in select re...

16/11/2019

Molly and Denton Making Jams in the Red Stick!

One of the best things about PreSonus is having our roots run deep into the heart of the Louisiana music scene. Louisiana has long known that the things that ma...

15/11/2019

How to Use FX Chain Transition Curves

FX Chains are a powerful Studio One feature, yet I can't help but notice that when I write tips about FX Chains, some people are lost without a download so ...

14/11/2019

How to get multiple outputs from Kontakt in PreSonus Studio One

In this video, Gregor shows you how to set up multiple outputs in a single Native Instruments Kontakt instance. Fortunately, this is extremely easy to do in Stu...

13/11/2019

PreSonus CDLs Headline at Spasskaya Tower in Moscow!

Spasskaya Tower is an annual music festival held in Moscow, Russia. It's a spectacular, week-long event, staged on the background of the monumental walls of...

09/11/2019

Football, Podcasts and Studio One

Over here stateside, Tis the season for family, over-eating, traveling, watching football, and more eating. You may not be a huge fan of the holidays, but I lo...

08/11/2019

Sound Design? Commitment Recording? Say What?

Maybe it's not a well-known feature, but Studio One allows inserting effects or FX Chains before a track, not just in a track. Open up the Input section, an...

07/11/2019

All Fat Channel Plugins and Bundles are 30% Off All Month!

Click to Shop! For this month only, SAVE 30% on the entire Fat Channel Collection right out of the PreSonus Shop! Buy the individual plug-ins at a discounted p...

07/11/2019

A Solid Deal - Save 30% on ALL MVP Loops!

For ONE month only, SAVE 30% on ALL MVP Loops right out of the PreSonus Shop! Sale prices start at only $20USD! MVP Loops provide some of our most popular, to...

01/11/2019

The VoxTool FX Chain

Y'all seem to like FX Chains, so here's one of my favorites-the VoxTool, a toolchest for bringing out the best in vocals and narration as quickly as pos...

31/10/2019

Studio One Tutorials!

These PreSonus Studio One Tutorials starring Gregor Beyerle will help you learn how to make beats on Studio One and more! You'll find everything you need ...

28/10/2019

Nigel Trego of DMT Productions: Commited to The StudioLive Series III Ecosystem

Nigel of DMT Productions [This just in from Nigel of DMT Productions!] Hi everyone, my name is Nigel Trego, I am the Technical Director at DMT Productions, a ...

26/10/2019

Tighten Mixes with the Tightener FX Chain

Sometimes when you're mixing, sounds conflict because they have too much energy in the same part of the spectrum. The usual solutions are to lower the level...

25/10/2019

New Arcades and Studio One!

Instagram isn't just for cute, filtered images of yourself and your dog or gear! It's a great community uniting musicians and artists brave enough to pu...

25/10/2019

A Special Treat 50% OFF the Audio Batch Converter for 7 Days only!

Click here to shop! For the next 7 days, SAVE 50% on one of the PreSonus Shop's top-selling add-ons, the Audio Batch Converter! Audio Batch Converter is a...

25/10/2019

Jonny Doyle of DMT Productions: Commited to The StudioLive Series III Ecosystem

Nigel of DMT Productions [This just in from Nigel of DMT Productions!] Hi everyone, my name is Nigel Trego, I am the Technical Director at DMT Productions, a ...

24/10/2019

Free e-bass bundle

Get lots of electric bass-four instruments in all-for FREE! A $99 USD value! Ends Nov. 22, 2019. These recordings of a real-deal 1970s P-bass have been recorde...

23/10/2019

OS X 10.15 Catalina Updates

Hey PreSonus users! We released a few updates today in support of Apple OS X 10.15 Catalina that we would like to tell you about. Universal Control v3.1.1, Cap...

19/10/2019

Double Guitar with Faux Bass

This technique dates back to when I was doing live gigs with Brian Hardgroove from Public Enemy-me on guitar, him on drums. Since there was no bass player, we n...

17/10/2019

WAVE AKADEMIE was a blast!

On October 11, our own Software Specialist Gregor Beyerle attended WAVE AKADEMIE Berlin's Dissertation Presentation of Audio Engineering and 3-D/Game Design...

16/10/2019

How to Create Compelling Mixes in Studio One-New from Craig Anderton

Available NOW at shop.presonus.com from Craig Anderton How to Create Compelling Mixes in Studio One! This is Craig's third book on Studio One, and it weig...

15/10/2019

FaderPort 16 went to Rock in Rio with Helloween!

[This just in from Charlie Bauerfeind, producer for genre-defining power metal pioneers, Helloween! In his search for the perfect DAW Controller for his ultra-c...

11/10/2019

Friday Tip: Percussion Part Generator

Just as we can use plug-ins to process audio, Studio One's Note FX are plug-ins for MIDI data. They tend to be overshadowed by our shiny audio plug-ins, but...