Sony Digital Rapids Pixel Power calrec Sony

Judge Rejects VidAngel Antitrust Claim Against Disney Et Al.

12/08/2017

In a victory for Hollywoods major studios and yet another setback for a video editing operation, a California Central District Judge has dismissed VidAngels counterclaim of antitrust violations against the studios, who are suing the company over its online delivery of filtered content.

VidAngel said it was disappointed and was considering its legal options.

Judge Andr Birotte Jr. also rejected VidAngels defense of Copyright misuse, which would have required VidAngel to make the case that the studios were restraining the development of competing products.

Related: VidAngel Flies Again, With Different Wings

The studios named in the suit are Disney, Lucasfilm, Twentieth Century Fox Film, and Warner Bros., and it was just the latest in a string of court decisions stretching over many months.

The studios had asked the judge to throw out VidAngels antitrust counterclaim on the grounds that it had failed to make a plausible claim either for a horizontal or vertical conspiracy or intentional interference with prospective economic advantage. They had also asked the judge to reject the Copyright misuse defense since it was tied to the antitrust counterclaims.

The judge agreed with the studios and granted the motion to dismiss. He also said they could not amend their claim.

VidAngel had alleged that the Directors Guild of American agreement on motion picture editing prohibits alteration of a work without director approval, which is an unreasonable restraint of trade. The judge instead concluded that while the language limits editing without initial consultation with the director, it is not a mandate to obtain permission.

The judge also concluded that VidAngel had mischaracterized an email from a Google representative, which it alleged informed VidAngel that Google was concerned that directors would block content filtering.

VidAngel had asserted that the studios would not all have rejected a licensing agreement if they had not agreed collectively to refuse to allow filtering, but the judge instead concluded that their refusal to engage in licensing discussions with a company that they allege is operating an infringing service is a rational business decision and does not support a plausible inference of an agreement to eliminate filtering.

VidAngel had also argued that the refusal to sell VidAngel their DVDs-VidAngel buys a copy of a DVD, filters out the swearing and nudity, and streams it to a subscriber-was counter to their economic self-interest since they were cutting out the retailer middleman. But VidAngel also said that the studios had an economic motive in subverting VidAngels business model because VidAngel DVDs are re-sold and streamed to new cuteroms, from which the studios get no money. VidAngel seemingly concedes that Plaintiffs have rational economic motives not to deal with VidAngel, said Birotte.

As to Copyright misuse, the judge said: VidAngel has not, and cannot allege that their filtering service is a competing product to Plaintiffs' movie production studios.

Just last week, the same judge denied a motion by VidAngel to declare that its new app-based online stream scrubbing business model does not violate an injunction it is under from operating under its previous model of buying, scrubbing and streaming DVDs.

We are once again disappointed by another decision by Judge Birotte that badly misconstrued VidAngel's allegations, said VidAngel CEO Neal Harmon. During the more than seven months it took the Court to rule, there were a number of highly-publicized events showing that VidAngel's antitrust allegations are correct, including the Directors Guild of America's assertion of its collective bargaining agreement with the studios to force Sony to cease offering clean content to home viewers. Such events notwithstanding, the Court inexplicably denied VidAngel's request for leave to amend its counterclaim to allege additional facts in support of its claim. We are conferring with our attorneys and will announce VidAngels legal response to the Court's ruling as soon as possible.
LINK: http://www.broadcastingcable.com/news/programming/judge-rejects-vidang...
See more stories from bandc

Most recent headlines

14/12/2017

Cisco Releases Security Connector App for iOS

San Jose, Calif., December 14, 2017 Today, Cisco (NASDAQ: CSCO) announces the availability of Cisco Security Connector, the first security app designed to g...

14/12/2017

Cisco Announces Leadership Changes

SAN JOSE, Calif. - Dec. 14, 2017 - Cisco (NASDAQ: CSCO) today announced changes to the executive leadership team. Rebecca Jacoby, senior vice president of Oper...

14/12/2017

NIKOLAI TUNKOWITSCH IS FREE TO ROAM WITH DPA'S NEW D:VICE

The renowned musician who performs regularly at Vienna's Burgtheater is using a d:vice and his phone as a field recorder to capture ideas and demos. DPA&#...

14/12/2017

IPE Partners with AVC Group

IPE today announced a new partnership with Auckland New Zealand-based AVC Group. AVC will represent IPE as a reseller of IPEs Intelligent Display Systems (IDS) ...

14/12/2017

Sonic Wave Enters Partnership with Sennheiser

Sonic Wave Enters Partnership with Sennheiser posted: 14/12/2017 Andrew Williams, CEO, Sonicwave - Ryan Burr, Head of Technical Sales & Application Enginee...

14/12/2017

CG Helps Shoppers Get into the Holiday Competitive Spirit

Electric Theatre Collective, the LA and London-based VFX/post production studio, teamed up with director Steve Rogers from Biscuit Filmworks and Venables Bell &...

14/12/2017

MPC Announces Leadership Changes

NEW YORK CITY - Global visual effects and creative production studio MPC, a Technicolor company, has announced major leadership changes for its advertising stud...

14/12/2017

Jaunts XR Platform Helping Media Companies Distribute VR Content

LONDON - Jaunt Inc. (www.jauntvr.com), a global partner for producing and distributing immersive content, has announced the Jaunt XR Platform, a white label dis...

14/12/2017

Shotgun 7.6 Adds New Analytics Feature Set

LOS ANGELES - Shotgun Software (www.shotgunsoftware.com) has released Shotgun 7.6, the latest version of its cloud-based review and production tracking software...

14/12/2017

NewTek Getting Ready To Ship LightWave 2018

SAN ANTONIO, TX - NewTek, Inc., will soon release LightWave 2018, the new iteration of their 3D animation system. The software for Windows and Mac operating sys...

14/12/2017

Kevin Adds To VFX Team

VENICE, CA - Visual effects studio Kevin (yourstrulykevin.com), which opened in September, has added to its team with the hiring of Mike Dalzell as head of CG, ...

14/12/2017

Extending the Star Wars story

Jonathan Cheetham, visual effects supervisor at Jellyfish Pictures, talks to TVBEurope about working on Star Wars: The Last Jedi Author: Jenny PriestleyPublis...

14/12/2017

Primetime Ratings: Fox Rides Ebullient Empire' To Wednesday Win

Fox took Wednesday ratings honors, riding Empire to a 1.6 prime score in viewers 18-49, per Nielsen's overnights, and a 6 share. In second was ABC at 1.2/5....

14/12/2017

The ELEAGUE Cup: Rocket League Feature Series Continues Friday, Dec. 15, at 10 p.m. ET/PT on TBS

The ELEAGUE Cup: Rocket League Feature Series Continues Friday, Dec. 15, at 10 p...

14/12/2017

ARRI LEDs illuminate studios in Nairobi

ARRI LEDs illuminate studios in Nairobi Newly equipped with ARRI SkyPanels and L-Series LED light fixtures, Citizen TV and Inooro TV in Kenya can now boast of ...

14/12/2017

SES Drives 5G Satellite Demonstration Testbed Initiative with ESA

Written on 14 Dec 2017 Luxembourg, 14 December 2017 - SES is expanding its efforts to support 5G developments as part of ESA's ARTES project, SATis5, wher...

14/12/2017

Cinegy Air Cloud Pack now available on Microsoft Azure

-- Cinegy today announced that it is making its Cinegy Air Cloud Pack available on the Microsoft Azure Marketplace. The Cinegy Air Cloud Pack includes Cinegy ...

14/12/2017

Roland V-1SDI Four-Channel Video Switcher Fills Critical Niches for AVFX

-- From its headquarters in Boston, AVFX, a leading event designer, planner and producer, serves clients across the U.S. with reliable and professional audiov...

14/12/2017

Kirstin Maldonados New Music Video Naked Shot with 15 Blackmagic Design Cameras Shooting Simultaneously

-- Blackmagic Design today announced that global singing sensation Kirstin Mal...

14/12/2017

New app for SuperSport fans

SuperSport has launched its new app, designed to provide users with a fresh, modern experience that makes content discovery easier. Navigation has been refined...

14/12/2017

Why and how to protect the local film and advertising industry

By Bobby Amm, executive officer, the Commercial Producers Association There are about 44.4 million black people in South Africa, 6 million of whom are middle ...

14/12/2017

Olympic Channel Welcomes Six New Federation Partners

Olympic Channel Welcomes Six New Federation Partners posted: 14/12/2017 Following the recent celebration of its one-year anniversary, the Olympic Channel t...

14/12/2017

Amazon recruits Mediapro, IMG, Film45 for Manchester City series

Trio will aid production of exclusive 10 million series Author: James GrovesPublish date: Dec 14, 2017Social count: 0 Trio will aid production of exclusiv...

14/12/2017

WWE to launch show on Facebook

Social platform secures exclusive rights to a live weekly show Author: Jenny PriestleyPublish date: Dec 14, 2017Social count: 0 Social platform secures exc...

14/12/2017

Sony Pictures launches free kids' app

Pop Fun app will bring together content from Pop, Tiny Pop and Pop Max Author: James GrovesPublish date: Dec 14, 2017Social count: 0 Pop Fun app will bring...

14/12/2017

AI is making inroads into media enterprises

Media companies are embracing AI technology to automate captioning, metadata tagging Author: ContributorPublish date: Dec 14, 2017Social count: 0 Media com...

14/12/2017

Warner Bros, Fox, Nickeodeon invest in VR company

Dreamscape Immersive is aiming to launch VR experiences in the UK Author: Jenny PriestleyPublish date: Dec 14, 2017Social count: 0 Dreamscape Immersive is ...

14/12/2017

Lord Burns appointed Ofcom chairman

Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport has confirmed appointment Author: Jenny PriestleyPublish date: Dec 14, 2017Social count: 5 Secreta...

14/12/2017

Disney acquires 21st Century Foxs entertainment assets for 49 billion

Deal includes Murdochs 39 per cent stake in Sky Author: Jenny PriestleyPublish date: Dec 14, 2017Social count: 0 Deal includes Murdochs 39 per cent stake i...

14/12/2017

Tedial Expands Role of LATAM Regional Sales Director to Include Middle East

Tedial, the leading independent MAM technology solutions specialist, has announced that its Regional Sales Director, LATAM, Jose Luis Monteros role will also no...

14/12/2017

INSIGHT TV Kicks Off Christmas and New Year with F2 Freestylers Marathon and Tackling Europe Launch

INSIGHT TV, one of the worlds largest UHD HDR broadcasters and producer of nativ...

14/12/2017

Utah Scientific President Tom Harmon to Retire

Utah Scientific today announced that Tom Harmon, president of Utah Scientific, has announced his retirement after 15 highly successful years at the helm of the ...

14/12/2017

Grand Lille TV Migrates to HD and Launches New Channel With Harmonic

Harmonic, the worldwide leader in video delivery technology and services, today announced that Grand Lille TV, a French regional TV news channel that is part of...

14/12/2017

Japans Yomiuri TV Selects TVU One with HEVC for Live Video-Over-IP Remote News Coverage

TVU Networks, the global technology and innovation leader in live IP video solut...

14/12/2017

US MILITARY LAUNCH NEW MPEG-4 HD SET-TOP BOXES WITH INVIEW MIDDLEWARE

Inview Technology, the broadcast/OTT software and service specialist, and DigitalGlue, a systems integrator, equipment provider and software developer for the p...

14/12/2017

TSL Products Announces New MPA1 Mix SDI Audio Monitor

TSL Products, a leading broadcast equipment manufacturer, today announced the release of the new MPA1 Mix SDI audio monitor. Part of the MPA (Monitor Plus Audio...

14/12/2017

Swiss Regional Broadcaster La Tele Installs New Aveco ASTRA Studios and Incite MAM Editing Solution

Aveco , the worldwide broadcast automation specialist, through Geneva-based syst...

14/12/2017

Globecast promotes Sylvain Merle to Chief Operating Officer

Globecast, the global solutions provider for media, announces the promotion of Sylvain Merle to Chief Operating Officer, effective immediately. He will replace ...

14/12/2017

Lets Dance

Across a 25-year career, CG veteran Remington Scott has worked on many projects that undoubtedly redefined what was possible within the realm of performance cap...

14/12/2017

Hardware Requirements in the Age of VR

It's no secret that virtual reality has made its way beyond gaming and consumer consumption - breaking into numerous industries, such as media and entertain...

14/12/2017

Special Delivery from MPC

In an attempt to answer the uncomfortable question that young children often ask their parents - Where do babies come from? - adults often abandon the truthfu...

14/12/2017

State of Alarm recipients announced

14 12 2017 - Media release State of Alarm recipients announced State of Alarm recipients with guest speaker Karrina Nolan Screen Australia's Indigenous D...

14/12/2017

Create NSW, ABC Arts and Screen Australia announce Double Happiness

14 12 2017 - Media release Create NSW, ABC Arts and Screen Australia announce Double Happiness Double Happiness / Photo credit Olivia Martin-McGuire Create N...

14/12/2017

Development funding announced for 17 screen projects and four industry placements

14 12 2017 - Media release Development funding announced for 17 screen projects ...

14/12/2017

Season Two of The Good Fight' On CBS All Access Mar. 4

The second season of The Good Fight starts on CBS All Access Sunday, Mar. 4. There will be 13 episodes in the new season. Each one will debut weekly on Sundays ...

14/12/2017

Sixth Season of My 600-Lb. Life' Back on TLC Jan. 10

TLC's My 600-Lb. Life returns for its sixth season starting Jan. 10. There are 14 two-hour episodes in the new season. Each episode will offer a look at th...

14/12/2017

Fox News Taps Neil Cavuto for Live Saturday Morning News Show

Fox News in January will launch a new live Saturday morning news show anchored by Neil Cavuto, the network said Wednesday. The two-hour series, Cavuto Live, de...

14/12/2017

Primetime Ratings: Gwen Stefani Helps NBC to Win

NBC was the top ratings earner in Tuesday prime, putting up a 1.3 in viewers 18-49, per the Nielsen overnights, and a 5 share. That squeaked by CBS at 1.2/5. N...

14/12/2017

Africa to Take Centre Stage at DISCOP Dubai 2018

14 December, 2017 - 08:01 The recent success of DISCOP Johannesburg highlighted the growing international interest in content made in Africa. This interes...

14/12/2017

Things quickly gets tense when SuzelleDIY and Tali_babes co-star

14 December, 2017 - 08:02 Interest in Tali's Wedding Diary, the first Showmax Original, is reaching fever pitch. Promotional videos for the show have ge...