The facts of the case
The case concerns the use of a 2-minute long promotional video clip about water pollution, created by BestWater International, which produces and sells water filters. The video appeared on YouTube, apparently without knowledge or authorisation by BestWater, and was used by a competitor, who linked to the clip by means of framing , thereby making the clip visible on its own website. BestWater claimed copyright infringement of its clip and sought an injunction from the German courts. The defendant had meanwhile voluntarily ceased the use of the clip and the procedure was therefore limited to the restitution of damages.
The question referred to the CJEU by the German Supreme Court
Does the embedding, within one's own website, of another person's work made available to the public on a third-party website, in circumstances such as those in the main proceedings, constitute communication to the public within the meaning of Article 3(1) of the 2001 Copyright Directive (2001/29/EC), even where that other person's work is not thereby communicated to a new public and the communication of the work does not use a specific technical means which differs from that of the original communication?
In the Svensson case (C 466/12), where the European Court ruled on (mere) hyperlinking, the question of whether the link created the impression that the framed work would be appearing on the third party's website (thus concealing its original website) was held as not relevant. The Court held the decisive issue to be the same in the BestWater case, prompting it to answer negatively.
The framing of a work (or other protected material) which is freely available on a publicly accessible website is thus allowed, unless it is directed at a different audience than originally intended or is communicated (to the same audience or not) by using different technical means.
Comments
The Courts decision raises several issues and questions remain unaddressed.
First of all, one would have hoped that the Court had seized this opportunity to differentiate its reasoning in the Svensson case and clearly distinguish between (mere) hyperlinking and framing. In the Svensson case, the Court determined that any form of hyperlink is in principle subject to the communication to the public right unless there is no new public . This reasoning seems very far-reaching given that a hyperlink is, as such, no more than a technical tool to switch from one URL address to another. By contrast, the framing technique (in particular of audio or video streams provided by another website) is markedly different from hyperlinking, because in this case the end-user is not directed to the webpage where the original content is placed. That makes this type of communication more clearly an economic form of exploitation, which is a crucial distinction. This follows on from the Courts decision in the TVCatchup case (C-607/11), where for the question whether the third-party's re-use of a broadcast programme was a communication under Art. 3 of the 2001 Copyright Directive the question of a "new public" was not held relevant.
Moreover, it is difficult to accept the idea that a general allowance for embedding or framing protected material found elsewhere on the Internet would create the possibility of unauthorised usage, going far beyond the boundaries of any limitation or exception under copyright. In particular, the lawful quotation of another's work is subject to relatively strict conditions. These are tested by the special characteristics of the Internet, but the careful legislative balance underlying the quotation exception is bypassed entirely if third-party use is simply not held to be a relevant act of communication. It would have been more appropriate to consider that embedding or framing are always copyright relevant communications and lawful only to the extent that their use is in line with the requirements of the quotation exception.
Secondly, the question of whether embedding copyrighted videos available on the Internet would ever be tantamount to copyright infringement remains open in cases where the source video was uploaded without permission of the right owner.
In this particular context, it is remarkable that the Court recognised, but did not validate, the BestWater's claim that it had not authorised the clip to be uploaded on YouTube, as this fact could, and arguably should, have been taken into account for the question of a new public . Also, the wording of the request for a preliminary ruling by the German Supreme Court explicitly referred to the given circumstances of the actual case. Did the Court wish to indicate that as long as the copyright owner had not ordered YouTube to take the clip down it was considered tolerated and thereby lawfully available for everyone's free (embedding) use? And what if, though such a take-down order had been given, the clip re-appeared on YouTube or any other social network, as is often the case? It is difficult to imagine that the Court wished to suggest that the lawfulness of the first uploading of the original content is entirely irrelevant.
Finally, the lawfulness of embedding copyright-protected content subject to conditional access, e.g. the website hosting the source video was protected by a technological measure designed to prevent or restrict access, was not addressed. The C More Entertainment case (C-279/13) which involves such situation is still pending before the European Court.
Share this page on
--
Most recent headlines
04/08/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, is excited to announce Santiago Solanas as its new Chief Executive Officer (CEO)....
03/06/2024
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, a...
28/04/2024
Mediahaus delivers the first SRT live-streaming sports production over 5G with U...
25/04/2024
Sundance Institute Founder Robert Redford during a press conference at the 1996 ...
25/04/2024
alt= class=wp-image-12361 data-lazy-src=/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/NAB-booth-2024-960x540-1.jpg/> Set against a vibrant backdrop of innovation and collaboratio...
25/04/2024
alt= class=wp-image-12356 data-lazy-src=/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/NAB-mod-win-960x540-1.jpg/>NAB's Eric Trabb (right) awards SNS with two NAB Show Product...
25/04/2024
PHILADELPHIA Comcast beat earnings estimates in its Q1 2024 financial report, as streaming losses continued to decline and Peacock's paid subscribers spiked...
25/04/2024
SEATTLE The Seattle Kraken have inked new multi-year agreements with Tegna and Prime Video that will expand access to their games over broadcast stations and st...
25/04/2024
M2A Medias Matt Hughes asks, is it time for news broadcasting to shift to the cloud?
By Contributor
Published: April 25, 2024
M2A Media's Matt Hughes ...
25/04/2024
Cintel Scanner G3 HDR Restores Egypt's Cinema Treasures to Their Former Glo...
25/04/2024
Sinclair Broadcast Group said it named Kevin Coskren chief meteorologist at KTUL, its ABC affiliate in Tulsa, Oklahoma....
25/04/2024
The Business of TV News, a new one-day event featuring Martha Raddatz, Shannon Bream, Glenn Kirschner and other major figures in television news, happens at Hot...
25/04/2024
Conditions put on the proposed sale of WADL Detroit, to Mission Broadcasting have created a potential drama in the Motor City....
25/04/2024
TelevisaUnivision reported a $52 million loss in the first quarter, up from $3 m...
25/04/2024
Comcast reported flat first-quarter earnings as it reduced the red ink at Peacock but continued to lose video and broadband customers....
25/04/2024
Music-video network Vevo said it launched its app on Telly, the company offering consumers free dual-screen TVs in return for data about what they're watchi...
25/04/2024
Future Today said it has introduced a redesigned user interface for about half of its 300 streaming apps, including Fawesome, HappyKids and iFood.TV....
25/04/2024
The writer and director of a hit Czech series tell Robert Shepherd about their approach to portraying real-life Pakistani kidnappings on the small screen, while...
25/04/2024
Notorious DIT will work with the Liverpool Film Office to increase opportunities for regional talent
By Matthew Corrigan
Published: April 25, 2024
Notorio...
25/04/2024
Broadpeak , a leading provider of content delivery network (CDN) and video streaming solutions for content providers and pay-TV operators worldwide, announced t...
25/04/2024
Lightware Visual Engineering, a leading manufacturer of connectivity solutions for the professional integrated systems market and a pioneer in signal management...
25/04/2024
Net Insight has entered into a collaboration with DMC Production that positions Net Insight at the forefront of sports broadcasting in the Nordics. Net Insight ...
25/04/2024
GlobalM has announced a strategic partnership with scoopa, the specialists in broadcast-quality content distribution, offering a complementary service for live ...
25/04/2024
PlayBox Neo announces the completion of a new multichannel playout system for the DDish direct-to-home satellite television network in Mongolia. Based in the na...
25/04/2024
Canadian music producer and engineer Garth Richardson also known as Gggarth due to his stutter - has embraced immersive audio by installing a PMC monitoring s...
25/04/2024
Leading video software provider Synamedia today announced that Televisa, the Mexican telecommunications and broadcasting company, has chosen Synamedia as its pa...
25/04/2024
OTTera, a leading provider of end-to-end OTT and FAST channel solutions, proudly announces its strategic partnership with ThinkAnalytics, a global leader in adv...
25/04/2024
The American Tobacco Campus will be hopping with activity tonight and this weekend with two fun events!
Durham Night Market
At last! The Durham Night Market i...
25/04/2024
WEST CHESTER, Pa. Video commerce provider Qurate Retail Group has launched The Big Dish, a new culinary-themed FAST channel on The Roku Channel....
25/04/2024
LOS ANGELES The Hollywood Professional Association has announced that submissions for the 2024 HPA Engineering Excellence Awards are now being accepted. This re...
25/04/2024
NEW YORK The digital media measurement and analytics firm DoubleVerify has announced that it has received Media Rating Council (MRC) accreditation for Video Vie...
25/04/2024
SAN FRANCISCO Fox Corp.'s ad-supported streaming service Tubi has announced a licensing agreement with the sports platform DAZN that will see DAZN Ringside ...
25/04/2024
NEW YORK In the runup to the 2024 IAB NewFronts, the IAB has announced three key appointments to its leadership team....
25/04/2024
Epic Games releases Unreal Engine 5.4 with new Motion Design Mode, Unreal VCam f...
25/04/2024
Content Creation, Production, Distribution Is In a State of Flux
Andy Marken April 24, 2024
0 Comments
My empathy is creeping towards what I would de...
25/04/2024
The Carolina Panthers and Capitol Broadcasting Company (CBC) announced they have...
25/04/2024
Berklee Student Riko Sasaski Named 2024 Yamaha Young Performing Artist The accomplished saxophonist secured a spot among the elite winners of this year's ...
25/04/2024
Stations everywhere take pride in having a main anchor who comes from the market they represent. That applies in St. Louis, too, but it also pertains to general...
25/04/2024
Edward Moody is joining the WBTW Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, anchor crew, and will anchor the 5, 6 and 11 p.m. newscasts alongside Trish Williford. He comes f...
25/04/2024
MTV said the 2024 Video Music Awards will return to New York and take place at the new UBS Arena....
25/04/2024
Season three of comedy The Outlaws premieres on Prime Video May 31. Stephen Merchant co-created the show, and stars. There are five episodes....
25/04/2024
The E.W. Scripps Co. is evaluating offers for Bounce, its multicast channel for African-American viewers, according to a report from CNBC....
25/04/2024
Paramount Plus has ordered a second season for Dora, the animated preschool show based on Dora the Explorer. The show, featuring Dora on a rainforest adventure ...
25/04/2024
April 25th, 2024 Press Materials Available Here
TRIBECA FESTIVAL 2024 ANNOUNCES AUDIO STORYTELLING AND GAMES LINEUP
Audio Storytelling Program Features 10th ...
25/04/2024
NFL Draft 2024: Verizon Expands Broadband Capacity To Handle the Spike in Demand Mobile cells will help accommodate first responders, social media, sports betti...
25/04/2024
NFL Draft 2024: NFL Media Teams With The Fantasy Footballers on Hybrid, REMI Pro...
25/04/2024
NFL Draft 2024: ESPN Motors Into Detroit With Trio of Simultaneous Live Presenta...
25/04/2024
Published On: April 25th, 2024
data-orig-src=https://www.sgo.es/wp-content/upl...
25/04/2024
Published On: April 25th, 2024
data-orig-src=https://www.sgo.es/wp-content/uploads/Dolce-Mia-Header-image.png width=1040 height=533 class=lazyload wp-image-0 ...
The facts of the case
